Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

Posted By Message

FreeButterfly
hum...

Member since 5/05

6263 total posts

Name:

Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

Do to divorce, I live w/ my mom and DS (3 y/o).

Sometimes he gets into a mood and doesn't want to say hello to her or answer her questions.

She gets on Chat Icon and decides to not to talk to him.

She says he needs to learn respect.

It seems really mean to me... you thoughts?

Message edited 2011-02-14 08:36:43.183000.

Posted 2/14/11 8:35 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

~Colleen~
my loves...

Member since 5/05

9129 total posts

Name:
guess

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

IMO, to learn respect you need to be taught respect and ignoring a 3yo is definitely not respectful (to say the least).

Posted 2/14/11 8:38 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

I agree-ignoring a child as retaliation sounds harsh.

DD-3.5 does this sometimes too. We tell her it's not polite and it hurts feelings but leave it at that for the most part-I'd like to hear how others handle.

Posted 2/14/11 8:39 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

I don't think it is too harsh. I don't talk to my nephew until he says hello to me. He does not have to kiss me but he has to say "Hi Zia!" If he doesn't I don't answer him when he tries to get me to play with him or get him something. He is going to be 3 in April.

Now, when he asks me something, he will stop in the middle and think for a second, and then he gives me a hug and a kiss first just to be sure, in case he didn't say hello when he came in LOL

Posted 2/14/11 8:47 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

Not talking to a 3 yo is childish and immature. That's not how to teach kid about manners IMO.

I think at 3 yo, yes you absolutely can teach about manners. Saying thank you and please and explain that you answer when a "known" grown-up asks a question. But they are also ONLY 3 yo and while you try to teach them you cannot expect a child that young to grasp everything.

Posted 2/14/11 8:47 AM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

The most respectful children I know, have the most respectful caretakers/parents. I think as with adults you show respect and get respect back.

Posted 2/14/11 8:53 AM
 

LoriH
There's no place like home

Member since 8/07

4110 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

I don't think ignoring in and of itself is harsh but I do not know if it is the right way to correct the stated behavor. I ignore DD when she is acting out because she does it for attention. Therefore ignoring helps redirect her behavior.

I agree that to teach respect you have to show the child some respect. With things like saying hello to family, being kind to friends, manners etc; I try to show her why it is important. I repeat what she should be doing and why. I know many may not agree with reasoning with a 3 y/o but they are perfectly capable of understanding. I could see ignoring being part of how you show a child why they should be polite and kind. However without other methods I do not think they will learn the lesson.

Posted 2/14/11 9:22 AM
 

MrsGmomof3
...

Member since 6/08

3290 total posts

Name:
Irrelevant

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

3 year olds are moody. This is why when anyone says "Oh, its the terrible two's" I laugh, because its not the 2's that are bad, its 3 year olds.

Honestly, I think your mom needs to relax. This is perfectly age appropriate behavior. 3 year olds are learning that they can get reactions from people. Your mom should try to treat your child with "the SILLIES" rather than ignoring him. Instead of ignoring, how about "Oh no... where did (insert name) go? I can't seem to find him! All I wanted to do was say hello and give (insert name) a hug.... oh well....".... guarentee the 3 year old will bust out into giggles, say "Here I am!" and calm will settle over the land LOL.

Honestly, taking anything a 3 year old does personally will get you no-where fast. Expecting "respect" from a 3 year old is ridiculous IMO.... all they want is a reaction. Treating them with amusement and a bit of "silly" seems to make everything better.

Message edited 2011-02-14 10:56:24.880000.

Posted 2/14/11 10:55 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

Posted by Tilde

I don't think it is too harsh. I don't talk to my nephew until he says hello to me. He does not have to kiss me but he has to say "Hi Zia!" If he doesn't I don't answer him when he tries to get me to play with him or get him something. He is going to be 3 in April.

Now, when he asks me something, he will stop in the middle and think for a second, and then he gives me a hug and a kiss first just to be sure, in case he didn't say hello when he came in LOL



I agree with this.

first of all, I will not allow my 3-year-old to ignore his grandma. we live with my MIL and every morning when he sees her, I say "hi abuela" and he now says Hi and waves. he learns from me that we greet people when we see them.

now, if he's in a puss, and he doesn't say Hi to her, I think she can deal with it however she wants. I have no problem with her making it known that he has hurt her feelings with his silence. or his disrespect.

but I would expect that she tell him first. "I am hurt and don't want to talk to you b/c you don't want to say hi" or something along those lines. nope. no problem whatsoever from me.

Posted 2/14/11 10:58 AM
 

FreeButterfly
hum...

Member since 5/05

6263 total posts

Name:

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

Thanks...DS has very good "please/thank you" manners, he is trying to share, very sweet/caring. But he's 3...sometimes he gets into a mood.

I remember my uncle had a beard and my parents/uncle had to bribe us a quarter to kiss him.

I'm not sure 2 wrongs equal a right here...especially if one "wrong" is an adult.

Posted 2/14/11 12:44 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

How long ago did you divorce?

I know with mine, they went through a a period where they would act out or get fresh and in all honesty, I truly believe it was because of the situation and not their being disrespectful...As much as I wanted to be hard on them for acting in that way, I had to handle it differently due to the situation.. I would ask your mom to sit your 3YO down and try and talk to DS and see what he's feeling and what's on his mind..

GL!Chat Icon

Posted 2/14/11 12:54 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

Posted by ~Colleen~

IMO, to learn respect you need to be taught respect and ignoring a 3yo is definitely not respectful (to say the least).



Agreed.

I do teach my DD about respect and even yesterday told her she should be more respectful to her father. But you can't teach respect if you don't show respect.

Posted 2/14/11 1:02 PM
 

FreeButterfly
hum...

Member since 5/05

6263 total posts

Name:

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

Posted by bicosi

How long ago did you divorce?

I know with mine, they went through a a period where they would act out or get fresh and in all honesty, I truly believe it was because of the situation and not their being disrespectful...As much as I wanted to be hard on them for acting in that way, I had to handle it differently due to the situation.. I would ask your mom to sit your 3YO down and try and talk to DS and see what he's feeling and what's on his mind..

GL!Chat Icon



Divorce was 1 year ago, been living w/ mom for about 8 months. I truely don't belive its divorce related except yesterday it did happen after DS was w/ ex-h for the weekend. Usually, every other sunday's when I get him back are HORRIBLE (Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon ) bad. This was just different. He may have been tired.

He did say hello when we got home. He did do something small that she was going to correct (which I was okay with - she does have to ask like a parent sometimes and not just the fun grandma). he knew he was in trouble and didn't want to listen to her.

Posted 2/14/11 1:06 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

Posted by nora101004

Posted by bicosi

How long ago did you divorce?

I know with mine, they went through a a period where they would act out or get fresh and in all honesty, I truly believe it was because of the situation and not their being disrespectful...As much as I wanted to be hard on them for acting in that way, I had to handle it differently due to the situation.. I would ask your mom to sit your 3YO down and try and talk to DS and see what he's feeling and what's on his mind..

GL!Chat Icon



Divorce was 1 year ago, been living w/ mom for about 8 months. I truely don't belive its divorce related except yesterday it did happen after DS was w/ ex-h for the weekend. Usually, every other sunday's when I get him back are HORRIBLE (Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon ) bad. This was just different. He may have been tired.

He did say hello when we got home. He did do something small that she was going to correct (which I was okay with - she does have to ask like a parent sometimes and not just the fun grandma). he knew he was in trouble and didn't want to listen to her.



That's how mine are too!!

Well then if that's the case, then ignoring him IMO isn't the way to go about it.. Chat Icon

Posted 2/14/11 1:13 PM
 

MaMaTeenie
Party of 5

Member since 4/08

6489 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

We faced a very similar situation ecently. We don't live with them, but DS would refuse to say hello, good-bye etc (which we handled as his parents). Recently FIL was teasing DS and said something like get away from me. FIL proceeded to give DS the silent treatment which I witnessed when he came to p/u MIL. I FLIPPED the EF OUT!!! It is my responsability to teach my child respect and I am doing that. Do not walk into my house and give my child the silent treatment. (and use my DD to taunt DS because you are making a big fuss over her and ignoring him) DH and FIL got into a big fight over it. DH said we are teaching him and this is a phase....FIL said he is smart he knows what he is doing! So i guess he has learned everything he needs to learn about life and has nothing more to learn Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Respect is something children learn with time, but it is your responsability as the parent to teach them the way you see fit and to me giving a 3 year old the cold shoulder is inmature and NOT the way to do it.

Sorry, as you can tell this is a very sensative subject for me currently. Please feel free to FM me if you want to talk more about it.

Eta: I had also discussed with my IL's and my parents how I would like it handled (since my mom and MIL watch my kids a few days a week) which was to explain to DS how his actions make them feel and what he should have done instead.

I would also be fine with them saying I don't wAnt to play that with you until you say hello to me, but IMO its inappropriate to just give him the silent treatment like that. FIL was very mean and spiteful about it.

Message edited 2011-02-14 14:17:30.907000.

Posted 2/14/11 1:40 PM
 

MST9106
My life:)

Member since 6/06

9589 total posts

Name:

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Tilde

I don't think it is too harsh. I don't talk to my nephew until he says hello to me. He does not have to kiss me but he has to say "Hi Zia!" If he doesn't I don't answer him when he tries to get me to play with him or get him something. He is going to be 3 in April.

Now, when he asks me something, he will stop in the middle and think for a second, and then he gives me a hug and a kiss first just to be sure, in case he didn't say hello when he came in LOL



I agree with this.

first of all, I will not allow my 3-year-old to ignore his grandma. we live with my MIL and every morning when he sees her, I say "hi abuela" and he now says Hi and waves. he learns from me that we greet people when we see them.

now, if he's in a puss, and he doesn't say Hi to her, I think she can deal with it however she wants. I have no problem with her making it known that he has hurt her feelings with his silence. or his disrespect.

but I would expect that she tell him first. "I am hurt and don't want to talk to you b/c you don't want to say hi" or something along those lines. nope. no problem whatsoever from me.



I'm sorry but this made me Chat Icon ... good luck with that one! I think its a phase and your DC will grow out of it eventually. All three year olds are grumpy and mean sometimes. All you can do is repeatedly tell them that it is not nice and that it hurts others' feelings, but IMO not to talk to a three year old just to teach them a lesson in very childish and is not teaching them well.

Posted 2/14/11 1:42 PM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

Posted by MST9106

I'm sorry but this made me Chat Icon ... good luck with that one! I think its a phase and your DC will grow out of it eventually. All three year olds are grumpy and mean sometimes. All you can do is repeatedly tell them that it is not nice and that it hurts others' feelings, but IMO not to talk to a three year old just to teach them a lesson in very childish and is not teaching them well.



I am not sure why the Chat Icon
Because honestly, this is a rule with MY 3yo.
He is NOT ALLOWED to ignore someone when he is spoken to. And he knows that. I now call him the "ignorning police" last night at dinner at ILs, I hear "Hey Nonna, XX (cousin) is talking to you, its not polite to ignore"
He never gets away with out a hello hug, goodbye kiss to family. Its not acceptable.

Does this mean he always does it volunteraily? No way. but we talk, I tell him the rules and we can usually reach the understanding that he has to be polite.

And as far as not talking to them. I have done it to DS, but like the PP said, I have told him, that its very rude to ignore people, it hurts people's feelings and if he isnt nice to me and wont talk to me, then I dont feel like talking to him either.
He hates the "hurt feelings" part the most and that usually changes his tune.

Yes 3yos are sometimes mean but that doesnt mean we should allow it.

ETA: I just went and read one of your replys. i think I might have given him the "get out of jail" free card simply because he had just gotten home from the weekend with EXH. That is a hard situation and even though its been 1 year there are going to be phases that go along with it. I think I would have given him some time to settle in before getting upset with his lack of manners if I was your mom.

Message edited 2011-02-14 14:55:35.793000.

Posted 2/14/11 2:51 PM
 

MST9106
My life:)

Member since 6/06

9589 total posts

Name:

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

Posted by Kelly9904

Posted by MST9106

I'm sorry but this made me Chat Icon ... good luck with that one! I think its a phase and your DC will grow out of it eventually. All three year olds are grumpy and mean sometimes. All you can do is repeatedly tell them that it is not nice and that it hurts others' feelings, but IMO not to talk to a three year old just to teach them a lesson in very childish and is not teaching them well.



I am not sure why the Chat Icon
Because honestly, this is a rule with MY 3yo.
He is NOT ALLOWED to ignore someone when he is spoken to. And he knows that. I now call him the "ignorning police" last night at dinner at ILs, I hear "Hey Nonna, XX (cousin) is talking to you, its not polite to ignore"
He never gets away with out a hello hug, goodbye kiss to family. Its not acceptable.

Does this mean he always does it volunteraily? No way. but we talk, I tell him the rules and we can usually reach the understanding that he has to be polite.

And as far as not talking to them. I have done it to DS, but like the PP said, I have told him, that its very rude to ignore people, it hurts people's feelings and if he isnt nice to me and wont talk to me, then I dont feel like talking to him either.
He hates the "hurt feelings" part the most and that usually changes his tune.

Yes 3yos are sometimes mean but that doesnt mean we should allow it.




To each its own. It is funny to me when sometimes people say oh I'm never going to allow this or that. When the times comes you deal with it. I'm not saying that you shouldn't talk to your 3 year old and explain to them that it is not nice to act this way, that it hurts people's feelings, etc. but giving them the silent treatment??? No, they're 3 years old and that is not the proper way to teach them how to act IMO.

Posted 2/14/11 4:32 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?

Posted by MST9106




To each its own. It is funny to me when sometimes people say oh I'm never going to allow this or that. When the times comes you deal with it. I'm not saying that you shouldn't talk to your 3 year old and explain to them that it is not nice to act this way, that it hurts people's feelings, etc. but giving them the silent treatment??? No, they're 3 years old and that is not the proper way to teach them how to act IMO.

Syl, what I mean by not "allow" it is to not let it go without consequence. or chalk it up to the age. of course I cannot completely control his behavior, but I CAN let him see that what he does has consequences, even at an early age. I won't chalk it up to a phase or the age. We weren't allowed to behave that way in my family and my nieces/cousins don't do it now. they are not allowed and get into trouble if they do.

the OP, it's different b/c of the divorce issue and I don't think that is a fact of his life that can be ignored. it's a big upheaval and that probably has something to do with his behavior some of the time and I do believe "tough love" may not be the best course of action to deal with a potentially hurting 3-year-old.

but as it stands now, in MY home, with MY son...no. he will not be allowed to just ignore people, especially his grandmother. whatever happens and whatever it means when that day comes is something I will deal with then. whether it means time out or my telling me son I don't want to talk to him until he learns how to be nice...that is what it will be. but it won't be taken lightly. and it won't be chalked up to age. he's 15 months and doesn't get off that easily now. Chat Icon

Posted 2/14/11 4:43 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
connecticut teaching requirements? christy 7/26/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Teaching ESL / tutoring CaseyGirl 5/24/05 1 Families Helping Families ™
Spinoff to teaching job - how long/how do you start-go about getting into teaching? Ambersmom 5/23/05 4 Career
Teaching Interview Question Missy 5/18/05 0 Career
Teaching in Catholic schools... CaseyGirl 5/14/05 0 Career
Looking for a teaching job on Long Island...anyone know any districts beautyq115 5/10/05 19 Career