Who's watching the debate?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5

hopingforbaby
We made a wish & you came true

Member since 2/10

2695 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by Kidsaplenty

Posted by bookworm

I love how in American politics, voters are so often concerned with whether the candidate's personality makes you feel warm and fuzzy inside, rather than the actual policies, platforms and factual evidence.

To me, straight lying about the facts is a bigger crime than acting like a jerk.



Chat Icon The stuff people seem to focus on instead of the facts baffles me.



As an undecided voter, i personally found it hard to focus on what was being said when Biden was laughing and mumbling to himself whenever Ryan spoke. It was very distracting to me. At this point neither party is getting my vote because I am just so disappointed with both options. I wish the independent candidates got more attention because IMO this two party system needs to change.

Posted 10/12/12 7:55 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Who's watching the debate?

I understand how Biden's demeanor may have been distracting or off-putting to Romney/Ryan supporters and even undecided voters.

But, honestly, for me as a liberal, I thought he was fantastic. His reaction while Ryan was speaking represented how I feel as a liberal, because I find much of what Ryan says unsettling and a misrepresentation. Biden made his points clearly, and called Ryan out on misrepresentations and flip-flopping. I was applauding and agreeing with Biden much of the time. Truthfully, while others may call it 'unprofessional', 'rude', or 'disrespectful', I think it is one thing to respect a person, but I don't think Biden respected what Ryan was saying when he was skewing the facts or giving vague answers. And neither did I.

Once again, I have to say as I have said a number of times before - THERE WERE NO SPECIFICS FROM RYAN on the economy and taxes. He even admitted as much! This baffles me.

Further - I can NOT believe that in the year 2012 a VP candidate stood (sat) up there and flat out said that under their ticket Roe v. Wade would be overturned and abortion would be illegal ('except in the most extreme cases'). Every single Republican voter I have had conversations with over the past few months has ASSURED me that in this day, abortion is a given in this country and as a woman I have no need for concern. Well, apparently I do. I can not FATHOM this. Even in the abortion thread here a few days ago, most who identified as pro-life/anti-abortion didn't think it should be ILLEGAL, and that the government should have a say in that. Ryan flat out said he can not separate his religion from his life as a politician, and this is acceptable in a country where one of the fundamental tenets is the separation of church and state? I am appalled. People ask why this election, or the Romney/Ryan ticket scares liberal voters? Last night Paul Ryan proved why it does, and why it should.

Posted 10/12/12 8:00 AM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: Who's watching the debate?

I'm not concerned about candidates lying or being vague about what they are going to do, that is historically what politicians at every level do in this country.
What I cannot move past is our current President & his team bold facing lying about our CURRENT state of affairs and their own track record.

Out of all the lies on fact checker from both sides this graphic is the most powerful thing I have seen yet!

Fact Checker

Posted 10/12/12 8:09 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by bookworm

I love how in American politics, voters are so often concerned with whether the candidate's personality makes you feel warm and fuzzy inside, rather than the actual policies, platforms and factual evidence.

To me, straight lying about the facts is a bigger crime than acting like a jerk.



Seriously! And also people who are undecided, I do not think the debate is the best vechile to use to make your decision, it can be a piece to the puzzle but to be informed I would not base my decision soley on a debate.

Message edited 2012-10-12 08:15:15.733000.

Posted 10/12/12 8:13 AM
 

hopingforbaby
We made a wish & you came true

Member since 2/10

2695 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by DiamondGirl

Posted by bookworm

I love how in American politics, voters are so often concerned with whether the candidate's personality makes you feel warm and fuzzy inside, rather than the actual policies, platforms and factual evidence.

To me, straight lying about the facts is a bigger crime than acting like a jerk.



Seriously! And also people who are undecided, I do not think the debate is the best vechile to use to make your decision, it can be a piece to the puzzle but to be informed I would not base my decision soley on a debate.



Oh, im not basing my decision solely on the debates. But any chance to sway me in either direction last night was lost.

Posted 10/12/12 8:31 AM
 

bookworm
Two Little Rosebuds

Member since 8/09

2106 total posts

Name:

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by KellyFG

I'm not concerned about candidates lying or being vague about what they are going to do, that is historically what politicians at every level do in this country.
What I cannot move past is our current President & his team bold facing lying about our CURRENT state of affairs and their own track record.

Out of all the lies on fact checker from both sides this graphic is the most powerful thing I have seen yet!

Fact Checker



This was great! Thanks for posting.

I'll start out by saying that I don't really want to vote for either of them and will probably throw my vote away on a 3rd party ticket that has zero chance...just so you don't think this is an apology for Obama.

But I think a lot of those numbers come from a force outside of Obama's control: globalization. Yes, a president needs to provide leadership and orchestrate the creative solutions required to deal with big challenges, but some things cannot be legislated away. The fact of the matter is that there is no incentive to hire Americans anymore. Our kids have been largely unmotivated to pursue education and training for a few generations now because of a comfort and complacency that comes from a high standard of living, whereas people in up and coming nations like China, India, and Brazil have a real, everyday motivation (poverty, suffering) to outperform the American worker. And they are...for a lot less money. A LOT less. If you were a corporation--even a happy, popular, bright and shiny corporation like Apple--you would send jobs overseas too. Because you will get more for less...and you won't have to pay medical insurance or deal with pesky human rights violations, etc.

So more and more people are coming to entitlement programs for help because of chronic unemployment, and these programs are overtaxed and underfunded as the tax base dwindles, which inflates public debt. Does this mean we shouldn't take care of people? I don't know. It's hard for me to turn a deaf ear and cold heart to human suffering, but I do hear the arguments for fiscal responsibility.

And big corporate lobbies have such a stranglehold on both parties in Washington, that the tough decisions never get made. We saw that with a completely dysfunctional, filibuster-paralyzed congress throughout the Obama administration. I haven't seen an end to corporate subsidies or tax incentives to ship jobs overseas. They talk about this stuff, but no politician can really pursue it because they are always 7 minutes away from campaigning again, and someone has to pay for the TV commercials.

Sorry that was so long, but I feel like people oversimplify and look to the president as some kind of hero. Some problems are just a too complicated to fix single-handedly in 4 years.

Posted 10/12/12 8:47 AM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by bookworm

This was great! Thanks for posting.

I'll start out by saying that I don't really want to vote for either of them and will probably throw my vote away on a 3rd party ticket that has zero chance...just so you don't think this is an apology for Obama.

But I think a lot of those numbers come from a force outside of Obama's control: globalization. Yes, a president needs to provide leadership and orchestrate the creative solutions required to deal with big challenges, but some things cannot be legislated away. The fact of the matter is that there is no incentive to hire Americans anymore. Our kids have been largely unmotivated to pursue education and training for a few generations now because of a comfort and complacency that comes from a high standard of living, whereas people in up and coming nations like China, India, and Brazil have a real, everyday motivation (poverty, suffering) to outperform the American worker. And they are...for a lot less money. A LOT less. If you were a corporation--even a happy, popular, bright and shiny corporation like Apple--you would send jobs overseas too. Because you will get more for less...and you won't have to pay medical insurance or deal with pesky human rights violations, etc.

So more and more people are coming to entitlement programs for help because of chronic unemployment, and these programs are overtaxed and underfunded as the tax base dwindles, which inflates public debt. Does this mean we shouldn't take care of people? I don't know. It's hard for me to turn a deaf ear and cold heart to human suffering, but I do hear the arguments for fiscal responsibility.

And big corporate lobbies have such a stranglehold on both parties in Washington, that the tough decisions never get made. We saw that with a completely dysfunctional, filibuster-paralyzed congress throughout the Obama administration. I haven't seen an end to corporate subsidies or tax incentives to ship jobs overseas. They talk about this stuff, but no politician can really pursue it because they are always 7 minutes away from campaigning again, and someone has to pay for the TV commercials.

Sorry that was so long, but I feel like people oversimplify and look to the president as some kind of hero. Some problems are just a too complicated to fix single-handedly in 4 years.



I actually agree wholeheartedly with everything you said, I want a president that can address this as FACT and not try to dumb us down with the liberal media propaganda. ADMIT IT, its a problem that is not easy to fix!
I want an admission about the severity of situation and that is what I am most frustrated about. I don't blame Mr Obama for being unable to solve all of the problems, I blame him for trying to convince us that EVERYTHING is all better thanks to him.

Message edited 2012-10-12 09:00:39.180000.

Posted 10/12/12 9:00 AM
 

DandN
Twins are here!

Member since 3/06

3597 total posts

Name:
Deirdre

Re: Who's watching the debate?

On substance, Biden won. Ryan refused to be specific on the Romney/Ryan tax plan, not saying what entitlements they would cut (except Sesame Street, apparently) and what loopholes they would close.

I'm sorry, but you can't cut taxes 20% across the board (which greatly benefits the wealthiest) and increase spending for the military, and make up the difference by closing tax loopholes, very few of which they have actually named. It doesn't work. The Congressional Budget Office has said it wouldn't work. The National Review has said it wouldn't work, along with many other publications and review boards.

Re: Afghanistan. I think Biden nailed Ryan when Ryan said we don't have troops in the RE section of Afghanistan, and Biden explained "that's the most dangerous area in the world - you want to put Americans over THERE?" Romney/Ryan can talk tough on foreign policy all they want, but we do not want any more troops in harm's way. We went to Afghanistan to find and kill Osama, and weaken his organization. It's time to leave.

The reason why it has been declared a draw by CNN, is (I think) because of Biden's laughing/smiling/interrupting. If Biden had been a bit more restrained, then I think he would have been overwhelmingly declared the winner.

I didn't have a problem with the interrupting because that goes on all the time in these debates- but as a long time Biden supporter, I kept saying to the tv "stop with the laughing, Joe - It's obnoxious."

Posted 10/12/12 9:02 AM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by KellyFG

Posted by bookworm

This was great! Thanks for posting.

I'll start out by saying that I don't really want to vote for either of them and will probably throw my vote away on a 3rd party ticket that has zero chance...just so you don't think this is an apology for Obama.

But I think a lot of those numbers come from a force outside of Obama's control: globalization. Yes, a president needs to provide leadership and orchestrate the creative solutions required to deal with big challenges, but some things cannot be legislated away. The fact of the matter is that there is no incentive to hire Americans anymore. Our kids have been largely unmotivated to pursue education and training for a few generations now because of a comfort and complacency that comes from a high standard of living, whereas people in up and coming nations like China, India, and Brazil have a real, everyday motivation (poverty, suffering) to outperform the American worker. And they are...for a lot less money. A LOT less. If you were a corporation--even a happy, popular, bright and shiny corporation like Apple--you would send jobs overseas too. Because you will get more for less...and you won't have to pay medical insurance or deal with pesky human rights violations, etc.

So more and more people are coming to entitlement programs for help because of chronic unemployment, and these programs are overtaxed and underfunded as the tax base dwindles, which inflates public debt. Does this mean we shouldn't take care of people? I don't know. It's hard for me to turn a deaf ear and cold heart to human suffering, but I do hear the arguments for fiscal responsibility.

And big corporate lobbies have such a stranglehold on both parties in Washington, that the tough decisions never get made. We saw that with a completely dysfunctional, filibuster-paralyzed congress throughout the Obama administration. I haven't seen an end to corporate subsidies or tax incentives to ship jobs overseas. They talk about this stuff, but no politician can really pursue it because they are always 7 minutes away from campaigning again, and someone has to pay for the TV commercials.

Sorry that was so long, but I feel like people oversimplify and look to the president as some kind of hero. Some problems are just a too complicated to fix single-handedly in 4 years.



I actually agree wholeheartedly with everything you said, I want a president that can address this as FACT and not try to dumb us down with the liberal media propaganda. ADMIT IT, its a problem that is not easy to fix!
I want an admission about the severity of situation and that is what I am most frustrated about. I don't blame Mr Obama for being unable to solve all of the problems, I blame him for trying to convince us that EVERYTHING is all better thanks to him.



He did admit it. He has. I'm not sure if you watched the DNC at all, but he very much said all that in his speech. He alluded to it in his debate as well, and Biden did too. Their point is that we ARE starting to see a recovery, it's slow but it's there. But I respectfully disagree that they haven't admitted it - they 100% have.

Posted 10/12/12 9:10 AM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by MandJZ
He did admit it. He has. I'm not sure if you watched the DNC at all, but he very much said all that in his speech. He alluded to it in his debate as well, and Biden did too. Their point is that we ARE starting to see a recovery, it's slow but it's there. But I respectfully disagree that they haven't admitted it - they 100% have.



Going back to the link I posted and the proof that the president and his people lie about the current facts and their own track record, that confirms to me that they are not being entirely honest about it. I don't expect him to have a magic ball for the future but I do expect him to be an absolute EXPERT with 100% accuracy about our CURRENT state of affairs. There should be zero embellishment, zero tolerence for number fluffing. He is currently in charge, if he's proud of what he's done and would like to continue to do he should tell us the exact figures good or bad.

Posted 10/12/12 9:18 AM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by KellyFG

Posted by MandJZ
He did admit it. He has. I'm not sure if you watched the DNC at all, but he very much said all that in his speech. He alluded to it in his debate as well, and Biden did too. Their point is that we ARE starting to see a recovery, it's slow but it's there. But I respectfully disagree that they haven't admitted it - they 100% have.



Going back to the link I posted and the proof that the president and his people lie about the current facts and their own track record, that confirms to me that they are not being entirely honest about it. I don't expect him to have a magic ball for the future but I do expect him to be an absolute EXPERT with 100% accuracy about our CURRENT state of affairs. There should be zero embellishment, zero tolerence for number fluffing. He is currently in charge, if he's proud of what he's done and would like to continue to do he should tell us the exact figures good or bad.



But haven't you said a few times in this thread that ALL politicians lie and are vague? Romney has lied and misrepresented and flip-flopped so many times it is hard to keep track. I understand your point, but I was responding to your comment about 'admitting it' by saying he has, and I stand by that.

ETA: I went back and saw your distinction between lying about future plans and lying about what has been done. I think Romney has lied or misrepresented what HE has done in the past a number of times as well...and IMO lying or being vague about future plans, whether it is done all the time or not, is still unacceptable when as a voter I am trying to make an informed decision.

Message edited 2012-10-12 09:22:25.220000.

Posted 10/12/12 9:20 AM
 

ALD618
LIF Infant

Member since 4/11

325 total posts

Name:
Ashley

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by Ayne11

Posted by ElizaRags35

Posted by Ayne11

Martha for president!!



She really was great. She asked some really good questions.



She was awesome!



Was I the only one who felt like Biden was scolding/screaming at her all night? Chat Icon

Posted 10/12/12 9:20 AM
 

JennP
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

3986 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by DandN

On substance, Biden won. Ryan refused to be specific on the Romney/Ryan tax plan, not saying what entitlements they would cut (except Sesame Street, apparently) and what loopholes they would close.

I'm sorry, but you can't cut taxes 20% across the board (which greatly benefits the wealthiest) and increase spending for the military, and make up the difference by closing tax loopholes, very few of which they have actually named. It doesn't work. The Congressional Budget Office has said it wouldn't work. The National Review has said it wouldn't work, along with many other publications and review boards.

Re: Afghanistan. I think Biden nailed Ryan when Ryan said we don't have troops in the RE section of Afghanistan, and Biden explained "that's the most dangerous area in the world - you want to put Americans over THERE?" Romney/Ryan can talk tough on foreign policy all they want, but we do not want any more troops in harm's way. We went to Afghanistan to find and kill Osama, and weaken his organization. It's time to leave.

The reason why it has been declared a draw by CNN, is (I think) because of Biden's laughing/smiling/interrupting. If Biden had been a bit more restrained, then I think he would have been overwhelmingly declared the winner.

I didn't have a problem with the interrupting because that goes on all the time in these debates- but as a long time Biden supporter, I kept saying to the tv "stop with the laughing, Joe - It's obnoxious."



100% agree

On another note, a good site that summarizes the candidate's plans in a pretty bipartisan way is presdebates.idebate.org. Check it out for great background on the issues.

Ladies, just get yourselves educated. Look past the smoke and mirrors of the debates. Read about the policies and analyze how they will affect YOU. I admit it's not easy. Americans are relatively uneducated about their finances, especially their "real" tax rate. If people REALLY read up on some of the policies that are being considered I think some people would rethink their choices.

That is all I can say right now without getting partisan.Chat Icon

Posted 10/12/12 9:22 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Who's watching the debate?

My 2 cents.

Biden seemed aggressive, maniacal and overly gleeful for the opportunity to pounce on every error of Ryan's.

Ryan seemed weak, unprepared and factually unsound.

I personally don't think EITHER candidate came off looking great, but Biden won on substance and his ability to own the debate.

Message edited 2012-10-12 09:25:48.903000.

Posted 10/12/12 9:24 AM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by KellyFG

Posted by MandJZ
He did admit it. He has. I'm not sure if you watched the DNC at all, but he very much said all that in his speech. He alluded to it in his debate as well, and Biden did too. Their point is that we ARE starting to see a recovery, it's slow but it's there. But I respectfully disagree that they haven't admitted it - they 100% have.



Going back to the link I posted and the proof that the president and his people lie about the current facts and their own track record, that confirms to me that they are not being entirely honest about it. I don't expect him to have a magic ball for the future but I do expect him to be an absolute EXPERT with 100% accuracy about our CURRENT state of affairs. There should be zero embellishment, zero tolerence for number fluffing. He is currently in charge, if he's proud of what he's done and would like to continue to do he should tell us the exact figures good or bad.



But haven't you said a few times in this thread that ALL politicians lie and are vague? Romney has lied and misrepresented and flip-flopped so many times it is hard to keep track. I understand your point, but I was responding to your comment about 'admitting it' by saying he has, and I stand by that.



Yes, all candidates lie. Its sad, but as the POTUS I hold him to a higher standard than his opponent. I expect the truth from him always and I have/will expect it from every president we have. The day they take that oath, we should all expect exemplary behavior and ethics from them!

Posted 10/12/12 9:25 AM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by KellyFG

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by KellyFG

Posted by MandJZ
He did admit it. He has. I'm not sure if you watched the DNC at all, but he very much said all that in his speech. He alluded to it in his debate as well, and Biden did too. Their point is that we ARE starting to see a recovery, it's slow but it's there. But I respectfully disagree that they haven't admitted it - they 100% have.



Going back to the link I posted and the proof that the president and his people lie about the current facts and their own track record, that confirms to me that they are not being entirely honest about it. I don't expect him to have a magic ball for the future but I do expect him to be an absolute EXPERT with 100% accuracy about our CURRENT state of affairs. There should be zero embellishment, zero tolerence for number fluffing. He is currently in charge, if he's proud of what he's done and would like to continue to do he should tell us the exact figures good or bad.



But haven't you said a few times in this thread that ALL politicians lie and are vague? Romney has lied and misrepresented and flip-flopped so many times it is hard to keep track. I understand your point, but I was responding to your comment about 'admitting it' by saying he has, and I stand by that.



Yes, all candidates lie. Its sad, but as the POTUS I hold him to a higher standard than his opponent. I expect the truth from him always and I have/will expect it from every president we have. The day they take that oath, we should all expect exemplary behavior and ethics from them!



We're going to have to agree to disagree on this, because I expect equally as ethical and exemplary behavior from the person TRYING to become POTUS.

Posted 10/12/12 9:26 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by luckyinlove

Posted by cds58019

Ehh I dont know. I think he needs to stop laughing while Ryan is speaking, it doesn't look professional on his part.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



this - it just irks me that this unprofessional, smug individual is one breath away from the presidency. Is that the person we want representing this country? Politics aside ... come on?

Posted 10/12/12 9:36 AM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by JennP

Posted by DandN

On substance, Biden won. Ryan refused to be specific on the Romney/Ryan tax plan, not saying what entitlements they would cut (except Sesame Street, apparently) and what loopholes they would close.

I'm sorry, but you can't cut taxes 20% across the board (which greatly benefits the wealthiest) and increase spending for the military, and make up the difference by closing tax loopholes, very few of which they have actually named. It doesn't work. The Congressional Budget Office has said it wouldn't work. The National Review has said it wouldn't work, along with many other publications and review boards.

Re: Afghanistan. I think Biden nailed Ryan when Ryan said we don't have troops in the RE section of Afghanistan, and Biden explained "that's the most dangerous area in the world - you want to put Americans over THERE?" Romney/Ryan can talk tough on foreign policy all they want, but we do not want any more troops in harm's way. We went to Afghanistan to find and kill Osama, and weaken his organization. It's time to leave.

The reason why it has been declared a draw by CNN, is (I think) because of Biden's laughing/smiling/interrupting. If Biden had been a bit more restrained, then I think he would have been overwhelmingly declared the winner.

I didn't have a problem with the interrupting because that goes on all the time in these debates- but as a long time Biden supporter, I kept saying to the tv "stop with the laughing, Joe - It's obnoxious."



100% agree

On another note, a good site that summarizes the candidate's plans in a pretty bipartisan way is presdebates.idebate.org. Check it out for great background on the issues.

Ladies, just get yourselves educated. Look past the smoke and mirrors of the debates. Read about the policies and analyze how they will affect YOU. I admit it's not easy. Americans are relatively uneducated about their finances, especially their "real" tax rate. If people REALLY read up on some of the policies that are being considered I think some people would rethink their choices.

That is all I can say right now without getting partisan.Chat Icon



Agree 100000%. I'm not the most educated person in general but this is how I research. I didn't watch more than a few minutes of the debate mostly because I really don't watch them and the Yankee game was on (see my priorities?) but as I stated in the thread last week, these are dog and pony shows. I just need to know the facts.

Posted 10/12/12 9:39 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by bookworm

I love how in American politics, voters are so often concerned with whether the candidate's personality makes you feel warm and fuzzy inside, rather than the actual policies, platforms and factual evidence.

To me, straight lying about the facts is a bigger crime than acting like a jerk.



they BOTH straight lied about MANY facts.

Posted 10/12/12 9:40 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Who's watching the debate?

and once it came to abortion, who gave Joe a sedative?

I was actually more impressed with the way Ryan handled abortion than I was Biden. As someone who is Pro Choice (within reason - not using abortion as birth control) I agree with Ryan's statements on abortion. Rape, incest, the health of the mother and I feel thats as it should be. Abortion has become a form of birth control in this country and that is unfortunate.

THIS was the topic I was waiting for. I did not get a clear message from Biden (well maybe I did, he is catholic yet still pro choice) but it didnt go beyond that and Martha asked for specifics, examples. Ryan went there. Biden did not. As long as abortion is legal under the guidelines set forth by Ryan, I can agree with that.

Posted 10/12/12 9:46 AM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by maymama

and once it came to abortion, who gave Joe a sedative?

I was actually more impressed with the way Ryan handled abortion than I was Biden. As someone who is Pro Choice (within reason - not using abortion as birth control) I agree with Ryan's statements on abortion. Rape, incest, the health of the mother and I feel thats as it should be. Abortion has become a form of birth control in this country and that is unfortunate.

THIS was the topic I was waiting for. I did not get a clear message from Biden (well maybe I did, he is catholic yet still pro choice) but it didnt go beyond that and Martha asked for specifics, examples. Ryan went there. Biden did not. As long as abortion is legal under the guidelines set forth by Ryan, I can agree with that.



See, I totally disagree. What I got from that is that abortion will NOT be legal except in the cases you mentioned. That seemed VERY clear to me and that is not okay by me. I think Biden was quite clear - the government and religion have no place in decisions between women and their medical providers.

Posted 10/12/12 9:49 AM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by maymama

and once it came to abortion, who gave Joe a sedative?

I was actually more impressed with the way Ryan handled abortion than I was Biden. As someone who is Pro Choice (within reason - not using abortion as birth control) I agree with Ryan's statements on abortion. Rape, incest, the health of the mother and I feel thats as it should be. Abortion has become a form of birth control in this country and that is unfortunate.

THIS was the topic I was waiting for. I did not get a clear message from Biden (well maybe I did, he is catholic yet still pro choice) but it didnt go beyond that and Martha asked for specifics, examples. Ryan went there. Biden did not. As long as abortion is legal under the guidelines set forth by Ryan, I can agree with that.



See, I totally disagree. What I got from that is that abortion will NOT be legal except in the cases you mentioned. That seemed VERY clear to me and that is not okay by me. I think Biden was quite clear - the government and religion have no place in decisions between women and their medical providers.



Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/12/12 9:50 AM
 

DandN
Twins are here!

Member since 3/06

3597 total posts

Name:
Deirdre

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by maymama

and once it came to abortion, who gave Joe a sedative?

I was actually more impressed with the way Ryan handled abortion than I was Biden. As someone who is Pro Choice (within reason - not using abortion as birth control) I agree with Ryan's statements on abortion. Rape, incest, the health of the mother and I feel thats as it should be. Abortion has become a form of birth control in this country and that is unfortunate.

THIS was the topic I was waiting for. I did not get a clear message from Biden (well maybe I did, he is catholic yet still pro choice) but it didnt go beyond that and Martha asked for specifics, examples. Ryan went there. Biden did not. As long as abortion is legal under the guidelines set forth by Ryan, I can agree with that.



Actually, Ryan said he wanted to overturn Roe V. Wade. He doesn't agree with an exception for cases of rape and incest. Romney wants an exemption in those cases, and Ryan is deferring to the top man on his ticket. He was a co sponsor of the Blunt Rubio amendment (in which ANY employer can deny ANY medical procedure if said employer has a moral argument with it), and an author of the personhood amendment, which would GREATLY restrict birth control availability.

I found Biden's answer more in keeping my own position - He's a Catholic and he's pro choice. Rather than focus on abortion, he chose to focus on the mission of social justice that has long been a part of the Catholic church. It was specifically because of the social justice position of the church that the council of American Bishops rejected the Ryan budget plan, because it was disproportionally unfair to the poor and middle class.

I was shocked that Ryan would go there re: Roe V. Wade. This is the law of the land and has been for 39 years. If you want to GREATLY decrease the number of abortions, the answer is not in making abortion illegal - just make birth control free and more readily available.

Posted 10/12/12 9:54 AM
 

kahlua716
3 Girls for Me!

Member since 8/07

12475 total posts

Name:
Keri

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by Missy

I hate that he keeps calling Paul Ryan "my friend".



This. It's demeaning.

I only caught the last 20 minutes or so on the radio, but that definitely irked me.

On the other hand I feel Biden had a much better answer to the "What would you say to the service member who is disgusted with the mudslinging campaigns" question.

Posted 10/12/12 9:55 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Who's watching the debate?

Posted by MandJZ

Further - I can NOT believe that in the year 2012 a VP candidate stood (sat) up there and flat out said that under their ticket Roe v. Wade would be overturned and abortion would be illegal ('except in the most extreme cases'). Every single Republican voter I have had conversations with over the past few months has ASSURED me that in this day, abortion is a given in this country and as a woman I have no need for concern. Well, apparently I do. I can not FATHOM this. Even in the abortion thread here a few days ago, most who identified as pro-life/anti-abortion didn't think it should be ILLEGAL, and that the government should have a say in that. Ryan flat out said he can not separate his religion from his life as a politician, and this is acceptable in a country where one of the fundamental tenets is the separation of church and state? I am appalled. People ask why this election, or the Romney/Ryan ticket scares liberal voters? Last night Paul Ryan proved why it does, and why it should.



do people realize that Romney/Ryan cannot make this decision themselves? Overturning Roe v. Wade does not lie in their hands but in the hands of the Supreme Court. Even if the SC overturned Roe V Wade, it wouldnt make abortion illegal, it would send the decision back to the states for the ultimate ruling on legality be each state.

Posted 10/12/12 9:55 AM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Who's watching Idol? Kierasmom 5/18/05 18 Families Helping Families ™
Chaotic (Britney/Kevin) - Who's watching? Leeners 5/17/05 40 Families Helping Families ™
Whose watching the SURVIVOR PALUA FINALE HarleyGirlFLA 5/15/05 26 Families Helping Families ™
Grandparent watching kids Redhead 5/13/05 32 Families Helping Families ™
anyone watching oprah luvsbob4603 5/12/05 6 Families Helping Families ™
who Dh falls asleep on the couch while watching tv luvsbob4603 5/11/05 32 Families Helping Families ™