Very wierd question re: baptism

Posted By Message

Michelle1123
Baby #5 on the way!

Member since 9/05

7919 total posts

Name:

Very wierd question re: baptism

I hope this makes sense.

Ever since my mom got sick, I found myself questioning alot of my beliefs. I'm really debating if I should baptize baby#3.

Part of me is scared NOT to do it so I guess there is still part of me that believes in SOMETHING.

But part of me is saying not to since I dont believe in it completely anymore and I dont know if I should be promising to raise this child catholic if theres a chance I might not.

I think my family would have a BIG problem if I dont do the baptism, but I feel like its my decision. Am I overthinking it too much? What would you do?

Posted 9/30/09 12:05 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Very wierd question re: baptism

Well.

It is totally up to you. I mean, you can baptize a child at any point, so if you don't want to do it when he/she is a baby, that is fine too.

I wasn't baptized and Christopher will be baptized later this year (he will be over 2.5). My parents chose not to baptize my sister and I because they wanted us to be able to make our own choices, and not be forced into a religion.

My husband is Catholic, my sister is a Buddhist.

I think that you should probably play it by ear, and eff anyone who gives you a hard timeChat Icon

ETA-I am still "nothing", I am spiritual and believe in a God, but I am not part of an organized religion

Message edited 2009-09-30 12:10:39.460000.

Posted 9/30/09 12:08 PM
 

AnnBrunoXO
2 Girls For Me!

Member since 5/05

4377 total posts

Name:
MaMMa

Re: Very wierd question re: baptism

Well - it really depends on what you feel internally. What does your husband believe you should do?
My husband's immediate family is another religion (my husband is Catholic - his family converted to another religion when he was a bit older but he decided that it wasn't for him and he remained catholic.)

We always felt that we would baptize our children the way we were - introduce them into the religion, make them aware of god (because I feel its important for them to look up to someone in a higher being in their lives) and if they choose to change religions when they are older - I really can't do anything to stop that, it will be their choice.
For us/me - it was important to baptize as catholics - but I don't have any intention of ever converting into another religion so it was never a question in my mind.

Why don't you read/look into the other religion if you are in question of what to do or converting ?......

Message edited 2009-09-30 12:24:52.587000.

Posted 9/30/09 12:12 PM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: Very wierd question re: baptism

Well I look at it this way - I am doing it b.c I want my girls to have a choice. It is a pain later in life to have to do the classes if they choose that they want to go to church or get married in the church. We aren't that religious but we do go on holidays to church more so for family than for ourselves. If my girls choose not to practice our religion I am okay with that - but I felt that at least I was offering them a choice. I don't think there is a right or wrong answer you have to do what feels right for your family.

Posted 9/30/09 12:20 PM
 

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Very wierd question re: baptism

We didn't baptize DD for the exact same reasons you're saying. My family (except my grandmothers) is not very religious. And after losses, I question things too sometimes.

I'm not anti-religion and it's not like I don't believe in *something*, but I honestly was very uncomfortable personally for having her christened/baptized at a church that I likely won't step foot in very often...I didn't want the congregation promising to help guide DD when I didn't have any intention of taking her to church regularly. I know lots of people don't have a problem with that and I am absolutely not judging that decision for others who make it, it was just my personal decision.

ETA: I'm not from LI. The church I went to when I was a child for Sunday School (b/c my grandmother wanted us to) is upstate. I believe that if I still lived upstate, I may have had her baptized in that church b/c it held childhood memories for me and because my beloved grandmother (who passed away last year) was a very active member in the church, I'd do it in honor of her perhaps. But not 100% if I would have, and obviously am never going to be in that situation to make that decision.

Message edited 2009-09-30 12:34:35.850000.

Posted 9/30/09 12:31 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Very wierd question re: baptism

I understand what you are going through, since I lost both of my parents.

While it might not be the best reason to baptize a child, I would consider whether or not your other children are baptized. I think it might be confusing to your next child(ren) if some of the babies were baptized but he/she wasn't. I also think the first year after losing a parent is a tough time to be making big life changes. Personally, if I were going through it, I think if I would have baptized the baby before my mom died, I would go through with it.

I know it's a serious decision, but I also think while grief causes us to question our beliefs, and re-examine our lives, it doesn't necessarily change them. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

If you are having doubts, you can always delay the decision, too.

Posted 9/30/09 12:32 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Very wierd question re: baptism

If you are on the fence, I would do it.

I think your child might feel like the odd one out compared to their siblings. I know that's not a religious reason to do it but I think it is important.

If you were definitive in your decision, I might say otherwise, but since you are still up in the air I would go through with it.

Posted 9/30/09 12:39 PM
 

mtnmama

Member since 5/06

4794 total posts

Name:

Re: Very wierd question re: baptism

Posted by CrankyPants

If you are on the fence, I would do it.

I think your child might feel like the odd one out compared to their siblings. I know that's not a religious reason to do it but I think it is important.

If you were definitive in your decision, I might say otherwise, but since you are still up in the air I would go through with it.



I agree. When my Dad died suddenly at the age of 50 I was angry for a couple of years. That is the wonderful thing about our faith as Catholics-it is not always simply black and white, it is a journey of questioning and learning. If you are on the fence, go ahead and do it for your childs sake Chat Icon

Posted 9/30/09 1:39 PM
 

kahlua716
3 Girls for Me!

Member since 8/07

12475 total posts

Name:
Keri

Re: Very wierd question re: baptism

Posted by mtnmama

Posted by CrankyPants

If you are on the fence, I would do it.

I think your child might feel like the odd one out compared to their siblings. I know that's not a religious reason to do it but I think it is important.

If you were definitive in your decision, I might say otherwise, but since you are still up in the air I would go through with it.



I agree. When my Dad died suddenly at the age of 50 I was angry for a couple of years. That is the wonderful thing about our faith as Catholics-it is not always simply black and white, it is a journey of questioning and learning. If you are on the fence, go ahead and do it for your childs sake Chat Icon



I also agree.

Posted 9/30/09 2:20 PM
 

Meggo613
im a big girl!

Member since 2/07

4536 total posts

Name:
Megan

Re: Very wierd question re: baptism

i just wanted to say that i baptized my dd although i do not 100% believe everything the cathloic religion does i do not go to church for my own reasons. (i dont feel you need to go to church to be able to speak with a higher power, nor do i feel i need to profess my sins to someone in the church i will take them up with god directly) but i felt it was improant for dd to belong to some type of religion and allow her to make her own choices from there when she gets older just like my parents allowed me to do.

i sometimes do feel like abit of a hipocrite but hey im ok with it ive taken it up with god in my own way and im a peace with all of my decisions and feel ive made the right choices for us!

Posted 9/30/09 2:34 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Very wierd question re: baptism

my parents raised me and my sisters Jewish. we were all Bat-mitvah'd (i do not recall if all of us had a naming ceremony).

when i was old enough, i made it clear to my parents how i felt - i believe in God, or a higher power, but i want nothing to do with organized religion. i was lucky to find a husband who feels exactly the same way i do.

my two sisters are much more religious than i am. we are all happy and well-adjusted, for the most part.

DH and I chose not to baptize our son OR have a bris. we will support him (and all of our children) in whatever they decide, whether he wants to become a rabbi, a priest, a monk, or not follow any religion at all.

now i do believe it might be harder for you because your other two chidlren are baptized but there is nothing that says you can't wait and see how you feel in a few months or even years. there is no "time limit."

and like Kate said - eff whoever has something to say. your child, your choice. as long as you and your DH are in agreement that's all that should matter.

Posted 9/30/09 2:53 PM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Very wierd question re: baptism

I can understand what you are feeling but I will say give it time! Its still so fresh, When my mom first died I felt the same, there cant be a God if he would take her away when she still have so much living to do, etc. But soon when the anger left I was comforted by the thought of God and Heaven.

Anyway my mom said something similar to me once. Her sister died young, left behind 3 kids and her and my mom were really close! My mom who was raised in a very close Irish Catholic home went to catholic school the whole thing was so angry she couldnt bring herself to believe or to step foot in church. But she sent my brother to church alone every week (they were 14 and 10 about) because she felt it was important regardless of what she was feeling. Years later she did return to church.

If it were me I would baptize my child but maybe a little later around 6 months or so. Because I think I would regret if I didnt and I know it would be what my mom would have wanted.

Message edited 2009-09-30 15:18:51.093000.

Posted 9/30/09 3:17 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Very wierd question re: baptism



Posted by Lillykat

Well I look at it this way - I am doing it b.c I want my girls to have a choice. It is a pain later in life to have to do the classes if they choose that they want to go to church or get married in the church. We aren't that religious but we do go on holidays to church more so for family than for ourselves. If my girls choose not to practice our religion I am okay with that - but I felt that at least I was offering them a choice. I don't think there is a right or wrong answer you have to do wh
at feels right for your family.



I agree with this. Same for me.

Posted 9/30/09 4:20 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Christening / Baptism Question KittyCat 2/7/07 2 Parenting
Baptism Question... qtptootie 1/17/07 4 Parenting
Baptism Question beachgirl13 9/19/06 34 Parenting
Baptism question..godparent not present. Janice 7/23/06 3 Parenting
Godparent/Baptism question... CaidensMommy 5/22/06 3 Families Helping Families ™
Baptism/Godparent question... CaidensMommy 5/22/06 8 Parenting