Who is right?

Posted By Message

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Who is right?

Here is the scenario:

Person A is driving on a 4 lane road with a divider in the middle. Speed limit is 40mph. Driver is driving at the speed limit. It's 7:40pm. Not dark yet but not as "bright" as the middle of the afternoon.

Right after a big intersection with another 4 lane road, the road curves a bit.

50 Ft into the curved road, in the right lane, 2 people are doing in-line skating and are "cruising along" (person B and person C) Both are side by side taking the whole right lane. There is no shoulder. Only a sidewalk.

Person A sees them 30ft or so after the intersection and the curved road. Another car is in the left lane. Person A push on horn to tell them person B and C they don't belong on the road taking a whole lane and putting themself in danger.

Person B screams at person A for pushing on the horn and calls person A a maniac.

Who is right?

Posted 4/28/09 7:48 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: Who is right?

IMO, person B

i don't think a motorist should ever beep at pedestrians unless there's a very important reason. it could scare them and cause an accident.

isn't the law that you have to be under a certain age to ride on the sidewalk and everyone else must be in the street? i thought i remember hearing that years ago. if it's true, then person A is even more wrong.

Posted 4/28/09 7:54 PM
 

itkocak

Member since 7/07

7639 total posts

Name:

Re: Who is right?

Message edited 2011-11-28 20:36:42.427000.

Posted 4/28/09 8:05 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: Who is right?

I would say person B is in the right. I'm not sure how in-line skates are classified, but both bicycles and pedestrians have a right to be on the roadway unless otherwise posted, I would assume it is the same for in-line skates.

Posted 4/28/09 8:06 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Who is right?

Legally speaking, I believe if there were an accident, the driver is the one at fault.

But in my own little world of justice, it depends on the honk. If it was a beep-beep, Person B was out of line. If it was a long honk (the i aaaammm annooyyyed honk), then Person A was wrong for startling the pedestrians.

Either way, I don't think B needs to scream at A to further provoke the situation.

Posted 4/28/09 8:17 PM
 

nicrae
He's here!

Member since 12/06

9289 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Who is right?

I think person A did the right thing by letting the skaters know she was there. I don't think on a four lane highway skaters should be taking up an entire lane. If someone came around the curve too fast there would be a bad accident.

Posted 4/28/09 8:20 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Who is right?

Posted by NinaLemon

I would say person B is in the right. I'm not sure how in-line skates are classified, but both bicycles and pedestrians have a right to be on the roadway unless otherwise posted, I would assume it is the same for in-line skates.



In such case, they should not be side by side, right? I mean, bicycles are supposed to stay to the right side of the road unless they want to turn left which they are supposed to signal with hand signals. By the right side, I mean each one of them on the right side, one behind the other, NOT side by side in the right lane. Correct? I know that motorcycle are entitled to the entire lane like a car and if you pass them you must pass them by going a full lane around them to pass them not half way through a lane like you would do with a bicycle.

Are in-line skaters considered pedestrians?

Posted 4/28/09 8:22 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Who is right?

Posted by nrthshgrl

Legally speaking, I believe if there were an accident, the driver is the one at fault.

But in my own little world of justice, it depends on the honk. If it was a beep-beep, Person B was out of line. If it was a long honk (the i aaaammm annooyyyed honk), then Person A was wrong for startling the pedestrians.

Either way, I don't think B needs to scream at A to further provoke the situation.



Without a doubt person A would be at fault for hitting B and C. A pushed horn to "warn" them of the danger and to tell them to move aside and to cruise one in front of the other. Give the time it was too, the situation would be even more dangerous later on.

Posted 4/28/09 8:24 PM
 

LightUpOurLife
Totally in love

Member since 8/06

12785 total posts

Name:
Bonnie-Jean

Re: Who is right?

Unofrtunatley, legally, B is right. Morally, anyone should would say A though since it is a DIVIDED ROAD. We aren't talking a side street here.

Posted 4/28/09 8:27 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: Who is right?

Posted by smdl

Posted by NinaLemon

I would say person B is in the right. I'm not sure how in-line skates are classified, but both bicycles and pedestrians have a right to be on the roadway unless otherwise posted, I would assume it is the same for in-line skates.



In such case, they should not be side by side, right? I mean, bicycles are supposed to stay to the right side of the road unless they want to turn left which they are supposed to signal with hand signals. By the right side, I mean each one of them on the right side, one behind the other, NOT side by side in the right lane. Correct? I know that motorcycle are entitled to the entire lane like a car and if you pass them you must pass them by going a full lane around them to pass them not half way through a lane like you would do with a bicycle.

Are in-line skaters considered pedestrians?



Bicycles are actually entitled to an entire lane as well, they don't have to ride on the white line. My brother does long distance biking and you should hear the horror stories he tells of motorist not knowing they are supposed to share the road. That last 100 mile ride he went on his buddy was struck by a car because the driver tried to pass them and didn't allow enough room.

In the case with a bike, if they are in the lane and you don't have room to pass you have to slow down until you can pass, the bicyclists don't have to move out of the way.

Posted 4/28/09 8:32 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Who is right?

Posted by NinaLemon

Posted by smdl

Posted by NinaLemon

I would say person B is in the right. I'm not sure how in-line skates are classified, but both bicycles and pedestrians have a right to be on the roadway unless otherwise posted, I would assume it is the same for in-line skates.



In such case, they should not be side by side, right? I mean, bicycles are supposed to stay to the right side of the road unless they want to turn left which they are supposed to signal with hand signals. By the right side, I mean each one of them on the right side, one behind the other, NOT side by side in the right lane. Correct? I know that motorcycle are entitled to the entire lane like a car and if you pass them you must pass them by going a full lane around them to pass them not half way through a lane like you would do with a bicycle.

Are in-line skaters considered pedestrians?



Bicycles are actually entitled to an entire lane as well, they don't have to ride on the white line. My brother does long distance biking and you should hear the horror stories he tells of motorist not knowing they are supposed to share the road. That last 100 mile ride he went on his buddy was struck by a car because the driver tried to pass them and didn't allow enough room.

In the case with a bike, if they are in the lane and you don't have room to pass you have to slow down until you can pass, the bicyclists don't have to move out of the way.



I meant out of the way as in if you don't pass anyone you really should stay to the right. Anyway, yes there are rules on how many ft you have to clear to pass a bicycle.

Posted 4/28/09 8:42 PM
 

TheWhiteRabbit
Thru the rabbit hole!

Member since 7/06

4412 total posts

Name:

Re: Who is right?

Posted by niikki-8-18-06

I think person A did the right thing by letting the skaters know she was there. I don't think on a four lane highway skaters should be taking up an entire lane. If someone came around the curve too fast there would be a bad accident.


I agree with this, and I also think that bicyclists, skaters & joggers need to be more conscience of traffic. I often feel like bicyclists think they 'own the road' and cause traffic problems, like being in the middle of a one lane road causing cars to have to wait to pass them, when there is a large shoulder free of debris/traffic that they could be using. When I am jogging/walking/biking I try to be as courteous to the cars as I want them to be of to me. I am not trying to offend bicyclists out there, this is my experience in my area.

Posted 4/28/09 8:48 PM
 

Gertyrae
Peace out Homies!

Member since 5/05

20046 total posts

Name:
Gerty ®

Re: Who is right?

Pedestrians, Cyclists and In-Line Skaters all have right of way - Especially if there is no shoulder.
When there is no shoulder, cars must yield the lane to the pedestrian, cyclist or skater.
So, in the scenario above - the driver should have slowed down, waited until he/she was able to move into the left lane and safely pass the skaters.

And, most likely the reason they were skating side by side was to be more visible - someone would be more likely to try to pass them if they were one behind the other and they could get hit.


As AP said - when you are participating in outdoor sports on roads, you would be amazed at what drivers do and I've been hit by a car on a bike...it's not fun. All the car had to do was wait a few seconds to get around me, but he was in too much of a rush....and I was not in the middle of the road, but hugging the shoulder.

Posted 4/28/09 11:00 PM