This is crazy....
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
This is crazy.... |
|
Posted 6/15/10 2:33 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: This is crazy.... I want to know what doctor would do IVF on a 70 year old...this is just sad for the children. |
|
Posted 6/15/10 2:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: This is crazy.... Posted by Hpe2baMom I want to know what doctor would do IVF on a 70 year old...this is just sad for the children. But the mom got to experience the joy of having a child. If there were no real medical risks (at the time of the IVF procedure) what doctor can judge who is and who isn't fit to be a mom? I am 30 years old, should a doctor not do IVF for me because I could get hit by a car tomorrow? |
|
Posted 6/15/10 2:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: This is crazy.... Posted by headoverheels Posted by Hpe2baMom I want to know what doctor would do IVF on a 70 year old...this is just sad for the children. But the mom got to experience the joy of having a child. If there were no real medical risks (at the time of the IVF procedure) what doctor can judge who is and who isn't fit to be a mom? I am 30 years old, should a doctor not do IVF for me because I could get hit by a car tomorrow? No def not but I just think that at 70 life expectancy isn't as high and it's not really fair to the child. But I do see your point and you are right in that aspect. I didn't look at it that way. |
|
Posted 6/15/10 2:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: This is crazy.... I think to each their own and it is her body, her choice. |
|
Posted 6/15/10 3:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: This is crazy.... Posted by Hpe2baMom Posted by headoverheels Posted by Hpe2baMom I want to know what doctor would do IVF on a 70 year old...this is just sad for the children. But the mom got to experience the joy of having a child. If there were no real medical risks (at the time of the IVF procedure) what doctor can judge who is and who isn't fit to be a mom? I am 30 years old, should a doctor not do IVF for me because I could get hit by a car tomorrow? No def not but I just think that at 70 life expectancy isn't as high and it's not really fair to the child. But I do see your point and you are right in that aspect. I didn't look at it that way. Life expectancy in India is 64. I just checked. So when she went through the treatments, the mother and her doctors knew that this child would be a very young orphan. I do think that life is precious and that any new, healthy life brought into this world is a good thing... but I also think that the mother and her doctors were being frivolous and short-sighted here. |
|
Posted 6/15/10 4:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: This is crazy.... Posted by headoverheels Posted by Hpe2baMom I want to know what doctor would do IVF on a 70 year old...this is just sad for the children. But the mom got to experience the joy of having a child. If there were no real medical risks (at the time of the IVF procedure) what doctor can judge who is and who isn't fit to be a mom? I am 30 years old, should a doctor not do IVF for me because I could get hit by a car tomorrow? That's totally different from a 70 year old having IVF IMO. Accidents happen and there's NO WAY I would ever say a dr shouldn't give IVF to a 30 year old because they could get hit by a car. BUT a 70 year old.. that's totally different. Sorry... I'm not on board. I don't know many 70 year olds who are healthy enough to be pregnant and give birth. And then on top of that there's always... their life expectancy age. I mean they are going to be 80 years old when they have a 10 year old! My grandmother is in her early 80s now and I CANNOT imagine her having a young kid now!! Even when she was in her 70's to be lifting a baby up for a few years would have been A LOT of work and strain on her. And my grandmother is in GREAT shape for a grandmother!!! For me... this is along the lines of that Natalie Sulomon having all those kids and the doctor's just doing whatever she asks. Sometimes it's all about money I guess. Message edited 2010-06-15 16:32:13.973000. |
|
Posted 6/15/10 4:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: This is crazy.... Posted by DavaDay Posted by Hpe2baMom Posted by headoverheels Posted by Hpe2baMom I want to know what doctor would do IVF on a 70 year old...this is just sad for the children. But the mom got to experience the joy of having a child. If there were no real medical risks (at the time of the IVF procedure) what doctor can judge who is and who isn't fit to be a mom? I am 30 years old, should a doctor not do IVF for me because I could get hit by a car tomorrow? No def not but I just think that at 70 life expectancy isn't as high and it's not really fair to the child. But I do see your point and you are right in that aspect. I didn't look at it that way. Life expectancy in India is 64. I just checked. So when she went through the treatments, the mother and her doctors knew that this child would be a very young orphan. I do think that life is precious and that any new, healthy life brought into this world is a good thing... but I also think that the mother and her doctors were being frivolous and short-sighted here. ITA w/ DavaDay!!! Message edited 2010-06-15 16:24:54.633000. |
|
Posted 6/15/10 4:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: This is crazy.... Posted by MrsKS Posted by headoverheels Posted by Hpe2baMom I want to know what doctor would do IVF on a 70 year old...this is just sad for the children. But the mom got to experience the joy of having a child. If there were no real medical risks (at the time of the IVF procedure) what doctor can judge who is and who isn't fit to be a mom? I am 30 years old, should a doctor not do IVF for me because I could get hit by a car tomorrow? That's totally different from a 70 year old having IVF IMO. Accidents happen and there's NO WAY I would ever say a dr shouldn't give IVF to a 30 year old because they could get hit by a car. BUT a 70 year old.. that's totally different. Sorry... I'm not on board. I don't know many 70 year olds who are healthy enough to be pregnant and give birth. And then on top of that there's always... their life expectancy age. I mean they are going to be 80 years old when they have a 10 year old! My grandmother is in her early 80s now and I CANNOT imagine her having a young kid now!! Even when she was in her 70's to be lifting a baby up for a few years would have been A LOT of work and strain on her. And my grandmother is in GREAT shape for a grandmother!!! For me... this is along the lines of that Natalie Sulomon having all those kids and the doctor's just doing whatever she asks. Sometimes it's all about money I guess. Kerri, I wrote out almost the exact same thing a few hours ago but then didn't post it cause I thought this thread was gonna turn into and I just wasn't in the mood for it today! I completely agree with everything you said, right down to the Nadia Suleman comment.
|
|
Posted 6/15/10 9:43 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What is it with all of our crazy InLaws??? | 2003fallwedding | 8/8/05 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| What would your last meal be?(I know kinda crazy but I heard this on the radio) | Luvlylady | 8/1/05 | 25 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Look what my crazy coworkers did for me today.... | CaseyGirl | 7/26/05 | 21 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| I called the RE....need my results! Going crazy not knowing! | MrsJ | 7/12/05 | 16 | TTC |
| What makes you crazy and you don't know why? | sunny | 6/19/05 | 37 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Am I crazy to go to Disney in late July? | Nik09 | 5/31/05 | 19 | Travel & Vacations |









and I just wasn't in the mood for it today! I completely agree with everything you said, right down to the Nadia Suleman comment.