WDYT?

Forum Opinion Poll
You should stay married for better or worse 53 28.49%
You should follow your heart and see what else life might have to offer you 133 71.51%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Totally out there poll

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3 4

mikeswife06
Drama Momma

Member since 9/06

9947 total posts

Name:
Anne

Totally out there poll

I know this type of question has many many shades of gray but I am just really curious to see what others think/feel.
IF you really wanted more children and your spouse did not....
Do you think it is worse to leave your marriage to have more children and have your child come from a broken family or stay in a marriage to someone you are going to always resent for not having any more children?

As you might have guessed, it came up and DH said "there is NO way in he!! I am doing this again" Chat Icon even though he says she is the best thing to ever happen and nothing in the world is better than her smile Chat Icon

It's like he is OK with the idea of me leaving. He always makes comments about my "second husband".

Please don't quote, I will be taking this down.

ETA: Unfortunately, I can say with 99% certainty that he is not changing his mind about this.Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-02-25 18:13:08.550000.

Posted 2/25/09 5:40 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

SeptemberBride03
Love my Kiddos!

Member since 5/05

3228 total posts

Name:

Re: Totally out there poll

As you said, many shades of gray and many other details needed. However, my opinion is that the best thing for your child (and for you) is to be happy. It that happiness is being a single parent or a parent married to someone other than your child's father than that is going to be the best place for your child to grow up. Children know whats going and sense tension and anxiety. If you are not happy in the marriage then they will feel that and that will affect their upbringing.

I'm sorry that this is crossing your mind and that you're going through this!! Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/09 5:45 PM
 

steph4777
**************

Member since 5/05

11726 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Totally out there poll

Did he always only want one child? Is there a chance that he might change his mind down the road? It might be too fresh in his mind now, so he can't imagine going through newborn phase again.

Posted 2/25/09 5:47 PM
 

Summersalwaysinseason
I'm finally able to write here

Member since 1/06

2044 total posts

Name:

Re: Totally out there poll

Awwww....I'm sorry you are going through this....

First off, Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Secondly...your daughter is VERY young...please give it some time. Give him some time. He just may come around as she gets older (and it gets "different" - not necessarily easier, but different). He can't see past the baby stage right now and all the hard work and things get so different as they get older. He just may wind up with baby fever after all - you just never know.

He thinks he doesn't NOW...you don't know what the future holds.

To answer your original question, I would not leave my husband. I would learn to be happy with the beautiful daughter I have because my marriage is very important to me and I would need both of us to be on board with another child. I married my DH for better or worse (I hope he feels the same) and I would remain married to him if heaven forbid we weren't able to have any children - and I hope he would do the same.

I hope his outlook changes in time...

Posted 2/25/09 5:47 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Totally out there poll

Many variables but in the end if not being able to have other children is changing your relationship is a way you don't want it too, resenting your DH for not having the same desire for more children, etc... then I think it is worth reconsidering the relationship someone is in.

Posted 2/25/09 5:47 PM
 

twinkletoes807
Mommy's Girls! ♥

Member since 11/07

10116 total posts

Name:
Gabi

Re: Totally out there poll

Ohhh Annie... Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I think what you need to ask yourself is are you happy in your marriage, removing the children issue totally. That question is what you need to answer for yourself. If you are truly happy with your hubby then I would suggest couples counseling to help get past the issue of not having more children.

If you do not think you could ever get past your husband's decision of only wanting one child, and you have an unwavering desire to have more then you need to explore your options.

May I ask, did you and your husband discuss children before you got married? What was said then? Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/09 5:49 PM
 

shellybean
Love my Baby Boy!

Member since 4/07

5191 total posts

Name:
mich

Re: Totally out there poll

Posted by twinkletoes807

Ohhh Annie... Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I think what you need to ask yourself is are you happy in your marriage, removing the children issue totally. That question is what you need to answer for yourself. If you are truly happy with your hubby then I would suggest couples counseling to help get past the issue of not having more children.

If you do not think you could ever get past your husband's decision of only wanting one child, and you have an unwavering desire to have more then you need to explore your options.

May I ask, did you and your husband discuss children before you got married? What was said then? Chat Icon



ITA...for me it would be more the fact that he said no way and doesnt care about what you want....it should be a joint decision...how old is your DC

Message edited 2009-02-25 18:02:30.680000.

Posted 2/25/09 6:02 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Totally out there poll

This is such a hard question and I don't even really know how to answer it. I do know that I remember you posting about this a few times so it's something that is obviously upsetting to you. I know that we all said hopefully he will come around but it doesn't seem that way. I do believe that your DD is still young (can't remember exactly how old she is) and I do want to believe that maybe he will come around still. The first year is so hard on everyone, and I think that men in general don't particularly know how to deal with all the changes in their life. I know that the first four months of my sons life my husband said he was done having kids....now, I'm pregnant with #2. Something happens and something inside of them changes. I pray this is what happens for you.

If this is not the case and your DH is absolutely never going to give in to the idea about another child, I think it comes down to your desire to really have more. Could you really be satisfied in life with just one child? If not then you truly have to do what is best for you - you never want to look back 15 years from now and regret not having more children. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/09 6:03 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Totally out there poll

Chat Icon we did not transisition into parenthood well at all.

it took 8 months for us to feel kind of normal.

DH could not think about TTC until 18 mos.

Now he can't wait for another, but early on loved Josh with everything in him but had zero desire to do it again.

while we were going through that...I knew I would stay even if Josh was our only. I would want him to respect my wishes if I only wanted one.

Now going on month 7 of TTC #2, I am learning to just appreciate my little family...what will be will be, but as of right now I would be a fool to wish I had more when I have so much already.

good luck!

Posted 2/25/09 6:12 PM
 

mikeswife06
Drama Momma

Member since 9/06

9947 total posts

Name:
Anne

Re: Totally out there poll

Thank you all so much. Obviously if our marriage was close to 100% perfect I probably wouldn't be writing this. Chat Icon

I really really really appreciate all of the support and input. You all make me see that I am not crazy.

Unfortunately, I can say with 99% certainty that he is not changing his mind about this.

Posted 2/25/09 6:12 PM
 

mikeswife06
Drama Momma

Member since 9/06

9947 total posts

Name:
Anne

Re: Totally out there poll

Also, when we discussed children before marriage, he would have been OK never having any but he knew I wanted 2 and we both knew if we got married that meant child(ren). The # itself was never decided on.

Posted 2/25/09 6:14 PM
 

mikeswife06
Drama Momma

Member since 9/06

9947 total posts

Name:
Anne

Re: Totally out there poll

Posted by twinkletoes807

Ohhh Annie... Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I think what you need to ask yourself is are you happy in your marriage, removing the children issue totally. That question is what you need to answer for yourself. If you are truly happy with your hubby then I would suggest couples counseling to help get past the issue of not having more children.

Chat Icon



I think you are right. Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/09 6:15 PM
 

twinkletoes807
Mommy's Girls! ♥

Member since 11/07

10116 total posts

Name:
Gabi

Re: Totally out there poll

Posted by mikeswife06

Posted by twinkletoes807

Ohhh Annie... Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I think what you need to ask yourself is are you happy in your marriage, removing the children issue totally. That question is what you need to answer for yourself. If you are truly happy with your hubby then I would suggest couples counseling to help get past the issue of not having more children.

Chat Icon



I think you are right. Chat Icon



Chat Icon Chat Icon I'm here if you need to talk. Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/09 6:19 PM
 

sunflowerjesss
Mommy to 3!

Member since 10/05

20369 total posts

Name:
Jesss, duh.

Re: Totally out there poll

That is a tough one.

I agree with Gabi. Putting Sydnie aside, would you consider yourself head over heels in love?

Ultimately, I do not believe in staying married for the sake of children involved. So the aspect of DC #1 coming from a "broken home" would never concern me. Love is what makes children thrive, not how or where it come from.

Please call or email me if you ever need some one to talk or just listen! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/09 6:22 PM
 

mikeswife06
Drama Momma

Member since 9/06

9947 total posts

Name:
Anne

Re: Totally out there poll

Posted by Summersalwaysinseason

Awwww....I'm sorry you are going through this....

First off, Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon


To answer your original question, I would not leave my husband. I would learn to be happy with the beautiful daughter I have because my marriage is very important to me and I would need both of us to be on board with another child. I married my DH for better or worse (I hope he feels the same) and I would remain married to him if heaven forbid we weren't able to have any children - and I hope he would do the same.

I hope his outlook changes in time...



Thank you so much. I really admire your honesty and your devotion and appreciation of your marriage. Yes, my hope would be that in time he changes his mind but I do not feel so strongly that I can ever be OK with it. But I wonder if it is more because I feel like his mind is made up before I even brought up the idea of TTC again. Even I want to wait a couple of years! Ugh, this is just so tough. It's really hard for me to take things day by day because I am so worried about the future. but I do love my little Sydnie- she is the BEST and I am sooooo lucky for her Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/09 6:23 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Totally out there poll

annie i have a question - both of your pregnancies were unplanned right? what is your DH going to do if you have another unplanned pregnancy?

if you are serious about considering leaving him, you may want to ask him about that first Chat Icon kind of put it in perspective, KWIM?

Posted 2/25/09 6:31 PM
 

shellybean
Love my Baby Boy!

Member since 4/07

5191 total posts

Name:
mich

Re: Totally out there poll

Posted by mikeswife06

Posted by Summersalwaysinseason

Awwww....I'm sorry you are going through this....

First off, Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon


To answer your original question, I would not leave my husband. I would learn to be happy with the beautiful daughter I have because my marriage is very important to me and I would need both of us to be on board with another child. I married my DH for better or worse (I hope he feels the same) and I would remain married to him if heaven forbid we weren't able to have any children - and I hope he would do the same.

I hope his outlook changes in time...



Thank you so much. I really admire your honesty and your devotion and appreciation of your marriage. Yes, my hope would be that in time he changes his mind but I do not feel so strongly that I can ever be OK with it. But I wonder if it is more because I feel like his mind is made up before I even brought up the idea of TTC again. Even I want to wait a couple of years! Ugh, this is just so tough. It's really hard for me to take things day by day because I am so worried about the future. but I do love my little Sydnie- she is the BEST and I am sooooo lucky for her Chat Icon



Are you having other problems that dont relate to this? or is it just this and everything else is fine...why does he say he doesnt want another?

Posted 2/25/09 6:32 PM
 

1stimemom
Love my boys

Member since 2/08

8766 total posts

Name:
Mrs Dee

Re: Totally out there poll

Honey, you know my thoughs on this already. Work the other issues out first and see where he is when his is better mentally, but also you can't wait forever for that time to *hopefully* come. All of my phones are on, if you can escape for a fewChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/09 6:37 PM
 

Karebaby
Precious

Member since 10/06

5304 total posts

Name:
Karyn

Re: Totally out there poll

Posted by twinkletoes807

Ohhh Annie... Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I think what you need to ask yourself is are you happy in your marriage, removing the children issue totally. That question is what you need to answer for yourself. If you are truly happy with your hubby then I would suggest couples counseling to help get past the issue of not having more children.]


I agree with this. But also, I can't help but wonder- if you sacrifice having more children to stay married to him because he doesn't want any more, would you end up resenting him for that? I think I might if I were in your shoes....

Message edited 2009-02-25 18:46:53.930000.

Posted 2/25/09 6:46 PM
 

Karebaby
Precious

Member since 10/06

5304 total posts

Name:
Karyn

Re: Totally out there poll

Sorry I quoted that last one wrong. The bottom paragraph is what I wrote.Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/09 6:47 PM
 

alexlynn7
Big brother to be!

Member since 9/06

6314 total posts

Name:

Re: Totally out there poll

Posted by sunflowerjesss

Ultimately, I do not believe in staying married for the sake of children involved. So the aspect of DC #1 coming from a "broken home" would never concern me. Love is what makes children thrive, not how or where it come from.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



i totally agree with this.

if you and your husband are not happy in your relationship, your child will sense it. and to me, that is worse than both of you being happy but apart.

growing up my parents clearly didn't get along but stayed together for the sake of the family. i can't tell you how many times i BEGGED for them to divorce - in the end i just wanted to see them happy, i didn't care if they were together or apart. i knew they loved me no matter what.

i'm so sorry you're going through this Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/09 6:48 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Totally out there poll

A- I think there is a long history of your needs not being met in this relationship. That is the crux of the issue in whatever form it presents itself. You are young, pretty and seem like a great girl. Follow your heartChat Icon

Posted 2/25/09 6:52 PM
 

avamamma
My Girl

Member since 7/06

3395 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: Totally out there poll

Your DC is young, def give it some time. It took me 3 years to decide to have a second child. I swore she was going to be an only child.

Posted 2/25/09 7:08 PM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Totally out there poll

What bothers me right off the bat is that the question is whether you would have no more children or leave your husband (assuming these are the options available). This alone would probably change the dynamic of my marriage forever. The fact that my husband would be willing to lose me forever over this and accept the fact that I would take our child and go off to start a new family would be something I could never get past in all honesty. I would like to think that within reason there is nothing that either I or DH would not compromise on if it meant losing the other or the family we have. So if your question were to have one child and keep DH happy or have more and him be miserable it would be different and I would think about the issue itself but, that isn't what you are asking I think.

I am so sorry you have to go through this Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-02-25 19:25:24.100000.

Posted 2/25/09 7:23 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Totally out there poll

I think the number of children you plan to have should be discussed before marriage

dh and I agreed to at least 2 but no more than 3

if he told me after we had DD#1 that he was done with children, yes, that would be a deal breaker for me Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/09 7:41 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3 4
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
This is totally random, but want to tell you about my FAVORITE television show at the moment... yankinmanc 8/26/06 1 Parenting
Lactomania...totally TMI, but everyone please come in and tell me what a FREAK OF NATURE I am... yankinmanc 8/26/06 13 Parenting
Can I be totally lame? (For the Lost fans-spolier, maybe) Mommyof2 3/22/06 2 Pregnancy
Am I totally out of line? (REALLY LONG) UPDATED pg2 Jax430 2/24/06 41 Families Helping Families ™
ok ok I hafta say it... I totally <3 my boyfriend Michi 1/16/06 15 Families Helping Families ™
Damn.. totally forgot about a lunch I had today Shelly 11/8/05 2 Families Helping Families ™