wedding conflict- UPDATED!
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
wedding conflict- UPDATED! OK here's the situation in a nutshell: Message edited 2008-06-16 21:45:44.587000. |
|
Posted 6/12/08 10:57 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions I think it depends on how you are goig to present your argument. Will you nicely say I dpn't particulary like or agree with this saying, can you switch the sayings you have picked out so I don't read this one, or maybe switchwhere in the day I read and you can keep the readings in order and I can read a different one. |
|
Posted 6/12/08 11:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions I think I would say something as tactfully as possible. Let them know that you are having trouble because you disagree with the passage and that you feel bad because you are not sure that you can give them an eloquent reading, which they deserve on their wedding day. Tell them that you do not want to be picky about your reading but this one is so far from your beliefs. Ask if they had considered any others before they got this one. Maybe they will tell you that they have a second choice that will suit them just as well. If you feel that you would not be insulted if they had someone else read it, let them know that. |
|
Posted 6/12/08 11:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions I can't speak for them but I know when we were looking at picking a reading from the Old Testament (the New was better) but the OLD... ALL of the readings were like that. So, at this point, even if they picked another reading I think you would run into statements like that no matter what. We picked the "best" one in terms of not saying things like that and it still said things like "finds a worthy wife" and all that stuff. |
|
Posted 6/12/08 11:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions i would have to say, do the reading. it is their wedding and this is the reading they chose so somehow, they gfeel it resonates with them. |
|
Posted 6/12/08 11:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions Even though I didn't believe in it, I would still read it. It's their wedding and their view. |
|
Posted 6/12/08 11:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions
|
|
Posted 6/12/08 11:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions OK...all good points ladies! |
|
Posted 6/12/08 11:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions Because you asked for opinions.......... |
|
Posted 6/13/08 7:32 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions I would not say anything and just do the reading. It is their wedding, and no one is going to think that YOU believe it. I have to agree with a PP, ALL of the Old Testament readings you can pick from ( if they are Catholic) include similar wording. |
|
Posted 6/13/08 7:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions I wouldn't say anything. I would just do the reading. |
|
Posted 6/13/08 7:46 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions Posted by Porrruss Because you asked for opinions.......... I wouldn't say a thing and just do the reading. You really need to suck this one up. The day is not about you or your feelings. This is the reading the bride and groom chose to be read at THEIR wedding. You are not being asked to endorse the message, just relay it. If someone questioned me on my choice of readings for my wedding citing a difference of opinion/belief, I would have really been insulted and felt that person was just trying to make it about themself. I agree. And I don't think anyone will assume that just because you are reading it that it is what you believe. And I cannot remember one verse read at any wedding I have ever attended, so that's about how well everyone will be paying attention, especially if it's a long Catholic ceremony.
|
|
Posted 6/13/08 7:46 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions Posted by Tilde I would not say anything and just do the reading. It is their wedding, and no one is going to think that YOU believe it. I have to agree with a PP, ALL of the Old Testament readings you can pick from ( if they are Catholic) include similar wording. Good Luck! ITA. You are doing the reading for THEM -- It's not about what you want to read or what you believe. It's what they have chosen to have read at their wedding and what they want to have read at their wedding. Think about the state you were in just 2 weeks before your wedding -- any sort of potential criticism like you want to offer would have been taken the exact wrong way by me when I was 2 weeks away from my wedding. ;) (And I thought I was a fairly sane bride - LOL) I've never once attributed a reading at a wedding to the reader. Ever. I attributed it to the couple. Along the same vein, unless a reading was horribly offensive and contained words I just could NOT read out loud EVER, I would just do the reading as I was asked. It's a wedding -- not a political statement or campaign speech for me. FWIW, I totally understand your problem with the reading. In fact, my DH went out of our way to make sure there was NO such sentiment in any of the readings at our wedding (and no mention of children / procreation in our readings either). So I do understand and respect your opinion. I'd feel the same way getting the reading... but I wouldn't say anything. |
|
Posted 6/13/08 7:54 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions Posted by Arieschick29 BUT 2nd dilemma- FSIL wrote in her e-mail that "any version" of the verse was ok with them.... I found one that words it more liberally. I was thinking of asking her to read that one instead. Should I try? (I don't know her very well- only met 2x- so this makes it tricky). I think this solves the first dilemma! I would present it exactly like you said to us- i found this version of the verse and i really love it! can i read that? i wouldn't say any more than that (that you don't like the old one), just that you like the more liberal one. see what she says. |
|
Posted 6/13/08 8:03 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions Posted by Shelly Posted by Arieschick29 BUT 2nd dilemma- FSIL wrote in her e-mail that "any version" of the verse was ok with them.... I found one that words it more liberally. I was thinking of asking her to read that one instead. Should I try? (I don't know her very well- only met 2x- so this makes it tricky). I think this solves the first dilemma! I would present it exactly like you said to us- i found this version of the verse and i really love it! can i read that? i wouldn't say any more than that (that you don't like the old one), just that you like the more liberal one. see what she says. I think this is a good idea! Plus, you can present it just as "oh, I love this version, is this okay?" and not have to say anything about the first version.
|
|
Posted 6/13/08 8:17 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions Posted by Shelly Posted by Arieschick29 BUT 2nd dilemma- FSIL wrote in her e-mail that "any version" of the verse was ok with them.... I found one that words it more liberally. I was thinking of asking her to read that one instead. Should I try? (I don't know her very well- only met 2x- so this makes it tricky). I think this solves the first dilemma! I would present it exactly like you said to us- i found this version of the verse and i really love it! can i read that? i wouldn't say any more than that (that you don't like the old one), just that you like the more liberal one. see what she says. I agree! |
|
Posted 6/13/08 8:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions Maybe she doesnt reallize the implications of the reading? |
|
Posted 6/13/08 9:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions Posted by angnick Maybe she doesnt reallize the implications of the reading? why dont you broach it with her by asking how she thought to choose this reading/ Considering it is 2 weeks before the wedding and the OP admits she's only met the FSIL a couple of times, I really feel this is truly being pushy. Message edited 2008-06-13 09:48:12.673000. |
|
Posted 6/13/08 9:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions Posted by DaniRella I can't speak for them but I know when we were looking at picking a reading from the Old Testament (the New was better) but the OLD... ALL of the readings were like that. So, at this point, even if they picked another reading I think you would run into statements like that no matter what. We picked the "best" one in terms of not saying things like that and it still said things like "finds a worthy wife" and all that stuff. : Us as well - it was very hard to pick a reading! If you find a less harsh version - it wouldn't hurt to show to FSIL- she might like it more than the one she had to choose from in the book! |
|
Posted 6/13/08 10:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions You believe what you believe. You participating in the ceremony doesn't necessarily mean you advocate the passage. I wouldn't say anything and I would do the reading as asked. |
|
Posted 6/13/08 10:25 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions Grrrr, my cousin had that reading at his wedding too and I swear I almost got whiplash turning around to see my family's reaction when it was read. We were all shocked. |
|
Posted 6/13/08 10:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions It is not your day so not your choice what the reading is. Stand up there, read it and smile. Blunt but JMHO. |
|
Posted 6/13/08 10:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions Posted by Kara Posted by Shelly Posted by Arieschick29 BUT 2nd dilemma- FSIL wrote in her e-mail that "any version" of the verse was ok with them.... I found one that words it more liberally. I was thinking of asking her to read that one instead. Should I try? (I don't know her very well- only met 2x- so this makes it tricky). I think this solves the first dilemma! I would present it exactly like you said to us- i found this version of the verse and i really love it! can i read that? i wouldn't say any more than that (that you don't like the old one), just that you like the more liberal one. see what she says. I think this is a good idea! Plus, you can present it just as "oh, I love this version, is this okay?" and not have to say anything about the first version. I agree
|
|
Posted 6/13/08 10:39 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions i'd ask her if the liberal version of the reading is good--WITHOUT mentioning anything about your feelings on the reading at all. if she prefers the traditional...just read it. |
|
Posted 6/13/08 10:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: wedding conflict- need opinions You know, my husband is pretty religious and before we got married we had a few long discussions about passages in the Bible like this. We even talked with our pastor about it. |
|
Posted 6/13/08 10:45 AM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| If you don't attend someone's wedding... (opinions needed) | Lucky09 | 1/23/07 | 6 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Sorry Wedding Related....but I need opinions | BriBri2u | 11/1/06 | 10 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Opinions Needed-Semi Wedding Related | traceyd | 10/13/06 | 13 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Opinions Needed on Wedding issue | jnico | 3/29/06 | 15 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| need opinions on planning trip for out of state wedding | Myrockette | 3/24/06 | 2 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Sorry, wedding related, but I'd prefer YOUR opinions over LIW... | Shorty | 10/13/05 | 53 | Families Helping Families ™ |



















