The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

mrsh2010
To travel is to live.

Member since 7/09

1679 total posts

Name:
Celia

The Drink Ban is Illegal!

I would like to shake this judges hand!

Sugary drink ban halted in New York City

NEW YORK (WABC) -- In a major defeat for New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg, a state judge has dismissed the city's planned ban on sugary drinks as illegal.

The ban was scheduled to take effect on Tuesday.

In the decision, the judge wrote that Bloomberg's sugary drink regulations are "fraught with arbitrary and capricious consequences. The simple reading of the rule leads to the earlier acknowledged uneven enforcement even within a particular city block, much less the city as a whole."

Judge Milton Tingling added that the ban raised concerns because it would apply "to some but not all food establishments in the city, (and) it excludes other beverages that have significantly higher concentration of sugar sweeteners and / or calories on suspect grounds..."

The ruling came as barbecue joints, coffee counters and bottle-service nightclubs prepared for the coming clampdown on big, sugary soft drinks.

Some restaurants ordered smaller glasses. Dunkin' Donuts shops told customers they'll have to sweeten and flavor their own coffee. Coca-Cola had printed posters explaining the new rules.

City officials had said it's a pioneering, practical step to staunch an obesity rate that has risen from 18 to 24 percent in a decade among adult New Yorkers. Health officials say sugar-filled drinks bear much of the blame because they carry hundreds of calories - a 32-ounce soda has more than a typical fast-food cheeseburger - without making people feel full.

The city "has the ability to do this and the obligation to try to help," the plan's chief cheerleader, Mayor Michael Bloomberg, said last month.

Critics say the regulation would not make a meaningful difference in diets but will unfairly hurt some businesses while sparing others. A customer who can't get a 20-ounce Coke at a sandwich shop could still buy a Big Gulp at a 7-Eleven, for instance, since many convenience stores and supermarkets are beyond the city's regulatory reach.

New Yorkers have been divided on the proposed restrictions. A Quinnipiac University poll released last week found 51 percent opposed it, while 46 percent approved.

link

Message edited 2013-03-11 16:08:04.890000.

Posted 3/11/13 3:47 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Kitten1929
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

6040 total posts

Name:

The Drink Ban is Illegal!

It doesn't bother me that it's been overturned, but I still think those enormous drinks are terrible.

Posted 3/11/13 3:51 PM
 

Tulips915
................

Member since 8/08

6851 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Posted by Kitten1929

It doesn't bother me that it's been overturned, but I still think those enormous drinks are terrible.


Of course big drinks are terrible but it's not up to Mayor Bloomie to tell us what we should do.

Can we ban him from talking?? How many more days of him left in office!?!? Chat Icon

Posted 3/11/13 4:03 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

The Drink Ban is Illegal!

I thought the law was silly. If someone feels the need to drink a ginormous soda, that's their prerogative and doesn't affect the people around them. I'd rather them ban cigarettes or smoking, which affects everyone surrounding the smoker. JMO

Posted 3/11/13 4:06 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Disappointed to see this but the judge seems to be right.

Posted 3/11/13 4:09 PM
 

dctead
It's 5 o'clock somewhere!

Member since 11/10

2139 total posts

Name:
Emily

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

The ban (or lack there of) doesn't effect me...but I'm glad it was overturned.

I don't condone the super large drinks, but IMO someone has a right to choose to drink or not to drink any volume of sugar drinks they want with out the government getting in the way.

Posted 3/11/13 4:23 PM
 

ChilisWife
God Bless America

Member since 5/05

3572 total posts

Name:
A.K.

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

100% right decision. The whole way it was structured was ridiculous.

Posted 3/11/13 4:23 PM
 

Ayne11
Yep

Member since 1/09

18021 total posts

Name:

The Drink Ban is Illegal!

I'm just happy Bloomberg didn't get his way. Chat Icon

Posted 3/11/13 4:25 PM
 

mrsm-2011
He is my world!

Member since 6/12

3009 total posts

Name:
Theresa

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Posted by Ayne11

I'm just happy Bloomberg didn't get his way. Chat Icon



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/11/13 4:38 PM
 

MrsM-6-7-08
<3

Member since 8/06

4249 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Posted by dctead

The ban (or lack there of) doesn't effect me...but I'm glad it was overturned.

I don't condone the super large drinks, but IMO someone has a right to choose to drink or not to drink any volume of sugar drinks they want with out the government getting in the way.




I agree, it doesn't effect me either, I don't drink soda or use sugar in my coffee because its not healthy Chat Icon

But i don't need the government dictating how much of something I can drink

Posted 3/11/13 4:57 PM
 

PearlJamChick
No one sings like you anymore.

Member since 7/10

9264 total posts

Name:
Petticoated Swashbuckler

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Posted by dctead

The ban (or lack there of) doesn't effect me...but I'm glad it was overturned.

I don't condone the super large drinks, but IMO someone has a right to choose to drink or not to drink any volume of sugar drinks they want with out the government getting in the way.




Same here.

If anything, maybe all the hubbub over the ban/non-ban will have informed some people about just how bad this stuff is for you.

Posted 3/11/13 5:09 PM
 

Jbon630
LIF Adult

Member since 12/11

1340 total posts

Name:

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Posted by ElizaRags35

I thought the law was silly. If someone feels the need to drink a ginormous soda, that's their prerogative and doesn't affect the people around them. I'd rather them ban cigarettes or smoking, which affects everyone surrounding the smoker. JMO



ITA! I am pregnant and have to hold my breath walking at least a few times a week so i don't inhale smoke.

Posted 3/11/13 6:46 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

The Drink Ban is Illegal!

I am happy that this didn't get passed based on the businesses that would suffer as a result and the fact that it targets the demographic that can least afford it.

Posted 3/11/13 7:19 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Posted by ElizaRags35

I thought the law was silly. If someone feels the need to drink a ginormous soda, that's their prerogative and doesn't affect the people around them. I'd rather them ban cigarettes or smoking, which affects everyone surrounding the smoker. JMO



Yup
The focus is in the wrong place.

Posted 3/11/13 7:37 PM
 

drpepper318
MIR MIR MIR!

Member since 6/07

8274 total posts

Name:
me

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Posted by ElizaRags35

I thought the law was silly. If someone feels the need to drink a ginormous soda, that's their prerogative and doesn't affect the people around them. I'd rather them ban cigarettes or smoking, which affects everyone surrounding the smoker. JMO


Chat Icon ITA

Posted 3/11/13 9:10 PM
 

ourlivesstartnow2012
New Year, New Everything!

Member since 6/12

2689 total posts

Name:

The Drink Ban is Illegal!

I thought the ban was just silly. I feel as though there are different problems that should be addressed instead of how much soft drink I want to drink. PLUS I was watching the news before and they said you could not buy that large of a drink but you can buy 2 16oz sodas instead. So if someone wants that much to drink they can still get it.

Bloomberg just needs to focus his attention on other things and not what I drink. I HATE when the gov't gets THAT involved in my life. Try to keep my safe, not tell me what I can and cannot do with my own life (if it doesn't affect others).

Posted 3/11/13 11:04 PM
 

RellyWife
LIF Infant

Member since 2/10

82 total posts

Name:

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Posted by ourlivesstartnow2012

I thought the ban was just silly. I feel as though there are different problems that should be addressed instead of how much soft drink I want to drink. PLUS I was watching the news before and they said you could not buy that large of a drink but you can buy 2 16oz sodas instead. So if someone wants that much to drink they can still get it.

Bloomberg just needs to focus his attention on other things and not what I drink. I HATE when the gov't gets THAT involved in my life. Try to keep my safe, not tell me what I can and cannot do with my own life (if it doesn't affect others).



The point was that if someone really wanted 32oz of regular coke (a TON of calories), it would hopefully make them stop and think about the implications from a health perspective.

I find that a "medium" soft drink at fast food places is more what I would consider a "large" or "extra large". Portion sizes are out of control! Maybe a better way to go about this would have been to regulate the amount of ounces a "medium" drink can be.

Obesity is a HUGE problem (pun intended). Something needs to be done because aside from the health issues it causes a person, it is placing a huge financial strain on the healthcare system! Which, in turn diverts money from other causes, affecting other people.

Posted 3/12/13 8:35 AM
 

Pumpkin1
LIF Adult

Member since 12/05

3715 total posts

Name:

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Posted by ourlivesstartnow2012

I was watching the news before and they said you could not buy that large of a drink but you can buy 2 16oz sodas instead.



That was the point, Bloomberg knew the law itself was illusory. People make this bad health decision because its only a few cents more to buy the bigger size and that bigger size is so unhealthy. However, by putting a financial disincentive in place, it would push people to stop supersizing.

Posted 3/12/13 8:37 AM
 

PaddysGirl
Little princess is here!

Member since 4/07

5923 total posts

Name:
Crystal

The Drink Ban is Illegal!

I can not stand Bloomberg. The big picture isn't what was being banned it was the fact that he was taking people's right to choose away. And I think that in itself is BS.

Yes, it will be more money to buy 2 sodas instead of one but if someone wants it they will buy it. The fact that the loophole around this was so obvious it was laughable.

And this ban was directly impacting my husbands job and the money he brings home so I was obviously against it from day one.

Posted 3/12/13 9:09 AM
 

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Posted by RellyWife


Obesity is a HUGE problem (pun intended). Something needs to be done because aside from the health issues it causes a person, it is placing a huge financial strain on the healthcare system! Which, in turn diverts money from other causes, affecting other people.



I think this was really the point, but similarly, smoking would me a more worthwhile focus, IMO.

Posted 3/12/13 9:38 AM
 

jlk51496
Mom of 3 - YIKES! =)

Member since 10/09

6758 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Posted by RellyWife

Posted by ourlivesstartnow2012

I thought the ban was just silly. I feel as though there are different problems that should be addressed instead of how much soft drink I want to drink. PLUS I was watching the news before and they said you could not buy that large of a drink but you can buy 2 16oz sodas instead. So if someone wants that much to drink they can still get it.

Bloomberg just needs to focus his attention on other things and not what I drink. I HATE when the gov't gets THAT involved in my life. Try to keep my safe, not tell me what I can and cannot do with my own life (if it doesn't affect others).



The point was that if someone really wanted 32oz of regular coke (a TON of calories), it would hopefully make them stop and think about the implications from a health perspective.

I find that a "medium" soft drink at fast food places is more what I would consider a "large" or "extra large". Portion sizes are out of control! Maybe a better way to go about this would have been to regulate the amount of ounces a "medium" drink can be.

Obesity is a HUGE problem (pun intended). Something needs to be done because aside from the health issues it causes a person, it is placing a huge financial strain on the healthcare system! Which, in turn diverts money from other causes, affecting other people.



Chat Icon Chat Icon

well said!!!

Glad I am not the only one that feels this way...if you want to order the super duper big gulp...that is just silly...maybe you should step back and ask is that much really necessary? The obesity problem is out of control...maybe people need forced portion control!!! Chat Icon

I mean really..look at this picture...do people really need this much sugar...

External Image

Posted 3/12/13 9:44 AM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Posted by RellyWife

Posted by ourlivesstartnow2012

I thought the ban was just silly. I feel as though there are different problems that should be addressed instead of how much soft drink I want to drink. PLUS I was watching the news before and they said you could not buy that large of a drink but you can buy 2 16oz sodas instead. So if someone wants that much to drink they can still get it.

Bloomberg just needs to focus his attention on other things and not what I drink. I HATE when the gov't gets THAT involved in my life. Try to keep my safe, not tell me what I can and cannot do with my own life (if it doesn't affect others).



The point was that if someone really wanted 32oz of regular coke (a TON of calories), it would hopefully make them stop and think about the implications from a health perspective.

I find that a "medium" soft drink at fast food places is more what I would consider a "large" or "extra large". Portion sizes are out of control! Maybe a better way to go about this would have been to regulate the amount of ounces a "medium" drink can be.

Obesity is a HUGE problem (pun intended). Something needs to be done because aside from the health issues it causes a person, it is placing a huge financial strain on the healthcare system! Which, in turn diverts money from other causes, affecting other people.




ITA, plus the gov't does put regulations on our health/safety all the time...seat belt laws? People complained about that when it first happened but now it's normal. Smoking in bars? Same deal...

It's arbitrary and I think Bloomberg still got his point across if all of these discussions are happening Chat Icon At the least, I'm sure this was his goal...

Posted 3/12/13 10:11 AM
 

RellyWife
LIF Infant

Member since 2/10

82 total posts

Name:

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Since it seems like a large part of the opposition in general on this issue is people lamenting the loss of their "right" to choose, I think another right that should be talked about is the right to be informed.

Informed about how much sugar is in their sodas (see above photo!)- would you ever put 16 teaspoons of sugar into your morning coffee?! A "Medium" Coke from Wendy's is roughly 22 ounces, 240 calories and 66 grams of sugar= 16 teaspoons. (source= wendys.com)

Informed about how fast food restaurants are playing with human nature's desire to get the "best deal" and order the bigger size since it is "only a few cents more." The extra soda costs them next to nothing but they get extra $$ from you= drives up profit.

Informed about how soda sizes have grown in leaps and bounds! This blog post is pretty informative- shows that the only size available in 1950s was 7 ounces!

http://www.motherjones.com/media/2012/06/supersize-biggest-sodas-mcdonalds-big-gulp-chart

If the sizes of soda that restaurants were able to sell was regulated, you would still have your "right" to order whatever size you wanted off of the menu. You also wouldn't feel the pressure to buy the next size up (30+ ounces!) for only "20 cents" more or have to exercise the self restraint to only drink half of a 32 ounce soda and throw out the rest (likelihood of that happening for anyone, myself included= slim).

Posted 3/12/13 10:24 AM
 

Pomegranate5
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

4798 total posts

Name:
Pomegranate5

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

Posted by ElizaRags35

I thought the law was silly. If someone feels the need to drink a ginormous soda, that's their prerogative and doesn't affect the people around them. I'd rather them ban cigarettes or smoking, which affects everyone surrounding the smoker. JMO



I agree.

I know the argument is that obesity affects everyone with higher health care costs, and I do agree with that, but I'd rather see insurance companies offering incentives and rewards for healthy living than this soda ban that seems to have the biggest negative affect on small businesses.

Posted 3/12/13 10:33 AM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: The Drink Ban is Illegal!

I couldn't be less of a Bloomberg fan. Chat Icon

But I do think he had a point. As others have said, obesity is a real problem.

We, collectively, pay for each other's crappy habits and bad lifestyle choices. People are always ******** about the cost of healthcare, complaining about illegals in the ER (and I'm not saying that's not an issue) while sucking down a 2 liter bottle of coke and 2 Nathans hot dogs. Then having a pack of cigs for dessert.

So, yeah, I still think Bloomie sucks. But I agree with his intentions. And I know I was too snarky to make a good point, but maybe you'll understand anyway. Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/12/13 11:40 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Do you drink during the week? missus-hbradio 8/10/05 50 Families Helping Families ™
New Drink LadyMaravilla 6/13/05 8 Families Helping Families ™
what do you drink? sunny 6/4/05 18 Pregnancy
Ummmmm I need a drink....anyone else? KPsquared 5/17/05 35 Families Helping Families ™
Anyone try the Ensure Healthy Mom drink? btrflygrl 5/14/05 3 Pregnancy
Anyone drink Trader Joe's Milk? mrswask 5/12/05 1 Families Helping Families ™