to pre-school or not to pre-school

Posted By Message

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

to pre-school or not to pre-school

i was having a discussion with a friend about pre-school and I mentioned that I wasn't sure I would enroll DS for a few reasons. As a teacher she was shocked and adamantly suggested I enroll him otherwise he would be behind and that kids in K and 1st grade are expected to know so much.

The reason I was considering not enrolling him is bc as a SAHM living off of one income, I can't afford to add what I consider to be an unnecessary monthly expense. Now, my sons education IS a top priority to me, but I kind of feel like I already work on all the things they would work on in pre-school with him. He has been VERY vocal since an early age. At 22 months he has over 30 words and has a 4-5 word phrase ("I don't want to" or "I don't want to do" and "now i know my"). he plays with other kids at the park. I do art with him and read him books. He knows some of the letters of the alphabet and sings the alphabet (some of the letters are all in random order...but he has the tune and knows the ABC ...NOW I KNOW MY parts) he knows several animal sounds. I feel that he is a good learner and I have done a good job with him at home and he does still get socialization with play dates and parks etc. I guess I just feel silly paying someone to do what i can do and already do at home. My only reason for considering enrolling him is the socialization aspect.

So...I guess the whole reason I'm posting this is...to find out how many of you really feel pre-school is necessary, to find out what exactly they learn in pre-school and what is expected by first grade. Also, to find out for those who did not pre-school...how did the transition to school go and how was homeschooling? what was your daily routine like?

Posted 5/28/13 1:49 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

nraboni
Uggh...

Member since 10/09

6905 total posts

Name:
Nicole

to pre-school or not to pre-school

Aside from the socialization aspect, I think the "structure" of a pre-school helps kids adjust to Kindergarten.

Posted 5/28/13 1:57 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

I did not send my DD to a formal Pre-K and I *personally* don't find it a MUST in order for a child to be successful in Kindergarten.

Prior to having my DD I was an elementary school teacher and in my last year teaching I taught Kindergarten. I honestly saw VERY little difference between the Pre-K and non Pre-K kids. Any slight difference between them was gone within the first few weeks.

Aside from that, I felt it was wasteful (for me) to spend hundreds of dollars a month on Pre-K when I am a SAHM and a certified teacher, Pre-K though 6th. It just seemed silly to spend so much money on something I was quite capable of doing with her myself.

So instead of Pre-K I enrolled my DD in a separation class (2 hrs a day/twice a week), dance, and classes through the local farm and library. As for Pre-K/Kindergarten skills, I have been working on those with her for the past few years. She starts Kindergarten in the fall and she is more than ready, I think she will do great.

There is nothing wrong with Pre-K, it's not like I think it's useless or silly. I just feel that it isn't a MUST in order to be successful in Kindergarten............especially if you have a parents(s) that works with their kids and gets them involved in other things that also foster learning and socialization. Chat Icon

It's a personal choice, there is no one right answer. For me, I don't regret my decision to not send my DD. I don't feel it will really have any affect on her readiness or success in Kindergarten.

ETA - I had no formal structure for teaching my DD. Every day there is an opportunity to interject learning and basic skills while having fun together. We play a lot of educational games, we read A LOT and go to the library frequently, we bake together, we play all the time with blocks, crayons, puzzles, etc. The learning is more organic then it is a structured learning experience.

Message edited 2013-05-28 14:14:15.187000.

Posted 5/28/13 2:10 PM
 

lucamon
LIF Adult

Member since 6/09

1133 total posts

Name:
Samantha

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

I am currently looking for a preschool for DS solely for the socializing aspect. We are only doing 2 days a week at $180 per month which is well worth it.
Is there anyway you can do something on the side while he's at school to help supplement your income?

Posted 5/28/13 2:12 PM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

Posted by Hofstra26

I did not send my DD to a formal Pre-K and I *personally* don't find it a MUST in order for a child to be successful in Kindergarten.

Prior to having my DD I was an elementary school teacher and in my last year teaching I taught Kindergarten. I honestly saw VERY little difference between the Pre-K and non Pre-K kids. Any slight difference between them was gone within the first few weeks.

Aside from that, I felt it was wasteful to spend hundreds of dollars a month on Pre-K when I am a SAHM and a certified teacher, Pre-K though 6th. It just seemed silly to spend so much money on something I was quite capable of doing with her myself.

So instead of Pre-K I enrolled my DD in a separation class (2 hrs a day/twice a week), dance, and classes through the local farm and library. As for Pre-K/Kindergarten skills, I have been working on those with her for the past few years. She starts Kindergarten in the fall and she is more than ready, I think she will do great.

There is nothing wrong with Pre-K, it's not like I think it' useless or silly. I just feel that it isn't a MUST in order to be successful in Kindergarten............especially if you have a parents(s) that works with their kids and gets them involved in other things that also foster learning and socialization. Chat Icon

It's a personal choice, there is no one right answer. For me, I don't regret my decision to not send my DD. I don't feel it will really have any affect on her readiness or success in Kindergarten.



thank you so much for sharing this. This is exactly how i feel...it's not so much a money issue as it is me feeling like I'm paying someone to do something I am perfectly capable of. I do however, worry about the "structure" too as another poster mentioned...but it's good to hear from someone who didn't do it and has experience as an educator with children who have gone down both roads and that there isn't much of a difference. I'm interested to hear how your DD transitions into her kindergarten class. Best of luck!

Posted 5/28/13 2:16 PM
 

Katareen
5,000 Posts!

Member since 4/10

7180 total posts

Name:
Katherine

to pre-school or not to pre-school

I think I *might* enroll DD at 3 years old, and will try to get into the free Universal Pre-K when she's 4.
At 2 years old I think you're doing just fine with what you're doing.

Posted 5/28/13 2:17 PM
 

bpmom
Feeling Blessed

Member since 6/07

2963 total posts

Name:

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

I, too, was on the fence for sending DS to pre-school. I spend a lot of time with him, he's been reading books since 3yrs old and his academics are excellent, plus we socialize him through various play groups and with our library/church programs. Neither DH nor I attended pre-school and we figured we turned out fine, why send him to something he doesn't need, right?

We found a center that is based on learning through play, and we enrolled him at 4.5yrs old for a 3 day program, mornings only. He's doing great. He's learned a lot, made great friends, and understands how the structure of school works, plus he's been having a lot of fun with the school (barnyard day, petting zoos, bring your bike to school day, etc). I'm glad we did it.

Posted 5/28/13 2:20 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

Posted by meloyellow

Posted by Hofstra26

I did not send my DD to a formal Pre-K and I *personally* don't find it a MUST in order for a child to be successful in Kindergarten.

Prior to having my DD I was an elementary school teacher and in my last year teaching I taught Kindergarten. I honestly saw VERY little difference between the Pre-K and non Pre-K kids. Any slight difference between them was gone within the first few weeks.

Aside from that, I felt it was wasteful to spend hundreds of dollars a month on Pre-K when I am a SAHM and a certified teacher, Pre-K though 6th. It just seemed silly to spend so much money on something I was quite capable of doing with her myself.

So instead of Pre-K I enrolled my DD in a separation class (2 hrs a day/twice a week), dance, and classes through the local farm and library. As for Pre-K/Kindergarten skills, I have been working on those with her for the past few years. She starts Kindergarten in the fall and she is more than ready, I think she will do great.

There is nothing wrong with Pre-K, it's not like I think it' useless or silly. I just feel that it isn't a MUST in order to be successful in Kindergarten............especially if you have a parents(s) that works with their kids and gets them involved in other things that also foster learning and socialization. Chat Icon

It's a personal choice, there is no one right answer. For me, I don't regret my decision to not send my DD. I don't feel it will really have any affect on her readiness or success in Kindergarten.



thank you so much for sharing this. This is exactly how i feel...it's not so much a money issue as it is me feeling like I'm paying someone to do something I am perfectly capable of. I do however, worry about the "structure" too as another poster mentioned...but it's good to hear from someone who didn't do it and has experience as an educator with children who have gone down both roads and that there isn't much of a difference. I'm interested to hear how your DD transitions into her kindergarten class. Best of luck!



You're welcome. Chat Icon And thanks! Chat Icon
I will keep you posted! Chat Icon

Posted 5/28/13 2:20 PM
 

Beck
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

1334 total posts

Name:
still can't believe it's mommy

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

Posted by meloyellow

i was having a discussion with a friend about pre-school and I mentioned that I wasn't sure I would enroll DS for a few reasons. As a teacher she was shocked and adamantly suggested I enroll him otherwise he would be behind and that kids in K and 1st grade are expected to know so much.

The reason I was considering not enrolling him is bc as a SAHM living off of one income, I can't afford to add what I consider to be an unnecessary monthly expense. Now, my sons education IS a top priority to me, but I kind of feel like I already work on all the things they would work on in pre-school with him. He has been VERY vocal since an early age. At 22 months he has over 30 words and has a 4-5 word phrase ("I don't want to" or "I don't want to do" and "now i know my"). he plays with other kids at the park. I do art with him and read him books. He knows some of the letters of the alphabet and sings the alphabet (some of the letters are all in random order...but he has the tune and knows the ABC ...NOW I KNOW MY parts) he knows several animal sounds. I feel that he is a good learner and I have done a good job with him at home and he does still get socialization with play dates and parks etc. I guess I just feel silly paying someone to do what i can do and already do at home. My only reason for considering enrolling him is the socialization aspect.

So...I guess the whole reason I'm posting this is...to find out how many of you really feel pre-school is necessary, to find out what exactly they learn in pre-school and what is expected by first grade. Also, to find out for those who did not pre-school...how did the transition to school go and how was homeschooling? what was your daily routine like?




I feel the same way! We should get together & talk soon. I'm so bad at keeping in touch but we really should since we live so close.

Posted 5/28/13 2:38 PM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

Posted by Beck

I feel the same way! We should get together & talk soon. I'm so bad at keeping in touch but we really should since we live so close.



Absolutely! Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/28/13 2:44 PM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

I am a first grade teaher and DH is a school psychologist and we will be sending DS (who is 3 this month) to pre school in september (its an academically based daycare with preshool within). DS is very energetic and also shows signs of adhd already so we want him in a more structured environment. I want him to see his peers sitting at a table and attaining to a task etc... I also think its important for him to have time with his peers playing but in a different way than he does when at the park.

If I was a sahm I would still be sending him but only 2 days a week half days.

That being said i dont think its necessary for all children and I dont think needed at 22 months old. I think you can teach him a lot of what he would learn. Ds already knows his letters and letter sounds, can count to 14, knows shapes, colors etc .

Posted 5/28/13 2:45 PM
 

krooshe
LIF Toddler

Member since 7/08

395 total posts

Name:

to pre-school or not to pre-school

My son is two and I won't be sending him until he is four. I'm a SAHM also and I work with him at home. I was a kindergarten teacher as well and the kids that didn't have pre-k got into the routine within a couple of weeks.
I do other things for socialization like My Gym and library progams. I don't think pre-k is necessary at 2 years old.

Posted 5/28/13 2:48 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

We skipped it. I had limited funds and felt money was better spent on sports, art, and spanish classes. I got workbooks from dollarstore and K books for us to work on together. First year of K almost done...he is so smart, popular...teachers love him. I worked hard with him, but so glad we went that route. I have yrs to cart him to school..happy we waited for 5

Posted 5/28/13 2:50 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

to pre-school or not to pre-school

Library classes were a great resource for teaching my kids for free to respect the teaxher and rules

Posted 5/28/13 2:52 PM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

It is the best thing I could've done for my kids. They have both thrived socially since starting school. They have learned so much. My oldest loves school. She likes the routine and likes knowing what to expect next.

It can be expensive, but church run programs are the cheapest.

Posted 5/28/13 2:53 PM
 

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

It's not a must and I think the need of it depends entirely upon the child's personality. Like you, for us it wasn;t an expense we could just afford. So for our DS who is starting K this fall, we didn't send him. He is mature, listens well, and I managed to teach him everything he'd learn in pre-k at home. At kindergarten orientation last week he had no issue, and I'm confident he'll adjust to kindergarten with no issue whatsoever.

Some kids need the structure and need to learn how to behave outside of their own environment. I think those are the children who NEED the pre-k (my older DS is one of them) So I don't think it's a one size fits all sort of thing.

Posted 5/28/13 3:01 PM
 

ml110
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

5435 total posts

Name:

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

I went through the same thing. DS is 2.5, and we adopted him 10 months ago. I've been home with him since then. He's doing GREAT as far as learning, speech, socially- especially considering hes only been here for 10 months Chat Icon knows his shapes, most letters, the ABC song, can count to 10, we're working on colors, he can put 4-5 word sentences together.... most of what i do isn't structured learning- i just do it as hes playing, or with other activities we're doing. I worked as a speech therapist in a school, so i have a good idea of where he should be and what he needs to know for school.
right now I take him to library classes, Little Gym, and another little "mommy and me" class. plus, a few of our friends have kids around his age, too. so he gets a lot of socialization.
BUT i'm still sending him to a nursery school program in september (about 2 months before he turns 3). its just 5 hours total a week, and its one where the parents take turns volunteering as the teachers aid... so like maybe once a month or so i'll be in there with him. The reason i'm sending him is just to get him more used to being seperated from me for short periods of time, and just getting him used to navigating things without me for a few hours. i also think it'll be good for him to get used to learning things from people besides me, and just learning more social language and talking with other kids.
he loves learning new things, so i think he'll love it! but again, he'll start when he's almost 3... so a little bit older than you DC so not sure if that makes a difference... i don't think you're wrong either way. every child and family is different, so whatever you think is best probably is Chat Icon

Posted 5/28/13 3:03 PM
 

NewLeaf2012
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

2741 total posts

Name:
....

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

I am second guessing sending my son to pre-k. Aside from him having some unknown medical issues, financially we can't do it right now... I did register him for a place, but if they can't do the afternoons that we need, then he definitely won't go.. I would rather do a separation class and other programs... He is a bright child and he knows his basics. ABC's, 123's, he can cut with scissors, he knows his colors, shapes, and is learning how to read....He will be 4 in late October... He is outgoing and loves other kids... He gets speech 2 days a week and OT 1 day a week and that will continue in September.. I don't want him overwhelmed already with stuff going on EVERY day!!!

I have a ton of stuff at home to help him. And a dear friend of mine has a degree in early childhood development and she sits with him once a week and teaches him stuff....

Posted 8/4/13 1:21 AM
 

PumpkinGirl
:o)

Member since 10/08

1838 total posts

Name:

to pre-school or not to pre-school

I'm sending my ds for 2 yr preschool. It starts as separation & is only 2 hours, 2 days a week. My main reason is fun. He has so much fun doing things with other kids, why not something structured & educational at the same time? I think it will be good for him to make friends and learn to listen to adults other than family. The only negative is the expense but I feel its good for him.

Message edited 2013-08-04 11:58:57.660000.

Posted 8/4/13 11:58 AM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

I don't think preschool is necessary. I do 100% think pre-k is necessary depending on the area in which you live. Honestly, it has nothing to do with academics and how smart they are. Kindergarten is not the transition year that it used to be. There is no acclamation time for separation - these kids are not the babies they used to be years ago coming in - they are mature socially and already used to independent socialization, structure, learning etc. I feel it is not fair to the child and does them a huge disservice in today's world to send them to K having never done any independent school program before. There are many group dynamics that they just don't learn in any other setting. And, in today's world many kids are starting K later and later after having done a 2's program, preschool, pre-k and sometimes even K twice...many of them are turning 6 or already 6 and the maturity and independence of these children is very different than what it was years ago.

Even 3 days a week would be enough. You cannot compare library programs, sports etc. to a school environment. There are many factors go into this and I'm sure any local K teacher would tell you no way to start a child in K these days. And, again, academics has nothing to do with it at all.

Now - there are exceptions to this I'm sure - I'm sure there are some areas and some parts of the country where kids are still not going to preschool, pre-k and starting in K and K is still what it used to be. But, here, in the tri-state area - and speaking to my own area I would NEVER do it. And, again, NOTHING to do with academics at all.

Message edited 2013-08-04 12:51:10.977000.

Posted 8/4/13 12:46 PM
 

butterfly20
Party of 5 - 2015

Member since 4/06

7390 total posts

Name:

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

my son attended Prek this past year... They reinforced the alphabet. They taught them how to write letters, and my son now writes his first name.

The reinforced numbers and now he can count up to 100, and even does some simple addition and subtraction.

They cut with safety scissors, they color more within the lines now, reinforced shapes. They worked on certain words like behind, in front, above, below.

and my son was actually a year early for PreK(but they felt he was ready) so he gets to do another year of it this year.

Posted 8/4/13 12:56 PM
 

Onemoretime
LIF Adult

Member since 9/12

1077 total posts

Name:

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

I started first DS at 3, and second ds at 2. I wish I started my first DS at 2. It is so beneficial for the kids. In my area, all of the children are in programs so there is no one to play with really. The financial burden is big, for 2 kids it was 1000.00 a month , but it is so great for them. Oldest is going to K in sept. so I only have to pay for 1 kid now.

If you can't do it financially, then you can't. We really stretch to pay for this because we feel strongly about it.

Message edited 2013-08-04 13:32:43.780000.

Posted 8/4/13 1:31 PM
 

MrsH2009
Thank you St. Gerard!

Member since 8/09

6631 total posts

Name:
M

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

My DS is starting preschool at 26 months. I too am a teacher. I work with him a lot, and he is very social, but regardless of how many mommy and me programs we do, he acts different when I'm around. I want him to get used to the structure of school and having a teacher and classmates. Plus it's fun! It's only 2 days a week, for 3 hours a day. And financially we will actually be saving $ based on what we do now.

Posted 8/4/13 1:41 PM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: to pre-school or not to pre-school

I'm also a SAHM and don't want to spend the money on preschool right now. I do plan to enroll DD (she's 2 now) in something 2 days/week when she's 4... But right now she is thriving and I don't see a need. We do free library classes, and I'm looking into dance for the fall. She "helps" me at home all day, she's great at following directions, knows the ABCs (just like you described, lol), we read, finger paint, play with play doh, go to the park, etc. She's not shy, and I'm not worried about her needing socialization, she socializes whenever we go out!

Posted 8/4/13 7:50 PM