updated - MMR Vaccination
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: updated - MMR Vaccination Posted by itsbabytime Posted by lynnd126 I understood the op's Q perfectly but will still respond that I think it is extremely irresponsible not to vaccinate. IMO if you post on the board you have to be ready for whatever responses come your way... I think this is an extremely ignorant thing to post and, I hope the OP gives absolutely no credence at all to you calling her irresponsible. IMO, to vaccinate without taking into considerations the risks in relation to your child is what is irresponsible. Obviously you haven't done enough research to know that there ARE serious risks with this shot, risks that some children are more susceptible to than others. For some children the benefits of a shot for such a rare disease that is not even fatal most of the time do NOT outweigh the serious life altering even deadly side effects. Its the same nonsense with these threads over and over again. Those who choose not to vaccinate or to delay and are looking for support or guidance FROM THOSE WHO HAVE DONE THE SAME are getting bashed by a bunch of people on an internet website who clearly have no knowledge of the situation whatsoever. It's sad that she couldn't have her post responded to by the people she addressed it to. To the OP - do your own research and make the best decision you can for your child - don't listen to a bunch of anonymous people on an internet chat board that probably have done 1/2 the research you have and don't know your child at all. So just want to make sure I understand... those who have decided to vaccinate their children based on the suggested AAP schedule are ignorant, uneducated, and "obviously" haven't done research? Simply because they made a different decision than you did? This is obviously a very sore spot for you for whatever reason. lynnd126 did not at any point call the OP ignorant, because (as the OP pointed out), she never said she wasn't planning to give the vaccine, just that she was curious if anyone hadn't. Lynnd was merely saying she thinks it is irresponsible not to. Everyone was so quick to jump down her throat for calling the OP irresponsible, when she never actually did that, if you had read her post correctly. My point is, it's obviously a ridiculous argument to say that someone hasn't done any research simply because they disagree with you. There are pros and cons to vaccines. Every parent has done the amount of research they feel necessary to do what is best for their children. There will always be varied views on this topic and we can debate until we are blue in the face, but there's really no point to that. I just refuse to be told that I have not done research when I know very well that I have done a large amount of research (as have you and many many other parents). But after my research, I (and my husband) have come to the conclusion that the risks of not vaccinating outweigh the risks of vaccinating. I'm sorry that this seems to offend you to the point of unnecessarily presumptuous insults. |
|
Posted 5/29/11 11:01 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: updated - MMR Vaccination Posted by wingsofsong Posted by itsbabytime Posted by lynnd126 I understood the op's Q perfectly but will still respond that I think it is extremely irresponsible not to vaccinate. IMO if you post on the board you have to be ready for whatever responses come your way... I think this is an extremely ignorant thing to post and, I hope the OP gives absolutely no credence at all to you calling her irresponsible. IMO, to vaccinate without taking into considerations the risks in relation to your child is what is irresponsible. Obviously you haven't done enough research to know that there ARE serious risks with this shot, risks that some children are more susceptible to than others. For some children the benefits of a shot for such a rare disease that is not even fatal most of the time do NOT outweigh the serious life altering even deadly side effects. Its the same nonsense with these threads over and over again. Those who choose not to vaccinate or to delay and are looking for support or guidance FROM THOSE WHO HAVE DONE THE SAME are getting bashed by a bunch of people on an internet website who clearly have no knowledge of the situation whatsoever. It's sad that she couldn't have her post responded to by the people she addressed it to. To the OP - do your own research and make the best decision you can for your child - don't listen to a bunch of anonymous people on an internet chat board that probably have done 1/2 the research you have and don't know your child at all. So just want to make sure I understand... those who have decided to vaccinate their children based on the suggested AAP schedule are ignorant, uneducated, and "obviously" haven't done research? Simply because they made a different decision than you did? This is obviously a very sore spot for you for whatever reason. lynnd126 did not at any point call the OP ignorant, because (as the OP pointed out), she never said she wasn't planning to give the vaccine, just that she was curious if anyone hadn't. Lynnd was merely saying she thinks it is irresponsible not to. Everyone was so quick to jump down her throat for calling the OP irresponsible, when she never actually did that, if you had read her post correctly. My point is, it's obviously a ridiculous argument to say that someone hasn't done any research simply because they disagree with you. There are pros and cons to vaccines. Every parent has done the amount of research they feel necessary to do what is best for their children. There will always be varied views on this topic and we can debate until we are blue in the face, but there's really no point to that. I just refuse to be told that I have not done research when I know very well that I have done a large amount of research (as have you and many many other parents). But after my research, I (and my husband) have come to the conclusion that the risks of not vaccinating outweigh the risks of vaccinating. I'm sorry that this seems to offend you to the point of unnecessarily presumptuous insults. I think you misread entirely what I wrote b/c in large part we are saying the same thing. I said that it was ignorant to call someone irresponisble b/c they might choose not to vaccinate for whatever reason. She did not know the poster's situation or her child's situation and, assumed b/c she was not vaccinating that she was irresponsible. Just like you said - we all do our research and come to the choices we feel are right for our child. I do feel like the post you are quoting was extremely ignorant if you look at what the original poster posted and the response. It did show IMO that she had no awareness at all of the potential risks of the shot for some children. And, now, that you see her update you in fact see that there are individual circumstances that led her to her decision - and, perhaps, she isn't so "irresponsible" at all. Yes, this is a sore subject for me and, I DO vaccinate both of my children. It is a sore subject because I feel really sad that this is one subject that no one on the other side of the spectrum can get a fair response. I found it EXTREMELY disheartening when I myself came on here looking for info from others that shared my concerns how one sided the arguments were and, actually, pretty nasty. The funny thing is that in real life - almost everyone I know in my town (and I live in an upscale affluent area where most people are very educated) delays and spaces shots for their children. But, yet, on this board, if you even suggest it you are irresponsible or an idiot. I'm sorry that you misread my post. I do vaccinate my children so, obviously I came to the same conclusion you did. That said, I respect every parent's right to choose what is right for THEIR child. And, I think that is something we all need to do. Message edited 2011-05-29 23:33:58.913000. |
|
Posted 5/29/11 11:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: updated - MMR Vaccination My DS didnt get it till he was 2. He was a late walker and I wanted to make sure he hit the milestone and sustained it for a while before giving the MMR. My doctors were fine with it. Also we were going to the bahamas at the same time and I felt more comfortable having him vacainated before we went, so the timing worked out well. |
|
Posted 5/29/11 11:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: updated - MMR Vaccination You guys can cut it up and decipher it any way you want and call me anything you want but what I said was that- |
|
Posted 5/30/11 10:39 AM
|
|
|
Re: updated - MMR Vaccination Posted by lynnd126 You guys can cut it up and decipher it any way you want and call me anything you want but what I said was that- I think it is very irresponsible not to vaccinate. That was the statement. The question- has anyone not given MMR? The answer- I think it is very irresponsible not to vaccinate (which implies that my answer is no- have not/will not skip the MMR) You can get up in arms and call ME irresponsible, ignorant- whatever- that's cool- I'm a big girl and I expect when I post on a board such as this to receive replies of varying opinion and varying degrees of vigor. But- the fact remains the same- imo it is very irresponsible not to vaccinate. (And no, that doesn't apply if your kid has some rare condition that makes vaccinating unsafe! Duh! I think the OP prob would have mentioned that though if it were the case) So, instead of answering yes or no, to the yes or no question, you gave an opinion about those people who may have answered no. The topic of vaccinations is a hotbed issue on this forum. To offer up an opinion which is guaranteed to offend in response to a yes or no question is IMO irresponsible at best, and deliberately at worst.For the record to the OP . . . I delayed until DD was 3. Three days later she developed a fever which didn't break for 14 days, sent us to urgent care 3 times, the ER once, and an infectious diseases specialist. All of which resulted in the forced cancellation of our Disney vacation. |
|
Posted 5/30/11 11:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: updated - MMR Vaccination Posted by lynnd126 I think it is very irresponsible not to vaccinate. To this I have to say, you sound like my husband (a physician) and 100% of the physicians that are our friends. This is how people educated in medical school think. My DH can argue all day about vaccines with me and has called me irresponsible a million times. My Ped is amazing, but rolls his eyes at me behind my back. He does everything I want but I know he gives DH a look like "talk to your wife" And its true, affluent areas don't vaccinate adequately for whatever reason, and the old viruses tend to break out in upper middle class communities. And I personally feel for serious diseases its very important to vaccinate. I merit the pause, to stop and think what you are doing to your baby's body. I commend the OP for taking the pause and asking for opinions. A responsible parent takes that pause, whether they decide to vaccinate or not. To the OP: I would get your daughter tested for antibodies before I do any vaccinations. They can test if she's had vaccines done properly, may not need more. Its a simple blood test.
|
|
Posted 5/30/11 1:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: updated - MMR Vaccination Posted by DancinBarefoot Posted by lynnd126 You guys can cut it up and decipher it any way you want and call me anything you want but what I said was that- I think it is very irresponsible not to vaccinate. That was the statement. The question- has anyone not given MMR? The answer- I think it is very irresponsible not to vaccinate (which implies that my answer is no- have not/will not skip the MMR) You can get up in arms and call ME irresponsible, ignorant- whatever- that's cool- I'm a big girl and I expect when I post on a board such as this to receive replies of varying opinion and varying degrees of vigor. But- the fact remains the same- imo it is very irresponsible not to vaccinate. (And no, that doesn't apply if your kid has some rare condition that makes vaccinating unsafe! Duh! I think the OP prob would have mentioned that though if it were the case) To offer up an opinion which is guaranteed to offend in response to a yes or no question is IMO irresponsible at best How? What does it do? Cause some debate between people who are interested in the topic? Cause people who aren't interested to move to another thread? What's irresponsible about me stating my opinion on a "hotbed issue"? Since you brought it up, I think "at best" if she did change her mind it could potentially stop an unvaccinated newborn from catching a deadly illness from her unvaccinated child. I think the value of that is probably higher than me just trying to I'll also repeat that these are all opinions of different people on a public internet forum- so I won't get my panties in a knot. |
|
Posted 5/30/11 1:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: updated - MMR Vaccination Posted by itsbabytime Those who choose not to vaccinate or to delay and are looking for support or guidance FROM THOSE WHO HAVE DONE THE SAME And she is getting her guidance, isn't she.- from people such as yourself- no? To me, only asking that supporters respond to a post is like a child putting their hands over their ears and singing la la la la whenever they hear something they don't like. It's just silly. |
|
Posted 5/30/11 1:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: updated - MMR Vaccination Posted by Sandra I am fine w/ all the posting of everyone - however, I didn't say I wasn't going to get it for my child. Ava came to us at 21months from China - she has had her vac's...but they wanted to do all again here - which we have done- except MMR - and she is due for her 3yr checkup and I know she needs it for school; we also have gone through open heart surgery for her last month - so I am not being irresponsible and I am also aware of the Nassau County outbreak, there was in Riverhead as well per my pediatrician.....I was just curious on others thoughts - that is all - just curious. Thanks ! _______________________________________ Has anyone decided just not to get it at all for their DC? It is the only one I haven't done...Ava is now 3...and I keep on pushing it off. OP- I wasn't calling you irresponsible- I was saying I think it is irresponsible NOT to vaccinate- a decision which without this new info you gave I think would be irresponsible. The update about china/ surgey etc. obviously changes the whole story completely. I hope your dd is doing well. |
|
Posted 5/30/11 1:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: updated - MMR Vaccination Posted by lynnd126 Posted by itsbabytime Those who choose not to vaccinate or to delay and are looking for support or guidance FROM THOSE WHO HAVE DONE THE SAME And she is getting her guidance, isn't she.- from people such as yourself- no? To me, only asking that supporters respond to a post is like a child putting their hands over their ears and singing la la la la whenever they hear something they don't like. It's just silly. She wasn't asking for your opinion of her, or anyone else. To offer up such an opinion, rubs people the wrong way. She was asking why or why wouldn't you. its like if someone asked do you shower or take a bath, and an opinion like "people who take baths destroy the environment" is just not called for in that case. You can just say you like to shower, and for you it works best. |
|
Posted 5/30/11 1:45 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Is the 15 Month Vaccination the MMR? | JenBenMen | 7/29/08 | 19 | Parenting |
| Did you see Amanda Peet and her new campaign for vaccination? | smdl | 8/7/08 | 27 | Parenting |
| Another vaccination q from those that have looked into this - Did anyone space out or delay or opt out of the 8 week shots? | itsbabytime | 9/19/07 | 14 | Parenting |
| Spinoff to Vaccination Q...Did your Ped's office let you... | itsbabytime | 9/17/07 | 11 | Parenting |
| The HEP-B Vaccination - Did your DC get it in the hospital? | itsbabytime | 8/9/07 | 23 | Parenting |
| Did your toddler have a well visit/vaccination b/w 18 months and 2 years old? | dree | 5/29/07 | 8 | Parenting |






at worst.