Voting Yes tomorrow question
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Voting Yes tomorrow question What are the positives to voting yes tomorrow on the ballot? |
|
Posted 11/6/17 12:43 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question See the link from the state board of elections website. Message edited 2017-11-06 13:23:24.067000. |
|
Posted 11/6/17 1:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Here's a pretty good list of benefits that could come out of a Convention: |
|
Posted 11/6/17 1:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question I thought this was an informative read about misconceptions |
|
Posted 11/6/17 1:47 PM
|
|
|
Voting Yes tomorrow question Is there any info about what proposals would likely be taken on? I'm reading these resources sms have looked into all this for a while and all I'm seeing is how this and that which people might be worried about are not likely to be proposed. So what is? I also don't get the point of a lengthy and costly convention if we can add amendments without a convention anyway. |
|
Posted 11/6/17 1:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question So whats the bottom line about pensions? Specifically for people who are retired, NYC police, correctional officer or fire fighter? I was told to vote no so their pensions won't be on the line. |
|
Posted 11/6/17 1:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by blu6385 So whats the bottom line about pensions? Specifically for people who are retired, NYC police, correctional officer or fire fighter? I was told to vote no so their pensions won't be on the line. If I am going to be honest I doubt this is going to pass. Any advertimsent I have seen about this is how everyone should vote no. I havent seen one advertisement about voting yes. I don't even really know what the whole thing is really about anyway Keep in mind, on long island we're seeing a small part of the population. Upstate is likely a different story. I hear the same regarding pensions. Goldenrod's link confused me about this yet again. It's not possible for them to touch pensions, then it sounds like yes they could but it's just not likely to be proposed, then if it were proposed it likely wouldn't be passed by voters. |
|
Posted 11/6/17 2:03 PM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by blu6385 So whats the bottom line about pensions? Specifically for people who are retired, NYC police, correctional officer or fire fighter? I was told to vote no so their pensions won't be on the line. If I am going to be honest I doubt this is going to pass. Any advertimsent I have seen about this is how everyone should vote no. I havent seen one advertisement about voting yes. I don't even really know what the whole thing is really about anyway From the link posted by Goldenrod above: A Convention Could Not Reduce the Pensions of Current Employees and Retirees The most irresponsible assertion being perpetrated by convention opponents is that the pensions of existing and retired public employees could “vanish” if a constitutional convention were to be held. This is patently false. Existing public employee and retiree pensions are protected by both federal and state law. The U.S. Constitution has a provision known as the Contract Clause, which prohibits states from doing precisely what is feared — retroactively changing the terms of existing contracts. It provides: No State shall ... make any ... Law impairing the Obligation of Contracts. Ever since the Constitutional Convention of 1938 made public pensions contractual, the rights of each public employee have vested on the date he or she entered the system, and any impairment of those rights through elimination of pension, reduction of benefits, or unfavorable changes in the way cost of living adjustments are calculated would violate the U.S. Constitution. Other states with similar constitutional provisions that have attempted to change the existing terms of their public employee pension programs through legislation have been routinely rebuffed by courts applying the Contract Clause. A 2013 Illinois statute that halted automatic cost of living increases for retirees, raised the retirement age for current employees, and capped the salary used in determining benefit amounts was held unconstitutional by a unanimous Illinois Supreme Court. Multiple Arizona laws adopted in 2011 that increased employee contribution rates for existing employees and altered the formula for calculating cost of living adjustments were found unconstitutional by a series of different courts. In addition to violating the Contract Clause of the national Constitution, any attempt by a constitutional convention to retroactively reduce benefits to retirees or to adjust accrued benefits to current employees would almost certainly run afoul of the state constitution — either the due process clause, the takings clause, or the pension provision in effect when every current and retired public employee entered the system. Even if a convention were inclined to eliminate the nonimpairment provision of the state constitution, such a change would apply only to employees hired after the effective date of the change; it could not bind existing employees whose rights already have been fixed. |
Posted 11/6/17 2:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by MrsT809 Posted by blu6385 So whats the bottom line about pensions? Specifically for people who are retired, NYC police, correctional officer or fire fighter? I was told to vote no so their pensions won't be on the line. If I am going to be honest I doubt this is going to pass. Any advertimsent I have seen about this is how everyone should vote no. I havent seen one advertisement about voting yes. I don't even really know what the whole thing is really about anyway Keep in mind, on long island we're seeing a small part of the population. Upstate is likely a different story. I hear the same regarding pensions. Goldenrod's link confused me about this yet again. It's not possible for them to touch pensions, then it sounds like yes they could but it's just not likely to be proposed, then if it were proposed it likely wouldn't be passed by voters. so you think there is more avertisment in upstate NY about what this is whole thing is even about? If so I wonder why they havent done them here. |
|
Posted 11/6/17 2:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by blu6385 So whats the bottom line about pensions? Specifically for people who are retired, NYC police, correctional officer or fire fighter? I was told to vote no so their pensions won't be on the line. If I am going to be honest I doubt this is going to pass. Any advertimsent I have seen about this is how everyone should vote no. I havent seen one advertisement about voting yes. I don't even really know what the whole thing is really about anyway I haven't see any advertisement about voting yes either. All I see are the "no" bumper stickers. |
|
Posted 11/6/17 2:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Many people I know are voting No because the last convention, they passed nothing. They sat, and spent money, and changed nothing - not a single thing passed. |
|
Posted 11/6/17 2:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by LiveForMoments Many people I know are voting No because the last convention, they passed nothing. They sat, and spent money, and changed nothing - not a single thing passed. Change to the state constitution is possible without a convention. Though I honestly do not know enough about to process at this point to be more than 75% certain of my vote. Research suggests that the last convention's proposals were voted down because they were all wrapped up together and voters could only vote on the whole of the proposals as opposed to each proposal. So not a single thing was passed because the proposals were not proposed singlely so it was all or none. The convention prior to that afforded labor and worker rights that were not already available. This is why it's so important that we each go and research instead of relying on bumper stickers and facebook postings. |
|
Posted 11/6/17 2:49 PM
|
|
|
Voting Yes tomorrow question The New York State Bar Association has been pushing for a Yes vote. They want to modernize and restructure the court systems and simplify voting registration. http://www.nysba.org/nyconstitution/ |
|
Posted 11/6/17 2:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by blu6385 Posted by MrsT809 Posted by blu6385 So whats the bottom line about pensions? Specifically for people who are retired, NYC police, correctional officer or fire fighter? I was told to vote no so their pensions won't be on the line. If I am going to be honest I doubt this is going to pass. Any advertimsent I have seen about this is how everyone should vote no. I havent seen one advertisement about voting yes. I don't even really know what the whole thing is really about anyway Keep in mind, on long island we're seeing a small part of the population. Upstate is likely a different story. I hear the same regarding pensions. Goldenrod's link confused me about this yet again. It's not possible for them to touch pensions, then it sounds like yes they could but it's just not likely to be proposed, then if it were proposed it likely wouldn't be passed by voters. so you think there is more avertisment in upstate NY about what this is whole thing is even about? If so I wonder why they havent done them here. Absolutely! There is a big push to tier NYS in to 3 areas and each area will govern itself. Upstate is tied to mandates and funding that does nothing for them and they vote on things like congestion and plastic bag liter. If you look at the interest groups on both sides, you will understand why the campaign downstate is a big no. |
|
Posted 11/6/17 2:53 PM
|
|
|
Voting Yes tomorrow question there are 3 props tomorrow, one has to do with stripping elected officials of pensions etc IF they have corruption charges against them |
|
Posted 11/6/17 2:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by hmm there are 3 props tomorrow, one has to do with stripping elected officials of pensions etc IF they have corruption charges against them That I am completely for! |
|
Posted 11/6/17 3:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by MrsT809 Keep in mind, on long island we're seeing a small part of the population. Upstate is likely a different story. I live upstate - Albany/Schenectady/Saratoga region - and everywhere I go it says to "Vote No" so we are hearing the same message. Message edited 2017-11-07 07:50:20.427000. |
|
Posted 11/7/17 7:46 AM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by CookiePuss Posted by hmm there are 3 props tomorrow, one has to do with stripping elected officials of pensions etc IF they have corruption charges against them That I am completely for!
|
|
Posted 11/7/17 7:46 AM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by blu6385 So whats the bottom line about pensions? Specifically for people who are retired, NYC police, correctional officer or fire fighter? I was told to vote no so their pensions won't be on the line. If I am going to be honest I doubt this is going to pass. Any advertimsent I have seen about this is how everyone should vote no. I havent seen one advertisement about voting yes. I don't even really know what the whole thing is really about anyway The reason why you see all the press and adverts for voting no is that there is a significant established base of unions with money who benefit significantly from the system currently in place. They fear-monger their membership and use their collective funds to promote the system that currently serves them. |
|
Posted 11/7/17 9:53 AM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by CSK Posted by blu6385 So whats the bottom line about pensions? Specifically for people who are retired, NYC police, correctional officer or fire fighter? I was told to vote no so their pensions won't be on the line. If I am going to be honest I doubt this is going to pass. Any advertimsent I have seen about this is how everyone should vote no. I havent seen one advertisement about voting yes. I don't even really know what the whole thing is really about anyway The reason why you see all the press and adverts for voting no is that there is a significant established base of unions with money who benefit significantly from the system currently in place. They fear-monger their membership and use their collective funds to promote the system that currently serves them. And from what I am reading, the pensions of current and past union members can NOT be reduced or changed by a Constitutional Convention as it is also protected by federal law. (see excerpt that I posted above) So I think it's a huge misconception that just grew bigger and bigger and morphed into this idea that people could lose their pensions. Like a rampant game of telephone gone bad. |
Posted 11/7/17 9:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by NervousNell Posted by CSK Posted by blu6385 So whats the bottom line about pensions? Specifically for people who are retired, NYC police, correctional officer or fire fighter? I was told to vote no so their pensions won't be on the line. If I am going to be honest I doubt this is going to pass. Any advertimsent I have seen about this is how everyone should vote no. I havent seen one advertisement about voting yes. I don't even really know what the whole thing is really about anyway The reason why you see all the press and adverts for voting no is that there is a significant established base of unions with money who benefit significantly from the system currently in place. They fear-monger their membership and use their collective funds to promote the system that currently serves them. And from what I am reading, the pensions of current and past union members can NOT be reduced or changed by a Constitutional Convention as it is also protected by federal law. (see excerpt that I posted above) So I think it's a huge misconception that just grew bigger and bigger and morphed into this idea that people could lose their pensions. Like a rampant game of telephone gone bad. That's crazy! All these people are voting no based on a giant misconception |
|
Posted 11/7/17 11:15 AM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by beachbabe Posted by NervousNell Posted by CSK Posted by blu6385 So whats the bottom line about pensions? Specifically for people who are retired, NYC police, correctional officer or fire fighter? I was told to vote no so their pensions won't be on the line. If I am going to be honest I doubt this is going to pass. Any advertimsent I have seen about this is how everyone should vote no. I havent seen one advertisement about voting yes. I don't even really know what the whole thing is really about anyway The reason why you see all the press and adverts for voting no is that there is a significant established base of unions with money who benefit significantly from the system currently in place. They fear-monger their membership and use their collective funds to promote the system that currently serves them. And from what I am reading, the pensions of current and past union members can NOT be reduced or changed by a Constitutional Convention as it is also protected by federal law. (see excerpt that I posted above) So I think it's a huge misconception that just grew bigger and bigger and morphed into this idea that people could lose their pensions. Like a rampant game of telephone gone bad. That's crazy! All these people are voting no based on a giant misconception From what i can tell, yes. But you know how it is in this day and age... one person posts something on FB and then one person shares it without doing any research into it's validity, and so on and so on and next thing you know it's God's truth and there is mass panic in the streets. |
Posted 11/7/17 11:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by NervousNell Posted by beachbabe Posted by NervousNell Posted by CSK Posted by blu6385 So whats the bottom line about pensions? Specifically for people who are retired, NYC police, correctional officer or fire fighter? I was told to vote no so their pensions won't be on the line. If I am going to be honest I doubt this is going to pass. Any advertimsent I have seen about this is how everyone should vote no. I havent seen one advertisement about voting yes. I don't even really know what the whole thing is really about anyway The reason why you see all the press and adverts for voting no is that there is a significant established base of unions with money who benefit significantly from the system currently in place. They fear-monger their membership and use their collective funds to promote the system that currently serves them. And from what I am reading, the pensions of current and past union members can NOT be reduced or changed by a Constitutional Convention as it is also protected by federal law. (see excerpt that I posted above) So I think it's a huge misconception that just grew bigger and bigger and morphed into this idea that people could lose their pensions. Like a rampant game of telephone gone bad. That's crazy! All these people are voting no based on a giant misconception From what i can tell, yes. But you know how it is in this day and age... one person posts something on FB and then one person shares it without doing any research into it's validity, and so on and so on and next thing you know it's God's truth and there is mass panic in the streets. from what I am being told by people who say to vote no is that the pension are protected currently but they can vote to change the Constitution to no longer protect it anymore and that's why they are voting no and telling people to vote no! |
|
Posted 11/7/17 1:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by beachbabe Posted by NervousNell Posted by CSK Posted by blu6385 So whats the bottom line about pensions? Specifically for people who are retired, NYC police, correctional officer or fire fighter? I was told to vote no so their pensions won't be on the line. If I am going to be honest I doubt this is going to pass. Any advertimsent I have seen about this is how everyone should vote no. I havent seen one advertisement about voting yes. I don't even really know what the whole thing is really about anyway The reason why you see all the press and adverts for voting no is that there is a significant established base of unions with money who benefit significantly from the system currently in place. They fear-monger their membership and use their collective funds to promote the system that currently serves them. And from what I am reading, the pensions of current and past union members can NOT be reduced or changed by a Constitutional Convention as it is also protected by federal law. (see excerpt that I posted above) So I think it's a huge misconception that just grew bigger and bigger and morphed into this idea that people could lose their pensions. Like a rampant game of telephone gone bad. That's crazy! All these people are voting no based on a giant misconception The unions got ahead of everything and put out this fear - I have a feeling it won't pass anyway, but it doesn't help the spread of misinformation. I know a lot of people who are voting yes because the pensions are protected. |
|
Posted 11/7/17 1:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question Posted by blu6385 ... from what I am being told by people who say to vote no is that the pension are protected currently but they can vote to change the Constitution to no longer protect it anymore and that's why they are voting no and telling people to vote no! http://www.lwvny.org/programs-studies/concon/2017/Press-Pension-reform_041117.pdf Pension benefits. The New York Constitution makes public employee pension benefits contractual and protects them from impairment. Any attempt by a convention to reduce benefits to retirees or to take accrued benefits from current employees would almost certainly violate the Contract Clause of the national Constitution. Even if a convention eliminated the state constitutional protection for pensions, the U.S. Constitution would require that such changes applied only to employees hired after the effective date of any such change. The state has made numerous changes over the course of time to the pension system for future employees. The most recent revision was in 2012, when the legislature put in place a new Tier (Tier VI) and significantly altered the pension conditions for employees joining the retirement system on or after April 1, 2016 (while not affecting existing employees and retirees). In 2017, New Yorkers will vote on a constitutional proposition that would allow pensions to be taken from public officials who have been convicted of a felony related to their public office. Basically, Federal law prohibits NY from touching the pensions of existing employees. At ANY time, NY can touch the pensions of future hires, but not existing employees. Voting no to protect your pension is fear-mongering and misinformation. If someone wants to vote no, that's their right, but they should really know the actual facts of why they are voting. |
|
Posted 11/7/17 2:00 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Question about voting tomorrow | Melmel821 | 11/5/12 | 4 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| School Delays tomorrow - yes or no? | beachgirl | 3/4/15 | 13 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| I Leave For Disney Tomorrow - Question | Heather | 8/20/06 | 2 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| First Sonogram tomorrow @ 7 weeks question.. | KittyCat | 1/22/06 | 4 | Pregnancy |
| Tomorrow Ryan goes( one more question at bottom) | 05mommy09 | 11/28/05 | 16 | Parenting |
| Tomorrow's my anniversary - question about Hamptons!! | Laura08 | 8/7/05 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |








