would you sacrifice...

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

would you sacrifice...

room size for property size?

the house we love has 3 bedrooms and an EIK. plus a dining room, which we are finding is NOT a given in most houses Chat Icon

it's a splanch so the "basement" is 1/2 finished and 1/2 unfinished.

it definitely has room for expansion, and sits on nearly 1/2 acre.

but the bedrooms are on the small side, and only has 1 bathroom.

the price is good - not great, but good.

Posted 4/27/09 10:44 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: would you sacrifice...

it really depends on what you really want.

I didn't need a giant property. I needed at least 3 bedrooms one that could fit a king bed set and 2 baths.

Posted 4/27/09 10:47 AM
 

BnBdreamin
Gonna be a BIG Bro in April!

Member since 10/06

5913 total posts

Name:
Denise

Re: would you sacrifice...

Yes, I would. Our house is over 50 years old so the rooms are on the small side but with the renovations we are making and the future potential, this was the perfect house for us in every way... property size, location (key, key, key), potential.

It really depends on you. I'm not the type who needs a giant bedroom with walk in closets. I change my clothes and sleep in there. We live in the yard, living room and kitchen so those are the spaces I'd like bigger.

This house your looking at... that fact that you say the price is not great and one bathroom would have me thinking. Chat Icon Is there potential in adding a second bath and if so, the cost worked into your offer? And for me, the location would have to be just what I wanted. You can only settle on so many things.

Good luck!

Posted 4/27/09 10:51 AM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: would you sacrifice...

Posted by Blu-ize

it really depends on what you really want.

I didn't need a giant property. I needed at least 3 bedrooms one that could fit a king bed set and 2 baths.




Those were our requirements too. I cared less about lot size than room size and at least 2 full baths.

Posted 4/27/09 10:52 AM
 

Sherwood
LIF Adult

Member since 8/08

1643 total posts

Name:
s

Re: would you sacrifice...

Personally I wouldnt. My theory is that I'd rather have more room inside than outside, since I will most likely be spending more time inside than out. I'd much prefer the bigger rooms...property size isnt that important to me.

Posted 4/27/09 10:52 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: would you sacrifice...

the location of this house is AWESOME. very close to stores, off of a main road, but on the end of the side street so it is somewhat secluded and safe/not as busy.

we plan on having a large family. we cannot afford a larger house, but we need the space to expand.

Posted 4/27/09 10:54 AM
 

Nik211
my little monkey<3

Member since 5/08

3303 total posts

Name:
Nik

Re: would you sacrifice...

its hard to say......the 1 bathroom would be more of an issue with me than the smaller sized bedrooms - but if its just the two of you than 1 bathroom could def work...

small sized bedrooms can work depending on what you plan on using them for - the house we are looking at has a 16.5 x 13 master bedroom - which for me, with a king sized bed is kind of on the tiny side but considering we'll have a house to keep the rest of our things i think it should be plenty - right now our bedroom is a little smaller than that but it is also the catch all since we have a 1 bedroom apartment - so all sorts of things end up in there - the treadmill, laundry, books, the computer, etc. - so i think 16.5 x 13 will be plenty considering its going to be strictly bedroom furniture - no books, no computer, no treadmill, no nothing! Chat Icon

the other 3 bedrooms in the house are 13x11, 13x11 and 13x12 - to me, the bedrooms aren't huge but i think they will be big enough for kids when the time comes, and the biggest room will be our office/guest room....

what i am trying to say is can you picture your things in those rooms? do you think they will be adequate? that is what i tried to do. the rooms that hopefully our future kids will be in are almost as big as our bedroom now in our apartment - so even though its not huge i think it will be plenty for them...

i tried to visualize what we'll need in the future. we needed 4 bedrooms for sure. we don't want to run out of room. and we also needed at least 2 bathrooms. the house we are looking into has 2 full baths.

Message edited 2009-04-27 10:56:43.470000.

Posted 4/27/09 10:54 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: would you sacrifice...

Posted by BnBdreamin

This house your looking at... that fact that you say the price is not great and one bathroom would have me thinking. Chat Icon Is there potential in adding a second bath and if so, the cost worked into your offer? And for me, the location would have to be just what I wanted. You can only settle on so many things.

Good luck!



i should clarify - the price for the house itself is very very good but i would have to go back to work full time for us to afford it. plus the taxes would need to be STARed.

the location, like i stated, is perfect.

and there is plenty of room to add another bedroom and a bathroom and expand on top of the garage to add a master suite.

we don't need those things right now, but we can't afford a house that already has them, KWIM?

Posted 4/27/09 10:56 AM
 

BnBdreamin
Gonna be a BIG Bro in April!

Member since 10/06

5913 total posts

Name:
Denise

Re: would you sacrifice...

Posted by headoverheels

i should clarify - the price for the house itself is very very good but i would have to go back to work full time for us to afford it. plus the taxes would need to be STARed.

the location, like i stated, is perfect.

and there is plenty of room to add another bedroom and a bathroom and expand on top of the garage to add a master suite.

we don't need those things right now, but we can't afford a house that already has them, KWIM?



I do but not to discourage, if you're going back to work full time for this house as is, what's going to happen when you expand it? Nevermind the cost of the renovation but your taxes and utilities go up as well. Star program is not always a guarantee these days. Who knows how long it's staying around with this economy.

There are so many other personal decisions/factors that way in. How long have you been looking, how soon do you need to get out of where you are, have you adjusted your search criteria...

But still answering your original question... seems like I'm in the minority, but I'll still take property size over room size. Chat Icon

Posted 4/27/09 11:11 AM
 

babymakes3
Almost there!

Member since 7/06

7376 total posts

Name:

Re: would you sacrifice...

I probably wouldn't bite on that house unless it was a GREAT price. One bathroom is a turn-off and it will be costly to add another one.

As for bedroom size, I would sacrifice bedroom size for property size with one condition...There needs to be room indoors for a play area. Our house has small bedrooms compared to today's standards but we will have a family room / play area in the basement when that's finished.

We also have a large lot (.5 acre) and even though we are only at the house on the weekends right now, my DD has not spent one sunshine-y moment indoors unless I'm trying to get her to nap. I'm glad to have the space for a large playground and then some.

Posted 4/27/09 11:15 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: would you sacrifice...

Posted by babymakes3

As for bedroom size, I would sacrifice bedroom size for property size with one condition...There needs to be room indoors for a play area. Our house has small bedrooms compared to today's standards but we will have a family room / play area in the basement when that's finished.

We also have a large lot (.5 acre) and even though we are only at the house on the weekends right now, my DD has not spent one sunshine-y moment indoors unless I'm trying to get her to nap. I'm glad to have the space for a large playground and then some.



the lower level of the house is 1/2 finished and the other 1/2 can easily be finished to add a bathroom and another bedroom, still leaving room for a laundry room and lots of storage, which is an issue for us.

the finished part is large and there is room for both a den and a play area.

the bedrooms are not tiny, but not as big as we are used to. they will easily fit all of our things (we have a queen bed and 2 tall dressers plus 2 nightstands).

in all honesty, i am less concerned with space for me and DH (we don't need a large bedroom) but we are thinking ahead to see if our kids will need to share a room or if we can afford to add a room and another bathroom.

Posted 4/27/09 11:22 AM
 

08BabySurprise
My Life. My Everything.

Member since 10/07

9151 total posts

Name:

Re: would you sacrifice...

I wouldn't no way unless the price was just out of this world great and we had room to build one One bathroom is not something we would be able to live with - thinking about us, DS, another child in a few years, guests... I wouldn't even think about doing it.

Posted 4/27/09 11:22 AM
 

JessInCA
live laugh love

Member since 8/06

5082 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: would you sacrifice...

I would if the property size was such that it meant I could expand the house later on if need be.

Posted 4/27/09 11:28 AM
 

tray831
Dee-licious!

Member since 3/06

5355 total posts

Name:
His Baby

Re: would you sacrifice...

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by babymakes3

As for bedroom size, I would sacrifice bedroom size for property size with one condition...There needs to be room indoors for a play area. Our house has small bedrooms compared to today's standards but we will have a family room / play area in the basement when that's finished.

We also have a large lot (.5 acre) and even though we are only at the house on the weekends right now, my DD has not spent one sunshine-y moment indoors unless I'm trying to get her to nap. I'm glad to have the space for a large playground and then some.



the lower level of the house is 1/2 finished and the other 1/2 can easily be finished to add a bathroom and another bedroom, still leaving room for a laundry room and lots of storage, which is an issue for us.

the finished part is large and there is room for both a den and a play area.

the bedrooms are not tiny, but not as big as we are used to. they will easily fit all of our things (we have a queen bed and 2 tall dressers plus 2 nightstands).

in all honesty, i am less concerned with space for me and DH (we don't need a large bedroom) but we are thinking ahead to see if our kids will need to share a room or if we can afford to add a room and another bathroom.



Then I say.........Go for it!! We kinda did something similar........Our bedrooms aren't huge either but we have 3/4 acre of property that I wouldn't trade for anything. There is always room for expansion. That's how we look at it!

Everyone has different likes. Some people wouldn't mind a home with a lot of big rooms and a tiny lil' piece of property. But DH and I love being outside......so it's different for everyone.

Chat Icon Chat Icon GL! Chat Icon

Posted 4/27/09 11:41 AM
 

PeasandCarrots
&hearts;

Member since 5/07

9579 total posts

Name:
L

Re: would you sacrifice...

Here's my 2cents...Joe and I bought our house thinking we were atleast 5yrs away from starting family. 1yr later we were ready and THAT is when we realized our house was only good for us and maybe 1 kid. We have crunched lots of numbers and to get our house how we want it to be would cost us way more then we want to invest, so after nursing school we'll be looking to buy again. I say this because you are TTC again and the last thing you want to do is worry about space. If expanding is a REAL possability then DO IT! But if it's a maybe in a few years thing I fear you will be unhappy just as quickly as we are and feel stuck. It's so expensive to remodel, build on and so forth, but if you can then I say buy the house and start planning. If you can't for some time I say keep looking. Houses are so expensive. I wish I had waited and bought a better house for our future. HTH

Posted 4/27/09 12:03 PM
 

carolyns4cupcakes
C &hearts;'s F

Member since 2/07

6456 total posts

Name:

Re: would you sacrifice...

What is the area anyway? Suffolk I hope.Chat Icon
We renovated our house; we made the bedrooms bigger and added more living space.
My biggest concern would be having a play area in the house. That is a must, IMO especially if you want a big family. The 1/2 acre is a dream for me. Our lot is 77X150 which is small, but good. You'll appreciate the property in beautiful weather and you will be ever so grateful for the playroom/family room for the kids to play in while they are young and to hangout in when they get older.

The bathroom is not a must right now. You can live with one bathroom for a while. Maybe it's easy for me to say that b/c that's what we have. We just made a 2nd bathroom (not finished yet) but we had 1 for a looooooong time. You can always add a bathroom later on like you mentioned.

GL !!!!!

Posted 4/27/09 12:21 PM
 

MrsO
Big Brothers to Be

Member since 1/07

4521 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: would you sacrifice...

When we looked at houses it was all about potential. If it has the location and the yard you want and the possibility to make it into your dream home. I would go for it. Just make sure the price will leave you some savings to help make it into your dream home.

Posted 4/27/09 12:31 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: would you sacrifice...

Posted by nov04libride

Posted by Blu-ize

it really depends on what you really want.

I didn't need a giant property. I needed at least 3 bedrooms one that could fit a king bed set and 2 baths.




Those were our requirements too. I cared less about lot size than room size and at least 2 full baths.



And we bought a big enough house although the layout was far more important we figured out after the fact. Live and learn. It's still a great house, just wish the layout was different. We have a small property and although I wish it was a tiny bit bigger I'm happy we don't have a giant lawn or property to maintain. It's expensive and hard work.

Location is key and if it has enough space for you to be happy for years to come. I know that if I had to dormer the house to add a bath or more living space I would't be able to afford it without completely leveraging ourselves.

Posted 4/27/09 12:32 PM
 

Nik211
my little monkey<3

Member since 5/08

3303 total posts

Name:
Nik

Re: would you sacrifice...

Posted by medic6809

Here's my 2cents...Joe and I bought our house thinking we were atleast 5yrs away from starting family. 1yr later we were ready and THAT is when we realized our house was only good for us and maybe 1 kid. We have crunched lots of numbers and to get our house how we want it to be would cost us way more then we want to invest, so after nursing school we'll be looking to buy again. I say this because you are TTC again and the last thing you want to do is worry about space. If expanding is a REAL possability then DO IT! But if it's a maybe in a few years thing I fear you will be unhappy just as quickly as we are and feel stuck. It's so expensive to remodel, build on and so forth, but if you can then I say buy the house and start planning. If you can't for some time I say keep looking. Houses are so expensive. I wish I had waited and bought a better house for our future. HTH



I think that is great advice. When DH and I started looking we wanted a 3 bedroom home with a pool (this is in Florida). But then we realized that we would really run out of room quickly with just 3 bedrooms. We wanted to have a room for our computer/home office and figured that could double as a space for guests. Then we'd be left with the master and 2 rooms for potential children. If we did 3 bedrooms where would our computer end up when we had more than 1 kid? And where would our guests sleep? So we ended up finding a great 4 bedroom with no pool. Hopefully can save enough to have one built but in the meantime there will be a community pool - I rather have the room for kids (which we plan on having a lot sooner than we expected).....

I dont think you can ever have too much room Chat Icon but you have to make due with what you can afford. I would have loved 5 bedrooms but its just not in our price range right now.

Posted 4/27/09 12:37 PM
 

Jenn627
Laaaaaaaambert!

Member since 5/08

9818 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: would you sacrifice...

I would def sacrifice room size for property size. I'm only going on my on upbringing though. I lived in a tiny room and did just fine. Plus - in my family we never "hung out" in our bedrooms - they were just for sleeping.... So bedroom size isn't important to me.

eta: We had two bathrooms in our house (up and down) but us kids (2) and my mom shared the upstairs. There was never an issue. My dad used the downstairs one - only because he got up real early and didn't want to wake us, so even if he used the upstairs one with us it still wouldn't have been an issue.

Message edited 2009-04-27 13:50:10.023000.

Posted 4/27/09 1:42 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: would you sacrifice...

I'm really no help bc I would not sacrifice a big yard OR large enough bedrooms. But that is me. I did however sacrifice having no basement.

I'm sitting here thinking of what I would do, and I can truly say I have no clue.Chat Icon

Posted 4/27/09 2:00 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: would you sacrifice...

lb, our house only has 2 dedicated bedrooms (both on level 2) with 2 baths (also on level 2)

we converted the back room on level on into a den/guest room/office, and have a large living room and an eat in kitchen (also fairly large)

we don't plan to have a large family (probably just the bambino in my belly) but we HAVE a large family...so we figure it out and make it work.

we plan to eventually add a bath on level 1, and convert part of our barn to create a guest suite.

I think having the space and option to fix potential problems negates their problematic-ness, so you WILL have the best of both worlds with this house if you put the work into it (and yes, the money...but better in stages than all at once).

I am with Denise...a bedroom is for sleeping and getting dressed...and anything else I am doing in there requires CLOSENESS more than anything else Chat Icon as long as you kid can have room for a twin bed, a toy chest and a dresser...all is good.

we have a "family" space...the den, and that is where I want us doing our thing...not enclosed in our bedrooms separate, so for us it works.

think about how you want to live your life and take it from there.

and think about if you'll eventually want something large in the yard (a pool...a trampoline Chat Icon ) b/c that will take up mucho space and you want some yard to run around in too.

anyway...that's all I got.

Posted 4/27/09 3:52 PM
 

rkoenke
my little piggys

Member since 3/08

4315 total posts

Name:
rachel

Re: would you sacrifice...

Posted by Jenn627

I would def sacrifice room size for property size. I'm only going on my on upbringing though. I lived in a tiny room and did just fine. Plus - in my family we never "hung out" in our bedrooms - they were just for sleeping.... So bedroom size isn't important to me.

eta: We had two bathrooms in our house (up and down) but us kids (2) and my mom shared the upstairs. There was never an issue. My dad used the downstairs one - only because he got up real early and didn't want to wake us, so even if he used the upstairs one with us it still wouldn't have been an issue.



I agree, bedroom size to me isn't a major issue. i did very little in my bedroom, even as a teenager... if you plan on having lots of family time and doing things all the time with DC, you won't have an issue. it sounds to me that the room size is fine (i hear it in your writing, that you have convinced yourself).
Go for it! low-ball the offer to get a great price, or at least a better price.

GOOD LUCK WITH WHATEVER YOU DECIDE!!
Chat Icon

Posted 4/27/09 4:43 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: would you sacrifice...

In my area, the houses are all the same (Levitts) so all the rooms are on the smaller size. We do fine. We have a big backyard and it great with DS. I don't worry about putting some outdoor toys, patio. We are even going to extend our patio to include a conversation patio furniture set. We still have LOTS of space. It's great in the Summer, parties, place to do a garden, etc... I don't mind smaller bedrooms. We really don't use those rooms but for sleeping. We have 2 additional bedrooms. I will convert 1 for DS for an official playroom.

We love our location. The convenience makes up for way more thahaving to move somewhere else to get bigger room.

Posted 4/27/09 4:53 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: would you sacrifice...

In general, I would prefer larger rooms and less property. However, there are other factors that I look at. I think it sounds like there will be another house that you are more sure about.

Posted 4/27/09 5:02 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Would you sacrifice location... SpiceGirl 11/18/07 21 Home
Should I sacrifice location? TaraHutch 11/14/07 15 Home
Would you sacrifice yourself for the happiness of others? LittleBlueBug 1/27/07 9 Families Helping Families ™
Finding it hard to keep Lenten sacrifice Juliet 4/3/06 7 Families Helping Families ™
Lenten Sacrifice Juliet 3/3/06 3 Families Helping Families ™