When did you start disciplining your DC?

Posted By Message

jambalady
Is it summer yet?

Member since 8/06

7392 total posts

Name:
Holly

When did you start disciplining your DC?

At what age do they understand discipline and what type of discipline?

DS is 13 mos and I'm not sure yet if he is old enough to understand discipline.

I feel sometimes like he is still a baby but then if I don't discipline him he will think his behavior is acceptable.

For example, throwing food on the floor when he is in his highchair. I say no sternly, but do I take his food/spoon/fork away after a certain number of times? I want him to eat but I don't want him thinking it is okay to constantly play with his food instead of eating.

or standing up when I am giving him his bath. if I sit him back down too many times he has a tantrum.

or when I take a toy away from him or don't give him something he wants, he has a tantrum.

I'm just not sure how stern I should be at this age . . .

Posted 6/10/09 2:04 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: When did you start disciplining your DC?

I started with time outs at 14 months and DS totally get that its not a good thing.

I started because he throws things out of anger. So he would throw his bottle or sippy cup. I give him 2 chances if he does it a 3rd time I wisk him off to a chair in the middle of my kitchen. I tell him very sternly that it was bad etc and I leave him there...at first I used to sit a few feet away with a very mad face on. But now I leave ht room. He never moves! Its actually funny.

It has helped with the throwing specifically of his bottle, now he may do it 1x and then he will raise his arm to do it again and stop and hand it to me instead! He still throws the tandrum but at least no one is getting hit with a flying bottle! Chat Icon

I will say that I have hit him on his hand when he continually feeds the dog his lunch after me telling him 100x not to. That backfired, for 3 days he made me feel horrible because every time I said the word no, he hit his own hand! So we dont do that anymore.

Posted 6/10/09 2:39 PM
 

FreeButterfly
hum...

Member since 5/05

6263 total posts

Name:

Re: When did you start disciplining your DC?

I think we started time outs about 12 months. Basically I think DS just realized that he was playing w/ toys, mommy yelled and now i'm here - hey I want to play with my toys again. Most of the time he cried but then he didn't repeat the behavior for a few days.

I'm not sure if he knew what was going on but it made us feel better that we were proactive.

Now he's 16 months and if you tell him to do something and he doens't and we say do it or time out - or do you want time out he'll shake his head no and do what we say (most of the time).

We take away all toys, bottles/cups, binkies and make him sit in the corner for about 1 minute.

I think that's the general rule - 1 minute per year.

Good luck


ETA: Sometimes when he would hit I'd hold him arms at his side and say "no hit". If DC thows the cup they could think its a game if you keep picking it up. We gave our son 1 chance as an oops. Then it sat on the floor.
Sometimes what comes across as anger is fustration b/c they can't communicate.

Message edited 2009-06-10 14:59:05.013000.

Posted 6/10/09 2:57 PM
 

MrsSteflily
I love chocolate

Member since 4/06

2047 total posts

Name:
Stef

Re: When did you start disciplining your DC?

We just started at 12 months.

DD throws food and her sippy from the high chair. She gets 2 warnings and then for the third offense, she faces the wall in her HC for 1 minute.

She knows she is doing something wrong when she does it. She looks at you waiting for the "No" to throw it. We know she's testing. I'm not sure if she gets the connection yet. But we want to be consistent.

Posted 6/10/09 3:06 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: When did you start disciplining your DC?

with the throwing of the food, I never did TO's, to me, that means that the child is not hungry and I would take dd out of her highchair when she started that Chat Icon

Posted 6/10/09 3:12 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: When did you start disciplining your DC?

I started early...probably 12 mos.

the throwing food I did not tolerate.

Throw it once, was told to stop.
throw it again, the meal is over. He learned quick.

hitting, biting I have zero tolerance. was sent to his room early on.

At 18 mos, I made a big deal out of not listening or crying for no reason. I have very little patience for TO. I figured if i acted like what he was doing was soooo wacky that he would not do it...and it worked.

Posted 6/10/09 3:19 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: When did you start disciplining your DC?

I don't do timeouts yet (almost 8 months old), but I already tell him 'No' in a stern voice if he is arching his back and kicking his feet so he shimmies down and out of his boppy seat (which he now does)Chat Icon . I tell him "No, you are going to hurt yourself." And then I fix him in the chair. He may not understand what I am saying, but I think he does understand that my tone is not pleasant.

My mom told me she had to tell him no the other day bc he was trying to tip the bumbo chair while she was feeding him (she was sitting there with him). She said she felt bad telling him no, but he needs to learn sometime. I agreed.

I figure the earlier I start with the small stuff, the better the transition will be when he really starts doing things that are wrong. Chat Icon

Posted 6/10/09 3:25 PM
 

jambalady
Is it summer yet?

Member since 8/06

7392 total posts

Name:
Holly

Re: When did you start disciplining your DC?

Thanks ladies. I will definitely take your suggestions and start taking things away if he is throwing them and maybe short time outs as well.

Posted 6/10/09 3:33 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: When did you start disciplining your DC?

We didnt have too many problems early on, and so we just recently started at 2.

We tried time outs but they were useless to us. We are lucky in a sense, we have someone from Early intervention come to our house weekly and she assists us with these issues and couls show us how time out was not working. He wouls fight so much to get up , he lost total track of what was going on, and why. If you can get them to sit in time out quickly they are more successful at being a form of discipline.

We have had better success with trying to get him to understand consequences.

When he would throw food, he got out of the high chair, even if he only ate one bite. ( and I still say if they are past 14-15 months old, try a booster seat if they throw food).

When he hits now we take away a privlege...no going outside after dinner, etc. But the child has to be old enough to understand that.

We take away toys until he apologizes ( this so far has worked the BEST)...

A stern voice and dissapointment in the voice may help at his age, as I'm sure he hates to dissapoint you.
Good luck!!

Posted 6/10/09 4:09 PM
 

JandJ1224

Member since 6/06

5911 total posts

Name:
Jannette

Re: When did you start disciplining your DC?

Posted by neener1211

I don't do timeouts yet (almost 8 months old), but I already tell him 'No' in a stern voice if he is arching his back and kicking his feet so he shimmies down and out of his boppy seat (which he now does)Chat Icon . I tell him "No, you are going to hurt yourself." And then I fix him in the chair. He may not understand what I am saying, but I think he does understand that my tone is not pleasant.

My mom told me she had to tell him no the other day bc he was trying to tip the bumbo chair while she was feeding him (she was sitting there with him). She said she felt bad telling him no, but he needs to learn sometime. I agreed.

I figure the earlier I start with the small stuff, the better the transition will be when he really starts doing things that are wrong. Chat Icon



At 9 mo's my DD is a nightmare on the changing table and my tells me I need to be stern with her and tell her NO when she starts squirming. She really just laughs at me. I don't know when the right time is to start being firm

Posted 6/10/09 4:19 PM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: When did you start disciplining your DC?

I think I'm against the majority here, but I've never been a big believer in a stern voice, unless it's something really big and dangerous. I don't think my dad ever raised his voice to me (actually, once when I was 15 or 16, but that's really it) and I always listened to him. I was never really punished either...never sent to my room, never not allowed out, etc. It was more disappoinment if I ever did anything wrong. And lots of reasoning---he would explain why I couldn't do things I did use a stern voice with my DD (I think when she was about 5 months) not as discipline, but as a reaction. She was about to grab something or put something in her mouth that was dangerous, and I said no sternly, but really as a reaction. She stopped and looked at me all serious. I like to save it for that. I know I'm not in the majority here

Posted 6/10/09 4:23 PM
 

Octobermom
LIF Adult

Member since 1/09

972 total posts

Name:
Anna Maria

Re: When did you start disciplining your DC?

Posted by neener1211

I don't do timeouts yet (almost 8 months old), but I already tell him 'No' in a stern voice if he is arching his back and kicking his feet so he shimmies down and out of his boppy seat (which he now does)Chat Icon . I tell him "No, you are going to hurt yourself." And then I fix him in the chair. He may not understand what I am saying, but I think he does understand that my tone is not pleasant.

My mom told me she had to tell him no the other day bc he was trying to tip the bumbo chair while she was feeding him (she was sitting there with him). She said she felt bad telling him no, but he needs to learn sometime. I agreed.

I figure the earlier I start with the small stuff, the better the transition will be when he really starts doing things that are wrong. Chat Icon




I have an eight month old and I say No once in a while but I think its a little too early for him to make the connection. If there's something he's doing that I don't want him to do I just take him out of that situation.

He arches his back when I put him the stroller, but I basically just talk to him if he's crying or give him something to distract him. They don't have words yet so actions are also ways that they communicate.

Posted 6/10/09 9:44 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: When did you start disciplining your DC?

We started TOs at 14 months. I didnt think he was old enough either to "get it" but he totally did and he stayed there. The first few times we picked him up and put him back without talking to him until he completed his one minute but he got the hang of it quickly.

Posted 6/10/09 9:46 PM
 

FreeButterfly
hum...

Member since 5/05

6263 total posts

Name:

Re: When did you start disciplining your DC?

Posted by mamabear

I think I'm against the majority here, but I've never been a big believer in a stern voice, unless it's something really big and dangerous. I don't think my dad ever raised his voice to me (actually, once when I was 15 or 16, but that's really it) and I always listened to him. I was never really punished either...never sent to my room, never not allowed out, etc. It was more disappoinment if I ever did anything wrong. And lots of reasoning---he would explain why I couldn't do things I did use a stern voice with my DD (I think when she was about 5 months) not as discipline, but as a reaction. She was about to grab something or put something in her mouth that was dangerous, and I said no sternly, but really as a reaction. She stopped and looked at me all serious. I like to save it for that. I know I'm not in the majority here



I can see disappointment at an older age - I would rather get in trouble w/ no tv then have my mom say she was dissapointed in me. But how does that work with a 12-24 month old? Do you think they understand disappointment as much as they understand I want that toy and I can't have it or a stern voice? I feel like when I try rationalizing with him he just has a puzzled look on his face - he's 16 months now.

Posted 6/11/09 8:45 AM
 

mikeswife06
Drama Momma

Member since 9/06

9947 total posts

Name:
Anne

Re: When did you start disciplining your DC?

Posted by Kelly9904


I will say that I have hit him on his hand when he continually feeds the dog his lunch after me telling him 100x not to. That backfired, for 3 days he made me feel horrible because every time I said the word no, he hit his own hand! So we dont do that anymore.




Oh my goodness. How sad was that Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 6/11/09 8:48 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: When did you start disciplining your DC?

We started TO at 18 months and so far have only done it for hitting. When she hits she gets a warning.

If she hits again, I tell her we don't hit and it's time for a TO. I hold her on my lap, facing away from me and count to 30. She cries the entire time. Then I tell her again that we do not hit and that we love her, and then I hug her.

When she is 2, we'll start a TO mat.

Food throwing, she gets one warning and then the meal is over.

Posted 6/11/09 9:09 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spinoff to Disciplining FireIslandLove 5/14/07 6 Parenting
Disciplining twins? Michelle 4/18/07 4 Multiple Births
Disciplining Your Dog jnico 9/7/06 4 Pets
Disciplining a 5 months - I need advice!!! AnnBrunoXO 7/16/06 10 Parenting
Disciplining?? dree 6/6/06 9 Parenting
Spinoff...Who does the disciplining in your home? Mommyof2 5/17/06 22 Families Helping Families ™