Was Oprah wrong?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

CaMacho
Sisters :)

Member since 7/06

15112 total posts

Name:
Jess

Was Oprah wrong?

Central Park Rape Victim and Oprah, at Odds

Ms. Winfrey: "When I first heard about you, I thought, why were you running alone in Central Park at night?"

Central Park Jogger: "You’re not the first person to say that. For me, running was a release at the end of the day, and I had this feeling that, hey, I have every right to run where I want, when I want. I’d been running in the park for two years. It was not a smart thing to do. Yet that is absolutely no justification for what happened to me."




Do you think that question is blaming the victim?

I think it's a valid question and one that i'm sure that almost everyone watching or hearing about this would want to know. It doesn't give someone the right to do this to her, but these days you have to be so careful. A woman, alone, in a huge park, in the dark at night, hardly anyone else around... scares me just thinking about it.

Posted 11/15/07 6:32 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

JessInCA
live laugh love

Member since 8/06

5082 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

Posted by CaMacho

Do you think that question is blaming the victim?




A little. It's not outright blaming the victim, but it does imply that she could have prevented what happened to her. I do think it's a valid question though, and that's Oprah's job, to ask tough questions (or questions the rest of us may have had but wouldn't ask ourselves). I don't think Oprah was wrong for asking her that.

Posted 11/15/07 6:38 PM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

I think she put herself at a higher risk by going in the park alone at night. Does that count as blaming the victim?

Posted 11/15/07 6:38 PM
 

DebG
Pick a cause & stand up for it

Member since 5/05

18602 total posts

Name:
The cure IS worse!

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

Sounds vaguely familiar to an old thoughtprocess which involved asking a victim what she was wearing


Chat Icon in my book

Posted 11/15/07 6:39 PM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

I don't think Oprah was wrong at all.

It was asking a very obvious question that is on a lot of peoples minds. It is not BLAMING the victim..its just a curious "why would you do that" question.

Put it this way...things happen every single day that are in no way a justification or fair result of an action...being raped is never warranted or justified...but Oprah's question is fair in my opinion.

Posted 11/15/07 6:47 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

Posted by DebG

Sounds vaguely familiar to an old thoughtprocess which involved asking a victim what she was wearing


Chat Icon in my book



I don't necessarily agree. I think the question was fair and reasonable.

Oprah is in the business of asking tough questions. Questions that, I have no doubt, many others were thinking themselves. I don't think she
was wrong for asking what she did.

Side bar: I do think this woman took a VERY unnecessary risk by running in Central Park alone at night. Is it right that she got attacked? NO! But it's an unfortunate truth of that place at night. People need to use their heads and keep themselves safe b/c there ARE people in this world who wouldn't think twice about harming another for no reason. I know this personally unfortunately.

I equate her running at night alone in the park to having unprotected sex with someone who you know is HIV positive. You're taking a VERY serious risk of getting HIV yourself.

ETA: I don't equate Oprah's question to that of asking a victim what she was wearing. I'm COMPLETE opposed to anyone asking a victim that question. What you wear out, should have no baring on being attacked.

Message edited 2007-11-15 19:00:26.453000.

Posted 11/15/07 6:55 PM
 

2PreciousBlessings
The Perfect Pair

Member since 5/06

19861 total posts

Name:
Best Wife & Mommy

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

Posted by Jennie0898

Posted by DebG

Sounds vaguely familiar to an old thoughtprocess which involved asking a victim what she was wearing


Chat Icon in my book



I don't necessarily agree. I think the question was fair and reasonable.

Oprah is in the business of asking tough questions. Questions that, I have no doubt, many others were thinking themselves. I don't think she
was wrong for asking what she did.

Side bar: I do think this woman took a VERY unnecessary risk by running in Central Park alone at night. Is it right that she got attacked? NO! But it's an unfortunate truth of that place at night. People need to use their heads and keep themselves safe b/c there ARE people in this world who wouldn't think twice about harming another for no reason. I know this personally unfortunately.

I equate her running at night alone in the park to having unprotected sex with someone who you know is HIV positive. You're taking a VERY serious risk of getting HIV yourself.



ITA!! I'm sure alot of people are thinking why would she take such risk especially knowing what can happen.

Posted 11/15/07 6:59 PM
 

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

It Oprah's job to ask those questions. Not to mention, Im sure a lot of us think "why the heck would you go running by yourself in the park after dark?"

Posted 11/15/07 7:00 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

Do I think the question was BLAMING the victim? No. I think the question brought up a really good point about safety and making smart choices.

We all know it's not the smartest decision to jog alone at night in Central Park. That doesn't mean she was asking for it OF COURSE - but there's a lesson to be learned from the horrible tragedy that happened to her.

Posted 11/15/07 7:01 PM
 

Whamtastic
LIF Adult

Member since 1/07

997 total posts

Name:
Big Fat Baby with a Blackberry

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

Posted by Kara

Do I think the question was BLAMING the victim? No. I think the question brought up a really good point about safety and making smart choices.

We all know it's not the smartest decision to jog alone at night in Central Park. That doesn't mean she was asking for it OF COURSE - but there's a lesson to be learned from the horrible tragedy that happened to her.



I agree. In no way was this woman asking for it, but she put herself in a risky situation and the question should be asked.

Posted 11/15/07 7:16 PM
 

donegal419
St. Gerard, pray for us.

Member since 7/07

7650 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

I don't think it's blaming the vicitim, it just seemed like a question one might ask in this day and age...like why put yourself at risk?

I think her actions (jogging alone at night) increased her risk for something happening to her. it does NOT justify what was done to her, that was wrong no matter what time of day or night.


Overall, I think there are things that we can do to make ourselves safer/less at risk for crime or other safety issues.

Posted 11/15/07 7:23 PM
 

SuzyQ
Mama to 3!?!?!?

Member since 7/06

8069 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

Posted by Kara

Do I think the question was BLAMING the victim? No. I think the question brought up a really good point about safety and making smart choices.

We all know it's not the smartest decision to jog alone at night in Central Park. That doesn't mean she was asking for it OF COURSE - but there's a lesson to be learned from the horrible tragedy that happened to her.



I completely agree.

Posted 11/15/07 7:30 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

I'm on the fence... if it was a random person saying that to her I would Chat Icon but it's Oprah's job to ask these types of questions. maybe she could have worded it differently - like "weren't you scared going jogging there alone at night"?

Posted 11/15/07 7:36 PM
 

DebG
Pick a cause & stand up for it

Member since 5/05

18602 total posts

Name:
The cure IS worse!

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

I'm on the fence... if it was a random person saying that to her I would Chat Icon but it's Oprah's job to ask these types of questions. maybe she could have worded it differently - like "weren't you scared going jogging there alone at night"?

I would respect and appreciate this version a LOT more.

Posted 11/15/07 7:42 PM
 

DebG
Pick a cause & stand up for it

Member since 5/05

18602 total posts

Name:
The cure IS worse!

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

ooh and I apologize if this is ignorant as I really don't know so that is why I am asking.
Doesnt Central Park specifically have a trail for walking/running/cycling?

Posted 11/15/07 7:43 PM
 

TheWhiteRabbit
Thru the rabbit hole!

Member since 7/06

4412 total posts

Name:

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

I don't know how I feel about it. When it's YOUR neighborhood, you tend to feel safe. Maybe due to her job she could only go jogging at that time. Maybe she couldn't afford a gym. Maybe she loved the beauty of the park and refused to live her life in fear of that very thing that happened to her happening.

Would it have been OK if say, she was walking her little chihuahua? Would you say that to a woman who works late and has to get her car from a parking garage alone late at night? I mean, almost everywhere we as women go there are risks. We hear about it everyday. I don't know how much we should let the fear of being attacked run our lives. I hate that I ever have to think about it when I am planning my errands.

Posted 11/15/07 7:47 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

Posted by DebG

ooh and I apologize if this is ignorant as I really don't know so that is why I am asking.
Doesnt Central Park specifically have a trail for walking/running/cycling?



There are paths throughout the park that can be used for walking, running, etc. I think some are specifically for that purpose.

Posted 11/15/07 8:02 PM
 

missus-hbradio
Twin mommy

Member since 5/05

15857 total posts

Name:

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

Ewww yes. There is no excuse for rape EVER. Doesnt matter if the woman was running in the worst neighborhood in the country at 3AM. Sorry thats the way I feel.

Posted 11/15/07 8:12 PM
 

DaniJude
You're My Home <3

Member since 11/06

14815 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

I think Oprah asked that because that is what a lot of people thought when they first heard about the story. Don't get me wrong- that girl had EVERY right in the world to jog in the park whenever she wants and it was horrible for her to get raped-- I'm just thinking, in reality, that Oprah asked that b/c a lot of people probably scratched their heads wondering why someone would put themselves at an increased risk like that. I think Oprah, and other famous people who interview others, ask the questions people want to know the answers to... the questions that are probably on a lot of people's minds.

I don't think that it has to do with is that question blaming the victim or not.

Posted 11/15/07 8:17 PM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

Posted by BellaPaige

Posted by Jennie0898

Posted by DebG

Sounds vaguely familiar to an old thoughtprocess which involved asking a victim what she was wearing


Chat Icon in my book



I don't necessarily agree. I think the question was fair and reasonable.

Oprah is in the business of asking tough questions. Questions that, I have no doubt, many others were thinking themselves. I don't think she
was wrong for asking what she did.

Side bar: I do think this woman took a VERY unnecessary risk by running in Central Park alone at night. Is it right that she got attacked? NO! But it's an unfortunate truth of that place at night. People need to use their heads and keep themselves safe b/c there ARE people in this world who wouldn't think twice about harming another for no reason. I know this personally unfortunately.

I equate her running at night alone in the park to having unprotected sex with someone who you know is HIV positive. You're taking a VERY serious risk of getting HIV yourself.



ITA!! I'm sure alot of people are thinking why would she take such risk especially knowing what can happen.



I agree with Deb and lets be honest for a second...When was the last time Oprah was a hard news journalist!? Her job is being an entertainer not a reporter. I think the question was worded VERY badly.

Posted 11/15/07 8:23 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

The question was inappropriate in my book.

I guess she "wanted it" since she was jogging at night?Chat Icon

Posted 11/15/07 8:26 PM
 

CaMacho
Sisters :)

Member since 7/06

15112 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

Posted by DaniRella

I don't think that it has to do with is that question blaming the victim or not.



This is what the victim said:

Ms. Meili told NY1: If she were to ask me that question now I’d say, “If that isn’t a blame the victim question, I don’t know what is,”

Posted 11/15/07 8:28 PM
 

CaMacho
Sisters :)

Member since 7/06

15112 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

Posted by nrthshgrl

I guess she "wanted it" since she was jogging at night?Chat Icon



No obviously not. But isn't there increased risk?

Posted 11/15/07 8:33 PM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

Posted by CaMacho

Posted by DaniRella

I don't think that it has to do with is that question blaming the victim or not.



This is what the victim said:

Ms. Meili told NY1: If she were to ask me that question now I’d say, “If that isn’t a blame the victim question, I don’t know what is,”



I find the whole situation very sad. That in this day and age rape victims still need to defend themselves in this wayChat Icon

Posted 11/15/07 8:33 PM
 

DaniJude
You're My Home <3

Member since 11/06

14815 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Was Oprah wrong?

Posted by CaMacho

Posted by DaniRella

I don't think that it has to do with is that question blaming the victim or not.



This is what the victim said:

Ms. Meili told NY1: If she were to ask me that question now I’d say, “If that isn’t a blame the victim question, I don’t know what is,”



Yikes, poor girl.

She apparently took it that way, didn't she? Aww, that's kinda sad that she was offended that way.

I mean, I don't know but I'm sure Oprah didn't mean it that way... being a victim of a sexual crime herself as a young girl... but either way- the rapist, as a person and a victim is entitled to her feelings and she is entitled to get offended if she wants.

I just know the media and how it works and it always seems like Oprah asks the questions she asks b/c she and her writers/producers (I'm guessing) feel that these are the questions people want the answers to.

I guess maybe she should have phrased it better - perhaps by saying that she didn't feel it was her fault in ANY way shape or form but that there were a lot of people who, when they first heard about the story, wondered why someone would put themselves in a risky situation like that... and maybe asked it more like that rather than the way she did.

Chat Icon

ETA: I'm not saying really if it was right or not- I can't really make that decision myself- I don't really know what to make of it b/c I don't know exactly what Oprah was thinking for SURE but I'm just trying to THINK of WHY she would have asked that-- and I think it has more to do with ratings and asking the questions that people are interested in hearing than trying to blame or offend... but I could be wrong, of course.

Message edited 2007-11-15 20:36:07.780000.

Posted 11/15/07 8:34 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Today on Oprah... 75 tons of junk in there house... Acerone 11/15/07 35 Families Helping Families ™
Oprah says I am wearing the wrong bra sunny 3/26/06 22 Families Helping Families ™
Posted Picture of the wrong dog :-) danielleandscott 3/21/06 17 Families Helping Families ™
I dont know what's wrong w/ me lately!! Cookiegobbler 3/20/06 20 Families Helping Families ™
sorry, wrong board! VirginiaDeb 3/19/06 0 Pregnancy
wrong board Shelly 3/17/06 1 Families Helping Families ™