Waiting for EI?

Posted By Message

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Waiting for EI?

Any ST's know why Dr's are so prone to wait? When all I have been reading suggests the earlier the better?

Noah still says NOTHING. He is 16 months old.

The Dr said to wait till 18 months. Well I dont see him reaching the 18 month milestone in 2 months...( putting two words together, sentances etc) when he cannot even say mama.

The Dr said that he may not even qualify for EI b/c he showed his receptive speech to be way above normal for his age.

But that bothers me. Do the two REALLY go together that much?

Just hate putting it off. HE gets more and more frustrated these days when I cannot understand him. He relies on the few signs we taught him but is not being receptive to the new ones we are trying.

TIA

Posted 10/6/08 7:47 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

purplegirl
.

Member since 5/06

2423 total posts

Name:

Re: Waiting for EI?

Many doctors are actually moving towards recommending evals now, I've noticed. It used to be that the parents would be the referral for the evals that I've done and now I'm getting a lot of pediatricians referring.

The only pro towards waiting a little longer is that the older the child is, and the greater the delay (ie: an 18 month old functioning at a 12 month level vs. a 15 month old at a 12 month level) the better chances of getting services.

Receptive language is very important for developing expressive speech (in other words, most kids understand vocab before they are going to say it)... but in the cases where the receptive is very high and expressive is very low, there is often a motor speech component to the situation (the child may have difficulty FORMING the sounds) as opposed to delayed language. If thats the case, I definitely recommend getting your child evaluated.

First of all, the EI eval is FREE. So there is really no harm in trying. And second of all, if he doesn't qualify first time around, you can request a re-eval.

Does your son make any sounds? Babble? Try to imitate words? Please FM me if you want to talk specifics (I'm a speech pathologist). I hope that helps... good luck!

Posted 10/6/08 7:53 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Waiting for EI?

Is he babbling- like it sounds like he's speaking another language? That crazy babbling is a baby's way of mimicing "adult speech" and is really the beginning of developing ltrue anguage.

Receptive language is REALLY the most important piece. A child with poor receptive language skills are really the most at risk for lasting delays. Most "late talkers" (expressive language delay only) catch up.

Message edited 2008-10-06 19:55:13.610000.

Posted 10/6/08 7:53 PM
 

laurenM
LIF Adult

Member since 6/05

1440 total posts

Name:

Re: Waiting for EI?

my doc also said to wait until 18 months... mt dd was only saying "hi" and "more". The day she turned 18 months I called and honestly in the few days it took to get he paperwork and I planned to bring it to my doc later in the week, I noticed that suddenly she started saying cheese, ball, stop, daddy.... very weird. So right now I am actually holding onto the paperwork and not doing anything with it.
When I did call and speak with the woman she also told me that she couldnt say for sure without actually evaluating but that usually if the little ones can follow commands (point to a body part, bring me the cup) that they dont quailify as easily for simply not speaking until 2.

She did keep telling me that it is our right as parents to follow through on an evaluation if we are concerned and that nothing stops us from re-testing at 2 if we are still not seeing progress.

Hope this helps! GOod luck.

Posted 10/6/08 7:55 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Waiting for EI?

Posted by purplegirl

, there is often a motor speech component to the situation (the child may have difficulty FORMING the sounds) as opposed to delayed language. If thats the case, I definitely recommend getting your child evaluated.




YES, this seems to be the problem. He used to babble age appropriately when he was younger, he said ba ba, ma ma, da da at like 4-6 months old and then stopped..we used to say he was gonna talk EARLY...LOL

He tends to gargle a LOT? Not sure if its anything or just a personality thing. He garbles when he speaks. IT's weird. and its just a mush of sounds.

Now, he will try...he tried to say Elmo yesterday and he kept going MAAAAAAAAAAAAA MOOOOOOOOOOOO...Like really trying so hard and it just wasnt coming out.

Posted 10/6/08 7:59 PM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: Waiting for EI?

Posted by Porrruss

Is he babbling- like it sounds like he's speaking another language? That crazy babbling is a baby's way of mimicing "adult speech" and is really the beginning of developing ltrue anguage.

Receptive language is REALLY the most important piece. A child with poor receptive language skills are really the most at risk for lasting delays. Most "late talkers" (expressive language delay only) catch up.




I'm obviously not a ST, but I would think both are equally important. One can be strong in receptive and very weak in expressive and still need therapy. My son is a good example of that, who at age 9 is still receiving speech therapy for expressive and articulation. They don't always catch up and I think addressing a potential issue early on is the best method.

Donna, I would just call EI and schedule the evaulation Chat Icon

Posted 10/6/08 8:08 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Waiting for EI?

Posted by Summerrluvv

Posted by Porrruss

Is he babbling- like it sounds like he's speaking another language? That crazy babbling is a baby's way of mimicing "adult speech" and is really the beginning of developing ltrue anguage.

Receptive language is REALLY the most important piece. A child with poor receptive language skills are really the most at risk for lasting delays. Most "late talkers" (expressive language delay only) catch up.




I'm obviously not a ST, but I would think both are equally important. One can be strong in receptive and very weak in expressive and still need therapy. My son is a good example of that, who at age 9 is still receiving speech therapy for expressive and articulation. They don't always catch up and I think addressing a potential issue early on is the best method.

Donna, I would just call EI and schedule the evaulation Chat Icon



I agree with SummerChat Icon Chat Icon

Summer texted me the number for C3, want me to text it to you?!

Posted 10/6/08 8:09 PM
 

My3Shmoos
Me and my Monkey

Member since 7/06

2437 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Waiting for EI?

Posted by dm24angel

Any ST's know why Dr's are so prone to wait? When all I have been reading suggests the earlier the better?

Noah still says NOTHING. He is 16 months old.

The Dr said to wait till 18 months. Well I dont see him reaching the 18 month milestone in 2 months...( putting two words together, sentances etc) when he cannot even say mama.

The Dr said that he may not even qualify for EI b/c he showed his receptive speech to be way above normal for his age.

But that bothers me. Do the two REALLY go together that much?

Just hate putting it off. HE gets more and more frustrated these days when I cannot understand him. He relies on the few signs we taught him but is not being receptive to the new ones we are trying.

TIA



It is like you read my mind. I was just abut to post this about my DS. He is 17 months. I had asked the ladies here before about calling EI nad put it off because he did start to talk a little more. Now we are taking steps back. I am alomost thinking that my DS is having some hearing problems too. I willbe calling this week. for our EI.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon to you!

Posted 10/6/08 8:20 PM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: Waiting for EI?

If I were you I would call. I did call actually 7 months ago, and my son is getting the help that he needs. Although part of me is sad that he needs help, most of me is really relieved that he is getting it.

I'm not saying at all that I think your son needs EI. Receptive language is great. I'm just saying that my doctor told me to wait, and told me my son would never quailify. It was only from coming on here, I pushed the female doctor in the office for answers, and she told me to call EI.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/6/08 8:29 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Waiting for EI?

Donna - my ped said I could call now - or wait until 18 months. I decided to call one of the Nassau agencies - the Marion Soloman Group. I spoke to the woman who handles the evaluations - and after speaking with her she suggested I call back at 17 months if Jack is still not talking. She said that what he is saying now - at his age - are considered to be words.

If you want to call them I have the Suffolk number - she was so helpful and sent me out a packet of information that I received the next day!

Posted 10/6/08 8:59 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: Waiting for EI?

Posted by Summerrluvv

Posted by Porrruss

Is he babbling- like it sounds like he's speaking another language? That crazy babbling is a baby's way of mimicing "adult speech" and is really the beginning of developing ltrue anguage.

Receptive language is REALLY the most important piece. A child with poor receptive language skills are really the most at risk for lasting delays. Most "late talkers" (expressive language delay only) catch up.




I'm obviously not a ST, but I would think both are equally important. One can be strong in receptive and very weak in expressive and still need therapy. My son is a good example of that, who at age 9 is still receiving speech therapy for expressive and articulation. They don't always catch up and I think addressing a potential issue early on is the best method.

Donna, I would just call EI and schedule the evaulation Chat Icon



I think what she means is that when a child has a receptive delay there is more likely an underlying issue going on then with a simple expressive delay...

Some kids are just late talkers.

Posted 10/6/08 9:19 PM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: Waiting for EI?

Posted by hbugal

Posted by Summerrluvv

Posted by Porrruss

Is he babbling- like it sounds like he's speaking another language? That crazy babbling is a baby's way of mimicing "adult speech" and is really the beginning of developing ltrue anguage.

Receptive language is REALLY the most important piece. A child with poor receptive language skills are really the most at risk for lasting delays. Most "late talkers" (expressive language delay only) catch up.




I'm obviously not a ST, but I would think both are equally important. One can be strong in receptive and very weak in expressive and still need therapy. My son is a good example of that, who at age 9 is still receiving speech therapy for expressive and articulation. They don't always catch up and I think addressing a potential issue early on is the best method.

Donna, I would just call EI and schedule the evaulation Chat Icon



I think what she means is that when a child has a receptive delay there is more likely an underlying issue going on then with a simple expressive delay...

Some kids are just late talkers.



I understood what she was saying, but as I pointed out, no receptive delay doesn't mean all that much. Case in point posted above.

Yes, I agree some are just plain late talkers.

Posted 10/6/08 9:43 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Waiting for EI?

Posted by hbugal

Posted by Summerrluvv

Posted by Porrruss

Is he babbling- like it sounds like he's speaking another language? That crazy babbling is a baby's way of mimicing "adult speech" and is really the beginning of developing ltrue anguage.

Receptive language is REALLY the most important piece. A child with poor receptive language skills are really the most at risk for lasting delays. Most "late talkers" (expressive language delay only) catch up.




I'm obviously not a ST, but I would think both are equally important. One can be strong in receptive and very weak in expressive and still need therapy. My son is a good example of that, who at age 9 is still receiving speech therapy for expressive and articulation. They don't always catch up and I think addressing a potential issue early on is the best method.

Donna, I would just call EI and schedule the evaulation Chat Icon



I think what she means is that when a child has a receptive delay there is more likely an underlying issue going on then with a simple expressive delay...

Some kids are just late talkers.



I worry about a physical issue with the expressive delay. He was a late solid food eater and still needs food real small. There was also a possibel issue when I was PG about a throat issue b/c I had so much extra amniotic fluid.

Anyway...How do I push this with the Dr? Wait the two months or call EI and ask? Anyone have a suggestion?

I feel he may just be a late "talker" but even those usually have a FEW words by now..mama, dada, baba etc. right?

Posted 10/6/08 10:04 PM
 

Sunshyne
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/07

563 total posts

Name:
Elissa

Re: Waiting for EI?

The reason they want you to wait may be that you can only have your child evaluated once in a set time period (6 months, I think). In order to qualify for services,he would need to have a 33% delay in his expressive language, (or 25% each in both expressive and receptive) which he may very well not, at 18 months, the expectations are greater, so he might at that point. The dr may not want to "waste" an eval, to have to wait to be eligible for another.

Posted 10/6/08 10:18 PM
 

groovypeg
:)

Member since 5/05

2423 total posts

Name:

Re: Waiting for EI?

you dont need to wait for your docs approval for the ei eval. just do it. if you have any concerns now is the time to call. pls dont wait. ei is free and confidential. the only thing your doc will need to do is to provide a copy of his immunizations.

Posted 10/6/08 10:20 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Waiting for EI?

Posted by Sunshyne

The reason they want you to wait may be that you can only have your child evaluated once in a set time period (6 months, I think). In order to qualify for services,he would need to have a 33% delay in his expressive language, (or 25% each in both expressive and receptive) which he may very well not, at 18 months, the expectations are greater, so he might at that point. The dr may not want to "waste" an eval, to have to wait to be eligible for another.



Thank you for this explanation!

Posted 10/6/08 10:21 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: Waiting for EI?

Posted by dm24angel


I worry about a physical issue with the expressive delay. He was a late solid food eater and still needs food real small. There was also a possibel issue when I was PG about a throat issue b/c I had so much extra amniotic fluid.

Anyway...How do I push this with the Dr? Wait the two months or call EI and ask? Anyone have a suggestion?

I feel he may just be a late "talker" but even those usually have a FEW words by now..mama, dada, baba etc. right?



My daughter went through EI back when it was first implemented in NY State. The guidelines were different back then. Pataki changed things when he was in office. (But Im not going to go there) So Im not sure how things go...BUT..do you need your doctors referrel to get EI? If not I'd just call. If not for anything else just piece of mind...

I dont mean to sound condesending but are you sure he isnt talking at all? Or is it just not real words? Caden talks quite a lot but some of the words can barely be understood. I mean his word for book is really just "ba" he does the k with his mouth but it's silent. Had I not had previous children and a child who received speech I might have missed it...

Posted 10/6/08 10:23 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Waiting for EI?

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by hbugal

Posted by Summerrluvv

Posted by Porrruss

Is he babbling- like it sounds like he's speaking another language? That crazy babbling is a baby's way of mimicing "adult speech" and is really the beginning of developing ltrue anguage.

Receptive language is REALLY the most important piece. A child with poor receptive language skills are really the most at risk for lasting delays. Most "late talkers" (expressive language delay only) catch up.




I'm obviously not a ST, but I would think both are equally important. One can be strong in receptive and very weak in expressive and still need therapy. My son is a good example of that, who at age 9 is still receiving speech therapy for expressive and articulation. They don't always catch up and I think addressing a potential issue early on is the best method.

Donna, I would just call EI and schedule the evaulation Chat Icon



I think what she means is that when a child has a receptive delay there is more likely an underlying issue going on then with a simple expressive delay...

Some kids are just late talkers.



I worry about a physical issue with the expressive delay. He was a late solid food eater and still needs food real small. There was also a possibel issue when I was PG about a throat issue b/c I had so much extra amniotic fluid.

Anyway...How do I push this with the Dr? Wait the two months or call EI and ask? Anyone have a suggestion?

I feel he may just be a late "talker" but even those usually have a FEW words by now..mama, dada, baba etc. right?



You don't need to push anything with the doctor - you don't need their referral to call EI - if you want to call them you should! Chat Icon

Posted 10/6/08 10:34 PM
 

LoveBeingMrsT
Love my Boys!

Member since 12/05

4648 total posts

Name:

Re: Waiting for EI?

josh has been getting e.i. for 2 months now so since he turned 14 months. i say get him eval'ed now and if he doesn't qualify then get him eval.'ed again when he turns 19 months. actually the process can sometimes take forever so if you call the agency now it may be a few weeks till they come to do the eval. anyway, then if he qualifies you have to wait more for a meeting and then for services to start. so it can take 1-2 months anyway.

josh is great receptively but expressively 2 months ago he said uh-oh and dada. we were lucky enough to get a slp to make him look at his worst and he got services (he also has a feeding issue too though.)

how is noah with eating? josh has low muscle tone so he has issues with eating and that was why he talked late. now that he has a bunch of words (maybe 30 in the last 2 months) his articulatioon is 'nt great though. we do lots of signs and if josh can't do them properly he just makes his own sign out of it and that is what we use.

gl!

Chat Icon

Posted 10/6/08 10:38 PM
 

architectnycity
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

2592 total posts

Name:

Re: Waiting for EI?

I have two friends who were starting to think their DCs needed EI because they weren't speaking. One child would basically say dada sometimes. When they both hit 18 months it was like BOOM! They were saying so many things and within weeks putting words together.

Posted 10/6/08 10:54 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Waiting for EI?

Posted by hbugal

Posted by dm24angel


I worry about a physical issue with the expressive delay. He was a late solid food eater and still needs food real small. There was also a possibel issue when I was PG about a throat issue b/c I had so much extra amniotic fluid.

Anyway...How do I push this with the Dr? Wait the two months or call EI and ask? Anyone have a suggestion?

I feel he may just be a late "talker" but even those usually have a FEW words by now..mama, dada, baba etc. right?



My daughter went through EI back when it was first implemented in NY State. The guidelines were different back then. Pataki changed things when he was in office. (But Im not going to go there) So Im not sure how things go...BUT..do you need your doctors referrel to get EI? If not I'd just call. If not for anything else just piece of mind...

I dont mean to sound condesending but are you sure he isnt talking at all? Or is it just not real words? Caden talks quite a lot but some of the words can barely be understood. I mean his word for book is really just "ba" he does the k with his mouth but it's silent. Had I not had previous children and a child who received speech I might have missed it...



Nope, nothing. Believe me if he even says the letter ...any letter or sound associated with the object we get excited and praise him. And We are always looking for it. Most of the time all you hear is this gargling sound he does or he says MA or a M sound to everything.

Posted 10/7/08 8:42 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Is anyone else waiting (or has waited) 20 plus weeks until Level II? (Vent) kathleeng 4/11/08 21 Pregnancy
I can't take the waiting anymore!!!! Now they need more time! Tine73 1/8/07 19 Home
while im sitting here just waiting... let me say this... 04bride 9/8/06 17 Pregnancy
July Mommies-to-be....who's patiently or impatiently waiting? Let's check in... HalloweenBride04 7/12/06 3 Pregnancy
I know its a long shot, but I am sitting here on the edge of my chair waiting for Mrs-Boop 10/19/05 8 Families Helping Families ™
So Footballs on instead of BB6** WHO IS STILL HERE WAITING? LOL megsmom 9/1/05 19 Families Helping Families ™