Thoughts on this news?

Posted By Message

evrythng4areason
And then there were 4

Member since 1/10

5224 total posts

Name:
Kayla

Thoughts on this news?

I'm curious to what other people think. I'm surprised at how this is being presented nsfw.

I nurse dd, so I am obviously pro-bf (even though I have never nursed in public, and nobody other than my husband has seen me nurse), but I'm shocked that they're putting disclaimers like this in the headline.

Alyssa Milano

Posted 4/9/15 8:37 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Thoughts on this news?

Not surprised sadly.

We live in a culture in the US where bf'ing is not suitable to see on work computers but you can log on to tmz and see kim K's nips through a white dress.

Posted 4/9/15 8:53 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Thoughts on this news?

Posted by EatingMyVeggies

Not surprised sadly.

We live in a culture in the US where bf'ing is not suitable to see on work computers but you can log on to tmz and see kim K's nips through a white dress.




I believe it happened at heathrow? No?

Posted 4/9/15 8:57 PM
 

queensgal
Smile

Member since 4/09

3287 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this news?

Honestly I work at a conservative company and they would have flagged this. I don't use work computer for anything personal - they watch us like big brother.

No I don't think breast feeding is nudity but America does have prudish standards. Unless of course it's a kardashion as mentioned, then child nudity, exposed anything seems glorified (agree with previous poster).

I bf my daughter so obviously support it but I think this is one if those hot buttons in the us like race relations and religion, abortion, anti-gay, etc People like to stir the pot and create drama.

Posted 4/10/15 5:20 AM
 

whoababy11
it's only forever

Member since 11/10

1598 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this news?

we live in a really backwards world. kim kardashian's greased up butt and boobs on the cover of a magazine for no reason other than to titillate? sure. a woman taking her boobs out to feed her child? DISGUSTING. ugh. so frustrating. good for milano for consistently standing up for breastfeeding mothers.

Posted 4/10/15 8:58 AM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: Thoughts on this news?

I'm confused by the replies. The issue was the passing of liquid through security, in this case breast milk. Not about her breastfeeding in public. She said she wouldve separated it out in smaller containers, so I dont understand why she didn't just do that from the beginning? Idk, but a mom wouldn't be able to pass through with formula if she didn't have the baby, right?

The story was vague as well, so it hard for me to really make a decision on who was wrong.

Posted 4/10/15 9:09 AM
 

whoababy11
it's only forever

Member since 11/10

1598 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this news?

Posted by Sash

I'm confused by the replies. The issue was the passing of liquid through security, in this case breast milk. Not about her breastfeeding in public. She said she wouldve separated it out in smaller containers, so I dont understand why she didn't just do that from the beginning? Idk, but a mom wouldn't be able to pass through with formula if she didn't have the baby, right?

The story was vague as well, so it hard for me to really make a decision on who was wrong.



i was just responding in general to the amount of crap breastfeeding mothers get on a daily basis. alyssa's issue was that she did not have her baby with her, and she had over 100ml of BM with her. she should have spread it out into multiple containers, apparently. she said she had those containers and would have done so if given the opportunity, but her milk was simply tossed. story

Posted 4/10/15 9:19 AM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: Thoughts on this news?

Posted by whoababy11

Posted by Sash

I'm confused by the replies. The issue was the passing of liquid through security, in this case breast milk. Not about her breastfeeding in public. She said she wouldve separated it out in smaller containers, so I dont understand why she didn't just do that from the beginning? Idk, but a mom wouldn't be able to pass through with formula if she didn't have the baby, right?

The story was vague as well, so it hard for me to really make a decision on who was wrong.



i was just responding in general to the amount of crap breastfeeding mothers get on a daily basis. alyssa's issue was that she did not have her baby with her, and she had over 100ml of BM with her. she should have spread it out into multiple containers, apparently. she said she had those containers and would have done so if given the opportunity, but her milk was simply tossed. story



I know I read the story and im actually the only one that responded with relation to the story. What is the proper protocol when carry liquid through security? Are you allowed as long it is separated out? I only know that if you do have a child they let you carry on milk but it changes if you don't. So what is the actually rules and regulations?

Eta: I meant liquid in terms of food!

Message edited 2015-04-10 09:38:21.917000.

Posted 4/10/15 9:25 AM
 

LiveForMoments
LIF Adult

Member since 10/10

2418 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this news?

Posted by Sash

I'm confused by the replies. The issue was the passing of liquid through security, in this case breast milk. Not about her breastfeeding in public. She said she wouldve separated it out in smaller containers, so I dont understand why she didn't just do that from the beginning? Idk, but a mom wouldn't be able to pass through with formula if she didn't have the baby, right?

The story was vague as well, so it hard for me to really make a decision on who was wrong.



The topic was about the pictures being NSFW, not the whole security thing.

A BF mom needs to pump if she's away from the baby, why would a mother need to carry formula without a baby with her? That's not really a point to compare. On top of that, you can buy formula wherever you are, you can't just buy breastmilk.

Honestly, I had no idea there was limit on breastmilk if you didn't have the baby with you. I read that they just took it without giving her the option to repackage, I really hope that's not the case. I mean the law is the law, but I take issue if her toiletries were treated better than her breastmilk. I agree the story was pretty vague though, it's hard to know what actually happened.

Posted 4/10/15 9:46 AM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: Thoughts on this news?

Posted by LiveForMoments

Posted by Sash

I'm confused by the replies. The issue was the passing of liquid through security, in this case breast milk. Not about her breastfeeding in public. She said she wouldve separated it out in smaller containers, so I dont understand why she didn't just do that from the beginning? Idk, but a mom wouldn't be able to pass through with formula if she didn't have the baby, right?

The story was vague as well, so it hard for me to really make a decision on who was wrong.



The topic was about the pictures being NSFW, not the whole security thing.

A BF mom needs to pump if she's away from the baby, why would a mother need to carry formula without a baby with her? That's not really a point to compare. On top of that, you can buy formula wherever you are, you can't just buy breastmilk.

Honestly, I had no idea there was limit on breastmilk if you didn't have the baby with you. I read that they just took it without giving her the option to repackage, I really hope that's not the case. I mean the law is the law, but I take issue if her toiletries were treated better than her breastmilk. I agree the story was pretty vague though, it's hard to know what actually happened.



No the article wasn't about NSFW, but the OP just said she was surprised that it was labeled as such. The actual news was about the airport security dumping her breast milk. The titles say is written: Thoughts on this news?

Honestly, I was just asking questions. I know moms need to pump even when they aren't around their kids. My point was are you able to carry liquid food through security if it's separated out? Would they toss formula out, baby food is baby food. I can see security not really putting thought into what kind of liquid it is?

Even if they handled this wrong, I don't think it was an attack on breastfeeding. I think they saw liquid milk and tossed it.

Posted 4/10/15 9:56 AM
 

OhBoyorGirl
LIF Adult

Member since 2/12

1789 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this news?

The site didn't just post an article about the instance that happened with Alyssa Milano, or just a picture of Alyssa Milano breast feeding though. It included a gallery of pics of various celebs not only breast feeding, but doing so in a sexualized way, IMO. The average mom does not breast feed in public heavily done up, wearing a robe or evening gown with a slit up to there, or in the nude! Pretty sure those are the pics that would be considered unsuitable for work. The way they're done, you barely even notice the baby.

Posted 4/10/15 10:26 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Thoughts on this news?

Posted by Sash

Posted by LiveForMoments

Posted by Sash

I'm confused by the replies. The issue was the passing of liquid through security, in this case breast milk. Not about her breastfeeding in public. She said she wouldve separated it out in smaller containers, so I dont understand why she didn't just do that from the beginning? Idk, but a mom wouldn't be able to pass through with formula if she didn't have the baby, right?

The story was vague as well, so it hard for me to really make a decision on who was wrong.



The topic was about the pictures being NSFW, not the whole security thing.

A BF mom needs to pump if she's away from the baby, why would a mother need to carry formula without a baby with her? That's not really a point to compare. On top of that, you can buy formula wherever you are, you can't just buy breastmilk.

Honestly, I had no idea there was limit on breastmilk if you didn't have the baby with you. I read that they just took it without giving her the option to repackage, I really hope that's not the case. I mean the law is the law, but I take issue if her toiletries were treated better than her breastmilk. I agree the story was pretty vague though, it's hard to know what actually happened.



No the article wasn't about NSFW, but the OP just said she was surprised that it was labeled as such. The actual news was about the airport security dumping her breast milk. The titles say is written: Thoughts on this news?

Honestly, I was just asking questions. I know moms need to pump even when they aren't around their kids. My point was are you able to carry liquid food through security if it's separated out? Would they toss formula out, baby food is baby food. I can see security not really putting thought into what kind of liquid it is?

Even if they handled this wrong, I don't think it was an attack on breastfeeding. I think they saw liquid milk and tossed it.



I agree with this ^^ .. milk is milk. Formula or breast milk. I FF and I guess she's lucky she had more at hand LOL I'd been royally screwed if they tossed AJ's formula, tho I always kept the ready to mix packets in my bag.

NSFW? well frankly yeah.. boss walking by a desk sees a boob isn't going to stare at it to justify if there's a baby nursing.. its a boob on a computer screen at work. Big no-no

Posted 4/10/15 11:14 AM
 

sunnyflies
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1757 total posts

Name:

Thoughts on this news?

Why did she need to carry extra B milk if she was breast feeding? It's already naturally packaged and easy to dispense to little one.

I breast feed everywhere. Literally. There was a picture of me in a local paper with a shawl covering LO as I spoke at a town hall meeting years ago. Guess what LO was doing as I spoke? It was my turn on the list and my only chance to speak, so I spoke. No one was the wiser.

Posted 4/10/15 11:18 AM
 

AudioLoveStory
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/10

538 total posts

Name:
Lindsay

Thoughts on this news?

Sort of related:

I flew cross country with my son when he was an infant. He was on special Soy formula at the time and they would not let me bring it on the plane. They tossed it! They told me I would have had to make the formula after security, I couldn't have it pre-made. Of course, I did not have another container of formula to make. Luckily I was still nursing as well at that point and was able to bf him while on the plane. It was unbelievable!

Posted 4/10/15 11:19 AM
 

Gratitude
LIF Infant

Member since 12/14

99 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this news?

Not an attack on breastfeeding. A liquid is a liquid - and there have been rules in place for over a decade regarding them. As an actress, I'll bet she flies all the time and is therefore aware of what she can fly with and how it should be packaged.

Posted 4/10/15 11:37 AM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Thoughts on this news?

Posted by sunnyflies

Why did she need to carry extra B milk if she was breast feeding? It's already naturally packaged and easy to dispense to little one.

I breast feed everywhere. Literally. There was a picture of me in a local paper with a shawl covering LO as I spoke at a town hall meeting years ago. Guess what LO was doing as I spoke? It was my turn on the list and my only chance to speak, so I spoke. No one was the wiser.



Her baby wasn't with her, hence the reason she, who nurses and doesn't EP, pumped.

Posted 4/10/15 11:41 AM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Thoughts on this news?

When I flew with breast milk (I EP'ed and did not directly nurse), they just took it to test it and gave it back. No issues.

Posted 4/10/15 11:43 AM
 

LuckyStar
LIF Adult

Member since 7/14

7274 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this news?

Posted by Gratitude

Not an attack on breastfeeding. A liquid is a liquid - and there have been rules in place for over a decade regarding them. As an actress, I'll bet she flies all the time and is therefore aware of what she can fly with and how it should be packaged.



I agree 100%. The only reason this is a big deal is because the mere suggestion of something being maybe, possibly, minutely, not really related to anti bf-ing everyone goes apes!t. Follow the rules and your liquids won't get tossed, whether they be shampoo or breast milk.

If anything, I give props to the TSA employees who didn't bend the rules for a celebrity.

Posted 4/10/15 11:58 AM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Thoughts on this news?

Posted by LuckyStar

Posted by Gratitude

Not an attack on breastfeeding. A liquid is a liquid - and there have been rules in place for over a decade regarding them. As an actress, I'll bet she flies all the time and is therefore aware of what she can fly with and how it should be packaged.



I agree 100%. The only reason this is a big deal is because the mere suggestion of something being maybe, possibly, minutely, not really related to anti bf-ing everyone goes apes!t. Follow the rules and your liquids won't get tossed, whether they be shampoo or breast milk.

If anything, I give props to the TSA employees who didn't bend the rules for a celebrity.



They didn't even give her the chance to disperse it into smaller containers... just threw it out. I'd be absolutely furious. You can't just go past security and buy a new bottle.

Posted 4/10/15 12:53 PM
 

CL2012
LIF Toddler

Member since 1/13

374 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on this news?

Posted by LuckyStar

Posted by Gratitude

Not an attack on breastfeeding. A liquid is a liquid - and there have been rules in place for over a decade regarding them. As an actress, I'll bet she flies all the time and is therefore aware of what she can fly with and how it should be packaged.



I agree 100%. The only reason this is a big deal is because the mere suggestion of something being maybe, possibly, minutely, not really related to anti bf-ing everyone goes apes!t. Follow the rules and your liquids won't get tossed, whether they be shampoo or breast milk.

If anything, I give props to the TSA employees who didn't bend the rules for a celebrity.



to the first poster, you definitely are not attacking breastfeeding, but your view is a bit shortsighted and misinformed. to the 2nd poster, the alyssa milano incident occurred in heathrow which is in the UK, so i'll get to that shortly.

in the US, the TSA does make exceptions for medically necessary liquids, which include breastmilk and formula. i'm sure loads of people on here can speak to the varying medications one might need to travel with in larger liquid quantities than 3oz portions fitting into a quart ziploc. thankfully, the TSA in the US has recognized that when a breastfeeding mother is traveling with or without her baby, she may need to transport breastmilk. the average daily intake for a breastfeeding infant is 19-30oz/day so if you are a breastfeeding mother who is away from the baby for a day+, you will need to pump at least that much to 1) keep up your supply and 2) replace the breastmilk your LO drank from a bottle in your absence. The breastmilk is subject to additional screening which, in my experience, includes a visual examination and a paper strip being held over an open bag/bottle of milk and tested for certain vapors; plus pat down of traveler and possibly additional screening of carry-ons.

It appears that the UK does not make the same allowances for breastmilk as the US does for travelers. Perhaps Alyssa Milano's travel experience until this point was domestic and she wasn't aware of a different policy in the UK. And this is a big deal not because it's an entitled celebrity sob story or it gives people a pro-breastfeeding bandwagon to jump onto, but rather because it highlights a huge flaw in a country's security policy that really should be reconsidered.

Posted 4/10/15 1:05 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Thoughts on this news?

Posted by CL2012

Posted by LuckyStar

Posted by Gratitude

Not an attack on breastfeeding. A liquid is a liquid - and there have been rules in place for over a decade regarding them. As an actress, I'll bet she flies all the time and is therefore aware of what she can fly with and how it should be packaged.



I agree 100%. The only reason this is a big deal is because the mere suggestion of something being maybe, possibly, minutely, not really related to anti bf-ing everyone goes apes!t. Follow the rules and your liquids won't get tossed, whether they be shampoo or breast milk.

If anything, I give props to the TSA employees who didn't bend the rules for a celebrity.



to the first poster, you definitely are not attacking breastfeeding, but your view is a bit shortsighted and misinformed. to the 2nd poster, the alyssa milano incident occurred in heathrow which is in the UK, so i'll get to that shortly.

in the US, the TSA does make exceptions for medically necessary liquids, which include breastmilk and formula. i'm sure loads of people on here can speak to the varying medications one might need to travel with in larger liquid quantities than 3oz portions fitting into a quart ziploc. thankfully, the TSA in the US has recognized that when a breastfeeding mother is traveling with or without her baby, she may need to transport breastmilk. the average daily intake for a breastfeeding infant is 19-30oz/day so if you are a breastfeeding mother who is away from the baby for a day+, you will need to pump at least that much to 1) keep up your supply and 2) replace the breastmilk your LO drank from a bottle in your absence. The breastmilk is subject to additional screening which, in my experience, includes a visual examination and a paper strip being held over an open bag/bottle of milk and tested for certain vapors; plus pat down of traveler and possibly additional screening of carry-ons.

It appears that the UK does not make the same allowances for breastmilk as the US does for travelers. Perhaps Alyssa Milano's travel experience until this point was domestic and she wasn't aware of a different policy in the UK. And this is a big deal not because it's an entitled celebrity sob story or it gives people a pro-breastfeeding bandwagon to jump onto, but rather because it highlights a huge flaw in a country's security policy that really should be reconsidered.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/10/15 1:15 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
UK Tabloid "The News of the World" is closing down due to phone hacking scandal - Thoughts? HoneyBadger 7/7/11 4 Families Helping Families ™
Not so good news... some prayers/positive thoughts please twinkletoes807 11/6/09 40 Parenting
Please keep in your thoughts**Update** UPDATED AGAIN!!! GOOD NEWS!!! EckoRed81504 12/4/08 38 Families Helping Families ™
Thoughts about telling our family the big news!!! MommaToBe 6/8/08 9 Pregnancy
UPDATED in first post, GREAT NEWS!: Is this a bad idea? A good idea? What are your thoughts? dandr10199 9/4/07 25 Parenting
Not such good news maybride2004 5/13/05 26 TTC