What are your thoughts on this?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

Posted by ckdk

Posted by Bxgell2

People, really, how in the world do you expect to "teach a toddler how to behave at a restaurant"? Ok, maybe if you were blessed with a little cool, calm and peaceful munchkin, but there are some of us parents who were equally blessed with "spirited" children, and that's putting it lightly, who, unlike yours, simply will not sit still and "behave" in a restaurant.

I am a firm believer in discipline, and I employ it whenever necessary. My daughter says "please", "thank you" and knows not to hit, bite, scratch or pinch. But, she was also born with a particularly fiesty disposition - she is HIGH energy, and as a result, there's quite simply nothing I can "teach" her to enable her to sit still in a high chair for more than 25 seconds.

That doesn't mean I don't set a good example for my daughter and that I'm lazy in employing discipline with her. It just means that different kids have different temperments and we all have to employ whatever skills we have to adapt to that temperment.

Ugh, these posts really aggravate me...



My thoughts exactly!! Chat Icon
Oh, and she never watches TV during any meal at home...

Also, some people wrote "take your child out early so they learn to behave"...
I have been taking her out since she was a few months old and believe me, things change!




Yup, been there done that. We starting taking Alex out everywhere with us at an early age, and let me tell you, EACH AND EVERY TIME WAS A SHINING EXAMPLE OF PURE AND TOTAL MISERY.

The last time my mother visited, she insisted on taking us "out" to eat. I spent the next hour doing whatever I could to avoid a temper tantrum. I spent about 45 minutes out of the hour taking Alex outside to avoid causing a scene.

Oh, and by the way, I've never used the DVD at a restaurant - in fact, for us, it wouldn't even work because Alex is So high energy that she doesn't care for TV - the DVD would engage her for all of 5 minutes and that's about it.

It's funny - I just went to get a mint, and inside the mint tin box it says:

"It is better to correct your own faults than those of another"

How fitting...

Posted 9/11/07 1:36 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Smileyd17
kids

Member since 5/05

20997 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

Fine. If it kept the child quiet...great.

I dont care for a screaming child, esp during dinner.
I wont allow my dd to do it and actually is she starts crying I walk out with her and ask my DH to wrap it up if I cant calm her down.


Posted 9/11/07 1:41 PM
 

MrsBlueSash
Love my sailor

Member since 6/05

5793 total posts

Name:
Christian

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

IMO it's a little too easy to always have the TV on, especially at dinner. To each their own, but I would not do that. I would try and keep dinner short, no long adult conversation after dinner coffee time, but I would also expect a 2 year old to participate in a family dinner and not zone out to TV.

Posted 9/11/07 2:09 PM
 

Eireann
Two ladies and a gentleman!

Member since 5/05

12165 total posts

Name:

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

I wonder...how is teaching your toddler to behave in a restaurant different from teaching them manners, teaching them not to hit or bite, teaching them to use a potty, teaching them their numbers, letters or any other thing we teach them on a regular basis? This is not a sarcastic question--I'm really wondering.

Posted 9/11/07 2:14 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

Posted by Eireann

I wonder...how is teaching your toddler to behave in a restaurant different from teaching them manners, teaching them not to hit or bite, teaching them to use a potty, teaching them their numbers, letters or any other thing we teach them on a regular basis? This is not a sarcastic question--I'm really wondering.
QUOTE]
--------------------------------------------------
Because those are specific behaviors that you are targeting, not a temperment/energy issue. My daughter responds quite well to discipline that focuses on specific actions that are not appropriate. But, I'm not going to punish her, or expect her to change the fact that she is very high energy, and cannot sit still, quietly, for extended periods of time. That doesn't mean we haven't tried - we have - but this is the one area that we cannot change, and I don't expect to change. I can only hope that as she gets older, she'll calm down a bit.

It's the same exact issue for the carseat. Driving long distances, or flying to Israel - pure, unadulterated torture. I still do it, but this is just who she is - she cannot sit in one place, happily, for too long. Now, for the car, I just let her cry - it only affects me. For the plane, and restaurants, I try to entertain her as best I can to avoid a scene, and to diminish the impact it makes on unwilling, innocent strangers.

There are plenty of children who don't have to be "taught" to behave in restaurants - those are the children who can play quietly, with some directed focus by the parents. Then there are children like mine - she NEVER sits quietly. She's always jumping, running around, in and out, yelling, laughing - just very spririted.

Yes, when she's older, and can understand better, she will learn what is and is not acceptable behavior when we are out. But, as a young, spirited, high-energy toddler, I can tell you, it's simply not possible. At this age, it's all about damage control.


Message edited 2007-09-11 14:32:23.007000.

Posted 9/11/07 2:30 PM
 

ckdk
My girls

Member since 5/05

7027 total posts

Name:
Cheryl

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

Posted by Eireann

I wonder...how is teaching your toddler to behave in a restaurant different from teaching them manners, teaching them not to hit or bite, teaching them to use a potty, teaching them their numbers, letters or any other thing we teach them on a regular basis? This is not a sarcastic question--I'm really wondering.




I don't know... DD is 18 months and so far she doesn't hit or bite and learns toys, books, puzzles etc just fine but I can't reason with her on why she should sit in a high chair for 1 1/2+ hours without screaming...
Maybe when she turns 2 or older it will be easier but at this age, I honestly don't think she has the capacity to understand that screaming and running around is not appropriate behavior in a restaurant...

Posted 9/11/07 2:31 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

Message edited 2007-11-24 17:23:27.433000.

Posted 9/11/07 2:32 PM
 

ChilisWife
God Bless America

Member since 5/05

3572 total posts

Name:
A.K.

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

I don't think it is reasonable to expect a toddler to sit quietly in a restaurant no matter how "well behaved" the kid is. Even as an adult, if I went somewhere where I was expected to sit quietly for 2 hours where I wasn't able to participate in the conversation or even understand most of the conversation, then I would get antsy too! It doesn't mean that they are not behaving, it means they are bored.

Before I had a kid I would have been the first one screaming from the rooftops, "discipline your child!" and "don't use TV as a babysitter!" It is amazing how things change once you see what it is really like and what kind of kid you have.

Posted 9/11/07 2:34 PM
 

Eireann
Two ladies and a gentleman!

Member since 5/05

12165 total posts

Name:

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

Posted by Bxgell2

Because those are specific behaviors that you are targeting, not a temperment/energy issue. My daughter responds quite well to discipline that focuses on specific actions that are not appropriate. But, I'm not going to punish her, or expect her to change the fact that she is very high energy, and cannot sit still, quietly, for extended periods of time. That doesn't mean we haven't tried - we have - but this is the one area that we cannot change, and I don't expect to change. I can only hope that as she gets older, she'll calm down a bit.

It's the same exact issue for the carseat. Driving long distances, or flying to Israel - pure, unadulterated torture. I still do it, but this is just who she is - she cannot sit in one place, happily, for too long. Now, for the car, I just let her cry - it only affects me. For the plane, and restaurants, I try to entertain her as best I can to avoid a scene, and to diminish the impact it makes on unwilling, innocent strangers.

There are plenty of children who don't have to be "taught" to behave in restaurants - those are the children who can play quietly, with some directed focus by the parents. Then there are children like mine - she NEVER sits quietly. She's always jumping, running around, in and out, yelling, laughing - just very spririted.

Yes, when she's older, and can understand better, she will learn what is and is not acceptable behavior when we are out. But, as a young, spirited, high-energy toddler, I can tell you, it's simply not possible. At this age, it's all about damage control.




Makes sense...thank you Chat Icon

Posted 9/11/07 2:38 PM
 

2girlsforme
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

3071 total posts

Name:
XXXXXXXXX

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

Posted by Bxgell2

People, really, how in the world do you expect to "teach a toddler how to behave at a restaurant"? Ok, maybe if you were blessed with a little cool, calm and peaceful munchkin, but there are some of us parents who were equally blessed with "spirited" children, and that's putting it lightly, who, unlike yours, simply will not sit still and "behave" in a restaurant.

I am a firm believer in discipline, and I employ it whenever necessary. My daughter says "please", "thank you" and knows not to hit, bite, scratch or pinch. But, she was also born with a particularly fiesty disposition - she is HIGH energy, and as a result, there's quite simply nothing I can "teach" her to enable her to sit still in a high chair for more than 25 seconds.

That doesn't mean I don't set a good example for my daughter and that I'm lazy in employing discipline with her. It just means that different kids have different temperments and we all have to employ whatever skills we have to adapt to that temperment.

Ugh, these posts really aggravate me...



I couldn't agree more. I have never brought a DVD player but I have brought crayons, books and small toys and don't really see the difference.

In my ten years of parenting I've learned to never judge others, as long as the child isn't being physically or verbally abused. An older woman I work with told me that before she became a parent she had all sorts of ideas about child rearing but now she has kids. I'm just curious if anyone with a "spirited" toddler (of which my second child was) has a problem with this??

Posted 9/11/07 2:40 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

Posted by 2girlsforme
I'm just curious if anyone with a "spirited" toddler (of which my second child was) has a problem with this??



I would venture to say that most who are saying that a child should be taught to behave well in a restaurant have never had the distinct pleasure of having a spirited, high-energy child.

And if they are, please share some of your secrets with the rest of us tortured parents! Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 9/11/07 2:45 PM
 

leighla
Support Cancer Research

Member since 5/05

16353 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

I'll admit, my first thought was to say "Absolutely not acceptable. Not for my child."

But after reading the other posts I've changed my mind.

As long as it wasn't loud enough to bother other patrons, I'm okay with it.

It still wouldn't be my first choice with DS, but in the 4 short months he's been here, I've already learned never day never.

Posted 9/11/07 2:45 PM
 

monters
Back in LI!

Member since 5/05

1525 total posts

Name:
Robyn

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

Posted by monkeybride

Not for me. I prefer my DD learn how to behave in restaurants. It's part of life and something she needs to learn.
To each his own I guess but you would never see me doing that.



exactly my thoughts ..crayons and toys I will bring but thats it..

Posted 9/11/07 2:53 PM
 

carolyns4cupcakes
C ♥'s F

Member since 2/07

6456 total posts

Name:

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

I only bring the portable DVD when we are taking road trips or if we are staying at my in laws for a day or 2.

But that's me and I wouldnt; judge anyone who does the opposite.

We all wear different shoes.

Posted 9/11/07 2:54 PM
 

CkGm
They get so big, so fast :(

Member since 5/05

13848 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

IF the child were older I may think it was a little strange, but for a child that age I would be all for it. If he was happy and the parents got to enjoy a night out- so what?Chat Icon

Posted 9/11/07 2:57 PM
 

HillandRon
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

2922 total posts

Name:
Hillary

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

I don't think it is a problem to use a DVD player at restaurants.. At first I thought like some posters that I would never do it.. but you know what, you do what you got to do..

I am sure there have been plenty of things that you said you wouldn't do when you had a baby and then end up doing it... This is one of those times...

I will say we do not bring every time I go out-- and I am out on an average 4 days a week for lunch and all weekend long... For instance.. we had a 60th Birthday dinner for my FIl that was 3 hours 9 very slow service) I really don't think any 2 year old will sit for 3 hours without something to occupy their time...

Everyone does what is good for their children.. You can't judge anyone and the way they parent.. What might work for one, might not work for another...

Posted 9/11/07 3:07 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

Posted by monters

Posted by monkeybride

Not for me. I prefer my DD learn how to behave in restaurants. It's part of life and something she needs to learn.
To each his own I guess but you would never see me doing that.



exactly my thoughts ..crayons and toys I will bring but thats it..



Yep this is what we do. She colors with what they give her and I bring a few toys that hold her attention. She eats when the food comes and usually get water in a restaurant cup which she loves. For us going out to eat is a family time thing and for us having DD zone out in a movie is not part of that.

Posted 9/11/07 3:16 PM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

You know what...if everyone has a pleasant dinner, good for them.

Lately I have slaved over a nice dinner on the weekends, had friends over to eat with us, sit down, make Noah a plate and as soon as I take my first bite...he goes into MELTDOWN stage. And thats not fun for anyone. So if the parents and the boy have a nice dinner...more power to them!

Posted 9/11/07 3:20 PM
 

lullabella
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

2246 total posts

Name:

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

My son is 21 months and is very high energy. He does not watch tv or sit still for a minute. In fact if he is not tearing through the house, he is sleeping.

That being said when we go out to eat (about once a week) he is generally good. How you ask? Because he loves to eat!!! I immediately start feeding him anything he wants when we arrive. Probably not the best idea but it works for me. Also now I bring playdo and he loves that. We used to eat out 3 nights a week but with him and a 6 month old, once is all we can manage!

Posted 9/11/07 3:22 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

not for us

Posted 9/11/07 3:24 PM
 

oops123
LIF Adult

Member since 8/05

2509 total posts

Name:
michelle

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

i think - hey....whatever works!

Posted 9/11/07 3:25 PM
 

MrsR
My love.

Member since 5/05

6247 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

reading this post makes me think maybe I should bring a dvd player for my husband to watch during dinner.

Clearly his mother never "taught" him when he was 2 that he should sit still because he is always checking his internet on his phone, and saying, "can we go now, can we go now"...

Ok I am being scarcastic (a little) - but my point is that there are some GROWN ups I know that can't sit through a meal without getting fidgity.

On the other side, for me personally I would rather not go out then bring a DVD player with me for my kid to watch. It's just not something I am comfortable with - but I am certainly not judging moms that use it - to each his own.

Posted 9/11/07 3:25 PM
 

ml110
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

5435 total posts

Name:

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

Posted by lullabella

My son is 21 months and is very high energy. He does not watch tv or sit still for a minute. In fact if he is not tearing through the house, he is sleeping.

That being said when we go out to eat (about once a week) he is generally good. How you ask? Because he loves to eat!!! I immediately start feeding him anything he wants when we arrive. Probably not the best idea but it works for me. Also now I bring playdo and he loves that. We used to eat out 3 nights a week but with him and a 6 month old, once is all we can manage!



this is what my friend did when we went out to eat with her 7 month old. she fed him snacks while we were waiting for our food. it kept him occupied while we were waiting for our food, and by the time our food got there, he was fed and happy and let us enjoy our dinner while he played with some toys she had brought.
i'm also a speech/language therapist and kids benefit SOOO much more when the parents are providiing the entertainment and interacting with them, than when they are zoned out in front of a DVD.

Posted 9/11/07 3:28 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

just a side note...I have seen one in church before. The girl must have been 3 or 4 years old. It seems weird to me, at some point kids have to realize that this is the world and you have to be able to function in it.

she sat their with her headphones on, oblivious...not standing on cue or kneeling. I almost think its a better message to leave the kid at home then to act like that in church.

Posted 9/11/07 3:28 PM
 

JerseyMamaOf3
Boo!

Member since 6/05

15144 total posts

Name:

Re: What are your thoughts on this?

Posted by monkeybride

Posted by monters

Posted by monkeybride

Not for me. I prefer my DD learn how to behave in restaurants. It's part of life and something she needs to learn.
To each his own I guess but you would never see me doing that.



exactly my thoughts ..crayons and toys I will bring but thats it..



Yep this is what we do. She colors with what they give her and I bring a few toys that hold her attention. She eats when the food comes and usually get water in a restaurant cup which she loves. For us going out to eat is a family time thing and for us having DD zone out in a movie is not part of that.



This is what we do too. Except it is hit or miss if he eats. Sometimes DS is great and then their are times were he just gets bored so fast with everything and we try and entertain him. We also try and go to dinner early, around 6pm the latest and to a place like Chili's or Friday's.
Just because I was bothered by it when I saw this family using it doesn't mean I was judging them. If it works for your family then it's fine by me. It is just something I choose not to introduce when we go out.

Posted 9/11/07 3:31 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
NYSC IN Oceanside vs. Sky Athletic Club...any thoughts/experiences??? beautyq115 1/16/07 8 Diet & Fitness
i cant stop baking!!! And having baby thoughts on my mind constantly! raken40 10/3/06 2 TTC
This might be heavy for a Sat. night... but what are your thoughts SweetestOfPeas 9/16/06 7 Families Helping Families ™
As my daughter approachs her first birthday I thought I might share my thoughts -- I will warn you very long!!!!!!!!!!!!! justthe4ofus 4/13/06 49 Parenting
I never do this but I really really need your good thoughts today... UPDATE 10/7 Leeners 10/6/05 54 Families Helping Families ™
UPDATED!!!Please cross your fingers and wish happy thoughts to Juliette for Monday!!! UPDATED!!! aliasPook 9/10/05 14 Parenting