Teachers...question or anyone else

Posted By Message

MrsM-6-7-08
<3

Member since 8/06

4249 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Teachers...question or anyone else

My good friend has a son in first grade.
He is a very good kid, has no issues with violence or anything like that

My friend gets a call to pick up her son, she gets to school and the principal and teacher say they are suspending him for one day on monday because he told another kid that he was going to kill them.
He didnt say it in a "sopranos" type of way.

There was no violence, there was no physical contact. And there was no teacher present.
They were also playing a game of some sort.
There is no investigation either.
And its going on his permanent record that he threatened another students life.

My friend is devastated.


We all say that we are going to kill someone.
I say it all the time, she says and perhaps he repeated it not knowing what it means.

I also say to myself if i do something wrong, DH is going to kill me, and i have seen posts with that title on here.

There is no warning, there is no other type of punishment, just the suspension

Your thoughts?


eta: my friend is last person to say her kids are angels. She is always the first one to be on top of the situation.

Message edited 2008-09-05 21:55:49.007000.

Posted 9/5/08 9:36 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

msrsfeb
LIF Adult

Member since 2/06

1277 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

I am a suprised at how fast they reacted. I think this usually would warrant a social worker/guidance person talking to the child but I am surprised they suspended so quick. I guess with everything going on in the world they take everything sersios. I am guility of saying it often too.

Posted 9/5/08 9:40 PM
 

beautyq115
New Year!

Member since 5/05

13729 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

Is she sure there was no investigation of this? Is she sure there were no other prior incidents? Just playing devils advocate. I am a teacher and I have a lot of parents who say "not my child" and the child has behavior problems.

On the other hand in my school it would be investigated. Both sides would write statements and the principal would interview the students individually.

Also sometimes the child who was supposedly threatened has a parent who demands a major punishment and won't take no for an answer and the principal tries to appease that parent.

Those are the scenarios that I have seen.

Posted 9/5/08 9:41 PM
 

Helene718
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/06

623 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

A lot of schools are taking a zero tolerance policy with these types of situations. Unfortunately, it's just the way it is today. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon to your friend.

eta. If the teacher didn't hear it then is it just one child's word against another's?

Message edited 2008-09-05 21:45:22.723000.

Posted 9/5/08 9:44 PM
 

DaniJude
You're My Home <3

Member since 11/06

14815 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

i have heard something like this before -- my friend's son (in kindergarten) was suspended for two days because a kid shoved him on the playground and he shoved him back - literally, that was it... push/push DONE suspended.

no questions, no investigation, no "warning" -- he didn't PUNCH the kid - it was a push to the shoulder like all kids to every few minutes on a playground. who gets suspended in kindergarten?!

i dunno nowadays - yikes.

Posted 9/5/08 9:44 PM
 

chrisnjoe8108
He's 1!

Member since 8/08

5649 total posts

Name:
Chris

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

Normally they would send the child to the school social worker or the psychologist. I can't fatham a 1st grader really understanding what a suspension is.

Posted 9/5/08 9:44 PM
 

beautyq115
New Year!

Member since 5/05

13729 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

Something that may have seemed simple or maybe not as big of a deal is taken very seriously these days with all of this school violence.

I feel like there is no easy answer on the one hand it seems like it isn't a big deal and on the other hand what if something minor escalates to something major

Posted 9/5/08 9:46 PM
 

MrsM-6-7-08
<3

Member since 8/06

4249 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

Posted by chrisnjoe8108

Normally they would send the child to the school social worker or the psychologist. I can't fatham a 1st grader really understanding what a suspension is.



They did not send him to the social worker or psychologist. And he definately does not understand the suspension.


One thing that worries me, is if he says something again, where will it end.
Its not like they found a piece of paper detailing the death of a student.

Posted 9/5/08 9:55 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

Sorry but while the punishment may seem harsh I think it's time that we as a society step up to things like this and don't take them lightly. Kids shouldn't go around saying "I'm going to kill you" and have us think it's not big deal.
Parents shouldn't think it's funny that their kids drop F bombs or say curses of any kind.
I'm a pretty liberal person but when it comes to children being mean and disrespectful to adults and each other I think zero tolerance is the only way it's going to change.

Posted 9/5/08 11:12 PM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

this is where schools show some fascist tendencies...you need to protect the student body first and foremost.

the SD probably has a zero tolerance policy - I know a lot of schools adopted them after Columbine. I was teaching when Columbine happened and it was/is pretty scary.

i do agree that the social worker or school psych should be called in - I don't think suspending the child is going to be meaningful at that age.

Posted 9/5/08 11:32 PM
 

luckyinlove
I love my baby girls!

Member since 12/06

2441 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

While i do feel badly for your friend, with the state of school violence being what it is today, and the amount of school shootings, bomb threats, and the like affecting schools every day, this is actually impressive of the school to take such a proactive approach to show all of the students that this type of behavior isn't tolerated, even in the lower grades. If kids are taught this early enough, maybe they wouldn't go around making "lists" every time some kids upset them, and ultimately planning to hurt these kids. This is not so far removed from our area, either. It happens in schools on the island quite commonly (the threats, not the actual execution of the crime).

Posted 9/5/08 11:35 PM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

schools have a zero tolerance policy regarding violence. age of the child doesn't matter. it's a necessary evil.

as harsh as it seems it is necessary in this day and age. with all the school shootings going on, administrations have to take this seriously. who's to say that the child doesn't have access to his parent's gun at home and WILL bring it in?

honestly....the "permanent record" thing is a joke. i don't even think elementary school records go on to middle school, and if they do, that information won't matter at that point. it's not like they would send it to possible colleges.

Posted 9/6/08 11:02 AM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

It s ucks, but it sends the message at a young age that this type of talk won't be tolerated...

We live in an age where kindergarteners bring guns to school and shoot each other Chat Icon

Posted 9/6/08 11:37 AM
 

freshstuff
I would do me

Member since 5/08

1188 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

I agree getting punished for something that isn't supposed to be said but I find myself saying "ooh no dh is going to kill my if i buy these shoes" It's a term that most people dont' literally mean. I think the child should totally understand the consequences to what he said but a kid that has no concept that they are suspended it nuts. What is giving a child a day off from school going to teach them. Columbine was a scary time and I understand teaching kids at an early age that behavior that is scary or threatening is unaccceptable but putting something in their permanent record that will follow them as someone who gives death threats is insanity. Take away a recess for a week, let them watch a video about tolerance or whatever needs to be taught but don't label a small child as someone capable of killing. I mean it's not the sopranos. I read an article about a child a few years ago that got suspended in kindergarten for kissing another student on the cheek because it was considered sexual harassment. it's just crazy I get zero tolerance but it sounds like a Witch hunt!

Posted 9/6/08 1:31 PM
 

MrsM-6-7-08
<3

Member since 8/06

4249 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

Posted by freshstuff

I agree getting punished for something that isn't supposed to be said but I find myself saying "ooh no dh is going to kill my if i buy these shoes" It's a term that most people dont' literally mean. I think the child should totally understand the consequences to what he said but a kid that has no concept that they are suspended it nuts. What is giving a child a day off from school going to teach them. Columbine was a scary time and I understand teaching kids at an early age that behavior that is scary or threatening is unaccceptable but putting something in their permanent record that will follow them as someone who gives death threats is insanity. Take away a recess for a week, let them watch a video about tolerance or whatever needs to be taught but don't label a small child as someone capable of killing. I mean it's not the sopranos. I read an article about a child a few years ago that got suspended in kindergarten for kissing another student on the cheek because it was considered sexual harassment. it's just crazy I get zero tolerance but it sounds like a Witch hunt!



ITA

there should of been some other form of education on the issue.
I use that line all the time, as does my sister who has a small child who will be going to school soon. I hear people use it all the time, and they are not mass murderers

Posted 9/6/08 6:53 PM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

Posted by stinkysmom80

Posted by freshstuff

I agree getting punished for something that isn't supposed to be said but I find myself saying "ooh no dh is going to kill my if i buy these shoes" It's a term that most people dont' literally mean. I think the child should totally understand the consequences to what he said but a kid that has no concept that they are suspended it nuts. What is giving a child a day off from school going to teach them. Columbine was a scary time and I understand teaching kids at an early age that behavior that is scary or threatening is unaccceptable but putting something in their permanent record that will follow them as someone who gives death threats is insanity. Take away a recess for a week, let them watch a video about tolerance or whatever needs to be taught but don't label a small child as someone capable of killing. I mean it's not the sopranos. I read an article about a child a few years ago that got suspended in kindergarten for kissing another student on the cheek because it was considered sexual harassment. it's just crazy I get zero tolerance but it sounds like a Witch hunt!



ITA

there should of been some other form of education on the issue.
I use that line all the time, as does my sister who has a small child who will be going to school soon. I hear people use it all the time, and they are not mass murderers



but some people ARE and that's the problem. if your friend's child came in with daddy's gun and shot someone, the school district would be sued for not stopping it.

that's society today that we live in. it's sad.

but your friend can teach her son not to say that again, even when joking. and all adults need to change their way of speaking around children.

schools can't take chances and have zero tolerance policies. first graders HAVE shot and killed people. they are not to judge who will actually do it and who was joking.

Posted 9/6/08 7:02 PM
 

freshstuff
I would do me

Member since 5/08

1188 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

Posted by browneyedgirl

Posted by stinkysmom80

Posted by freshstuff

I agree getting punished for something that isn't supposed to be said but I find myself saying "ooh no dh is going to kill my if i buy these shoes" It's a term that most people dont' literally mean. I think the child should totally understand the consequences to what he said but a kid that has no concept that they are suspended it nuts. What is giving a child a day off from school going to teach them. Columbine was a scary time and I understand teaching kids at an early age that behavior that is scary or threatening is unaccceptable but putting something in their permanent record that will follow them as someone who gives death threats is insanity. Take away a recess for a week, let them watch a video about tolerance or whatever needs to be taught but don't label a small child as someone capable of killing. I mean it's not the sopranos. I read an article about a child a few years ago that got suspended in kindergarten for kissing another student on the cheek because it was considered sexual harassment. it's just crazy I get zero tolerance but it sounds like a Witch hunt!



ITA

there should of been some other form of education on the issue.
I use that line all the time, as does my sister who has a small child who will be going to school soon. I hear people use it all the time, and they are not mass murderers



but some people ARE and that's the problem. if your friend's child came in with daddy's gun and shot someone, the school district would be sued for not stopping it.

that's society today that we live in. it's sad.

but your friend can teach her son not to say that again, even when joking. and all adults need to change their way of speaking around children.

schools can't take chances and have zero tolerance policies. first graders HAVE shot and killed people. they are not to judge who will actually do it and who was joking.



Yes kids have brought guns to school etc. but punishing a small child by suspension isn't going to teach them anything. Schools have to do damagae control? yes, a day off from school sounds more like reward. It's basically giving them a day off when their minds aren't grasping the concept or severity of suspension. There are far better punishements a school can give but a day off? it's nuts.

Posted 9/7/08 8:37 AM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

Without witnesses or an investigation, it is hard to say what is the right thing to do but random statements like that should not and can not be tolerated.


Posted by freshstuff

Yes kids have brought guns to school etc. but punishing a small child by suspension isn't going to teach them anything. Schools have to do damagae control? yes, a day off from school sounds more like reward. It's basically giving them a day off when their minds aren't grasping the concept or severity of suspension. There are far better punishements a school can give but a day off? it's nuts.



I don't know what would be appropriate for a child this young, but if I was ever suspended for anything - suspension would be the least of my problems. The punishment from my parents would have been far worse and I am pretty sure it would not feel like a day off.



Posted 9/7/08 8:43 AM
 

janet
WITH LOVE MY ANGEL MISS YOU!!!

Member since 5/05

12823 total posts

Name:
janet

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

as a mom who was on the other side of this kind of situation, here is my thoughts

dd was in the 3rd grade and this child threatened her not only with words but the child had to restrained by 3 adults... and this kid did have problems.

he was removed from the school all together, later to return 3 years later... dd was terrified when she saw him but no other troubles have arised with child.

in the 6th grade another child just with words did threaten dd and that child did get a warning as per my asking as i do believe this child had no clue what he meant , yes even in the 6th grade.

point is there is a zero tolerance in all schools and these days kids at that age sadly know what it means to actually"kill" someone. first grade and to have it put on his record is i think a LITTLE much though and should be sat down and explained what and why. parents of the other child do have some say on how situations like this are handled, at least i have had that with my experience. i am very sorry that happened to you friend. sadly even from a first grader these days nothing is taken lightly now.

Posted 9/7/08 9:08 AM
 

juanvi
Get Out!

Member since 10/06

4463 total posts

Name:
Christina

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

This is a tough one. I don't know how i feel about it. It the school has a no tolerance policy on stuff like this...they have to suspend. Personally, on a first offense, I think it's a little rough. He probably heard sponge bob say something like this and repeated it. I hope he learns his lesson and never says something like this again, he probably won't, especially if he's a good kid. Poor thing Chat Icon

Posted 9/7/08 9:19 AM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: Teachers...question or anyone else

Posted by freshstuff


Yes kids have brought guns to school etc. but punishing a small child by suspension isn't going to teach them anything. Schools have to do damagae control? yes, a day off from school sounds more like reward. It's basically giving them a day off when their minds aren't grasping the concept or severity of suspension. There are far better punishements a school can give but a day off? it's nuts.



if it's an in school suspension, it will not be a day off.

if it's out of school, it's the PARENT's responsibility to use the day in the correct way and not make it a day off. educate the child as to why it's happening...even in first grade

Posted 9/7/08 9:28 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Question about paternity leave for Dads that are teachers? preciouslove 3/20/06 12 Pregnancy
Teachers....Question about being pregnant and NOT tenured beautyq115 3/20/06 7 Pregnancy
Teachers Question LulaBell 3/13/06 5 Families Helping Families ™
Question about insurance for those that are teachers... preciouslove 2/28/06 11 Pregnancy
Teachers- question for you Cheryl 2/26/06 2 Families Helping Families ™
Teachers! Question about CST. MissJones 2/25/06 5 Families Helping Families ™