Venue Help

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

tnelson22
LIF Infant

Member since 3/15

95 total posts

Name:

Venue Help

Good Morning...first let me say thank you to all who responded to a previous post. Your ideas have been great!

My follow up post is looking for anyone who may have been to a shower or party or even just brunch at any of the following places:

The Bulldog Grille
Smuggler Jack's
Paddy's Loft
Croxley Ales in Farmingdale

I really like The Bulldog Grille and Croxley's for their price and what you get for that price however, the Bulldog Grille doesn't have the greatest reviews in regards to their food and Croxley's just seems dark inside for a shower.

Any thoughts, opinions, suggestions would be so helpful!!! Thank you!!

Posted 3/31/15 7:14 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Venue Help

I have had multiple parties and showers at Bulldog. We have never had an issue. Croxleys the food is ehhh and you will not have your own room just part of the restaurant.

Posted 3/31/15 8:50 AM
 

tnelson22
LIF Infant

Member since 3/15

95 total posts

Name:

Re: Venue Help

Thanks! I have actually never been to Bulldog but have seen a lot of recommendations for it. I think I will check it out this week!

Posted 3/31/15 8:54 AM
 

BaysideForever
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

9976 total posts

Name:

Re: Venue Help

croxleys is not a good place to have a shower...

Posted 3/31/15 9:19 AM
 

chilltocam
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

9141 total posts

Name:

Venue Help

My brother had his rehearsal at the Bulldog - the food was really good. And I've eaten there a few times and enjoyed the food very much

Posted 3/31/15 9:20 AM
 

Pinkisles
<3

Member since 11/13

2868 total posts

Name:

Venue Help

I find Croxleys very dark, I wouldn't want to have a shower there.

Posted 3/31/15 9:23 AM
 

JDubs
different, not less

Member since 7/09

13160 total posts

Name:

Re: Venue Help

I had two events at Paddy's Loft. The first was my baby shower. We were in the back room and we had to guarantee 40 people, I believe. It was a little bit tight with all the gifts so we had to put some of them outside of the room. Other than that the food and price was great. I actually booked DS' christening there too, this time the main dining room, I believe we had to guarantee 60, I will say it was a little tight. Plus they did not kick out their dinner guests until the exact time of our party (3:30) so I was annoyed I couldn't set up to decorate or anything. Also they kept the back room open for other diners so there were people coming through our room to get to the back. Again the food and prices were good but I prob would not be booking any more parties there just based on my last experience. If you are doing a shower around 12 noon, then no one would be in the restaurant so I would have no problem booking something around that time there, since you would have free reign to set up.

Posted 3/31/15 9:30 AM
 

Seawolf
LIF Adult

Member since 3/14

1336 total posts

Name:
Scrumba

Re: Venue Help

I've only been to the Bulldog. Its ok. Nothing to write home about, but not bad either.

Posted 3/31/15 9:34 AM
 

tnelson22
LIF Infant

Member since 3/15

95 total posts

Name:

Re: Venue Help

Posted by chilltocam

My brother had his rehearsal at the Bulldog - the food was really good. And I've eaten there a few times and enjoyed the food very much



Thanks!

Posted 3/31/15 9:49 AM
 

tnelson22
LIF Infant

Member since 3/15

95 total posts

Name:

Re: Venue Help

Posted by Pinkisles

I find Croxleys very dark, I wouldn't want to have a shower there.



That's what my husband and I thought but you can't beat what they offer for the price...with the alcohol!

Posted 3/31/15 9:49 AM
 

tnelson22
LIF Infant

Member since 3/15

95 total posts

Name:

Re: Venue Help

Posted by JDubs

I had two events at Paddy's Loft. The first was my baby shower. We were in the back room and we had to guarantee 40 people, I believe. It was a little bit tight with all the gifts so we had to put some of them outside of the room. Other than that the food and price was great. I actually booked DS' christening there too, this time the main dining room, I believe we had to guarantee 60, I will say it was a little tight. Plus they did not kick out their dinner guests until the exact time of our party (3:30) so I was annoyed I couldn't set up to decorate or anything. Also they kept the back room open for other diners so there were people coming through our room to get to the back. Again the food and prices were good but I prob would not be booking any more parties there just based on my last experience. If you are doing a shower around 12 noon, then no one would be in the restaurant so I would have no problem booking something around that time there, since you would have free reign to set up.



This is one of my issues as well - the guest list. It seems like I have too many for the normal rooms in which we will be tight, especially with gifts, and not enough to meet the minimums for the larger rooms Chat Icon
I just think minimums should be lower for afternoon parties, but that's just my opinion. Thanks.

Posted 3/31/15 9:51 AM
 

tnelson22
LIF Infant

Member since 3/15

95 total posts

Name:

Re: Venue Help

Posted by Seawolf

I've only been to the Bulldog. Its ok. Nothing to write home about, but not bad either.



Have you been there to just eat or for a party or shower? Any chance it was the brunch you can comment on as this is what I am looking to do. Thanks.

Posted 3/31/15 9:52 AM
 

alexb
LIF Adult

Member since 5/13

960 total posts

Name:

Venue Help

I think the food at Bulldog is decent but my main gripe was the smell of the place. It smelled like the beer tap lines needed to be cleaned big time. If you personally dont notice it then i think this is a decent place to host a shower.

Posted 3/31/15 11:08 AM
 

Pinkisles
<3

Member since 11/13

2868 total posts

Name:

Re: Venue Help

Posted by tnelson22

Posted by Pinkisles

I find Croxleys very dark, I wouldn't want to have a shower there.



That's what my husband and I thought but you can't beat what they offer for the price...with the alcohol!


Have you tried the Nutty Irishman down the block from Croxleys? I had my son's first birthday party there and the price was great and the food was amazing. The service was also excellent! They close off the back for you to make it a private room. And if it's a nice day they will probably let you use their patio.

Posted 3/31/15 12:30 PM
 

MaeDe
LIF Adult

Member since 4/11

1169 total posts

Name:

Re: Venue Help

The bull dog is from the owners of the blessings restaurants so they should all be relatively close or the same in price. Have you checked out the The Library in Farmingdale or the Post Office in Babylon. The lessings food is very good. I am not a huge croxlys fan. Its basically a bar, your feet stick to the ground.
I have herd good things about Paddys loft. But never been there personally.

Message edited 2015-03-31 16:44:21.240000.

Posted 3/31/15 4:43 PM
 

tnelson22
LIF Infant

Member since 3/15

95 total posts

Name:

Re: Venue Help

Posted by Pinkisles

Posted by tnelson22

Posted by Pinkisles

I find Croxleys very dark, I wouldn't want to have a shower there.



That's what my husband and I thought but you can't beat what they offer for the price...with the alcohol!


Have you tried the Nutty Irishman down the block from Croxleys? I had my son's first birthday party there and the price was great and the food was amazing. The service was also excellent! They close off the back for you to make it a private room. And if it's a nice day they will probably let you use their patio.



I was thinking about the Nutty Irishman but in looking at the photos online it seemed like it might be dark as well (like Croxley's). How did you find it? Was it like when you go there on a Friday night or do they turn on the lights so people can see whats going on???

Posted 3/31/15 5:29 PM
 

tnelson22
LIF Infant

Member since 3/15

95 total posts

Name:

Re: Venue Help

Posted by MaeDe

The bull dog is from the owners of the blessings restaurants so they should all be relatively close or the same in price. Have you checked out the The Library in Farmingdale or the Post Office in Babylon. The lessings food is very good. I am not a huge croxlys fan. Its basically a bar, your feet stick to the ground.
I have herd good things about Paddys loft. But never been there personally.



I didn't know that actually. I did try the Library and I would love to use them but my headcount is causing an issue. I will probably have between 40 and 50 people, with gifts, and their downstairs only holds 50 max. I could book it and hope but my luck everyone will RSVP yes an then I would be royally screwed lol! I will check out the Post Office though. Thanks!

Posted 3/31/15 5:31 PM
 

Pinkisles
<3

Member since 11/13

2868 total posts

Name:

Re: Venue Help

Posted by tnelson22

Posted by Pinkisles

Posted by tnelson22

Posted by Pinkisles

I find Croxleys very dark, I wouldn't want to have a shower there.



That's what my husband and I thought but you can't beat what they offer for the price...with the alcohol!


Have you tried the Nutty Irishman down the block from Croxleys? I had my son's first birthday party there and the price was great and the food was amazing. The service was also excellent! They close off the back for you to make it a private room. And if it's a nice day they will probably let you use their patio.



I was thinking about the Nutty Irishman but in looking at the photos online it seemed like it might be dark as well (like Croxley's). How did you find it? Was it like when you go there on a Friday night or do they turn on the lights so people can see whats going on???



They turned the lights up when I requested it. You can also decorate however you want and they have the big stage to out all the gifts.

Posted 3/31/15 6:24 PM
 

kn2011
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/10

537 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Venue Help

HOw many people are you having.. Ive been to smuggler Jacks -- Its actually on my block.. I feel like it would be a weird layout for a shower .. like an L shape --- Food is decent.. same owner as Paddys Loft -- Bulldog is decent -- same owner as the library/post office (have you looked into either of those?) Croxley is too bar-ish to me -- although I like the food ..

Posted 3/31/15 6:30 PM
 

kn2011
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/10

537 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Venue Help

Are you looking for bar type venues specifically? Theres a bunch of locations local to those that can probably accommodate a party of that size

Posted 3/31/15 6:39 PM
 

tnelson22
LIF Infant

Member since 3/15

95 total posts

Name:

Re: Venue Help

Posted by kn2011

Are you looking for bar type venues specifically? Theres a bunch of locations local to those that can probably accommodate a party of that size



No, what I was looking for was something close to home so that we don't have to trek the gifts too far. I really would like a private space that serves brunch. I did try both The Library and The Post Office but the library's may be too small (50 max on the main floor and I will have 45-55) and the Post Office doesn't offer brunch.

I have actually never been to Smuggler Jacks. I found it when I i was looking at Paddys Loft site. I was thinking of going down there tomorrow but I think I will have the same issue with the amount of people. The pictures though looked nice.

I was also thinking of looking into Milk and Sugar Cafe but it's kind of far.

Posted 3/31/15 7:24 PM
 

kn2011
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/10

537 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Venue Help

What about palmers in farmingdale. Hudson mill in massapequa. Mercato in massapequa. Hemingways in wantagh

Posted 3/31/15 7:38 PM
 

kn2011
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/10

537 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Venue Help

Sals place on Hicksville road?

Posted 3/31/15 7:39 PM
 

EMC11709
LIF Toddler

Member since 3/10

484 total posts

Name:
Erica

Re: Venue Help

We had my Hubby's 30th birthday Trescalini in December, it's the Italian restaurant next door to croxleys. Food was delicious and the prices were reasonable.They did not have a private room however it felt private. If you have more questions FM me.

Message edited 2015-03-31 23:35:24.890000.

Posted 3/31/15 11:34 PM
 

tnelson22
LIF Infant

Member since 3/15

95 total posts

Name:

Re: Venue Help

Posted by kn2011

What about palmers in farmingdale. Hudson mill in massapequa. Mercato in massapequa. Hemingways in wantagh



I wish I could do Palmer's but current budget doesn't allow for it. Hudson Mill, Sal's Place and Hemingways doesn't offer brunch Chat Icon

I will try Mercato's though. It looks really nice. It doesn't show brunch on their site but doesn't hurt to call and ask.

Thanks again for your help!

Posted 4/1/15 7:21 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Can anyone recommend a Christening venue in Brooklyn, we *may* switch? kathleeng 1/15/10 15 Parenting
Blah. I may have to change DD's 1st b-day party venue... Candy Girl 12/14/09 0 Parenting
How far in advance did you book your venue for your baby's 1st birthday? Bridex100 10/5/09 4 Parenting
Can you recommend a bar/club/non-dive venue nr Stanton Social? Rycois 1/21/09 0 Dining In or Out
UPDATE**** STARTING A BOOK CLUB ... venue change! zuzuspetals 7/30/08 2 Teachers
UPDAT**** STARTING A BOOK CLUB ... venue change! zuzuspetals 7/29/08 0 StoryBoard