TurboTax vs. Accountant

Posted By Message

AKD
LIF Adult

Member since 1/12

2637 total posts

Name:

TurboTax vs. Accountant

We normally use an accountant, but I was just playing around w/ TurboTax and went through a bunch of the questions and I feel like there's not a big difference from going to an accountant who asks us the same questions.

Does anyone use TurboTax that used to use an accountant and find it still gives them a great return?

For what its worth - we don't have a complicated financial situation - have a house, just had a baby, each one has a W-2. Nothing intense.

Posted 2/3/15 5:28 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: TurboTax vs. Accountant

If you don't have any complicated issues, it works just fine.
DH has been doing it for years- even when he was working and had to itemize deductions.

It is pretty fool proof for simple tax situations.

Posted 2/3/15 5:34 PM
 

AKD
LIF Adult

Member since 1/12

2637 total posts

Name:

Re: TurboTax vs. Accountant

That's what I thought too - I'm going to do it and not submit and see how the numbers net out, but every year so far its such a headache to try and find a good accountant (we've moved a lot until recently) so we want to find someone near by but have not been huge fans of anyone to date - and do not want to be paying $400+ for tax preparation thats fairly straight forward.

Posted 2/3/15 5:36 PM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

TurboTax vs. Accountant

We went to an accountat and paid $250 the first year we had house. Have been doin turbo tax ever since and it has worked out great. Just be careful if u have sold any stocks or anything like that because it can get dicey there if u arent familiar with it. I remember sitting at thw computer for hrs that year trying to figure it out lol. For basic w-2 and basic deductions situation it is very easy

Posted 2/3/15 6:13 PM
 

Dani
Life is about choices.

Member since 5/05

6532 total posts

Name:
Dani

Re: TurboTax vs. Accountant

can you see what you get back before submitting? id be curious to compare it to what i get back with my accountant.

Posted 2/3/15 7:33 PM
 

CSK
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/11

892 total posts

Name:

TurboTax vs. Accountant

As an accountant, I would say, if you have a simple return, are fairly intelligent and are aware of your main documents/issues, turbo tax works. I haven't used it. From my understanding it asks questions covering most of the standard issues that most people have.

On the other hand, accountants have expertise to identify unusual situations, deal with them and able to deal with the normal stuff without stressing over it, since they've done it a lot of times. They're also able to answer your questions at tax time and throughout the year.

Just for full understanding, accountants don't have black magic to get you back more money than doing it yourself, they just have more complete knowledge of what's out there. For a lot of people, there is 1 way to do the return, 1 right answer. There is more room for interpretation when someone is self employed.

Posted 2/3/15 8:32 PM
 

melbalalala
Little Lady

Member since 5/07

5015 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: TurboTax vs. Accountant

Posted by Dani

can you see what you get back before submitting? id be curious to compare it to what i get back with my accountant.



Yes, you can go through the screens and find out what they think your return will be before you pay for the TurboTax service (you have to pay to print/submit them).

We have a fairly complex return (we own a rental property and a few other quirky investments) and use the fancier TurboTax every year.

They run specials if you use it earlier in the year, too

Posted 2/4/15 8:56 AM
 

AKD
LIF Adult

Member since 1/12

2637 total posts

Name:

Re: TurboTax vs. Accountant

Ok, so last night we went through TurboTax and got our estimated returns - you can do the whole process (took me about 30-45 minutes) and not click submit until you want to and are ready to pay.

We're in the same bracket as last year, own the same house, etc., not much has changed except that we had a kid --- and TurboTax estimated half of the return we got last year from going through the accountant. Needless to say, I did not click submit and will be going through an accountant instead. I feel like Ive heard this a lot about Turbo Tax too - that it doesn't give you the best return possible.

Posted 2/4/15 9:09 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: TurboTax vs. Accountant

Posted by AKD

Ok, so last night we went through TurboTax and got our estimated returns - you can do the whole process (took me about 30-45 minutes) and not click submit until you want to and are ready to pay.

We're in the same bracket as last year, own the same house, etc., not much has changed except that we had a kid --- and TurboTax estimated half of the return we got last year from going through the accountant. Needless to say, I did not click submit and will be going through an accountant instead. I feel like Ive heard this a lot about Turbo Tax too - that it doesn't give you the best return possible.




We used Turbo Tax for years, now we use an accountant but we still run our numbers through Turbo Tax for comparison. Our return is basically the same with both.

Posted 2/4/15 9:40 AM
 

Eunyboo
<3

Member since 7/12

4376 total posts

Name:
E

Re: TurboTax vs. Accountant

Posted by AKD

Ok, so last night we went through TurboTax and got our estimated returns - you can do the whole process (took me about 30-45 minutes) and not click submit until you want to and are ready to pay.

We're in the same bracket as last year, own the same house, etc., not much has changed except that we had a kid --- and TurboTax estimated half of the return we got last year from going through the accountant. Needless to say, I did not click submit and will be going through an accountant instead. I feel like Ive heard this a lot about Turbo Tax too - that it doesn't give you the best return possible.



Maybe your accountant itemizes and you're taking the standard deduction on turbotax? I'm an accountant and if people typically have "boring" situations (w-2, a 1099 or two, a house purchased in prior years), I recommend Turbotax to people who don't want to pay the $$$ for an accountant. It is super user friendly and straightforward.

Posted 2/4/15 9:51 AM
 

AKD
LIF Adult

Member since 1/12

2637 total posts

Name:

Re: TurboTax vs. Accountant

Posted by Eunyboo

Posted by AKD

Ok, so last night we went through TurboTax and got our estimated returns - you can do the whole process (took me about 30-45 minutes) and not click submit until you want to and are ready to pay.

We're in the same bracket as last year, own the same house, etc., not much has changed except that we had a kid --- and TurboTax estimated half of the return we got last year from going through the accountant. Needless to say, I did not click submit and will be going through an accountant instead. I feel like Ive heard this a lot about Turbo Tax too - that it doesn't give you the best return possible.



Maybe your accountant itemizes and you're taking the standard deduction on turbotax? I'm an accountant and if people typically have "boring" situations (w-2, a 1099 or two, a house purchased in prior years), I recommend Turbotax to people who don't want to pay the $$$ for an accountant. It is super user friendly and straightforward.



That might be what happened is I didn't do the right deductions.

Posted 2/4/15 10:17 AM
 

Cataverri
LIF Toddler

Member since 9/12

390 total posts

Name:

Re: TurboTax vs. Accountant

So a few weeks ago I posted this same question here. We always used an accountant and pay him around $250.00. I thought it was a lot of money and wanted to give turbo tax a shot...
One night we also went through the entire process to just see what the net return would be and noticed it was less than half from what we received last year (nothing has changed since last year), so we decided to see the accountant again and got a much better return filing with him.

Good luck.

Message edited 2015-02-04 10:37:58.650000.

Posted 2/4/15 10:37 AM
 

jerrysgirl
I love my hot dog!!

Member since 6/06

5357 total posts

Name:
E & J

Re: TurboTax vs. Accountant

Posted by Cataverri

So a few weeks ago I posted this same question here. We always used an accountant and pay him around $250.00. I thought it was a lot of money and wanted to give turbo tax a shot...
One night we also went through the entire process to just see what the net return would be and noticed it was less than half from what we received last year (nothing has changed since last year), so we decided to see the accountant again and got a much better return filing with him.

Good luck.




you should go line by line of the tax return and see what is different.

my dad and i both use turbo tax. my dad and i are/were both accountants. my dad never worked for a cpa, I did. I reviewed his taxes a few years ago and found he had to amend since he missed out on some deductions. i do a basic return and turbo tax is fine for both of us.

Posted 2/4/15 3:31 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
TurboTax.. anyone have a coupon code? melbalalala 4/7/14 0 Families Helping Families ™
Just did my taxes on Turbotax- so confused HELP! CCMommy 3/14/11 13 Families Helping Families ™
Did anyone use TurboTax AND another tax prep co. see if you get the same return? CaMacho 2/9/09 1 Families Helping Families ™
Accountant vs. HR Block vs. Do it Yourself baghag 2/16/06 32 Families Helping Families ™
Can someone recommend an accountant that can do my taxes ??? DjPiLL 2/16/06 14 Families Helping Families ™
Need an Accountant! Any Suggestions? jar823 12/7/05 0 Families Helping Families ™