The Lighthouse Project

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

The Lighthouse Project

How do you all feel about The Lighthouse Project proposed by Charles Wang?

I'm curious to see what the opinions are for and against it.

I am tentatively for it.. but completely for selfish reasons. Basically if the project is given a green light.. the skilled trades will be back to work. As the wife of an unemployed union electrician.. the idea gives me hope where I am currently filled with fear.

But my perspective is fairly narrow given my circumstances. I don't want to my full support because I know I don't know ENOUGH about it to fully understand the potential adverse effects. I want to see all POV before going with my greedy gut and throwing my support at it wholeheartedly.

What do you all think of it?

Information on The Lighthouse Project.

Message edited 2009-11-04 10:05:05.637000.

Posted 11/4/09 9:29 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

greenfreak
.

Member since 9/06

11483 total posts

Name:
greenfreak

Re: The Lighthouse Project

I don't know enough about it at this point because although I've read articles on it, I try to always get information from both "for" and "against" sources to balance it out.

What I do know is that that area was not meant to carry as much traffic as it currently has in times of high congestion like when the tree is lit, there's a concert, class is in session, etc. You add a draw like that and it makes me wonder if they're considering the traffic enough. It would be great if there was a high capacity train closeby too.

Posted 11/4/09 9:35 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: The Lighthouse Project

I do not know enough about it to give my opinion honestly.

I know my cousins who live near there are against it though.

Posted 11/4/09 9:47 AM
 

8ternity
<3

Member since 11/08

10586 total posts

Name:
Formally NYPD-Wife

Re: The Lighthouse Project

Saw a blueprint of it...looks like its going to look amazing and it will bring in more jobs...I'm for it!

Posted 11/4/09 9:57 AM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: The Lighthouse Project

I'm not for it.

The plans are too big for the area and the area is already congested enough.

NYC is the place for big dense construction, not LI.


Posted 11/4/09 10:07 AM
 

DaniJude
You're My Home <3

Member since 11/06

14815 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: The Lighthouse Project

It really doesn't make a difference what we think. They are going to do it no matter what.

Sorry to be so cynical - it is just the way it is which is annoying sometimes. And with this particular project, I really don't have a "for" or "against" opinion -- it just gets old after a while when the politicians pretend that the public has a say when they are going to do what they want because, in the end, it is all about money in their pockets.

Posted 11/4/09 10:17 AM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: The Lighthouse Project

Against it. I think whoever did their traffic study is completely unrealistic. Hempstead Tpke, stewart Ave., Merrick Ave and the Meadowbrook Pkwy during rush hour are already at what I would guess are peak capacity. If you drive on any of those roads during the holiday shopping season, it's insane. I can't see adding that much more traffic to the area without it creating a huge mess.

I know there are proposals for improved public transportation, but unless they could add a LIRR stop there, which they won't, I don't see how that would really help. I also think Wang's proposal included $$ to create improvements to the roads and traffic, but I don't think the number he put out there would come close to covering what they would have to spend to make a difference.

This is my feeling without even delving into the enviornmental impact or anything else.

Posted 11/4/09 10:35 AM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: The Lighthouse Project

I'd love to see some more of the 'cons' for the project as the website above really only lists the 'pros'
- once i can see how this will impact the existing area, then i can make an informed decision.

however, my initial thought is about the traffic.. it's already way too crowded over there and unless they do major overhauls, it will only get much much worse.
I think bringing in new development/jobs/industry to the area is good, but again, need more info.

Posted 11/4/09 11:30 AM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: The Lighthouse Project

Posted by Otherme

I'd love to see some more of the 'cons' for the project as the website above really only lists the 'pros'
- once i can see how this will impact the existing area, then i can make an informed decision.

however, my initial thought is about the traffic.. it's already way too crowded over there and unless they do major overhauls, it will only get much much worse.
I think bringing in new development/jobs/industry to the area is good, but again, need more info.




That site was put up by supported so we'll never see the Cons listed there.



Posted 11/4/09 11:32 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: The Lighthouse Project

Posted by Otherme

I'd love to see some more of the 'cons' for the project as the website above really only lists the 'pros'
- once i can see how this will impact the existing area, then i can make an informed decision.

however, my initial thought is about the traffic.. it's already way too crowded over there and unless they do major overhauls, it will only get much much worse.
I think bringing in new development/jobs/industry to the area is good, but again, need more info.




I would too.. that's why I figured to post here.

From what I can gather, the biggest concerns are increased congestion in the area and the idea that all of the new proposed retail and commercial space will not be filled. So property values will be driven down by a glut of unused space.

I believe there are also some concerns about the ability of the sewage treatment plants to process the projected amount of waste that could be produced.

It seems as though a lot of the concerns could be addressed by scaling back the project to some degree - but not eliminating it entirely.

Posted 11/4/09 11:57 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: The Lighthouse Project

From the website you posted:

•An unprecedented comprehensive traffic and transportation study (extending 6 miles from the Coliseum) has been in progress for over five years. The study includes addressing;
?The existing traffic and transportation conditions within the study area
?Evaluating potential Impact: to traffic and transportation
?Potential Mitigation: opportunities


Apparently that person has not travelled in the area at any time of the day. Maybe they looked at him on a Major Holiday when nobody was out.

Meadowbrook: packed during traffic times. Hempstead turnpike: full of stop lights already. Packed in morning, lunch, evening traffic.
NSP: packed already at Meadowbrook pkwy. I can't even imagine the exit ramps to go South.


I am not against any projects. But using what is already available (the existing roads) is not a good project. If they come up with infrastructures "passed" the immediate parking lot of this project, maybe I would think it's a good idea. Otherwise, I won't even go close to the area.


ETA: I may be flamed here but when I see this "study"

?Project site is already well served by underutilized LI Bus system

If that's the Hempstead line... I will pass!

Message edited 2009-11-04 12:13:16.907000.

Posted 11/4/09 12:11 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: The Lighthouse Project

I am not 100% sold on the location

but it's hard to deny that long island needs a project like this to improve the economy

we can't sit back and wait for the economy to improve- we need to do things that will improve it



Posted 11/4/09 12:21 PM
 

heathergirl
Cocktail Time!

Member since 10/08

4978 total posts

Name:
American mouth

Re: The Lighthouse Project

Posted by annoyedTTCer

I'm not for it.

The plans are too big for the area and the area is already congested enough.

NYC is the place for big dense construction, not LI.





I pretty much agree, but as more info or definite plans come out, we'll see.

Posted 11/4/09 12:34 PM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: The Lighthouse Project

Against it although it does sound interesting. As someone who lives not that far away I can say that the whole Roosevelt field area/Source etc is already tremendously overcrowded and the traffic is horrendous in that area. They are saying that it will overload the water, sewer supplies, etc.

Additionally they are expecting it to take away office space and business from smaller stores in surrounding towns. Also apartments will most likely be higher end starting around $2500 a month.

Posted 11/4/09 1:02 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: The Lighthouse Project

Posted by Beth

I am not 100% sold on the location

but it's hard to deny that long island needs a project like this to improve the economy

we can't sit back and wait for the economy to improve- we need to do things that will improve it






How does this improve the LI economy?

Aside for a few temporary construction jobs?

Posted 11/4/09 1:06 PM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: The Lighthouse Project

i wish they would put it in suffolk county and combine it with the ducks because A. we could use the tax revenue B. we would have more jobs created and C. I think the traffic flow would be better suited over there since Southern State is there, Meadowbrook/Northern State. The only issue would be islip avenue/carlton avenue.

Personally i am all for it but not as that large of a scale project. But i know they can't just put a new coliseum up because they do not get enough people going to it to justify it - so they need to build housing/new roads in order to access the key grant money to help pay for the projects.

Posted 11/4/09 1:10 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: The Lighthouse Project

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by Beth

I am not 100% sold on the location

but it's hard to deny that long island needs a project like this to improve the economy

we can't sit back and wait for the economy to improve- we need to do things that will improve it






How does this improve the LI economy?

Aside for a few temporary construction jobs?




it's far from a few temporary construction jobs-

new housing, hotel, shopping, offices and most important TAX DOLLARS for NY and LI

here is the breakdown from the website-

•2,300 new residential units
•300 new 5-star hotel rooms (617 existing)
•500,000 SF of new retail space
•1,000,000 SF new office space (1.6 million existing between RexCorp Plaza and Omni)
•200,000 SF of new convention/exhibition space (in addition to the existing 113,000+ SF)
•650,000 SF of new Coliseum and sports complex space ( in addition to the existing 400,000+ SF)
Housing
•20% of housing (460 Units) will be next generation on-site housing
•5% of housing will be rentals (50% for students and 50% for seniors)
•Over 1,700 market rate units (1,2,3 Bedrooms-lofts to luxury)
Economics:
•$3.74 billion estimated development cost; labor costs estimated $2.2 billion. These wages will generate the standard federal and state taxes plus provide spending dollars into the local economy for the badly needed sales taxes.
•Over 75,000 construction and support jobs (almost 15,500 and almost 60,000 respectively) will be created over the estimated 10-year build period. Each construction worker will work on-site for a part of the total construction time; therefore direct hires are about 31,000 jobs.
•Almost 19,000 permanent jobs (full and part-time; on and off site) will be created at full build out. These jobs will generate payrolls of more than $725 million dollars annually. These wages will generate the standard federal and state taxes plus provide spending dollars into the local economy for the badly needed sales taxes.
•Over $71 million of annual property, sales and entertainment taxes on full build out.
•Over $61 million of property tax revenue annually from the Project ($43 million new). Out of the new tax dollars, the following numbers are projected
?$25.34 million to Uniondale Schools
?$6.08 million to County Police departments and headquarters
?$3.03 million to Town Refuse, Garbage and Disposal districts
?$1.54 million to Town Fire department and Prevention fund
?$1.38 million to the Town Highway department
?$1.08 million to the Town Park district
?$1.03 million to the County General fund
•Coliseum alone will generate over $250 million in sales and entertainment taxes over the next 25 years to the County and the State.
•Jobs are badly needed now. The Town and the County have almost a 6% unemployment rate which translates into 45,066 and 79,539 respectively, of residents looking for work. Unemployment clearly has a trickle down effect to spending (sales taxes) and housing foreclosures (home values).
•Without the Islanders, Coliseum will likely not exist. County has to financially support it now and will cost more money without primary tenant and facility continues to age. Thus, Long Island residents will have to travel to NYC, NJ and CT for their entertainment options (spending captive dollars in those locations). The Coliseum tenants (NYI, NYD, entertainers, etc) account for more than $250 million in goods and service purchases.

Posted 11/4/09 1:43 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: The Lighthouse Project

Posted by Beth

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by Beth

I am not 100% sold on the location

but it's hard to deny that long island needs a project like this to improve the economy

we can't sit back and wait for the economy to improve- we need to do things that will improve it






How does this improve the LI economy?

Aside for a few temporary construction jobs?




it's far from a few temporary construction jobs-

new housing, hotel, shopping, offices and most important TAX DOLLARS for NY and LI

here is the breakdown from the website-

•2,300 new residential units
•300 new 5-star hotel rooms (617 existing)
•500,000 SF of new retail space
•1,000,000 SF new office space (1.6 million existing between RexCorp Plaza and Omni)
•200,000 SF of new convention/exhibition space (in addition to the existing 113,000+ SF)
•650,000 SF of new Coliseum and sports complex space ( in addition to the existing 400,000+ SF)
Housing
•20% of housing (460 Units) will be next generation on-site housing
•5% of housing will be rentals (50% for students and 50% for seniors)
•Over 1,700 market rate units (1,2,3 Bedrooms-lofts to luxury)
Economics:
•$3.74 billion estimated development cost; labor costs estimated $2.2 billion. These wages will generate the standard federal and state taxes plus provide spending dollars into the local economy for the badly needed sales taxes.
•Over 75,000 construction and support jobs (almost 15,500 and almost 60,000 respectively) will be created over the estimated 10-year build period. Each construction worker will work on-site for a part of the total construction time; therefore direct hires are about 31,000 jobs.
•Almost 19,000 permanent jobs (full and part-time; on and off site) will be created at full build out. These jobs will generate payrolls of more than $725 million dollars annually. These wages will generate the standard federal and state taxes plus provide spending dollars into the local economy for the badly needed sales taxes.
•Over $71 million of annual property, sales and entertainment taxes on full build out.
•Over $61 million of property tax revenue annually from the Project ($43 million new). Out of the new tax dollars, the following numbers are projected
?$25.34 million to Uniondale Schools
?$6.08 million to County Police departments and headquarters
?$3.03 million to Town Refuse, Garbage and Disposal districts
?$1.54 million to Town Fire department and Prevention fund
?$1.38 million to the Town Highway department
?$1.08 million to the Town Park district
?$1.03 million to the County General fund
•Coliseum alone will generate over $250 million in sales and entertainment taxes over the next 25 years to the County and the State.
•Jobs are badly needed now. The Town and the County have almost a 6% unemployment rate which translates into 45,066 and 79,539 respectively, of residents looking for work. Unemployment clearly has a trickle down effect to spending (sales taxes) and housing foreclosures (home values).
•Without the Islanders, Coliseum will likely not exist. County has to financially support it now and will cost more money without primary tenant and facility continues to age. Thus, Long Island residents will have to travel to NYC, NJ and CT for their entertainment options (spending captive dollars in those locations). The Coliseum tenants (NYI, NYD, entertainers, etc) account for more than $250 million in goods and service purchases.



Sorry, have the numbers the supporters are quoting been verified by anyone?

As for the Coliseum not exiting without the Islanders that is totall bull.

The Whalers left Hartford yet that arena is still home to plenty of events each year.

Posted 11/4/09 1:56 PM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: The Lighthouse Project

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by Beth

I am not 100% sold on the location

but it's hard to deny that long island needs a project like this to improve the economy

we can't sit back and wait for the economy to improve- we need to do things that will improve it






How does this improve the LI economy?

Aside for a few temporary construction jobs?




I just wanted to say that construction jobs are temporary by nature. The impact is not 'a few temporary construction jobs'. This particular venture could potentially put back to work over 300 electricians, untold numbers of steamfitters, plumbers, carpenters and such for probably over 2 years. That's WAY more than 'a few'. Temporary.. but enough so that these families get a little bit of a shot in the arm while the economy starts to recover enough so that HOPEFULLY when it is over there might be more work ready.

The hope is also that by creating a new attraction centerpiece - the entire area will gain a boost. Increased revenue for existing stores and restaurants - space for new retail places, more housing, a world class hotel.. all these things aimed at making Long Island a destination for something other than the Hamptons - and something a little more than the footrest of NYC.

Having said that.. I still think the project is a little too big the more I read about it. I can see making the Coliseum more updated and new. I can even see creating a true 5 star hotel - but the plans they have are just a little TOO big to be sustainable. Of course.. that's only what I see so far. I'm still learning more.

Message edited 2009-11-04 14:01:48.880000.

Posted 11/4/09 2:00 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: The Lighthouse Project

Posted by rojerono

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by Beth

I am not 100% sold on the location

but it's hard to deny that long island needs a project like this to improve the economy

we can't sit back and wait for the economy to improve- we need to do things that will improve it






How does this improve the LI economy?

Aside for a few temporary construction jobs?




I just wanted to say that construction jobs are temporary by nature. The impact is not 'a few temporary construction jobs'. This particular venture could potentially put back to work over 300 electricians, untold numbers of steamfitters, plumbers, carpenters and such for probably over 2 years. That's WAY more than 'a few'. Temporary.. but enough so that these families get a little bit of a shot in the arm while the economy starts to recover enough so that HOPEFULLY when it is over there might be more work ready.

The hope is also that by creating a new attraction centerpiece - the entire area will gain a boost. Increased revenue for existing stores and restaurants - space for new retail places, more housing, a world class hotel.. all these things aimed at making Long Island a destination for something other than the Hamptons - and something a little more than the footrest of NYC.

Having said that.. I still think the project is a little too big the more I read about it. I can see making the Coliseum more updated and new. I can even see creating a true 5 star hotel - but the plans they have are just a little TOO big to be sustainable. Of course.. that's only what I see so far. I'm still learning more.



I understand you wanting your husband back at work but I can't support overdevelopment of LI for temporary employment gains.
What LI needs is long term plans to keep these people working balanced with a need for us to not look like Queens.

Why do we need a world class hotel in the middle of the island? For what? Who is starying there?
What are the occupancy rates of LI hotels right now?
As a business person these are the questions to ask.

How does is this project an attraction centerpiece? Do we think people will visit LI just to see this?

Posted 11/4/09 2:10 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: The Lighthouse Project

Posted by annoyedTTCer

.



Sorry, have the numbers the supporters are quoting been verified by anyone?

As for the Coliseum not exiting without the Islanders that is totall bull.

The Whalers left Hartford yet that arena is still home to plenty of events each year.



I have no clue- even if the numbers aren't 100%- you can't say it's just a few temp construsction jobs

there is much more to it then that

I wouldn't call myself a supporter- so I don't care enough to reserach more- I think suffolk could benefit from this more then Nassau - and there is more land there

Posted 11/4/09 2:10 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: The Lighthouse Project

Posted by Beth

Posted by annoyedTTCer

.



Sorry, have the numbers the supporters are quoting been verified by anyone?

As for the Coliseum not exiting without the Islanders that is totall bull.

The Whalers left Hartford yet that arena is still home to plenty of events each year.




I have no clue- even if the numbers aren't 100%- you can't say it's just a few temp construsction jobs

there is much more to it then that

I wouldn't call myself a supporter- so I don't care enough to reserach more- I think suffolk could benefit from this more then Nassau - and there is more land there



Is it much more than that?

What is the net addition of jobs? How many are really newly created jobs versus jobs just move from other parts of the island?

Would the office space be used by firms new to LI? Or would it be firms moving from other areas of LI to this development thus leaving other areas with empty office space?

The problem the Islanders would have with being in Suffolk is pulling pepole into the games. Granted not a lot of city folks come out to see Islander games but in NC you have a bigger population to pull from than in SC.

Posted 11/4/09 2:15 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: The Lighthouse Project

Posted by annoyedTTCer


The problem the Islanders would have with being in Suffolk is pulling pepole into the games. Granted not a lot of city folks come out to see Islander games but in NC you have a bigger population to pull from than in SC.




according to the Cenus- Suffolk has more people then Nass

not sure how islander fans break up Nas vs Suffolk

not sure it matters.....

Posted 11/4/09 2:20 PM
 

3girls1dog
LIF Adult

Member since 10/09

929 total posts

Name:

Re: The Lighthouse Project

I don't know whether I am for or against. I have lived in the area all my life and the traffic is ridiculous adding more to it would seem to be negative.

As far as retail and housing space there have been so many apartment buildings recently built that aren't even rented out yet and every where you look stores are vacant and for rent.

And what about resources. It seems that we are always being told to conserve and save the environment what impact would this have on our environment?

It seems like a cool idea and an advancement for long island, but I think there are also a lot of negatives too.

Posted 11/4/09 2:22 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: The Lighthouse Project

Posted by Beth

Posted by annoyedTTCer


The problem the Islanders would have with being in Suffolk is pulling pepole into the games. Granted not a lot of city folks come out to see Islander games but in NC you have a bigger population to pull from than in SC.




according to the Cenus- Suffolk has more people then Nass

not sure how islander fans break up Nas vs Suffolk

not sure it matters.....



Sorry meant Nassau County can pull audience from NYC and SC

Located in Suffolk County they can pull from NC and NYC but the chances dimish as you get further from location.





Posted 11/4/09 2:23 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
What would you wear to a Sunday wedding at The Lighthouse at Chelsea Piers? Tine73 10/10/08 12 Fashion & Beauty!
New shopping/attractions! The Arches/Tanger Outlets at Deer Park and the LI Lighthouse! Goobster 8/17/07 10 Families Helping Families ™
New shopping,etc The Lighthouse at LI in Uniondale! Goobster 6/3/07 3 Families Helping Families ™
My first crochet project tourist 8/23/05 16 Crafts, Hobbies & Interests
Anyone hear of The Noah's Ark Project? azoodie 8/21/05 3 Pets
Look at our latest project! (pics) Bxgell2 6/16/05 18 Home