Which Humidifier do you prefer?

Forum Opinion Poll
cool air 29 80.56%
warm air 6 16.67%
neither we have a vaporizer 1 2.78%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Which Humidifier w/ poll

Posted By Message

RandiG
Love my Boys!

Member since 7/09

4440 total posts

Name:
Randi

Which Humidifier w/ poll

did you girls register for cool air or warm air and why?

Posted 11/9/09 2:54 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Which Humidifier w/ poll

cool

eta: because when I was looking, that is what was suggested on LIF

Message edited 2009-11-09 15:09:39.287000.

Posted 11/9/09 3:09 PM
 

SuperLRN
Im a big boy now

Member since 5/08

2527 total posts

Name:

Re: Which Humidifier w/ poll

I just came from meeting with a pediatrician and he recommended we get a cool mist humidifier.

Posted 11/9/09 3:11 PM
 

RandiG
Love my Boys!

Member since 7/09

4440 total posts

Name:
Randi

Re: Which Humidifier w/ poll

I have been reading many sites and I am just so confused. I registered for warm air and when I came home my mom said that pediatricians suggest cool air. Then when I read about them, cool air doesn't kill bacterias. It is just way too confusing! Chat Icon

Posted 11/9/09 3:12 PM
 

SuperLRN
Im a big boy now

Member since 5/08

2527 total posts

Name:

Re: Which Humidifier w/ poll

Posted by RandiG

I have been reading many sites and I am just so confused. I registered for warm air and when I came home my mom said that pediatricians suggest cool air. Then when I read about them, cool air doesn't kill bacterias. It is just way too confusing! Chat Icon



The pediatrician told us that we need to clean teh cool air humdfier regularly with vinegar and water for this reason but he still recommends it over the warm mist.

We actually registered for the vicks warm mist germ free humidifier which we got at our shower but I will now be exchanging it for a cool one.

Posted 11/9/09 3:16 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Which Humidifier w/ poll

Posted by RandiG

I have been reading many sites and I am just so confused. I registered for warm air and when I came home my mom said that pediatricians suggest cool air. Then when I read about them, cool air doesn't kill bacterias. It is just way too confusing! Chat Icon



I don't think either one is going to kill bacteria. Think of it this way (as I did). When you are all stuffed up in the winter and you put the heat on in the car, you find it even harder to breathe. But if you turn the cool air on, somehow your sinuses clear up and you can breathe again.

The cool air feels better and it will do the same for DC.

Posted 11/9/09 3:17 PM
 

katiebug
I'll love you for always

Member since 2/08

4624 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: Which Humidifier w/ poll

Posted by neener1211

Posted by RandiG

I have been reading many sites and I am just so confused. I registered for warm air and when I came home my mom said that pediatricians suggest cool air. Then when I read about them, cool air doesn't kill bacterias. It is just way too confusing! Chat Icon



I don't think either one is going to kill bacteria. Think of it this way (as I did). When you are all stuffed up in the winter and you put the heat on in the car, you find it even harder to breathe. But if you turn the cool air on, somehow your sinuses clear up and you can breathe again.

The cool air feels better and it will do the same for DC.



This is a good point. I never really thought of it this way.

Posted 11/9/09 3:22 PM
 

RandiG
Love my Boys!

Member since 7/09

4440 total posts

Name:
Randi

Re: Which Humidifier w/ poll

Posted by katiebug

Posted by neener1211

Posted by RandiG

I have been reading many sites and I am just so confused. I registered for warm air and when I came home my mom said that pediatricians suggest cool air. Then when I read about them, cool air doesn't kill bacterias. It is just way too confusing! Chat Icon



I don't think either one is going to kill bacteria. Think of it this way (as I did). When you are all stuffed up in the winter and you put the heat on in the car, you find it even harder to breathe. But if you turn the cool air on, somehow your sinuses clear up and you can breathe again.

The cool air feels better and it will do the same for DC.



This is a good point. I never really thought of it this way.



ITA great point, thanks!

Posted 11/9/09 3:55 PM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: Which Humidifier w/ poll

cool air never worked for DS. only warm air does. so now that he's mobile, i just put it on top of his bookshelf so he can't reach it or the cord.

Posted 11/9/09 6:31 PM
 

summerBaby10
let's be nice

Member since 9/07

10208 total posts

Name:
Wifey

Re: Which Humidifier w/ poll

I registered for cool air.

Posted 11/9/09 7:10 PM
 

LoveMySMT09
<3mySMT.AJT

Member since 1/09

2623 total posts

Name:
VT

Re: Which Humidifier w/ poll

as with anything warm or hot related -- its more of a chance for bacterial growth. same reason the OR is soooo darn cold during your c-section Chat Icon


ive read that its highly suggested that people with immune problems stay away from warm mist humidifiers for the same reason

Posted 11/9/09 8:58 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Which Humidifier w/ poll

Posted by SuperLRN

Posted by RandiG

I have been reading many sites and I am just so confused. I registered for warm air and when I came home my mom said that pediatricians suggest cool air. Then when I read about them, cool air doesn't kill bacterias. It is just way too confusing! Chat Icon



The pediatrician told us that we need to clean teh cool air humdfier regularly with vinegar and water for this reason but he still recommends it over the warm mist.

We actually registered for the vicks warm mist germ free humidifier which we got at our shower but I will now be exchanging it for a cool one.



I have the Vicks Germ Free and I have to say...........it works GREAT! I love it. My ped. actually recommends the warm mist which is why we got that one. Chat Icon

Posted 11/9/09 9:43 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Which Humidifier w/ poll

Posted by RandiG

Posted by katiebug

Posted by neener1211

Posted by RandiG

I have been reading many sites and I am just so confused. I registered for warm air and when I came home my mom said that pediatricians suggest cool air. Then when I read about them, cool air doesn't kill bacterias. It is just way too confusing! Chat Icon



I don't think either one is going to kill bacteria. Think of it this way (as I did). When you are all stuffed up in the winter and you put the heat on in the car, you find it even harder to breathe. But if you turn the cool air on, somehow your sinuses clear up and you can breathe again.

The cool air feels better and it will do the same for DC.



This is a good point. I never really thought of it this way.



ITA great point, thanks!



Except.................heat is dry, dry air. Warm mist humidifiers are putting warm, wet droplets in the air which are amazing at clearing congestion. Humid, hot air is not the same as hot, dry air.

Posted 11/9/09 9:46 PM
 

munchkinfacemama
LOVE

Member since 11/07

15800 total posts

Name:
<FONT COLOR="#FF0099">Michelle</FONT>

Re: Which Humidifier w/ poll

I've always heard cool is better. I forget why that is though.

Posted 11/9/09 11:43 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Which humidifier and safety gate did you register for? IrishMom77 2/24/08 4 Pregnancy
Looking for a cool mist humidifier that is easy to clean and doesn't leak! itsbabytime 1/23/08 6 Parenting
How do you clean the filter in your humidifier? LaPetiteSirène 1/19/08 1 Home
Vicks Filter-Free Humidifier...how do I clean it? johnsae 11/19/07 0 Parenting
do you use the humidifier only when sick or in the winter? KittyCat 8/25/07 11 Parenting
vaporizer vs. humidifier & hot vs. cold Charly 2/13/07 5 Parenting