Thank you

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

Posted by maybebaby

So for those that think there should be no limit...a 38 week abortion would be ok? A 40 week? A 32 week?

I don't understand how a baby couldn't just be delivered at that point except for EXTREME circumstances. And then let nature take its course (albeit mother in severe danger).

THAT i don't get. And never ever will.

And I should have stated that my question was more about abortions where there are no medical problems to baby or mother...because there ARE women who abort at the 6 month mark because they just do not want the child.

Sorry, but that will never ever sit well with me.



I would think unless the mother's life is at risk, she would be induced at that point. As for the whose life is more important - as much as many moms would die for their child - I believe the mom's life trumps the child. The mother is a living, breathing being. The child is not yet. I know people that lost the baby during delivery. Potential life versus actual life in my opinion. In that case, the only one who should be able to decide is the mother of the child.

Posted 9/6/08 7:52 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

mcl916
my two loves

Member since 10/06

5133 total posts

Name:
Megan

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

Posted by maybebaby

So for those that think there should be no limit...a 38 week abortion would be ok? A 40 week? A 32 week?

I don't understand how a baby couldn't just be delivered at that point except for EXTREME circumstances. And then let nature take its course (albeit mother in severe danger).

THAT i don't get. And never ever will.

And I should have stated that my question was more about abortions where there are no medical problems to baby or mother...because there ARE women who abort at the 6 month mark because they just do not want the child.

Sorry, but that will never ever sit well with me.



Exactly- there are definately two different issues at hand. Those that chose to have abortions for personal reasons and those that need abortions for medical reasons. In my mind, these are unrelated and I believe they should be unrelated when it comes to lawmaking.

Posted 9/6/08 7:52 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

Posted by Blazesyth

It sounds kind of weird, but on Jezebel.com a couple of weeks ago they put up an article about a woman that is blogging about her abortion.

She said she is doing it because she went online looking for information about what would happen, what the process was, etc and all she could find was pro-life, religious sites telling the reader not to do it, or medical sites with details she didn't want.

The reason I bring this up is her latest post is about how there is only certain weeks where it could be done, depending upon the method of choice. (Or maybe these restrictions are only put in place by the doctor that is doing it, I'm not sure.) I did not know that, and think that maybe others don't know the same and that might make them have to wait longer than they want to for an abortion.

If anyone's interested in the blog, here is the link to the Jezebel article.




Okay I may get flamed for this. I know I have no right to judge other people. I know I have no right to judge other's choices. But reading this blog - this is the exact reason that I always tend to be more on the pro life side. Maybe it is bc I view the "tumor" as a life, but to go about it like its some kind of joke makes me physically ill and I wonder how many women out there think like her.

Posted 9/6/08 7:54 PM
 

donegal419
St. Gerard, pray for us.

Member since 7/07

7650 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

Posted by Tilde


Okay I may get flamed for this. I know I have no right to judge other people. I know I have no right to judge other's choices. But reading this blog - this is the exact reason that I always tend to be more on the pro life side. Maybe it is bc I view the "tumor" as a life, but to go about it like its some kind of joke makes me physically ill and I wonder how many women out there think like her.



I agree... i found her blog to be quite disgusting, to put it mildly. But perhaps her joking is really masking the pain she may be feeling. i foudn thw hole blog to be in poor taste. granted, i am pro-life, so of course i am going to disagree, but i found her casual attitude about the whole thing very unnerving and her jokes were not funny.

Posted 9/6/08 7:56 PM
 

mcl916
my two loves

Member since 10/06

5133 total posts

Name:
Megan

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

Posted by donegal419

Posted by Tilde


Okay I may get flamed for this. I know I have no right to judge other people. I know I have no right to judge other's choices. But reading this blog - this is the exact reason that I always tend to be more on the pro life side. Maybe it is bc I view the "tumor" as a life, but to go about it like its some kind of joke makes me physically ill and I wonder how many women out there think like her.



I agree... i found her blog to be quite disgusting, to put it mildly. But perhaps her joking is really masking the pain she may be feeling. i foudn thw hole blog to be in poor taste. granted, i am pro-life, so of course i am going to disagree, but i found her casual attitude about the whole thing very unnerving and her jokes were not funny.



ITA. If it were informative it would be one thing, but this is just sad Chat Icon

Posted 9/6/08 8:01 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

Posted by donegal419

Posted by Tilde


Okay I may get flamed for this. I know I have no right to judge other people. I know I have no right to judge other's choices. But reading this blog - this is the exact reason that I always tend to be more on the pro life side. Maybe it is bc I view the "tumor" as a life, but to go about it like its some kind of joke makes me physically ill and I wonder how many women out there think like her.



I agree... i found her blog to be quite disgusting, to put it mildly. But perhaps her joking is really masking the pain she may be feeling. i foudn thw hole blog to be in poor taste. granted, i am pro-life, so of course i am going to disagree, but i found her casual attitude about the whole thing very unnerving and her jokes were not funny.



When I read the earlier post about what that poor woman had to go through, it made me so sympathetic to what women may be faced with and why it is so hard to be against medically necessary abortions ( for me ). But then reading that blog, or hearing a (married, with two children and financially okay) friend say that if she is knocked up she is going straight to the clinic - I just lose all sympathy. Sorry. I try to be a bigger person and not judge, but I am human and I can't help it.

Posted 9/6/08 8:01 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

I don't believe people are randomly deciding to abort in the 3rd trimester because they don't want a baby. I believe 3rd trimester abortions are because of medical issues with the child or the mother.

To make that distinction between medical necessity & the ones for "personal" reasons, it's a slippery slope.

It is a personal decision to not have a child with Down's Syndrome or mental retardation. People have children like that every day, knowing what they are getting into & love that child with all of their heart. That is the choice they made. It is not medically necessary to terminate a pregnancy those pregnancies. That is a personal choice. In a sense, it is eugenics.

I don't want the government legislating who makes the choice that the pregnant women HAS to have that child.

I have 2 children. I became pregnant with my 3rd child. We were petrified because we had learned that we have chromosomal issues in our family. I was going for the earliest test you can have to determine if there were chromosomal issues - the earliest test (CVS test) is 10 weeks, the results take about 10 -14 days. That would have put me right into my 2nd trimester. Should the government have had the right to say "you have to have this child?". I made the decision when I first got that BFP that I would terminate the pregnancy if there was anything wrong. I realize plenty of people have developmentally disabled siblings & love them. I worked in a group home where I saw a 65 year old man visiting his 68 year old sister every 2 weeks. She had the mental capacity as a 2 year old. It is not something I wanted for my children. I was not comfortable giving my child that lifetime responsibility of a sibling with severe disabilities. The end result was a miscarriage so there was no need to ever make that decision. However it should only be my decision to make, not the government's.

Message edited 2008-09-06 20:34:59.177000.

Posted 9/6/08 8:13 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

Posted by monkeybride

I don't think we should limit. It should be on a case by case basis. Late term abortions are sometimes necessary for the health of the mother or because the baby will be born dead anyway.



My thoughts exactly, and I would venture to say that the amount of women seeking abortions in the 2nd and 3rd trimesters have more reason to terminate than just not wanting the child.

Posted 9/6/08 8:32 PM
 

VirginiaDeb
Don't eat me, hippo!

Member since 5/05

9252 total posts

Name:
Deb

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

Posted by prncss

Posted by monkeybride

I don't think we should limit. It should be on a case by case basis. Late term abortions are sometimes necessary for the health of the mother or because the baby will be born dead anyway.



My thoughts exactly, and I would venture to say that the amount of women seeking abortions in the 2nd and 3rd trimesters have more reason to terminate than just not wanting the child.



I agree.

Posted 9/6/08 8:35 PM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

The cut off in Roe and subsequent cases was based on the point at which - the scientific community at that point had established that the child could survive - on it's own - outside the mother's womb. According to the case law - which is the law in our country - b/f the baby can survive on its own - it is not a "life" worthy of protection but, only a "potential life."

I also used to be "pro-choice" but not pro-abortion. I just felt it was a necessary alternative in our society b/c I feared what would happen if there was not this alternative - especially for young people. HOWEVER, after going through pregnancy myself - and seeing my child on the sonogram at 12 and 20 weeks it was shocking to me - and changed my views on the subject forever - b/c to me, there was NO WAY at that point that what I was seeing could be described as anything other than a life.

Posted 9/6/08 8:38 PM
 

Chai77
Brighter days ahead

Member since 4/07

7364 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

It's just my opinion, but I think the cut off should be the age of viability. After that point, having an elective abortion is just not ok IMO. I do think there should be exceptions however when the mother's health is in jeopardy or in a case like Barb posted, when the baby will be severely disabled or will die shortly after birth. I know that is all very subjective. I am 100% pro-choice policy-wise, however, I personally would never choose to have an abortion, unless there was a serious medical reason.

Message edited 2008-09-06 20:41:54.530000.

Posted 9/6/08 8:41 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

What it comes down to for me is that I am beyond 100% pro-choice and by limiting a woman's choice, that would go against everything I believe. Why should a woman be forced to have a baby if it's going to be detrimental to her health? And while I would tend to agree with the age of viability, I could never possibly know all of the situations that would warrant a late term abortion, so I could never advocate for a cut off. As upsetting as it is for me to think about, personally, the law isn't just for ME, it's for all women in this country adn just because I don't plan on utilizing that part of the law doesn't mean it shouldn't be in place for those who need to. KWIM?

Posted 9/6/08 8:47 PM
 

MissJones
I need a nap!

Member since 5/05

22152 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

Barb...I'm sorry to hear about what happened. Chat Icon And I whole heartedly agree about not wanting your children to have to ever be in the place of the older man.

Posted 9/6/08 8:49 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

Posted by maybebaby

So for those that think there should be no limit...a 38 week abortion would be ok? A 40 week? A 32 week?

I don't understand how a baby couldn't just be delivered at that point except for EXTREME circumstances. And then let nature take its course (albeit mother in severe danger).

THAT i don't get. And never ever will.

And I should have stated that my question was more about abortions where there are no medical problems to baby or mother...because there ARE women who abort at the 6 month mark because they just do not want the child.

Sorry, but that will never ever sit well with me.



Ethically a doctor is not going to perform an abortion on a 38 week fetus, I just don't think that will ever happen.

I still stand strong in my belief there should be no limit, it's not the government's choice to make.

Posted 9/6/08 8:55 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

Posted by maybebaby

So for those that think there should be no limit...a 38 week abortion would be ok? A 40 week? A 32 week?

I don't understand how a baby couldn't just be delivered at that point except for EXTREME circumstances. And then let nature take its course (albeit mother in severe danger).

THAT i don't get. And never ever will.

And I should have stated that my question was more about abortions where there are no medical problems to baby or mother...because there ARE women who abort at the 6 month mark because they just do not want the child.

Sorry, but that will never ever sit well with me.



Ethically a doctor is not going to perform an abortion on a 38 week fetus, I just don't think that will ever happen.

I still stand strong in my belief there should be no limit, it's not the government's choice to make.

Posted 9/6/08 8:55 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about the abortion issue...




Okay I may get flamed for this. I know I have no right to judge other people. I know I have no right to judge other's choices. But reading this blog - this is the exact reason that I always tend to be more on the pro life side. Maybe it is bc I view the "tumor" as a life, but to go about it like its some kind of joke makes me physically ill and I wonder how many women out there think like her.

I haven't read it yet but I get the idea and probably a lot of women think like her (maybe they wouldn't call it a tumor or joke about it) because a lot of people do not believe that life begins at conception, myself included and I have a child and another on the way.

Posted 9/6/08 9:00 PM
 

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

Posted by mcl916

Posted by maybebaby

So for those that think there should be no limit...a 38 week abortion would be ok? A 40 week? A 32 week?

I don't understand how a baby couldn't just be delivered at that point except for EXTREME circumstances. And then let nature take its course (albeit mother in severe danger).

THAT i don't get. And never ever will.

And I should have stated that my question was more about abortions where there are no medical problems to baby or mother...because there ARE women who abort at the 6 month mark because they just do not want the child.

Sorry, but that will never ever sit well with me.



Exactly- there are definately two different issues at hand. Those that chose to have abortions for personal reasons and those that need abortions for medical reasons. In my mind, these are unrelated and I believe they should be unrelated when it comes to lawmaking.



ITA!

Posted 9/6/08 9:04 PM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

Wow 6 months... I didn't know they did it that late. I am pro choice but unless it is medically needed that seems way too far along.

Posted 9/6/08 9:04 PM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

I am pro-choice, but definitely not pro-abortion. I believe that unless absolutely medically necessary (for either the health of the mother or child) that a pregnancy shouldn't be terminated. I also don't believe there should be a time limit for those that need to make that horrible choice.

But I am glad that we live in a country that allows us to make such a personal choice for our families if we had to.

Posted 9/6/08 9:11 PM
 

Little-J-Mommy
I'm a Big Brother

Member since 5/06

8041 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Question about the abortion issue...

Barb, I'm sorry for your loss, I had no ideaChat Icon

and that article had meChat Icon Chat Icon

I am with Prncss on this one. I am pro-choice. I would never be able to judge a woman for having to make possibly the most difficult and heart-wrenching decision of her life. And I would NEVER be ok with having the gov't make that decision FOR her.

Posted 9/6/08 9:16 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Formula question & Issue....alittle long...*Update* Mdolph6 6/25/08 9 Parenting
Quick work issue/question spooks 5/11/07 3 Families Helping Families ™
Antibiotic and feminine issue question... Jen2999 3/12/07 6 Families Helping Families ™
Health Insurance Issue/Question Beth 1/16/07 5 Families Helping Families ™
health insurance question/issue- UPDATE nferrandi 9/7/06 17 Pregnancy
Spinoff to Abortion Issue KrisT 4/20/07 54 Families Helping Families ™