Would you change doctors over this??? (Kinda long)

Posted By Message

ReiRei13
Life is Good!!

Member since 1/08

6460 total posts

Name:

Would you change doctors over this??? (Kinda long)

I really like my doctor here in NC (nowhere near like my NY Ped but I really do like him). He's super gentle with Frankie, takes his time with us and never makes me feel rushed when I have a gazillion questions.

In the past, we have had lengthy debates on CIO vs my POV on nighttime parenting and while we disagree, we respected eachother's opinion (even though I wasn't crazy about hearing how his DS was puke from CIO and he'd go in there, change the sheets and continue letting him cry himself to sleep).

Today I took my DS to him because he has some stomach bug and I mentioned how my DS has been refusing his vitamins. My DS is anemic and needs his iron everyday. Lately he will just spit out the liquid so we were trying flinstones chewables and now he won't take those either. His response was to hold him down, give him the liquid and hold his mouth shut till he swallows itChat Icon Chat Icon Theres NO WAY I am going to do that and I'm a little taken back that that was his advice!!

I also mentioned that my DS will not drink reg milk. He told me to stop giving him anything else to drink and after a week or two he'll drink it! Again, this is not something I feel comfortable doing. Maybe because I hate milk, so I can relate and I feel bad doing this.

WWYD??
Would you switch doctors over something like this??
How would you handle the vitamin & milk situation?
Am I overreacting.....is the doctor right and me overly sensitive??

Posted 6/11/10 9:55 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Would you change doctors over this??? (Kinda long)

I think if you and the doctor are on totally different wave lengths, then yes, I would switch and find someone who is more in line with my parenting style

I disagree about the vitamins but agree about the milk Chat Icon

Posted 6/11/10 9:56 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Would you change doctors over this??? (Kinda long)

I dunno.. i think we all answered before where we would use our doctors advice as guidelines unless it was a medical necessity.

Every parent is different, including doctors. And each child reacts to situations and methods differently. There's no truly right answer. Just advice.

Personally... yes I've 'force fed' things to AJ, meds, vitamins, etc. She'd cry longer if I tried to be nice about it and waffle about it. She'd suffer more if I didnt do it. So the only real solutions was to just get it done, and get it done quick. I'd hold her nose and tickle her throat. I swear it was like a half a second and she'd swallow quickly cause I'd let her nose go and she'd try to inhale. Instinct had her swallow first. She'd cry but it wasn't nearly as long and frankly I'd distract her and she could care less. With her claritin its a bit harder since its so much more. I'd slowly ease it to the side of her cheek and take my time. Make a big yum yum deal out of it. I usually got MOST of it in her. She'd spit out some but I got the job done. If she shook her head and resisted or started to cry I went straight back to quick and to the point. Just try to avoid heading for the back of the throat, that quick will set off the gag reaction and for AJ she'd spit it all back out (happened once).

The milk.. yep again I sort of followed the same principal. But then again I let AJ have a bottle longer. I did half and half milk to formula, then more milk and more milk and more milk. Still she refused it and yes, I let her go without for a bit. Never long she'd be so hungry she'd eat it anyway within a few hours. She quickly learned it was always going to be the same stuff. I'm not a fan of milk myself but honestly she loves her last milk bottle of the day. Now sippy cup is a whole different story. But I supplement her diet with cheese, yogurt and other calcium inputs.


Bottom line tho, if you feel uncomfortable with him, try another doctor. You don't have to agree with your doctor 100% of the time but you do need to trust his opinion is sound.

Posted 6/11/10 10:43 PM
 

ChrisDee
My Girls

Member since 11/06

9543 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Would you change doctors over this??? (Kinda long)

I think the things he says make sense. They just may be different from the way you would handle things. I do not think that is a bad thing. Different does not equal bad.

Posted 6/11/10 11:10 PM
 

ReiRei13
Life is Good!!

Member since 1/08

6460 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you change doctors over this??? (Kinda long)

Thank you all for the responses!! You all make valids points- maybe I am overreacting! And just because his advice is different than what I'd do doesn't mean its wrong either! I think I'm going to continue to see him for now!

Posted 6/12/10 12:17 AM
 

MrsRivera
2 under 2...whew!!

Member since 2/07

9876 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Would you change doctors over this??? (Kinda long)

Posted by ChrisDee

I think the things he says make sense. They just may be different from the way you would handle things. I do not think that is a bad thing. Different does not equal bad.



ITA with this (I'm saying that a lot lately, I think the pregnancy brain has left me without adequate words to say what I want to say these days Chat Icon).

I agree with his approach about the vitamins. They're super important.

However, I disagree with his stance on how to get your DS to drink milk. Does he mean that he wants to withhold water as well, in your quest to get him to drink it? I think in NC in the summer, that could be potentially dangerous. If he means to withhold other liquids (like juice), then I can see his point. But IMO, there are plenty of other ways for him to get his calcium intake. Yogurt, cheese...whatever he'll take instead.

In the end, you can take your ped's advice as a POV, but do what you feel is right for your child Chat Icon

Posted 6/12/10 12:30 AM
 

architectnycity
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

2592 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you change doctors over this??? (Kinda long)

I wouldnt switch doctors. To me. those things are more advice on parenting than medical advice.

The liquid vitamins with iron smell disgusting. DS started refusing them as well. I put them in his juice. My son will only drink chocolate milk. Our ped didn't have a problem with that.

Posted 6/12/10 7:38 AM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you change doctors over this??? (Kinda long)

My ped. says the same exact things, even about letting their children throw up. I never switched, I just do what I want.

The milk, I would try it with a little ovaltine or carnation instant breakfast first.

The vitamins, maybe try the Flintstones gummys. Or put them in something that he does drink.

Posted 6/12/10 7:44 AM
 

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Would you change doctors over this??? (Kinda long)

Posted by ChrisDee

I think the things he says make sense. They just may be different from the way you would handle things. I do not think that is a bad thing. Different does not equal bad.



ITA....but if you just can't get past some of his ideas, then I'd try to switch to someone more on the same page with you about things like this.

Posted 6/12/10 8:20 AM
 

ReiRei13
Life is Good!!

Member since 1/08

6460 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you change doctors over this??? (Kinda long)

Posted by MrsRivera

Posted by ChrisDee

I think the things he says make sense. They just may be different from the way you would handle things. I do not think that is a bad thing. Different does not equal bad.



ITA with this (I'm saying that a lot lately, I think the pregnancy brain has left me without adequate words to say what I want to say these days Chat Icon).

I agree with his approach about the vitamins. They're super important.

However, I disagree with his stance on how to get your DS to drink milk. Does he mean that he wants to withhold water as well, in your quest to get him to drink it? I think in NC in the summer, that could be potentially dangerous. If he means to withhold other liquids (like juice), then I can see his point. But IMO, there are plenty of other ways for him to get his calcium intake. Yogurt, cheese...whatever he'll take instead.

In the end, you can take your ped's advice as a POV, but do what you feel is right for your child Chat Icon



Beth, he said to withhold all other liquids including water, which I thought was crazy!!

I decided I'm going to stay with him for now but do what my gut says is right and not take his word as the end all!!

Thanks everyone for responding and for your advice!Chat Icon

Posted 6/12/10 7:33 PM
 

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you change doctors over this??? (Kinda long)

Personally, I would take my doctor's advice, because I trust him. I dothink there are times you have to make you kid make kids do things they don't like, because its important to their health and wellbeing.

If I didn't trust my doctors advice then I would find a new doctor I could trust. BUT I would NOT look for a doctor who is just going to tell me what me want to hear. That would be a big mistake.

My doctor argues with me only when it counts, it sounds like your doctor does that too.

Posted 6/12/10 10:24 PM
 

JerseyMamaOf3
Boo!

Member since 6/05

15144 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you change doctors over this??? (Kinda long)

I wouldn't switch...

-As a believer in CIO I wouldn't use his approach. I would just ignore that.

-The medicine I would force. I have had to force tylenol when DS was little and I think it sounds worse than what it actually is.

-I would try adding some chocolate powder to it. I use Nesquick because it has a lot less sugar and it was the only way my DS would drink milk. I never made it chocolatity, I would use 1 tsp. to 8-9oz,

Posted 6/13/10 9:08 AM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: Would you change doctors over this??? (Kinda long)

My DD won't drink milk in any way, shape or form. But, she'll eat yogurt so she gets her dairy from that and cheese. She also will take a bit of milk in cereal so she'll get some cheerios with milk some days (gotta mix it up... she won't eat the same thing daily) Dr said that is fine. Plus, she eats a TON of veggies so I know she is getting her vitamins. And, she gets a glass of OJ in the AM which has calcium in it.

I pretty much hate milk as well, so I get why she doesn't like it. IMO, I'd rather teach her to make healthy choices with yogurts, cheeses and fruits and veggies rather than add flavorings to milk so she'll drink it.

As for the vitamin issue, I agree with your Dr. You've got to get them in him somehow especially if he's anemic. Have you tried to mix the vitamins into applesauce or yogurt?

The CIO thing is really another parenting choice. If you're not comfortable with it, don't do it. Dr's are parents too and they have their own styles, not to mention I think they learn some "bad habits" during their schoolingl. Find a method you're comfortable with and go that route.

Would I switch? If I was otherwise confident in his abilities and agreed with him on the major things, then no. If this was a "tip of the iceberg" type situation then I probably would.

Good luck
Chat Icon

Posted 6/13/10 9:41 AM
 

MrsGmomof3
...

Member since 6/08

3290 total posts

Name:
Irrelevant

Re: Would you change doctors over this??? (Kinda long)

I would not switch doctors over it. However, I take the stance with my ped that I am the mom, and he is the medical doctor. He gets to dispence medical advice to me, NOT parenting advice. I do not tell him how to be a doctor, so he does not get to tell me how to be a mom.

We have a respectful relationship, and he knows me Chat Icon

Posted 6/13/10 10:42 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Would you change doctors if . . . jambalady 12/3/09 12 Pregnancy
How do I get my medical records to change doctors? CathyB 1/25/07 6 Parenting
Would you change doctors? Katie111806 6/3/08 11 Pregnancy
did you change doctors? AlwaysSnow 10/25/07 4 TTC
Would you change doctors? snuggleupagus 10/16/06 11 Pregnancy
Need Advice on Switching Doctors and Timing...Kinda Long Tine73 7/28/09 19 Infertility