Would you ever....

Posted By Message

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Would you ever....

refuse to be a god parent to a child if you and the parents weren't on good terms?

Posted 5/18/11 1:48 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Would you ever....

Yes.

My question is, why would someone ask you to be the godparent of their child if they weren't on good terms with you?

Posted 5/18/11 1:49 PM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Would you ever....

Posted by neener1211

Yes.

My question is, why would someone ask you to be the godparent of their child if they weren't on good terms with you?



I was wondering the same thing. The only thing I can think is that they asked you before you had a falling out? If that's the case, and you are no longer on good terms, I couldn't imagine saying yes. What an uncomfortable ceremony that would be.

Posted 5/18/11 1:51 PM
 

BethanyLynn
Love these munchkins

Member since 10/09

6295 total posts

Name:
Bethany

Re: Would you ever....

Posted by jerseypanda

Posted by neener1211

Yes.

My question is, why would someone ask you to be the godparent of their child if they weren't on good terms with you?



I was wondering the same thing. The only thing I can think is that they asked you before you had a falling out? If that's the case, and you are no longer on good terms, I couldn't imagine saying yes. What an uncomfortable ceremony that would be.



ITA

Posted 5/18/11 1:51 PM
 

Bella01
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

3708 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Would you ever....

Honestly, I would never refuse. I would do it for the child. With that being said, I would question why she would ask me.

Quick story. I wasn't on good terms with my DD's God mother but because of my DH I asked her. Fast forward to present day, her and I are good friends now so I am glad I chose her!

Message edited 2011-05-18 13:55:28.700000.

Posted 5/18/11 1:52 PM
 

mlny
blessed <3

Member since 10/09

2113 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Would you ever....

I'm with the PPs.. I can't imagine why parents would ask someone they aren't on good terms with to be their childs godparent.



ETA - if by chance they did ask, I would do it. In the long run it's about the child anyways, not their parents.

Message edited 2011-05-18 13:53:48.047000.

Posted 5/18/11 1:52 PM
 

LadyBug1209
Mommy to FOUR little men!

Member since 8/08

9655 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you ever....

Posted by Bella0701

Honestly, I would never refuse. I would do it for the child.



Same here. I would leave it up to the child's parents... If they want to take back the invitation to be a Godparent that's one thing, but I would never say no.

Posted 5/18/11 1:53 PM
 

PeasandCarrots
&hearts;

Member since 5/07

9579 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Would you ever....

Seems to have worked out well for Teresa and Joe from RHONJ























Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/18/11 1:53 PM
 

allIwant
Love my crazy life!

Member since 1/10

9170 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you ever....

I would refuse...DH doesn't have contact with his godfather bc his father is no longer friends with him,,,not fair to the child

Posted 5/18/11 1:54 PM
 

Dee0522
And then there were four...

Member since 6/09

2088 total posts

Name:
Denise

Re: Would you ever....

Posted by Bella0701

Honestly, I would never refuse. I would do it for the child. With that being said, I would question why she would ask me.




Only thing is... if you aren't on good terms with the parents, how would you be able to maintain a relationship with your godchild? I guess I would just question how I would be able to spend time with the child and be a part of their life if I wasn't on good terms with his/her parents.

Posted 5/18/11 2:01 PM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Would you ever....

Just to clarify not me. I was speaking with a distant cousin of mine. She was crying because she asked her Catholic best friend (they have been having issues because her best friend has gotten pretty deeply into religion) to be godmother to her daughter and her best friend refused because they are lutheran and she said she wouldn't be able to commit to helping to rear her as a good lutheran.

Posted 5/18/11 2:04 PM
 

Bella01
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

3708 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Would you ever....

Posted by Dee0522

Posted by Bella0701

Honestly, I would never refuse. I would do it for the child. With that being said, I would question why she would ask me.




Only thing is... if you aren't on good terms with the parents, how would you be able to maintain a relationship with your godchild? I guess I would just question how I would be able to spend time with the child and be a part of their life if I wasn't on good terms with his/her parents.



I see what you are saying. It is a tough situation!

Posted 5/18/11 2:05 PM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Would you ever....

Posted by Bella0701

Posted by Dee0522

Posted by Bella0701

Honestly, I would never refuse. I would do it for the child. With that being said, I would question why she would ask me.




Only thing is... if you aren't on good terms with the parents, how would you be able to maintain a relationship with your godchild? I guess I would just question how I would be able to spend time with the child and be a part of their life if I wasn't on good terms with his/her parents.



I see what you are saying. It is a tough situation!

Yea and I am having trouble saying anything to her advice wise because I don't understand why she asked her, knowing how she feels about her religion. But she is clearly upset and I feel this will make the situation worse. Not better. I told her to ask her sister.

Posted 5/18/11 2:07 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Would you ever....

Posted by CookieMomster

Just to clarify not me. I was speaking with a distant cousin of mine. She was crying because she asked her Catholic best friend (they have been having issues because her best friend has gotten pretty deeply into religion) to be godmother to her daughter and her best friend refused because they are lutheran and she said she wouldn't be able to commit to helping to rear her as a good lutheran.



I think she is justified in refusing, I can understand that.

Being a God parent is about more than just a special birthday present every year-it should be about supporting your faith. If a person feels they can't do that, I respect the choice.

I'm a God parent to 2 kids, each a kid of a different cousin of mine. One I see all the time and get to spend time with. The other I almost never see and I really should have refused. I just didn't know how to.

Posted 5/18/11 2:09 PM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Would you ever....

Posted by CookieMomster

Just to clarify not me. I was speaking with a distant cousin of mine. She was crying because she asked her Catholic best friend (they have been having issues because her best friend has gotten pretty deeply into religion) to be godmother to her daughter and her best friend refused because they are lutheran and she said she wouldn't be able to commit to helping to rear her as a good lutheran.



I think this is a valid reason--I am godmother to my niece on DH's side, but I was never baptized and am an athiest. I want to be there for her, but I know I will never be a religious influence in her life, so in some ways, it didn't make sense to choose me, though I was flattered.

Posted 5/18/11 2:09 PM
 

JennB
My princess <3

Member since 5/09

2473 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Would you ever....

Posted by CookieMomster

Just to clarify not me. I was speaking with a distant cousin of mine. She was crying because she asked her Catholic best friend (they have been having issues because her best friend has gotten pretty deeply into religion) to be godmother to her daughter and her best friend refused because they are lutheran and she said she wouldn't be able to commit to helping to rear her as a good lutheran.



Well that makes sense. For Catholics, at least one of the two godparents must also be Catholic - the whole point of a godparent is to guide the child spiritually. Most people don't choose based on that reason anymore, though. I think the friend is just being honest, especially if she is very religious - it seems more of like a moral issue.

Posted 5/18/11 10:45 PM