There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Murder verdict tossed because his mom couldn't find a seat

External Image

Meet Daniel Floyd — the luckiest “killer” in New York.
The 23-year-old Brooklyn man was tried, convicted and sent to prison for 15-years-to-life when a jury found he shot a rival dead at a dice game. But the state’s highest court overturned the guilty verdict — all because Floyd’s mother couldn’t find a seat in the courtroom during jury selection.
A juror who voted to convict Floyd was shocked to learn of the stunning reversal.
“On a technicality like there was no room in the courtroom! That’s something new for me. I don’t think that’s right,” said the woman, who didn’t want her name used.
“Oh my gosh! This is very surprising, boy, because I didn’t know people could get off once they were convicted,” the 65-year-old public-school teacher said.
On Monday, Floyd was back in a Brooklyn courtroom for a pre-retrial hearing, as was the heartbroken mother of the man he had been convicted of killing.
“It’s very frustrating,” said Linda Dixon Hill, whose son, Leon Hill, was gunned down in the March 9, 2008, gambling dispute.
“He was found guilty by a jury [and then] the Court of Appeals overturned it,” she said sadly, adding that Leon’s daughter was four months old when he was killed. She is now 6.
Floyd’s conviction was tossed in an April 25, 2013, decision based on his trial lawyer’s complaint to Brooklyn Supreme Court Judge Michael Gary that Melissa Floyd was forced to wait outside a courtroom that was packed with potential jurors.
“Defense counsel observed, ‘Certainly, as a public spectator, she has an absolute right to be present,’?” the decision states. “Defendants have a constitutional right to a ‘public trial,’?” the decision goes on, adding that overcrowding does not justify courtroom closure.
“This violation .?.?. requires a new trial,” the judges ruled.
On his initial appeal, the Appellate Division had found Judge Gary’s offer to get a seat for Floyd’s mom once some juror candidates had been weeded out was sufficient — and upheld the conviction. But the higher court disagreed.
Melissa Floyd declined to comment as she left court. But jurors who convicted her son were shocked to hear of the judicial U-turn.
“That’s a very bizarre reason,” said a male juror, 31, of Crown Heights. “What difference would it have made to the jury selection if she had been in the courtroom?”
Floyd and Hill argued over money on the dice table. Floyd stormed out and returned 20 minutes later, according to court papers — and allegedly fired a fatal shot into Hill’s neck.
Floyd’s current defense attorney, Mario Romano, said they were mulling whether to accept a plea deal or go back to trial.
Floyd, who remains incarcerated, will next appear in court Sept. 12.




I could not believe what I was reading!
Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

The Post

Message edited 2014-07-29 08:40:58.607000.

Posted 7/29/14 8:39 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

BargainMama
LIF Adult

Member since 5/09

15660 total posts

Name:

There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Ridiculous! He is still in jail though, and I'm sure he will be convicted again, and remain in jail. It's just terrible that this costs taxpayers a lot of money to have a second trial.

Posted 7/29/14 9:05 AM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Posted by BargainMama
It's just terrible that this costs taxpayers a lot of money to have a second trial.



YUP! Nice waste of taxpayers time and money. Unbelievable.

Posted 7/29/14 9:11 AM
 

BaysideForever
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

9976 total posts

Name:

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

so ridiculous!!!!

Posted 7/29/14 9:17 AM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

wait, what? Is this even possible? I dont understand what happened, at all.

Posted 7/29/14 9:48 AM
 

Paramount
Sweet!

Member since 7/12

4289 total posts

Name:

There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Its just going to cost the taxpayers the cost of a new trial. He is still in Jail.

Plus, he might be more willing to take a plea now, saving the taxpayers the cost of a trial.

ETA: I have no idea what happened. Mommy could not be in court so its overturned? Makes no sense...

Message edited 2014-07-29 10:07:52.127000.

Posted 7/29/14 10:07 AM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Posted by Paramount
ETA: I have no idea what happened. Mommy could not be in court so its overturned? Makes no sense...



right? That doesnt make any sense? I feel like Im missing something.

Posted 7/29/14 10:37 AM
 

fashiong1rl
LIF Adolescent

Member since 3/14

689 total posts

Name:

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

wow!

Posted 7/29/14 10:38 AM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Posted by Paramount

Its just going to cost the taxpayers the cost of a new trial. He is still in Jail.

Plus, he might be more willing to take a plea now, saving the taxpayers the cost of a trial.

ETA: I have no idea what happened. Mommy could not be in court so its overturned? Makes no sense...




I understand he's still in jail. Thank god!
But to waste tax payers time and money over a damn seat makes no sense to me either. And the idea that he may now be offered and accept a plea deal over this is sickening.

I wonder if something else will come out about this. Because it does seem like something is missing here....

Posted 7/29/14 10:42 AM
 

Tulips915
................

Member since 8/08

6851 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

You've got to be kidding.....
Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/29/14 10:43 AM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Posted by 2BadSoSad

Posted by Paramount
ETA: I have no idea what happened. Mommy could not be in court so its overturned? Makes no sense...



right? That doesnt make any sense? I feel like Im missing something.



Yeah this is mindboggling.

ETA: Apparently bc she wasn't allowed in the courtroom b/c there weren't any seats, it violated his right to have a public trial.

Message edited 2014-07-29 10:58:31.807000.

Posted 7/29/14 10:50 AM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

All because of a stupid technicality.

Here is the decision from the CoA -

Decision

People v Floyd
People v Floyd 2013 NY Slip Op 02779 Decided on April 25, 2013 Court of Appeals Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431. This opinion is uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports.

Decided on April 25, 2013
No. 137 SSM 2

[*1]The People & c., Respondent,

v

Daniel Floyd, Appellant.




Submitted by Allegra Glashausser, for appellant.
Submitted by Rhea A. Grob, for respondent.


MEMORANDUM:
The order of the Appellate Division should be reversed and a new trial ordered.
Defendant was convicted of second degree felony murder, second degree manslaughter, and second degree criminal possession of a weapon for murdering Leon Hill during the robbery [*2]of an underground dice game. Before jury selection, defense counsel informed the judge that defendant's mother was waiting outside, unable to find a seat in the courtroom. Defense counsel observed "[c]ertainly, as a public spectator, she has an absolute right to be present...I can't think of anything else at this particular point about which I might make a record."
The trial judge informed defense counsel that because the jury panel was larger than normal, defendant's mother would need to wait outside the courtroom until he could excuse jurors to create room. Defense counsel replied "right" and informed defendant's mother.
The Appellate Division found that defendant failed to preserve his objection to his mother's exclusion from the courtroom and otherwise upheld his convictions (People v Floyd, 95 AD3d 1138, 1139 [2d Dept 2012]). We reverse.
Defendants have a constitutional right to a "public trial" (US Const Amend VI; Presley v Georgia, 130 S Ct 721, 723-724 [2010]). Mere courtroom overcrowding is not an overriding interest justifying courtroom closure, and the trial judge failed to consider reasonable alternatives before excluding defendant's mother from the courtroom (People v Alvarez, 20 NY3d 75 [2012]; People v Martin, 16 NY3d 607, 612 [2011]). This violation is per se prejudicial and requires a new trial (Martin, 16 NY3d at 613).
Defense counsel properly preserved his objection by raising the issue to the trial court when given the opportunity to "make a record" before jury selection. His statements "unquestionably apprised" the trial judge of the constitutional rights at issue and the obligation to consider reasonable alternatives (People v Garcia, 95 NY2d 946 [2000]).
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
On review of submissions pursuant to section 500.11 of the Rules, order reversed and a new trial ordered, in a memorandum. Chief Judge Lippman and Judges Graffeo, Read, Smith, Pigott and Rivera concur.
Decided April 25, 2013

Posted 7/29/14 10:54 AM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

I still dont get this....it was public, the room just filled up. He wasnt denied the right to a public trial she just should have gotten there sooner to get a seat, no? So anytime someone doesnt get a seat in a courtroom it is grounds for tossing out a conviction?

Posted 7/29/14 11:29 AM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Posted by 2BadSoSad

I still dont get this....it was public, the room just filled up. He wasnt denied the right to a public trial she just should have gotten there sooner to get a seat, no? So anytime someone doesnt get a seat in a courtroom it is grounds for tossing out a conviction?



I believe it was because the judge wouldn't let anyone in?

Posted 7/29/14 11:44 AM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Ridiculous.

Maybe if his mother had been more present in the first place he wouldn't have become a dirtbag murderer.

Posted 7/29/14 11:46 AM
 

2boys4me
He's coming soon!

Member since 4/10

4260 total posts

Name:

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Posted by ElizaRags35

Posted by 2BadSoSad

I still dont get this....it was public, the room just filled up. He wasnt denied the right to a public trial she just should have gotten there sooner to get a seat, no? So anytime someone doesnt get a seat in a courtroom it is grounds for tossing out a conviction?



I believe it was because the judge wouldn't let anyone in?



So if 7000 people showed up there obviously wouldn't be room in the court room for all of them so the judge would have to say sorry there is no more room at some point, right? If that happened, would the person convicted be able to get a retrial because not everyone could fit in the room there by not being a public trial? That doesn't make any sense. Are we suppose to have these in a stadium now to fit everyone who wants to come? Build bigger court rooms? Why didn't she get there first thing so she could make sure she had a seat? This whole thing is insane and Im hoping doesn't set a precedent for future trials.

Posted 7/29/14 12:29 PM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Posted by 2boys4me

Posted by ElizaRags35

Posted by 2BadSoSad

I still dont get this....it was public, the room just filled up. He wasnt denied the right to a public trial she just should have gotten there sooner to get a seat, no? So anytime someone doesnt get a seat in a courtroom it is grounds for tossing out a conviction?



I believe it was because the judge wouldn't let anyone in?



So if 7000 people showed up there obviously wouldn't be room in the court room for all of them so the judge would have to say sorry there is no more room at some point, right? If that happened, would the person convicted be able to get a retrial because not everyone could fit in the room there by not being a public trial? That doesn't make any sense. Are we suppose to have these in a stadium now to fit everyone who wants to come? Build bigger court rooms? Why didn't she get there first thing so she could make sure she had a seat? This whole thing is insane and Im hoping doesn't set a precedent for future trials.



Right? I dont understand this AT ALL.

Posted 7/29/14 12:52 PM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

This may be a stupid question - but did they somehow violate HIS rights but not allowing his Mother to be present for Jury selection?
How is that even relevant?

Posted 7/29/14 12:58 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Posted by MrsProfessor

Ridiculous.

Maybe if his mother had been more present in the first place he wouldn't have become a dirtbag murderer.



possibly


I have no faith in the justice system.

My family has directly been affected by the so called justice system. An innocent kid has had his life turned upside down. Yeah, no faith.

Posted 7/29/14 1:14 PM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Posted by 2boys4me

Posted by ElizaRags35

Posted by 2BadSoSad

I still dont get this....it was public, the room just filled up. He wasnt denied the right to a public trial she just should have gotten there sooner to get a seat, no? So anytime someone doesnt get a seat in a courtroom it is grounds for tossing out a conviction?



I believe it was because the judge wouldn't let anyone in?



So if 7000 people showed up there obviously wouldn't be room in the court room for all of them so the judge would have to say sorry there is no more room at some point, right? If that happened, would the person convicted be able to get a retrial because not everyone could fit in the room there by not being a public trial? That doesn't make any sense. Are we suppose to have these in a stadium now to fit everyone who wants to come? Build bigger court rooms? Why didn't she get there first thing so she could make sure she had a seat? This whole thing is insane and Im hoping doesn't set a precedent for future trials.



Right! And here I always thought the only people that needed a seat in the court room were the jurors!

Stupid Stupid Stupid.

And if I was on the jury I would be livid! You do your civic duty and for a murderer no less and it gets tossed out for this.

Message edited 2014-07-29 13:48:08.530000.

Posted 7/29/14 1:44 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

I think this may set a terrible precedent.

Posted 7/29/14 1:48 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Honestly, it's embarrasing. Other countries must look at us and laugh and laugh.

And this may not be a popular or PC opinion, I am sorry, but the issue is that we give way too many "rights" to criminals in this country. Everyone is worried about violating rights.
The cops, judges, etc have to do everything by the book to the LETTER of a script or you are violating their "rights".

You know what? Screw their rights.
What about the rights of their victims?
Who is protecting those rights?
Our country is so asss backwards it amazes me.

Posted 7/29/14 3:15 PM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Posted by 2boys4me

Posted by ElizaRags35

Posted by 2BadSoSad

I still dont get this....it was public, the room just filled up. He wasnt denied the right to a public trial she just should have gotten there sooner to get a seat, no? So anytime someone doesnt get a seat in a courtroom it is grounds for tossing out a conviction?



I believe it was because the judge wouldn't let anyone in?



So if 7000 people showed up there obviously wouldn't be room in the court room for all of them so the judge would have to say sorry there is no more room at some point, right? If that happened, would the person convicted be able to get a retrial because not everyone could fit in the room there by not being a public trial? That doesn't make any sense. Are we suppose to have these in a stadium now to fit everyone who wants to come? Build bigger court rooms? Why didn't she get there first thing so she could make sure she had a seat? This whole thing is insane and Im hoping doesn't set a precedent for future trials.



It sounds like bc all the people that took the seats were not "public" in this sense. they were potential jurors so kinda looked at as 'involved' in the case. If the judge didnt let anyone in besides the potential jurors then it looks like he was denied a "public" trial.
Honestly - the judge should have moved some of the jurors outside and made room for the family. But I still can't believe they reversed a decision over this.

Message edited 2014-07-29 15:44:40.020000.

Posted 7/29/14 3:39 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Posted by NervousNell

Honestly, it's embarrasing. Other countries must look at us and laugh and laugh.

And this may not be a popular or PC opinion, I am sorry, but the issue is that we give way too many "rights" to criminals in this country. Everyone is worried about violating rights.
The cops, judges, etc have to do everything by the book to the LETTER of a script or you are violating their "rights".

You know what? Screw their rights.
What about the rights of their victims?
Who is protecting those rights?
Our country is so asss backwards it amazes me.




Not disagreeing completely with you .. especially the PC part.. but I can say this.. the innocent until proven guilty is a riot too. My brother is proof of that. He's been treated like a criminal for the past three years for a crime he did not commit. They call it justice. I call it a sham

Posted 7/29/14 4:56 PM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: There is seriously something wrong with our justice system

Posted by NervousNell

Honestly, it's embarrasing. Other countries must look at us and laugh and laugh.

And this may not be a popular or PC opinion, I am sorry, but the issue is that we give way too many "rights" to criminals in this country. Everyone is worried about violating rights.
The cops, judges, etc have to do everything by the book to the LETTER of a script or you are violating their "rights".

You know what? Screw their rights.
What about the rights of their victims?
Who is protecting those rights?
Our country is so asss backwards it amazes me.




Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/29/14 4:59 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
OK. Seriously, WTH Is Wrong With People lvdolphins 5/4/08 19 Parenting
Something is seriously wrong with me, advice please! avamamma 2/22/08 20 Parenting
Ok...there is something SERIOUSLY WRONG MrsERod 2/12/08 21 Families Helping Families ™
Seriously - Manny Ramirez...what's wrong with you? lorich 4/20/07 4 Sports
seriously, what the f*ck is wrong with pple Michi 1/16/07 22 Families Helping Families ™
Seriously --- what is wrong with Britney???? Diana1215 12/2/06 7 Celebrities & Entertainment