Would you retract the negative feedback you gave?

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes, she was fair to offer a refund 16 34.04%
No, what she did was shady 26 55.32%
Other (please explain) 5 10.64%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

What would you do? POLL

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

glinda-goodwitch
:-)

Member since 7/06

9149 total posts

Name:
Beth

What would you do? POLL

I recently bought a Kooba bag from an ebay seller. I believe the bag to be real, because it has a clothingline stamp inside from the sample sale. BUT...the seller advertised it as new with tags, and there were no tags when she sent it to me. Plus, she said it was Made in the USA, but the tags say it was made in China.

I kept the bag because I am happy with the bag, but I feel that she misrepresented her item. I NEVER would have bid on a bag that was not new with tags.

I gave her negative feedback, even though she offered a full refund. This is because even though I am happy with the bag, I feel that she did not sell me what she advertised. She asked me to retract the negative feedback because she offered a refund. Should I? Or should I keep the negative feedback that I sent? I feel that even though she did offer a refund, what she did was shady.

What would you do?

ETA: I want to add that I requested pictures of the tags, and she sent them to me. So I have pictures of these tags that supposedly go with the bag, and then the bag arrives with NO tags.

Message edited 2007-02-27 16:16:37.417000.

Posted 2/27/07 2:57 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

J9-13
We're gonna be big sisters!

Member since 6/06

14887 total posts

Name:
J9

Re: What would you do? POLL

ooo...thats tough. How is her feedback overall? Does she have good ratings?

Posted 2/27/07 2:58 PM
 

randella
Love my little man

Member since 8/05

16290 total posts

Name:
Randi

Re: What would you do? POLL

Perhaps you can revise the feedback?

Posted 2/27/07 2:58 PM
 

julz33
i run for bacon

Member since 5/05

20584 total posts

Name:
julz

Re: What would you do? POLL

I would maybe change it to neutral feedback and write what you just wrote here as a comment.

Posted 2/27/07 2:59 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? POLL

I would change the feedback to read:

"Item was not new with tag as seller indicated. However she did offer a full refund."

Posted 2/27/07 3:00 PM
 

Lanabean
Yoginis

Member since 11/05

9202 total posts

Name:
Lana

Re: What would you do? POLL

Posted by julz33

I would maybe change it to neutral feedback and write what you just wrote here as a comment.



i agree; but i would take it somewhere to check authenticity. Check mypoupette.com. I have inquired about bags w/them before and they also have a list of authentic sellers.

Posted 2/27/07 3:00 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: What would you do? POLL

as an ebay seller- if you keep the item - you should take back the negatitive feedback

but are all Kooba bags made in the USA?

b/c if this one is made in china- I would be concerned

ETA- keep your comments- but make it neutral

Message edited 2007-02-27 15:11:30.190000.

Posted 2/27/07 3:01 PM
 

Lisa
I'm a PANK!!!

Member since 5/05

22334 total posts

Name:
Professional Aunts No Kids

Re: What would you do? POLL

Posted by nrthshgrl

I would change the feedback to read:

"Item was not new with tag as seller indicated. However she did offer a full refund."



I agree with this,

Posted 2/27/07 3:03 PM
 

Kate07
Feel better my little guy!

Member since 5/05

4476 total posts

Name:
Kate

Re: What would you do? POLL

So she offered a refund, but you were happy with your purchase? If I were you I probably would have given neutral feedback with a detailed comment

Posted 2/27/07 3:09 PM
 

MABLE03
I <3 SATC

Member since 6/06

4563 total posts

Name:
Fabulous

Re: What would you do? POLL

Posted by Lisa

Posted by nrthshgrl

I would change the feedback to read:

"Item was not new with tag as seller indicated. However she did offer a full refund."



I agree with this,



I agree also. Change it to neutral and leave that as a feedback.

It was fair of her to offer a refund but you should still let other know you didn't recieve exactly what was advertised.

Posted 2/27/07 3:10 PM
 

ml110
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

5435 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? POLL

QUOTE]

I agree also. Change it to neutral and leave that as a feedback.

It was fair of her to offer a refund but you should still let other know you didn't recieve exactly what was advertised.

i agree with this, too...

Posted 2/27/07 3:11 PM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? POLL

The seller tried to resolve the situation and you agreed to keep the bag, there's no need for the negative feedback. If you can retract it and post a neutral comment, I would do that. Negative feedback is for transactions with an unsatisfactory conclusion which does not appear to be the case here.

Posted 2/27/07 3:12 PM
 

glinda-goodwitch
:-)

Member since 7/06

9149 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: What would you do? POLL

But was she not shady in her practice? Even if I was happy with the bag, I was not happy with how she handled her auction. She took pictures of the bag WITH tags, and then did not send tags. She probably had tags that she uses for multiple bags. Isn't this shady?

Posted 2/27/07 3:37 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: What would you do? POLL

Posted by glinda-goodwitch

But was she not shady in her practice? Even if I was happy with the bag, I was not happy with how she handled her auction. She took pictures of the bag WITH tags, and then did not send tags. She probably had tags that she uses for multiple bags. Isn't this shady?



that's why you should leave the comments there

are you sure the bag is real?
I couldn't find online where kooba bags are made and I don't have one- so I am not that fimilar with them

Posted 2/27/07 3:39 PM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? POLL

Posted by Lisa

Posted by nrthshgrl

I would change the feedback to read:

"Item was not new with tag as seller indicated. However she did offer a full refund."



I agree with this,



me tooChat Icon

Posted 2/27/07 3:40 PM
 

Chatham-Chick
*********************

Member since 5/05

10312 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? POLL

Kooba bags are manufactured in China.

She offered you a full refund, but you declined because you like the bag even though you have doubts? Chat Icon

As I see it, the seller tried to make good on the transaction, so I don't think I would leave negative feedback.

What is the seller's other feedback like? Has this happened before? I might leave neutral or positive feedback depending on her feedback history and I would state that listing said NWT when item was NWOT.

Could it be that the Seller purchased a few of the same Kooba bags and the one you received just happened not to have the hang tags? What were her other listings?

Message edited 2007-02-27 15:50:42.657000.

Posted 2/27/07 3:50 PM
 

Reese1106
Family of 4! :o)

Member since 8/06

6655 total posts

Name:
Theresa

Re: What would you do? POLL

Hmmmm. I would see if I can change it to neutral. I don't think she deserves to have it retracted though. If she was going to stand by her product, she should have done exactly what she advertised.

Posted 2/27/07 3:53 PM
 

glinda-goodwitch
:-)

Member since 7/06

9149 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: What would you do? POLL

See, the problem is that she has other "negative" comments but they were neutral. Probably she did the same thing with someone else and they changed it to neutral.

My problem with this is that I saw she had 100% positive feedback, so I didn't look way back to those negative comments. One comment was changed to neutral saying that the product wasn't new even though she stated it was.

So...If I change it to neutral, it may be less noticeable, and someone else may have a problem in the future.

Posted 2/27/07 3:57 PM
 

glinda-goodwitch
:-)

Member since 7/06

9149 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: What would you do? POLL

Posted by Chatham-Chick

Kooba bags are manufactured in China.

She offered you a full refund, but you declined because you like the bag even though you have doubts? Chat Icon




No, I don't really have doubts. I think it is real. I just REALLY don't like that she listed it as new WITH tags. I emailed her specifically asking for pictures of the tags. She sent them to me, and then didn't send the bag WITH the tags she sent pictures of. So she lied to me. I like the bag, but I don't like being lied to.

Posted 2/27/07 3:59 PM
 

DebG
Pick a cause & stand up for it

Member since 5/05

18602 total posts

Name:
The cure IS worse!

Re: What would you do? POLL

Leave the negative. The seller did in fact LIE to you, regardless of what they did after.

Posted 2/27/07 3:59 PM
 

sasha96
lovin' my 2 little ladies!

Member since 5/05

7401 total posts

Name:
Julianne

Re: What would you do? POLL

I agree with neutral. She offered a resolution in the form of a refund but she misrepresented her item.

Posted 2/27/07 4:00 PM
 

Chatham-Chick
*********************

Member since 5/05

10312 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? POLL

Did she leave you feedback yet?

Posted 2/27/07 4:01 PM
 

glinda-goodwitch
:-)

Member since 7/06

9149 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: What would you do? POLL

Posted by Chatham-Chick

Did she leave you feedback yet?



Yes, she left it before I left mine, but I did not see it until later. It was positive.

Posted 2/27/07 4:08 PM
 

Chatham-Chick
*********************

Member since 5/05

10312 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? POLL

Posted by glinda-goodwitch

Posted by Chatham-Chick

Did she leave you feedback yet?



Yes, she left it before I left mine, but I did not see it until later. It was positive.



Whew...you're in the clear. Chat Icon Then you can leave the negative feedback you already wrote. Chat Icon

Posted 2/27/07 4:10 PM
 

glinda-goodwitch
:-)

Member since 7/06

9149 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: What would you do? POLL

Posted by Chatham-Chick

Posted by glinda-goodwitch

Posted by Chatham-Chick

Did she leave you feedback yet?



Yes, she left it before I left mine, but I did not see it until later. It was positive.



Whew...you're in the clear. Chat Icon Then you can leave the negative feedback you already wrote. Chat Icon



I just feel that leaving it WILL help other buyers. I know I didn't notice the poor feedback when it was neutral, otherwise I may not have trusted her so much.

I mean, she took pictures of tags specifically because I requested them, and did not send them. To me that is lying.

Posted 2/27/07 4:15 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2