Re: Teaching 3 y/o "Respect"...too harsh?
Posted 2/14/2011 4:32:05 PM by MST9106


Posted by Kelly9904


Posted by MST9106

I'm sorry but this made me Chat Icon ... good luck with that one! I think its a phase and your DC will grow out of it eventually. All three year olds are grumpy and mean sometimes. All you can do is repeatedly tell them that it is not nice and that it hurts others' feelings, but IMO not to talk to a three year old just to teach them a lesson in very childish and is not teaching them well.



I am not sure why the Chat Icon
Because honestly, this is a rule with MY 3yo.
He is NOT ALLOWED to ignore someone when he is spoken to. And he knows that. I now call him the "ignorning police" last night at dinner at ILs, I hear "Hey Nonna, XX (cousin) is talking to you, its not polite to ignore"
He never gets away with out a hello hug, goodbye kiss to family. Its not acceptable.

Does this mean he always does it volunteraily? No way. but we talk, I tell him the rules and we can usually reach the understanding that he has to be polite.

And as far as not talking to them. I have done it to DS, but like the PP said, I have told him, that its very rude to ignore people, it hurts people's feelings and if he isnt nice to me and wont talk to me, then I dont feel like talking to him either.
He hates the "hurt feelings" part the most and that usually changes his tune.

Yes 3yos are sometimes mean but that doesnt mean we should allow it.




To each its own. It is funny to me when sometimes people say oh I'm never going to allow this or that. When the times comes you deal with it. I'm not saying that you shouldn't talk to your 3 year old and explain to them that it is not nice to act this way, that it hurts people's feelings, etc. but giving them the silent treatment??? No, they're 3 years old and that is not the proper way to teach them how to act IMO.
Print Post      Close Window