Which car would you buy

Posted By Message

chilltocam
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

9141 total posts

Name:

Which car would you buy

I am looking to buy a new car, but am so undecided about what to get. I like the design of both of the 2 cars I am deciding between, but one comes in colors that I like more. They are both "fully loaded" (navigation, leather, moonroof,etc), but the one with better color options also has more "bells and whistles". But I like the way the other one (less color options and fewer "extras") drives/handles better. Both have good reliability ratings, but the one with less options has a bit more "prestige", if you can call it that (so possibly better re-sale). They are pretty similar in price - not enough difference to make the decision any easier. Which one would you go for?

Message edited 2012-06-25 12:23:59.033000.

Posted 6/25/12 10:53 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Which car to buy

It sounds like it's a matter of driveability vs gadgets. I would probably lean towards the car I would be more comfortable driving all the time. Whatever color you get, you'll get used to it, and after a while, you won't even notice the color anymore. If a car isn't as nice to drive, you'll notice that all the time.

Posted 6/25/12 11:09 AM
 

MrsS1976
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/11

534 total posts

Name:
M

Which car would you buy

which 2 models are you deciding between?

Message edited 2012-06-27 23:56:30.903000.

Posted 6/25/12 2:39 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Which car would you buy

The one that drove better, unless I really couldn't live without some of the missing features.

Posted 6/25/12 2:48 PM
 

chilltocam
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

9141 total posts

Name:

Which car would you buy

I am deciding between a Nissan Maxima or Acura TL

Posted 6/25/12 2:49 PM
 

moonmist09
Thank you, St. Gerard!

Member since 2/11

5043 total posts

Name:
Antonella

Re: Which car would you buy

Posted by chilltocam

I am deciding between a Nissan Maxima or Acura TL



are you looking at new cars?
i only ask because we just bought a new Acura TL and it was over $40K with all th bells and whistles.
My sister just bought a new Maxima and it was A LOT less than what we paid for the Acura, so i'm not sure what models you are looking at that the price wouldn't be that much of a difference Chat Icon

Acura is considered a luxury car and honestly, drives wonderfully. It maneuvers well and is dependable. The resale value is amazing, it ccan really retain its value if you take care of it.
My DH works for acura now, but he has worked at Nissan and Honda before as a tech and we were just talking the other day about the new Maxima. I was saying how i really liked the shape but he was saying that after 2000, every single year of Maxima's produced afterwards has had recalls and problems where clients are always coming in for one problem or another.
Obviously, many of these cars could have been "lemons" but after all he has told me i wouldn't chance it.

Good Luck!

Posted 6/25/12 3:02 PM
 

MrsS1976
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/11

534 total posts

Name:
M

Which car would you buy

I'd go with the Acura hands down.

Posted 6/25/12 3:10 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Which car would you buy

According to Consumer Reports, the Acura has very high Owner Satisfaction and Reliability, while the Nissan has only average for both (they make an educated guess based on the last 3 years of history). Owner cost for both is the same, and they're both kind of low. Owner cost includes depreciation, repairs, insurance, fuel, etc. The Acura has a much higher price range than the Nissan, though. An entry level Acura is about the same as a loaded Nissan.

The 2011 reliability is very high for all components of the car in both vehicles.

Posted 6/25/12 3:14 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: Which car would you buy

Posted by MrsS1976

I'd go with the Acura hands down.



Yep!

Posted 6/25/12 3:16 PM
 

chilltocam
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

9141 total posts

Name:

Re: Which car would you buy

Posted by moonmist09

Posted by chilltocam

I am deciding between a Nissan Maxima or Acura TL



are you looking at new cars?
i only ask because we just bought a new Acura TL and it was over $40K with all th bells and whistles.
My sister just bought a new Maxima and it was A LOT less than what we paid for the Acura, so i'm not sure what models you are looking at that the price wouldn't be that much of a difference Chat Icon

Acura is considered a luxury car and honestly, drives wonderfully. It maneuvers well and is dependable. The resale value is amazing, it ccan really retain its value if you take care of it.
My DH works for acura now, but he has worked at Nissan and Honda before as a tech and we were just talking the other day about the new Maxima. I was saying how i really liked the shape but he was saying that after 2000, every single year of Maxima's produced afterwards has had recalls and problems where clients are always coming in for one problem or another.
Obviously, many of these cars could have been "lemons" but after all he has told me i wouldn't chance it.

Good Luck!



Acura has an incentive program right now, so the cost of the Acura with the technology package is about the same as the Maxima loaded with every possible option (both have sticker prices of about $40K). That's great to know about the recalls and problems. Thanks!

Message edited 2012-06-25 15:23:41.127000.

Posted 6/25/12 3:22 PM
 

FirstMate
My lil cowboy

Member since 10/10

7790 total posts

Name:

Re: Which car would you buy

You can't lose with either car. I have owned a Maxima and have driven Acuras in the past. Both are great cars with little to no maintenance (in my experience). Since they are rather comparable, I would look at gas mileage. That would definitely be a deciding factor for me. Also bear in mind that an Acura will be more expensive to repair and maintain. That's part of the "prestige" that comes with owning a luxury vehicle. Chat Icon

Posted 6/25/12 4:06 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Which car would you buy

I never buy on 'prestige' since I keep my cars long term. Resell value means little to nothing to me. I am all in for comfort and extras I'll need. A fancy car is nice but if I'm not happy with the extras that I got free for a cheaper car, I won't buy it. Bells & Whistles and comfort while driving are big for me.

Which could be why I drive Mazdas I get all the bells and whistles and a good price, I never buy new and keep my cars for 10plus years every time. They've never died on me. I've always just traded in around 10-12 yrs or 115k-130k miles. Upkeep is cheap and my cars keep their 'appeal' for me as well.

Posted 6/25/12 4:13 PM
 

CSK
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/11

892 total posts

Name:

Which car would you buy

First, I would make sure you're getting a good price for each, I normally check out carsdirect.com and truecar.com

Looking at what they have, if you load up the max or TL with tech, you're around $35K assuming you get their rebates.

I owned a maxima, it was nice, and pretty loaded, I bought it used. the new one is really nice too, but I don't think I'm up for pay 35K for a new one. the other thing I noticed, it wasn't a cheap car to maintain, and when things broke on it, it cost $$ as well. I felt it had the maintance bills of a luxary car.

Acura no direct experience except I own a honda. I would think it will be more reliable than the Nissan assuming you don't get a lemon.

I would personally go with whatever car you like driving more. the gizmos I feel will get old. Although for that matter, I don't knwo what extra you're getting in one vs the other, they both are pretty loaded.

a 5 year old Acura I would think is worth more than a 5 year old maxima.

Posted 6/25/12 4:49 PM
 

chilltocam
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

9141 total posts

Name:

Re: Which car would you buy

Posted by CSK

Looking at what they have, if you load up the max or TL with tech, you're around $35K assuming you get their rebates.




Yes, that's the price range they are both in. The Acura would be about $4K more (still in my price range) if I decide to go with the AWD and advanced package, but is pretty much the same price as the fully loaded Maxima if I got it with just the tech package.

Message edited 2012-06-25 17:12:09.610000.

Posted 6/25/12 4:57 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Which car would you buy

I have the maxima loaded. Honestly I have never owned a better car.

I lease it and I will buy this car off the lease and I have never done that before.

If they were the same price not sure what I would do.

I've never owned an Acura but they have excellent reputations.

I know that there is usually more negotiating room with Nissan.

Posted 6/25/12 5:09 PM
 

anonymoususer
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

3393 total posts

Name:

Re: Which car would you buy

how funny- i have an acura (tsx-the smaller 'tl') and we got a maxima too, as my husbands car

i like the maxima
i LOVE the acura

i love the way acuras handle

just based on that alone, id get the acura.

that being said, i dont remember what you wrote about pricing, but if pricing were the same id go for the acura- if money were an issue, id go for the cheaper of the two...

Posted 6/26/12 2:40 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
when buying a car what does a smart buy and smart lease program mean? 04bride 8/27/07 6 Families Helping Families ™
Can you buy a pretty decent used car for $10,000? BigB 7/3/07 7 Families Helping Families ™
Opinions...Is it better to buy or lease a car?? beautyq115 6/27/07 40 Families Helping Families ™
When is the best time to buy a new car? chikita315 4/5/07 15 Families Helping Families ™
Which type of car seat should I buy? Convertible or Booster? Tany 3/23/07 8 Parenting
If you were in the market for a NEW car under $25K, what would you buy? SweetestOfPeas 3/16/07 27 Families Helping Families ™