What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Last night I got home from work and asked Ryan about his day. He spent the day at his grandparents with his cousin.

I asked him who he played with.

He said, "Aidy" (my 4.5 yr old sister whom he adores but his day was with cousin Jack).

I was like, "Really Ryan, you saw Aidy today?"

"Yes, Aidy".

I asked, "Ok, who else?"

He tells me "Puppies" (the last time we were there (at my mom's) they had 3 puppies around)

"Really Ryan?"

"Yes, Aidy Puppies".

"Ok, what did you do?"

"Jump" (and he starts jumping in his chair).

I couldn't believe my 16-month old had a full blown story to tell. Obviously harmless, and I guess more imagination, but is this when they start the white lies? Should I be correcting him, or letting him go on with his story? Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-08-13 12:45:24.267000.

Posted 8/13/09 12:40 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

I can't believe your 16 month old can speak and have conversations like that LOL. I would be thrilled if Nina was storytelling, at least she was talking LOL.

I think Ryan is a little too smart for his good.

Posted 8/13/09 12:42 PM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted by NinasMommy

I can't believe your 16 month old can speak and have conversations like that LOL. I would be thrilled if Nina was storytelling, at least she was talking LOL.

I think Ryan is a little too smart for his good.



I was a bit confused though - I wonder if he knows he was lying, was he confused about what I was asking him (he did see her over the weekend), or did he have a dream or something that involved Aidy and puppies jumping??

He was watching her jump in the pool the last time he saw her.

But he had a little smirk on after after answer - like he knew he was making it all up Chat Icon

He is a smarty pants though. I asked his daycare director where he'll be when I bring him back after my maternity leave - if he'll be moved up to the 2 yr old room at that point. She said it depended on how many kids where in each room, but she's ready to put him with the 4 yr olds Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-08-13 12:47:36.980000.

Posted 8/13/09 12:44 PM
 

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Im going to go with he was probably really just stuck on that day because he had so much fun, especially if he was acting out what he did that day!

Although he could by fibbing which is just the freaking cutest thing!

Posted 8/13/09 12:45 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

I don't think the fibbing starts until a little older, like 2.5-3 years old... although talking like that usually doesn't start until later as well, but it seems like Elizabeth and Ryan could carry on a conversation together if they were so inclined. Chat Icon

I think he may have just been recalling a fun day...

I'll never forget the day I picked Elizabeth up from my mom's house and I asked her "were you a good girl for Grandma?" and she said "No!" Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/13/09 12:50 PM
 

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted by eroxgirl

I don't think the fibbing starts until a little older, like 2.5-3 years old... although talking like that usually doesn't start until later as well, but it seems like Elizabeth and Ryan could carry on a conversation together if they were so inclined. Chat Icon

I think he may have just been recalling a fun day...

I'll never forget the day I picked Elizabeth up from my mom's house and I asked her "were you a good girl for Grandma?" and she said "No!" Chat Icon Chat Icon



Ok I have officially come to the conclusion that I am the only one who has a 17 month old that doesn't want to talk.

Im sure Elizabeth was telling the truth too!

Posted 8/13/09 12:54 PM
 

wowcoulditbe
wow, pic is already 1 yr old!!

Member since 1/06

6689 total posts

Name:
D

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

i know our dd did it a little before two...

Posted 8/13/09 12:56 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted by NinasMommy

Posted by eroxgirl

I don't think the fibbing starts until a little older, like 2.5-3 years old... although talking like that usually doesn't start until later as well, but it seems like Elizabeth and Ryan could carry on a conversation together if they were so inclined. Chat Icon

I think he may have just been recalling a fun day...

I'll never forget the day I picked Elizabeth up from my mom's house and I asked her "were you a good girl for Grandma?" and she said "No!" Chat Icon Chat Icon



Ok I have officially come to the conclusion that I am the only one who has a 17 month old that doesn't want to talk.

Im sure Elizabeth was telling the truth too!



would it make you feel better if I reminded you that Elizabeth will be 19 months this weekend?

AND she's in day care....surrounded by other kids who talk to her. She probably wouldn't be talking as much if I were home with her.

Posted 8/13/09 1:00 PM
 

RM23
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

997 total posts

Name:
Rachel

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Its cute! Im pretty sure he was trying hard to remember his day, but i think they get confused. I think they have a very small short term memory.

Anyway, Luke is 17 months, Im home with him too and he doesnt say much either. I think we have about 10 words right now. He understands a lot more then he speaks...so im fine with it!

Posted 8/13/09 1:27 PM
 

Mkr09
.....

Member since 5/05

7550 total posts

Name:
M

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Well considering Kaydyn two weeks ago knocked something off my ILs shelf...my FIL asked her if she did it and she said "No Mema (grandma)" in a perfectly serious tone. My MIL wasn't even in the same room as her.

Posted 8/13/09 1:51 PM
 

Charly
LOVE!

Member since 5/05

12578 total posts

Name:

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

DD definitely tells stories and fibs and she's 2.5

Posted 8/13/09 2:34 PM
 

08BabySurprise
My Life. My Everything.

Member since 10/07

9151 total posts

Name:

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Ok don't laugh - but his favorite story to tell is that of the USAir Hudson River emergency plane landing. Chat Icon

My mom has Fox News on 24/7 at the house so Athan (17 months old) became obsessed and my mom kept talking about it I guess.

So he actually tells you how the plane went up (insert plane noises Vrrrooom and hand pointing upwards) and then the Canadian geese came (insert quack quack quack) - BTW do not ask me how the Canadian geese got tied into this story but that was his "bird of choice") - and they (the geese) got sucked into the motor and then BOOM! And he takes his hand and smacks it down on the table to show the plane coming down. Chat Icon

So yes - he is big on story telling... and preferably in Greek! I hope he picks up on this thing called "English" soon Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-08-13 14:47:29.307000.

Posted 8/13/09 2:46 PM
 

Tah-wee-ZAH
Kisses

Member since 5/05

15952 total posts

Name:

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted by 08BabySurprise

Ok don't laugh - but his favorite story to tell is that of the USAir Hudson River emergency plane landing. Chat Icon

My mom has Fox News on 24/7 at the house so Athan (17 months old) became obsessed and my mom kept talking about it I guess.

So he actually tells you how the plane went up (insert plane noises Vrrrooom and hand pointing upwards) and then the Canadian geese came (insert quack quack quack) - BTW do not ask me how the Canadian geese got tied into this story but that was his "bird of choice") - and they (the geese) got sucked into the motor and then BOOM! And he takes his hand and smacks it down on the table to show the plane coming down. Chat Icon

So yes - he is big on story telling... and preferably in Greek! I hope he picks up on this thing called "English" soon Chat Icon



OMG... that's HILARIOUSChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Is there a local Greek news program??? I think they've found their next reporterChat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/13/09 3:01 PM
 

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted by 08BabySurprise

Ok don't laugh - but his favorite story to tell is that of the USAir Hudson River emergency plane landing. Chat Icon

My mom has Fox News on 24/7 at the house so Athan (17 months old) became obsessed and my mom kept talking about it I guess.

So he actually tells you how the plane went up (insert plane noises Vrrrooom and hand pointing upwards) and then the Canadian geese came (insert quack quack quack) - BTW do not ask me how the Canadian geese got tied into this story but that was his "bird of choice") - and they (the geese) got sucked into the motor and then BOOM! And he takes his hand and smacks it down on the table to show the plane coming down. Chat Icon

So yes - he is big on story telling... and preferably in Greek! I hope he picks up on this thing called "English" soon Chat Icon




OMG I'm peeing!!! thats hysterical!!!!

Posted 8/13/09 3:05 PM
 

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted by 08BabySurprise

Ok don't laugh - but his favorite story to tell is that of the USAir Hudson River emergency plane landing. Chat Icon

My mom has Fox News on 24/7 at the house so Athan (17 months old) became obsessed and my mom kept talking about it I guess.

So he actually tells you how the plane went up (insert plane noises Vrrrooom and hand pointing upwards) and then the Canadian geese came (insert quack quack quack) - BTW do not ask me how the Canadian geese got tied into this story but that was his "bird of choice") - and they (the geese) got sucked into the motor and then BOOM! And he takes his hand and smacks it down on the table to show the plane coming down. Chat Icon

So yes - he is big on story telling... and preferably in Greek! I hope he picks up on this thing called "English" soon Chat Icon



just stop it right now, I can't!!! Im taking that baby boy of yours and keeping him forever. I will make him tell me that story EVERY DAY! I have tears in my eyes reading that. OMG

Posted 8/13/09 3:07 PM
 

08BabySurprise
My Life. My Everything.

Member since 10/07

9151 total posts

Name:

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted by pickles16

Posted by 08BabySurprise

Ok don't laugh - but his favorite story to tell is that of the USAir Hudson River emergency plane landing. Chat Icon

My mom has Fox News on 24/7 at the house so Athan (17 months old) became obsessed and my mom kept talking about it I guess.

So he actually tells you how the plane went up (insert plane noises Vrrrooom and hand pointing upwards) and then the Canadian geese came (insert quack quack quack) - BTW do not ask me how the Canadian geese got tied into this story but that was his "bird of choice") - and they (the geese) got sucked into the motor and then BOOM! And he takes his hand and smacks it down on the table to show the plane coming down. Chat Icon

So yes - he is big on story telling... and preferably in Greek! I hope he picks up on this thing called "English" soon Chat Icon




OMG I'm peeing!!! thats hysterical!!!!



And the best part? Now he HATES Canadian Geese - I think because he thinks they brought the plane down. So when he sees one he points and yells (and I mean yells) "DAAAAAAAAAAAAAAMMMMMMNNNNNNNN" - and yes... he STRETCHES the word out so you get the full affect of how much he dislikes them. Thanks mom! Chat Icon

Posted 8/13/09 3:08 PM
 

jambalady
Is it summer yet?

Member since 8/06

7392 total posts

Name:
Holly

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted by 08BabySurprise

Ok don't laugh - but his favorite story to tell is that of the USAir Hudson River emergency plane landing. Chat Icon

My mom has Fox News on 24/7 at the house so Athan (17 months old) became obsessed and my mom kept talking about it I guess.

So he actually tells you how the plane went up (insert plane noises Vrrrooom and hand pointing upwards) and then the Canadian geese came (insert quack quack quack) - BTW do not ask me how the Canadian geese got tied into this story but that was his "bird of choice") - and they (the geese) got sucked into the motor and then BOOM! And he takes his hand and smacks it down on the table to show the plane coming down. Chat Icon

So yes - he is big on story telling... and preferably in Greek! I hope he picks up on this thing called "English" soon Chat Icon



Are you serious????Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

That is too funny!!!

Posted 8/13/09 3:10 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted by 08BabySurprise

Ok don't laugh - but his favorite story to tell is that of the USAir Hudson River emergency plane landing. Chat Icon

My mom has Fox News on 24/7 at the house so Athan (17 months old) became obsessed and my mom kept talking about it I guess.

So he actually tells you how the plane went up (insert plane noises Vrrrooom and hand pointing upwards) and then the Canadian geese came (insert quack quack quack) - BTW do not ask me how the Canadian geese got tied into this story but that was his "bird of choice") - and they (the geese) got sucked into the motor and then BOOM! And he takes his hand and smacks it down on the table to show the plane coming down. Chat Icon

So yes - he is big on story telling... and preferably in Greek! I hope he picks up on this thing called "English" soon Chat Icon



I love him and I'm claiming him for Elizabeth! I don't care about the love affair between Nina and Athan. It's over. Ryan wants her anyway. Athan belongs to my Elizabeth now. Chat Icon Chat Icon

Besides, he's the only toddler on the board her age who's taller than she is.

Posted 8/13/09 3:11 PM
 

08BabySurprise
My Life. My Everything.

Member since 10/07

9151 total posts

Name:

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted by NinasMommy

Posted by 08BabySurprise

Ok don't laugh - but his favorite story to tell is that of the USAir Hudson River emergency plane landing. Chat Icon

My mom has Fox News on 24/7 at the house so Athan (17 months old) became obsessed and my mom kept talking about it I guess.

So he actually tells you how the plane went up (insert plane noises Vrrrooom and hand pointing upwards) and then the Canadian geese came (insert quack quack quack) - BTW do not ask me how the Canadian geese got tied into this story but that was his "bird of choice") - and they (the geese) got sucked into the motor and then BOOM! And he takes his hand and smacks it down on the table to show the plane coming down. Chat Icon

So yes - he is big on story telling... and preferably in Greek! I hope he picks up on this thing called "English" soon Chat Icon



just stop it right now, I can't!!! Im taking that baby boy of yours and keeping him forever. I will make him tell me that story EVERY DAY! I have tears in my eyes reading that. OMG



I really have to get it on video. It's the funniest thing EVER!!!! The sound effects are so hysterical. Way to go yia-yia! The best is the ending when he says "BOOM" and the one hand comes crashing down and smacks the other one so you get the full effect of the tragic ending. Dear Lord... Chat Icon

Posted 8/13/09 3:12 PM
 

08BabySurprise
My Life. My Everything.

Member since 10/07

9151 total posts

Name:

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted by jambalady

Posted by 08BabySurprise

Ok don't laugh - but his favorite story to tell is that of the USAir Hudson River emergency plane landing. Chat Icon

My mom has Fox News on 24/7 at the house so Athan (17 months old) became obsessed and my mom kept talking about it I guess.

So he actually tells you how the plane went up (insert plane noises Vrrrooom and hand pointing upwards) and then the Canadian geese came (insert quack quack quack) - BTW do not ask me how the Canadian geese got tied into this story but that was his "bird of choice") - and they (the geese) got sucked into the motor and then BOOM! And he takes his hand and smacks it down on the table to show the plane coming down. Chat Icon

So yes - he is big on story telling... and preferably in Greek! I hope he picks up on this thing called "English" soon Chat Icon



Are you serious????Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

That is too funny!!!



I am sure I am just days away from his reenactment of the health care town halls! Can you imagine how THAt will go? Chat Icon

Posted 8/13/09 3:14 PM
 

dawnygirl25
Growing up soo fast..

Member since 1/06

14917 total posts

Name:
Dawn

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

around 2.5

Posted 8/13/09 3:15 PM
 

jambalady
Is it summer yet?

Member since 8/06

7392 total posts

Name:
Holly

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted by 08BabySurprise

Posted by jambalady

Posted by 08BabySurprise

Ok don't laugh - but his favorite story to tell is that of the USAir Hudson River emergency plane landing. Chat Icon

My mom has Fox News on 24/7 at the house so Athan (17 months old) became obsessed and my mom kept talking about it I guess.

So he actually tells you how the plane went up (insert plane noises Vrrrooom and hand pointing upwards) and then the Canadian geese came (insert quack quack quack) - BTW do not ask me how the Canadian geese got tied into this story but that was his "bird of choice") - and they (the geese) got sucked into the motor and then BOOM! And he takes his hand and smacks it down on the table to show the plane coming down. Chat Icon

So yes - he is big on story telling... and preferably in Greek! I hope he picks up on this thing called "English" soon Chat Icon



Are you serious????Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

That is too funny!!!



I am sure I am just days away from his reenactment of the health care town halls! Can you imagine how THAt will go? Chat Icon



Now, that I would pay to see on video tape!!!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/13/09 3:18 PM
 

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted by 08BabySurprise

Posted by jambalady

Posted by 08BabySurprise

Ok don't laugh - but his favorite story to tell is that of the USAir Hudson River emergency plane landing. Chat Icon

My mom has Fox News on 24/7 at the house so Athan (17 months old) became obsessed and my mom kept talking about it I guess.

So he actually tells you how the plane went up (insert plane noises Vrrrooom and hand pointing upwards) and then the Canadian geese came (insert quack quack quack) - BTW do not ask me how the Canadian geese got tied into this story but that was his "bird of choice") - and they (the geese) got sucked into the motor and then BOOM! And he takes his hand and smacks it down on the table to show the plane coming down. Chat Icon

So yes - he is big on story telling... and preferably in Greek! I hope he picks up on this thing called "English" soon Chat Icon



Are you serious????Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

That is too funny!!!



I am sure I am just days away from his reenactment of the health care town halls! Can you imagine how THAt will go? Chat Icon



I hope he doesn't start acting like an "angry mob" LMAO

Posted 8/13/09 3:21 PM
 

08BabySurprise
My Life. My Everything.

Member since 10/07

9151 total posts

Name:

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted by eroxgirl

Posted by 08BabySurprise

Ok don't laugh - but his favorite story to tell is that of the USAir Hudson River emergency plane landing. Chat Icon

My mom has Fox News on 24/7 at the house so Athan (17 months old) became obsessed and my mom kept talking about it I guess.

So he actually tells you how the plane went up (insert plane noises Vrrrooom and hand pointing upwards) and then the Canadian geese came (insert quack quack quack) - BTW do not ask me how the Canadian geese got tied into this story but that was his "bird of choice") - and they (the geese) got sucked into the motor and then BOOM! And he takes his hand and smacks it down on the table to show the plane coming down. Chat Icon

So yes - he is big on story telling... and preferably in Greek! I hope he picks up on this thing called "English" soon Chat Icon



I love him and I'm claiming him for Elizabeth! I don't care about the love affair between Nina and Athan. It's over. Ryan wants her anyway. Athan belongs to my Elizabeth now. Chat Icon Chat Icon

Besides, he's the only toddler on the board her age who's taller than she is.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I think Ryan and Athan need to get together with Nina and Elizabeth ASAP. They will get the ladies to open up and start chatting in NO TIME!! Either that or the young ladies will get frustrated and lash out on the poor boys!

Posted 8/13/09 3:23 PM
 

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: What age does storytelling/fibbing start??

Posted by 08BabySurprise

Posted by eroxgirl

Posted by 08BabySurprise

Ok don't laugh - but his favorite story to tell is that of the USAir Hudson River emergency plane landing. Chat Icon

My mom has Fox News on 24/7 at the house so Athan (17 months old) became obsessed and my mom kept talking about it I guess.

So he actually tells you how the plane went up (insert plane noises Vrrrooom and hand pointing upwards) and then the Canadian geese came (insert quack quack quack) - BTW do not ask me how the Canadian geese got tied into this story but that was his "bird of choice") - and they (the geese) got sucked into the motor and then BOOM! And he takes his hand and smacks it down on the table to show the plane coming down. Chat Icon

So yes - he is big on story telling... and preferably in Greek! I hope he picks up on this thing called "English" soon Chat Icon



I love him and I'm claiming him for Elizabeth! I don't care about the love affair between Nina and Athan. It's over. Ryan wants her anyway. Athan belongs to my Elizabeth now. Chat Icon Chat Icon

Besides, he's the only toddler on the board her age who's taller than she is.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I think Ryan and Athan need to get together with Nina and Elizabeth ASAP. They will get the ladies to open up and start chatting in NO TIME!! Either that or the young ladies will get frustrated and lash out on the poor boys!



Oh no you didn't, Rebecca!!! Remember, Nina bites, watch out!

Posted 8/13/09 3:28 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spinoff to kids & age appropriateness PiyoPika566 3/21/06 45 Families Helping Families ™
women's age differences jersee3380 3/7/06 6 Families Helping Families ™
Kirby Puckett passed at age 45 DjPiLL 3/7/06 2 Sports
At what age did your baby start feeding themself? mommy2Alex 3/6/06 9 Parenting
Actor Franklin Cover Dies at Age 77 HarleyGirlFLA 2/10/06 0 Families Helping Families ™
What age where you when you first saw... Moehick 2/3/06 10 Families Helping Families ™