What would you do?

Forum Opinion Poll
Guy #1 - save money and take my chances. 2 3.03%
Guy #2 - more money, better peace of mind. 57 86.36%
Other (please explain) 2 3.03%
Don't fence me in. 2 3.03%
We don't need no stinking fences. 0 0.00%
Shut UP with the fence crap already! SHEESH! ;-) 3 4.55%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

What would you do? [Poll]

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

greenfreak
.

Member since 9/06

11483 total posts

Name:
greenfreak

What would you do? [Poll]

My fence saga continues...

I have narrowed down all my quotes to two choices.

#1.... I have a rock-bottom quote from a guy who barely speaks english. He is a contractor who has done business with the family of my neighbor. I don't know my neighbor well enough to trust her reccomendation.

Rock-bottom quote guy has a hard time understanding what I want, or even how to spell my first name. (Tricia. It's not hard.) I have to point to pictures in his catalog from a supply company named Illusions. I have a feeling that his crew will be the best of what's available at the 7-11 parking lot, if you know what I mean.

When I asked him for a copy of his license, he was evasive. He said he had to go down to Town Hall to get it - I said WHAT? You don't have a license? He said yes, he does, he just needed to have it renewed. Chat Icon

He missed an appointment he had with me at 5pm tonight - and I only found out when I called him at 5:30 that he wasn't coming.

...

#2.... I have a decent quote from Liberty Fence. They were the lowest of the big guys - Rose fence, Suffolk County, North Shore, etc.

They make their own fencing, have their own catalogs, website, license, insurance, and full-time employed crews. Their quote is about $300-$900 above the other guy.

Liberty says the guy is undercutting them so much because their fence grade is substandard, that they're just getting it from a supply company like you would Home Depot. And he could give me a much lower price too if I want the same lower grade. That their fence is a higher quality, and so are their crews, thus the higher quote. I really don't know if all vinyl is created equal or not, so I don't know if this is just a line.

Guy #1 can do it with "one day notice". Liberty says 4-5 weeks. I'm not in DIRE need but of course I want a fence as soon as possible.


So there you have it. Choice #1 - save $300 to $900 but possibly have a permit/quality worry on my hands. Or Choice #2 - pay more, wait longer, but have better peace of mind.

What would you do?

Message edited 2008-09-10 20:19:17.000000.

Posted 9/10/08 8:16 PM
 
Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Long Island Weddings

Tracy705
LIF Infant

Member since 5/08

301 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

we used liberty and they were in the middle of the row quote. I am very happy with my fence. 2 sides of my yard are amendolas fence and I can def. see the difference in quality!!

Posted 9/10/08 8:24 PM
 

strongisland
All you need is love

Member since 8/07

2474 total posts

Name:
T

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

i would try wayside---they have great quality if not wayside---i would go w/liberty b/c they understand what you want, if there is a problem down the road you can call them and hopefully they will resove it since they are a big company, this is what they do everyday in comparison to how the crew might be from the other guy, etc....i always go the 'safe' route!

Posted 9/10/08 8:31 PM
 

MommyTeffi
Yummy!!!

Member since 2/06

1827 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

I would go with #2. The whole not having a license ( or copy) and missing an appointment would be a deal breaker. I would spend the extra money. I would be concerned with #1 taking your money and running. I have seen it happen way to many times.

Posted 9/10/08 8:33 PM
 

PotofLuck06
Our Baby Boy Is Here!!!

Member since 11/06

13241 total posts

Name:
Betsy

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

When it comes to your home, it's better to be safe than sorry. I'd go with #2.

Posted 9/10/08 9:40 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

Installing fence is not rocket science. I had a guy from craigslist do my gate and he did a good job. PVC Gate gost me $450 when the fence company wanted over $1000 installed.

I would see if guy #1 would come down in price more. If you can get the job cheaper I would probably go for #1. If it's only a $300 difference then i'd probably go with #2.

I wouldn't use "he barely speaks english" against him. Some of the best guys I had working in my house couldn't speak a word of english.

Posted 9/10/08 10:17 PM
 

Elizabeth
Mom of Three

Member since 9/05

7900 total posts

Name:
"MOMMY!!!"

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

I would go with #2. Maybe installing a fence seems easy and on some properties it is, some can be trickier. We have what looks to be flat property but it apparently isn't. Our fence was put up by a crew who clearly didn't know how to deal with this issue and still keep the fence at 6 feet tall and look good on the bottom. It was a few inches above 6 feet and I told my DH that there was no way it would pass inspection. We called the company and they said they would come back and redo it if it didn't pass but they deal with my town all the time and it would most likely be fine. I knew they were wrong and drove to their office to have them put it in writing. It didn't pass inspection and to their credit, they came back very fast and sent a much more experienced crew to redo it and it came out beautiful. But it was a big hassle.

I wouldn't hold the barely speaks English part against anyone either except if I am trying to make my wishes clean and they don't understand, then as a customer that's a problem to me. No license is a problem too unless it's my BIL helping my DH in a DIY job or a friend. A friend of a friend of a friend without a license and no chance to see their previous work doesn't appeal to me. I hate the idea of spending more than the lowest, we just went through this with getting siding done. It might go OK but it might not and if you have any trepidation already, I'd go with #2.

Posted 9/10/08 11:06 PM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

#2 or get another opion.

My mom always told me not to go with the lowest or highest. Chat Icon

If you go with #1, make sure the permit deal is taken care of!

My parents got me hooked on Holmes on Homes & I am so suspicious of contractors, etc, now!

Posted 9/11/08 12:06 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

#2 or wait a bit longer (which you said you can't!) for an even better quote.

Problems with #1:
- No licence so most likely not insured (imagine he damages something: sewer line, does something to the house, etc...)
- How is he going to install a fence the way you want it if he can't understand you?

I would go back to Liberty Fence and tell them you really want them to do the job but you have other people who can do it sooner. Doing it sooner (even just 1-2 weeks!!) would swing your vote in their favor.

Message edited 2008-09-11 07:24:39.547000.

Posted 9/11/08 7:24 AM
 

greenfreak
.

Member since 9/06

11483 total posts

Name:
greenfreak

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

Posted by Elizabeth

I wouldn't hold the barely speaks English part against anyone either except if I am trying to make my wishes clean and they don't understand, then as a customer that's a problem to me.



I wouldn't either, with the same exception in mind. He made me write my name because he couldn't write the letters himself. And circle the item numbers in the book so he could copy them onto his paper. There was no official paperwork or quote, just a piece of lined paper that he kept. I got nothing guaranteeing the price or materials.

Like I said, he had a hard time understanding me to the point I had to stop talking and use hand gestures. Point to the picture. Hold my hand flat out next to me and say four. feet. high. Chat Icon

I wish I was kidding. But if there's a language barrier, how is he going to express what I want to the crew and get it right? Call me crazy but I'd expect someone doing business with people who speak fluent English to be fluent themselves. At least enough to understand letters, numbers, and be able to write them down correctly.

We feel like the dollar amount should not be the only factor here - and we were curious if others felt the same. But it would still feel silly to pay more for the "same" product although the guy from Liberty insists they're not the same quality.

Posted 9/11/08 8:21 AM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

Guy #1's quote is lower b/c he is not a legitimate business based upon what you said. Is he insured? Paying Workers Comp? Bonded? I would check that out before any of his workers stepped foot on my property. One of his workers gets hurt on your property, you could be in bigger trouble than with your average, properly insured business.

Nothing about what you have described makes me believe that he is operating his business totally legally...

ETA -- and nothing about my post has anything to do with the language barrier at all.

Message edited 2008-09-11 08:32:34.677000.

Posted 9/11/08 8:28 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

Posted by greenfreak

Posted by Elizabeth

I wouldn't hold the barely speaks English part against anyone either except if I am trying to make my wishes clean and they don't understand, then as a customer that's a problem to me.



I wouldn't either, with the same exception in mind. He made me write my name because he couldn't write the letters himself. And circle the item numbers in the book so he could copy them onto his paper. There was no official paperwork or quote, just a piece of lined paper that he kept. I got nothing guaranteeing the price or materials.

Like I said, he had a hard time understanding me to the point I had to stop talking and use hand gestures. Point to the picture. Hold my hand flat out next to me and say four. feet. high. Chat Icon

I wish I was kidding. But if there's a language barrier, how is he going to express what I want to the crew and get it right? Call me crazy but I'd expect someone doing business with people who speak fluent English to be fluent themselves. At least enough to understand letters, numbers, and be able to write them down correctly.

We feel like the dollar amount should not be the only factor here - and we were curious if others felt the same. But it would still feel silly to pay more for the "same" product although the guy from Liberty insists they're not the same quality.



All PVC is not created equal. That's correct!

I would not want a bunch of uninsured people working on such project.

Posted 9/11/08 9:19 AM
 

mamochk
LIF Toddler

Member since 11/06

379 total posts

Name:
Alison

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

Liberty installed PVC fence around our neighbors yard (their backyard buts up against ours) and it looks good. We are going give them a call this fall/winter to do our side fence(s). If you are not in dire need of a fence wait a couple months when their business slows and you should get a lower quote.

Posted 9/11/08 9:56 AM
 

JldDolphin

Member since 1/07

6929 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

I would go with Contractor #2. Believe me, we went through the same thing with a contractor that did speak English well and when we came home things were a little different then me & my DH thought we had agreed to. It wasn't anything that crazy and the price was right even though things weren't exactly what we expect, but in the end my DH said, we probably should have hired someone else. So I think for me, from now on I want someone I can understand and someone that completely understands me. This is just my opinion.

Posted 9/11/08 3:26 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: What would you do? [Poll]



We feel like the dollar amount should not be the only factor here - and we were curious if others felt the same. But it would still feel silly to pay more for the "same" product although the guy from Liberty insists they're not the same quality.

You're not only paying for a product, you're also paying for a service and for certain protections. When you factor in the communication issues and most imporantly the insurance issues, contractor #2 is likely a much, much better deal, even if the fencing material both contractors use is identical.

Posted 9/11/08 3:35 PM
 

greenfreak
.

Member since 9/06

11483 total posts

Name:
greenfreak

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

I agree. I have guy #1 coming back tonight for a new quote but it's just a formality at this point, to kind of reinforce the decision we will probably make.

Liberty has something like 10 and 15 year warranties on not just the material but the labor too. And I definitely am the kind of person who would get them back there if I wasn't satisfied. I'm a PITA like that. Chat Icon

Posted 9/11/08 3:51 PM
 

Superkat
More a stranger than a friend

Member since 5/06

9730 total posts

Name:
K

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

Posted by MommyTeffi

I would go with #2. The whole not having a license ( or copy) and missing an appointment would be a deal breaker. I would spend the extra money. I would be concerned with #1 taking your money and running. I have seen it happen way to many times.



Agreed. My neighbor recommend my tiling guy and you remember how THAT fiasco went. We lost thousands in material and cash. Go with the reputable company and tell them to put a rush on it. Chat Icon

Posted 9/11/08 3:59 PM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

Im a firm believer in " you get what you pay for".

Go for the second guy, 700-900 extra above a group of 7-11 parking lot guys is worth the piece of mind. JMO

Posted 9/11/08 3:59 PM
 

legallyblonde
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/08

850 total posts

Name:
K

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

From what I'm reading, guy #1 makes me nervous. For one, if he isn't a legit business, without permits, insurance, etc. you could have reliability and liability issues. Second, if he can't understand what you are saying, you may not get what you want.

My DH is a contractor. It's a shady business so definitely go with someone you are sure is legit. It's not worth any aggravation it may cause you to save a couple of bucks.

FWIW, my MIL used Rose Fence and she was very pleased with the work, the timeliness and the price.

Posted 9/11/08 4:07 PM
 

JldDolphin

Member since 1/07

6929 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

Posted by greenfreak

I agree. I have guy #1 coming back tonight for a new quote but it's just a formality at this point, to kind of reinforce the decision we will probably make.

Liberty has something like 10 and 15 year warranties on not just the material but the labor too. And I definitely am the kind of person who would get them back there if I wasn't satisfied. I'm a PITA like that. Chat Icon



I think with something like a fence I would want the 10-15 year warranty over the lesser price. At least you can call Liberty back to your house in 5 years if something went wrong. Guy #1 probably wouldn't have his phone number anymore in 5 years. I would go with the warranty over the price. GL can't wait to see how it comes out.

Posted 9/11/08 4:10 PM
 

greenfreak
.

Member since 9/06

11483 total posts

Name:
greenfreak

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

My gut instinct was right.

He shows up half an hour late again. This time he was next door at my neighbor's house. He gives me the photocopy of the license but it's not in his name! It's some guy from a landscaping company. He blamed it on the town, said it was their fault he didn't have a license. Ok sure.

But the insurance was under his company. I'm sure the town would love that.

Also, his warranty on labor is only one year - Liberty is 15. I had to supply him with a pen and a piece of paper to write down the new measurements of the new quote. I don't even know why I went through the motions.

My neighbor is still using him anyway, more power to them. She said they already had a CO for the existing fence (which is impossible, because the stockade between our yards is mine, not theirs - I have the CO) so they're not getting a new permit for this fence.

Okey dokey. Good luck with that. I'm signing my contract with Liberty in an hour. Instead of a contract, they got a handshake. Chat Icon


THANK YOU for everyone who voted and commented. I truly appreciate your feedback. Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-09-12 07:31:53.533000.

Posted 9/11/08 6:27 PM
 

Elizabeth
Mom of Three

Member since 9/05

7900 total posts

Name:
"MOMMY!!!"

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

I definitely think you made the right decision. The price difference will really be small in the end, esp over the life of the fence and for the peace of mind. Post again with an update after the install.

Posted 9/11/08 6:54 PM
 

rkoenke
my little piggys

Member since 3/08

4315 total posts

Name:
rachel

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

Posted by ave1024

Installing fence is not rocket science. I had a guy from craigslist do my gate and he did a good job. PVC Gate gost me $450 when the fence company wanted over $1000 installed.

I would see if guy #1 would come down in price more. If you can get the job cheaper I would probably go for #1. If it's only a $300 difference then i'd probably go with #2.

I wouldn't use "he barely speaks english" against him. Some of the best guys I had working in my house couldn't speak a word of english.




I second every bit of this! the best taper / spacklers i've seen couldn't speak english...

Posted 9/11/08 7:47 PM
 

Katie111806
Team Pink!

Member since 12/06

5349 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

I think you made the right choice! Can't wait to see the new fence.

Posted 9/11/08 7:58 PM
 

strongisland
All you need is love

Member since 8/07

2474 total posts

Name:
T

Re: What would you do? [Poll]

Posted by rkoenke

Posted by ave1024

Installing fence is not rocket science. I had a guy from craigslist do my gate and he did a good job. PVC Gate gost me $450 when the fence company wanted over $1000 installed.

I would see if guy #1 would come down in price more. If you can get the job cheaper I would probably go for #1. If it's only a $300 difference then i'd probably go with #2.

I wouldn't use "he barely speaks english" against him. Some of the best guys I had working in my house couldn't speak a word of english.




I second every bit of this! the best taper / spacklers i've seen couldn't speak english...



i agree that some of the best work u can get comes from people who don't speak english---i wouldn't mind using people who didnt speak english as long as it wasn't the 'main' guy...as long as the 'head' guy spoke english well at least then he could translate what u want to the crew...it would bother me if the main/head guy didn't understand exactly what i wanted done
i think u made the right choice too!

Posted 9/11/08 8:44 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2