what would you do?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

~Melissa~

Member since 5/06

1462 total posts

Name:

what would you do?

(If you think this should go on the Home board, please feel free to move it...I wasn't sure)


Would you...

A. Move to a small, beautiful, upper-class town with amazing schools...but you'd only able to afford a smallish, older house (but in a really pretty neighborhood).

or

B. Move to a huge middle-class town with okay schools...but you could afford a brand spanking new large house in a gorgeous, "rich" (lol) neighborhood.

??

Posted 9/28/06 4:35 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MABLE03
I <3 SATC

Member since 6/06

4563 total posts

Name:
Fabulous

Re: what would you do?

A.

Location, Location, Location.
especially if you have children who will be going to schools in the area.

Posted 9/28/06 4:37 PM
 

MrsPorkChop
Twinning!!

Member since 5/05

9941 total posts

Name:
Missy

Re: what would you do?

i dont know
can you post the towns?

can you send kids to private school?

how GREAT are the schools in #1?

so many factors


#2 sounds good but i really would need to hear details before deciding

Posted 9/28/06 4:37 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: what would you do?

A

Posted 9/28/06 4:37 PM
 

ssbride05
:-)

Member since 5/05

2654 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: what would you do?

Posted by MrsPorkChop

i dont know
can you post the towns?

can you send kids to private school?

how GREAT are the schools in #1?

so many factors


#2 sounds good but i really would need to hear details before deciding



same here...

Posted 9/28/06 4:41 PM
 

sirk1020
*************

Member since 9/06

3046 total posts

Name:

Re: what would you do?

Would you be just getting by in Neighborhood A? or would you have the same amt of spending $$ in both neighborhoods?


I think I would choose B and here is why

Neighborhood A in the upperclass neigborhood - althougth probably lovely to live there - "the keeping up the joneses" on a day to day basis would really bother me - especially if I had children.

Let's face it, an upperclass neighborhood has mostly wealthy people living there - which means nice cars, maybe more than one home, kids in a tons of activities, super sweet sixteens (i am exaggerating here - but you get my point) It is not the big vs small house that bothers me , it is all the other stuff that is associated with an expensive area. Don't get me wrong if I had the money I would do it, but if it was going to be a little bit of a struggle , I would go for B

That is my opinion at least - sorry
I worry about dumb things..

My FH,unlike me, couldn't care less what other people do so he would go for A

Posted 9/28/06 4:51 PM
 

~Melissa~

Member since 5/06

1462 total posts

Name:

Re: what would you do?

These are Connecticut towns....

Choice A has the number 2 school district in the entire state. I taught at one of them, it made me fall in love with the area and the people. They aren't snobby like other wealthy people can be. It's a very beautiful area...reminds me a lot of the north shore of Long Island. We could afford a decent but older house there in need of renovation, on about an acre of land.

Choice B is the town my husband works in. There are very wealthy sections, and some not so desirable areas as well. The schools are so so. Not horrible, but not super great. We could get a BRAND new house, probably 2600+ square feet for around $350,000, in a really nice neighborhood.

This is the hardest decision ever. Chat Icon
We want this house to be THE house. Meaning, one that we'll live in for 15 years or more.

Posted 9/28/06 4:53 PM
 

Redhead
You Live, You Learn

Member since 5/05

31871 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: what would you do?

B

Middle class IMO is great...

I have no need to move into any upper class area ...

sooo much other pressures go along with that

Posted 9/28/06 4:55 PM
 

MrsPorkChop
Twinning!!

Member since 5/05

9941 total posts

Name:
Missy

Re: what would you do?

Posted by princessMOMMY

These are Connecticut towns....

Choice A has the number 2 school district in the entire state. I taught at one of them, it made me fall in love with the area and the people. They aren't snobby like other wealthy people can be. It's a very beautiful area...reminds me a lot of the north shore of Long Island. We could afford a decent but older house there in need of renovation, on about an acre of land.

Choice B is the town my husband works in. There are very wealthy sections, and some not so desirable areas as well. The schools are so so. Not horrible, but not super great. We could get a BRAND new house, probably 2600+ square feet for around $350,000, in a really nice neighborhood.

This is the hardest decision ever. Chat Icon
We want this house to be THE house. Meaning, one that we'll live in for 15 years or more.



ok i live in CT so tell me the towns

ill tel lyou what i think

Posted 9/28/06 4:56 PM
 

Tany
Becoming a different woman

Member since 5/05

24460 total posts

Name:
Tania

Re: what would you do?

well is this a starter house?

if it is, I would move to b.

Posted 9/28/06 4:57 PM
 

sirk1020
*************

Member since 9/06

3046 total posts

Name:

Re: what would you do?

Posted by princessMOMMY

These are Connecticut towns....

Choice A has the number 2 school district in the entire state. I taught at one of them, it made me fall in love with the area and the people. They aren't snobby like other wealthy people can be. It's a very beautiful area...reminds me a lot of the north shore of Long Island. We could afford a decent but older house there in need of renovation, on about an acre of land.

Choice B is the town my husband works in. There are very wealthy sections, and some not so desirable areas as well. The schools are so so. Not horrible, but not super great. We could get a BRAND new house, probably 2600+ square feet for around $350,000, in a really nice neighborhood.

This is the hardest decision ever. Chat Icon
We want this house to be THE house. Meaning, one that we'll live in for 15 years or more.




If that is the situation, I change my answer. Go for A - if you love the area, and feel comfortable there - your home is what you make it - I would go for the older house and renovate it little by litte
It'll have some personality Chat Icon

Posted 9/28/06 4:57 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: what would you do?

B- for the reasons that others have already stated.

Great schools are great to have, but I really believe that involved parents make a huge difference.

Posted 9/28/06 4:58 PM
 

~Colleen~
my loves...

Member since 5/05

9129 total posts

Name:
guess

Re: what would you do?

Location, location, location...

I'd go for A...mostly b/c I prefer older homes.

Posted 9/28/06 4:58 PM
 

My2Boys
Love.

Member since 10/05

4796 total posts

Name:

Re: what would you do?

I wouldn't think twice about this one. The #2 SD would do it for me. I would find a home that had the potential to expand (should you need to in the future Chat Icon).

Posted 9/28/06 4:59 PM
 

MABLE03
I <3 SATC

Member since 6/06

4563 total posts

Name:
Fabulous

Re: what would you do?

Voting A again - you can't put a price on your childrens eduaction and the schools sound great.

Eta and with an acre of land you have PLENTY of room to expand in the future. Chat Icon

Message edited 2006-09-28 17:00:27.177000.

Posted 9/28/06 4:59 PM
 

~Melissa~

Member since 5/06

1462 total posts

Name:

Re: what would you do?

Posted by My2Boys

I wouldn't think twice about this one. The #2 SD would do it for me. I would find a home that had the potential to expand (should you need to in the future Chat Icon).




Oh God no Kathi! Chat Icon

The towns are Avon (A) and Southington (B). With Southington though, I was also really thinking of ANY middle class town...

Posted 9/28/06 5:01 PM
 

Eva Luna
Be kind...life's hard!

Member since 8/05

4750 total posts

Name:
God, bless & heal my DH, JenG's DH Rob & DebG

Re: what would you do?

I believe that all of us always know the answers to the questions that we ask others, that we just put them out there to hear them back and help the truth resonate.

With that said...what do you want?

An older house with charms and flaws or a brand new house?

The prestige of saying that your kids attend the second best school in the country or an OK/acceptable school that may lack that distinction?

Average, middle-class friends for your kids or upper class, wealthy friends for your kids?

It's all about what you truly desire deep inside.

If you buy the older house in the rich neighborhood, will you always feel like an outsider living there, in the cheapest house in the 'hood?

If you buy in the middle class neighborhood, would you regret not choosing the other one?

Again, all these answers are truly inside you.

Good luck figuring it out! Chat Icon Pray for clarity! Chat Icon

Posted 9/28/06 5:01 PM
 

Redhead
You Live, You Learn

Member since 5/05

31871 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: what would you do?

Posted by MABLE03

Voting A again - you can't put a price on your childrens eduaction and the schools sound great.

Eta and with an acre of land you have PLENTY of room to expand in the future. Chat Icon


true

but can you say that you get a BAD education from a middle class area?


i woudl totally understand if the SD was BAD....but usually middle class areas are pretty decent in SD

Posted 9/28/06 5:01 PM
 

PRETTYPINK
LIF Toddler

Member since 7/06

393 total posts

Name:
A

Re: what would you do?

A.
You buy the neighborhood.

You can always fix the house.
You can't fix the neighborhood.

Posted 9/28/06 5:02 PM
 

~Melissa~

Member since 5/06

1462 total posts

Name:

Re: what would you do?

Posted by Redhead

Posted by MABLE03

Voting A again - you can't put a price on your childrens eduaction and the schools sound great.

Eta and with an acre of land you have PLENTY of room to expand in the future. Chat Icon


true

but can you say that you get a BAD education from a middle class area?


i woudl totally understand if the SD was BAD....but usually middle class areas are pretty decent in SD




I agree. It's not a BAD area and I am sure the schools are just fine.

Honestly, and this is coming from a teacher who has worked in one of the poorest schools in NY state, and one of the richest in CT...school is what you make of it. It all depends on the student. A smart child can do well anywhere. Chat Icon

Posted 9/28/06 5:04 PM
 

My2Boys
Love.

Member since 10/05

4796 total posts

Name:

Re: what would you do?

Posted by princessMOMMY

Posted by My2Boys

I wouldn't think twice about this one. The #2 SD would do it for me. I would find a home that had the potential to expand (should you need to in the future Chat Icon).




Oh God no Kathi! Chat Icon

The towns are Avon (A) and Southington (B). With Southington though, I was also really thinking of ANY middle class town...



Chat Icon

OK, OK! But I'm still voting for A! What would DH's commute be like from Avon?

Posted 9/28/06 5:06 PM
 

MrsPorkChop
Twinning!!

Member since 5/05

9941 total posts

Name:
Missy

Re: what would you do?

avon definitely


Posted 9/28/06 5:07 PM
 

~Melissa~

Member since 5/06

1462 total posts

Name:

Re: what would you do?

Well, his commute would be about 20 minutes or so. Right now it's 5-10 minutes.

BUT...he will eventually (within a few years) be opening his own practice and Avon is a GREAT town for that. Chat Icon

Posted 9/28/06 5:09 PM
 

MABLE03
I <3 SATC

Member since 6/06

4563 total posts

Name:
Fabulous

Re: what would you do?

Posted by princessMOMMY

Well, his commute would be about 20 minutes or so. Right now it's 5-10 minutes.

BUT...he will eventually (within a few years) be opening his own practice and Avon is a GREAT town for that. Chat Icon



Well then living in Avon would be great for his practice.. he will have contacts and be known in the small community.

Message edited 2006-09-28 17:12:24.863000.

Posted 9/28/06 5:12 PM
 

My2Boys
Love.

Member since 10/05

4796 total posts

Name:

Re: what would you do?

Posted by princessMOMMY

Well, his commute would be about 20 minutes or so. Right now it's 5-10 minutes.

BUT...he will eventually (within a few years) be opening his own practice and Avon is a GREAT town for that. Chat Icon



That's what I meant by expansion! In case he wants to make a home office. Chat Icon:

I think you answered your own question, Melissa! Chat Icon

You're moving to Avon. Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 9/28/06 5:13 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2