Tax Cap

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 >>

hanna7636
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

921 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

I am all for it. I live in Elwood school district and the taxes are so high. My question is how do I afford these increases if I will not see a raise anytime in the future? Why are the teachers at my district getting raises? Check the website of your district and it breaks down the budget. My district spend most of their money on salary and benefits.


My taxes are $15000 a year on a fixer upper house.

Message edited 2011-02-17 04:25:03.027000.

Posted 2/17/11 4:23 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

bookworm
Two Little Rosebuds

Member since 8/09

2106 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

people don't pay attention to local politics and then you end up with local business people on the school board who know squat about education (and don't care, really) and are just there to promote their own self-interests. that's the voters' fault.

they get chummy with upper admin, and one hand washes the other, so they protect each other. district money is squandered on a fatty layer of directors, multiple assistant sups, generous benefits & raises that no one else in the district enjoys. the admins use their chummy relationship to keep paying themselves more and adding jobs while teachers are bullied into accepting pay freezes--something many would be willing to do (and have done) if they felt it was a shared sacrifice, but it usually isn't.

the tax cap will result in an explosion in class sizes and extra (hidden) "fees" to make up for lost tax revenue. your kid will get less attention. you'll have to wait longer for grades and phone calls. the teacher will be burnt out, which doesn't do much for creativity and innovation in the classroom.

it's just a game cuomo is playing to turn voter frustration into good will for his office. it's not a real solution because it doesn't address the real problem: corruption.

the lesson: pay attention to local politics or don't complain.

Posted 2/17/11 5:52 AM
 

mom2aidan
2 boys & 1 girl :)

Member since 11/06

1874 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by hanna7636

I am all for it. I live in Elwood school district and the taxes are so high. My question is how do I afford these increases if I will not see a raise anytime in the future? Why are the teachers at my district getting raises? Check the website of your district and it breaks down the budget. My district spend most of their money on salary and benefits.


My taxes are $15000 a year on a fixer upper house.



Teachers have a contract and until the contract expires, the district will have to live up to the terms of the contract.

Once again - PLEASE look at how many administrators you have and THEIR salaries...

Posted 2/17/11 5:53 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by hanna7636

I am all for it. I live in Elwood school district and the taxes are so high. My question is how do I afford these increases if I will not see a raise anytime in the future? Why are the teachers at my district getting raises? Check the website of your district and it breaks down the budget. My district spend most of their money on salary and benefits.


My taxes are $15000 a year on a fixer upper house.



Not sure if you went to the board meeting where they were exploring combining school districts. It was really interesting.

One point that was driven home was NOT that the teachers are getting raises nor is it the amdinistration salaries. The salaries of the current teaching staff, the extracurricular activites they'll cut, every elective they will eliminate doesn't even touch what we pay out for the retirement funds of the PAST teachers. That factor can't be altered or touched in anyway per federal law (The Taft Hartley Act).


Posted by mosh913

Posted by nrthshgrl

I agree that something has to be done to cap property taxes. Right now, school districts are looking to combine - which - from the meetings I've attended sound like the fiscally responsible thing to do.

Elwood School District will need to cut EVERY extracurricular activity, all electives, shorten the high school day & increase the elementary class sized to 30.

Northport School District is fighting LIPA's tax challenge, which if successful will be impact every resident of Northport & East Northport.

With the economy the way it is now, you can't get blood from a stone. Taxpayers are...well taxed. Laid off, underemployed taxpayers are facing some serious economic challenges & managing taxes is one of them.

I don't know what the answers are but I do know something needs to be done.



Thousands of teachers will be laid off on LI if this tax cap passes. Is anybody thinking about a rippling effect??? Like an above poster stated, how much money is it going to save you a year? Is it worth compromising your child's education? Even if you don't have children, this is our future. I'm a homeowner myself, and sure I hate LI taxes. I'm also a teacher and I'm going to lose my house if I lose my job Chat Icon



I do have children - and I am concerned about the state of their education. I'm also a homeowner - and while I'm employed I've seen our cost of living go up while most of us have had our salaries have remained stagnant, taken salary cuts or been laid off.

This isn't teacher bashing. I'm not begrudging teacher's salaries.

It's about a real problem we're facing. I do believe the solution is combing school districts. At the board meeting I went to, every resident got up & talked about how merging will destroy their community, their schools, etc. Very few actually listened to the crisis budget we are facing. The community that they cherish will be long gone as the district tries to manage their budgets.

Message edited 2011-02-17 06:27:03.420000.

Posted 2/17/11 6:26 AM
 

MegZee
My bunny

Member since 5/06

8777 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Re: Tax Cap

I hate to say it, but also look at the cost of special education.

NOT saying that these kids don't deserve it. But when I was in elementary school - we had one Special Education class for the entire school - and I went to a large elementary school (6+ classes per grade).

I read an interesting study that showed how in the 80s, 56% of special education funding was from the state, 36% locally, and 8% federal.

fast forward to 2000, 46% as coming locally (ie taxpayers), 45% from state, and 9% from federal.

10% more of the pie on our shoulders is a lot.


Posted 2/17/11 6:56 AM
 

colesmom
Brady's mom too!

Member since 5/05

1989 total posts

Name:
Lea

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Meaghan729

I hate to say it, but also look at the cost of special education.

NOT saying that these kids don't deserve it. But when I was in elementary school - we had one Special Education class for the entire school - and I went to a large elementary school (6+ classes per grade).

I read an interesting study that showed how in the 80s, 56% of special education funding was from the state, 36% locally, and 8% federal.

fast forward to 2000, 46% as coming locally (ie taxpayers), 45% from state, and 9% from federal.

10% more of the pie on our shoulders is a lot.





When we went to school there was one special ed. class because the majority of special needs students went to BOCES schools which taxpayers were still paying (more) for. We've come a long way in the special education field and realize how effective (for ALL students as well as economically) integrated/inclusion teaching is. It's well documented that for every $1 spent in special education the country's taxpayers are saving $7 down the line. (Successful students = future taxpayers and far fewer younger adults on SS and/or medicare)

Posted 2/17/11 7:06 AM
 

MegZee
My bunny

Member since 5/06

8777 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by colesmom

Posted by Meaghan729

I hate to say it, but also look at the cost of special education.

NOT saying that these kids don't deserve it. But when I was in elementary school - we had one Special Education class for the entire school - and I went to a large elementary school (6+ classes per grade).

I read an interesting study that showed how in the 80s, 56% of special education funding was from the state, 36% locally, and 8% federal.

fast forward to 2000, 46% as coming locally (ie taxpayers), 45% from state, and 9% from federal.

10% more of the pie on our shoulders is a lot.





When we went to school there was one special ed. class because the majority of special needs students went to BOCES schools which taxpayers were still paying (more) for. We've come a long way in the special education field and realize how effective (for ALL students as well as economically) integrated/inclusion teaching is. It's well documented that for every $1 spent in special education the country's taxpayers are saving $7 down the line. (Successful students = future taxpayers and far fewer younger adults on SS and/or medicare)




I see your point and agree Special Education is more effective TODAY - but it comes at a cost. A cost that the State is putting on the local taxpayer.

BOCES receives a lot of funding for the state.

Posted 2/17/11 7:10 AM
 

SlurpeeDad
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

713 total posts

Name:
SlurpeeDad

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by mom2aidan

I'm
IMPLORING you - don't vote for the tax cap. This is a democracy. They are taking away your RIGHT to vote for the school budget.

And truthfully - this is not 23 years ago. 30 kids per class is a HORRIBLE idea. Our population has changed soooo much!




I do not understand this, so please explain. How has our population changed so much that 30 kids per class is a horrible idea? My sister works in a private school and some years has 28+ kids in a class. While she said she enjoys having 20 kids, she has no problem teaching 28-30 kids.

Posted 2/17/11 7:51 AM
 

SlurpeeDad
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

713 total posts

Name:
SlurpeeDad

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by nrthshgrl


Not sure if you went to the board meeting where they were exploring combining school districts. It was really interesting.

One point that was driven home was NOT that the teachers are getting raises nor is it the amdinistration salaries. The salaries of the current teaching staff, the extracurricular activites they'll cut, every elective they will eliminate doesn't even touch what we pay out for the retirement funds of the PAST teachers. That factor can't be altered or touched in anyway per federal law (The Taft Hartley Act).




I understand that the retirement of PAST teachers can't be changed, but lets make sure that current teachers don't get that same retirement luxury. I, like the majority of the population, have to fund my own retirement, with a minimal match from my employer. I know I come across as slamming teachers, and I apologize for that. I just really feel it is time for a reality check when it comes to finances that come from public money.

Posted 2/17/11 8:11 AM
 

JDubs
different, not less

Member since 7/09

13160 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

I don't know but something needs to be done, we are already paying 1k a month alone in taxes (and i just have a 68x100 property), how much further up can they go? no wonder why everyone is relocating!

Posted 2/17/11 9:18 AM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Tax Cap

I really have to read it really to base my opinion on yet and hopefully at my union meeting today we might get one side of it.

I think the only people against educational reform are those who work in education. Because usually you get excited of what your union rep tells you. Honestly take what your union rep says with a grain of salt and make sure your opinion is based on fact. This is why I am not sure of my opinion yet since all i have heard is from my union which is very one sided.

What should be reformed? We need to setup outside entities to oversea each SD budget and really look deep into it. Is there any forensic accountants taking a peek at our local budgets?

Teach reform - sorry people but seniority needs to be changed. Too many young teachers out there with just as much passion/talent and ability then someone sitting in a class for 20+ years to be cut. I don't know a solution but there has to be.

Benefits - I am a state employee and i pay into all my benefits. So should teachers and cops (and my family is filled with cops.)

Super, VPs, etc - higher ups need to be consolidated - jobs overlap WAY to much and there needs to be someway to solve this.

Posted 2/17/11 9:27 AM
 

juanvi
Get Out!

Member since 10/06

4463 total posts

Name:
Christina

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by SlurpeeDad

Posted by juanvi

Yeah but when times are good those in the private sector get sick raises or promotions or bonuses. Its all relative. Its not the teachers that suck up all the tax $ its administration. This tax crap I mean cap will do noth ing to fix any sort of problem we have to get out there as community. Go to board of ed meetings. Get involved. Quit complaining about the teachers and uncover the truth.



Not true at all. I am sure there are some places that get great raises, but just because the economy does well doesn't mean private sector jobs get "sick raises." If I am wrong and that's the case, I want one of those jobs!



Perhaps not all get "sick raises" but when things were going well with the economy people were making good, sometimes very good money. If not, they were hopefully making a living. I don't know what you do so I can't comment on your profession.

I read somthing you had posted about your sister teaching 25+ kids with "no problem". I've had that many students in my HS classes since I've started over 10 years ago. I agree, I can teach with "no problem" but I would think with the taxes Long islanders are currently paying, myself included, classes shouldn't be so packed. Why do colleges proclaim to have small class size in their commercials? Because it's better. I would talk with your sis about her experience with teaching large class sizes, but I think unless you have stood in front of 30 teens...elementary kids...whatever you really have no idea how difficult it is. It's not for everyone..I guess that's why not everyone could be a teacher.

Tax cap will no nothing to fix the problem. Go to your school board meetings, get involved...we need to fix things by being in the know.

Posted 2/17/11 9:52 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

I can't see pointing to special education as the huge part of the increase in education costs. As someone mentioned previously, people were in BOCES. We've come too far to send special education needs back to the teaching to the lowest denominator and I believe it was a matter of shifting dollars from institutions to learning centers to the school districts. I would bet if you intervene at a young age for special needs, long term costs of to taxpayers is significantly less.

Posted by juanvi
I would talk with your sis about her experience with teaching large class sizes, but I think unless you have stood in front of 30 teens...elementary kids...whatever you really have no idea how difficult it is..



There is a huge difference between a 30 student class size of elementary students versus teens.If the sister taught high school or even junior high, those numbers are with in my expectations. That wouldn't be ok for me for elementary schools.

Posted 2/17/11 10:02 AM
 

MegZee
My bunny

Member since 5/06

8777 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by nrthshgrl

I can't see pointing to special education as the huge part of the increase in education costs. As someone mentioned previously, people were in BOCES. We've come too far to send special education needs back to the teaching to the lowest denominator and I believe it was a matter of shifting dollars from institutions to learning centers to the school districts. I would bet if you intervene at a young age for special needs, long term costs of to taxpayers is significantly less.




I pulled figures directly from a study. I actually read multiple studies.

the localities are funding a larger piece of the pie than the state.

I am in agreement that it is needed- but is a part of the increase.

BOCES is funded by the state mostly. State funding has dropped considerably to local districts.

the long term cost is less, but not in the terms of property taxes, which is what we are discussing.

Posted 2/17/11 10:12 AM
 

Jenhos
Maeve

Member since 6/05

3273 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

I work in the private sector and I do make good money (non of which comes from the tax payer). My raises and bonuses are paid for performance. Over the last few years no matter how well I performed bonuses and raises are minimal if any. I pay into my benefits, I will fund my own retriement. I have no pension because the BIG company I work for did away with that to save money. My cost of living is increasing waaay faster than my salary these days.

I don't have a contract that ensures I get a x% raise every year. I don't get tenure that basically ensures I won't ever get laid off.

Maybe it is time for teachers as well as super int. and administrators get paid how every private sector gets paid. You negotiate a salary when you get hired, you get increases based on performance and do away with pensions and have them fund their own retirements.

Every industry is taking a hit and I think at this point everyone has to share in the pain.

I pay more than 13k in taxes and my kids go to Catholic school. Should I get a break because I am not even using the schools in my town?

My dad is retired and all his kids are way past school age yet he still pays a crazy amount in taxes. How can we expect seniors on a fixed income to keep up?

I don't think this is just a teacher issue. All the schools need to investigate where they can cut costs. But the teachers have to expect that they need to do more with less like everyone else (at least for awhile)

Posted 2/17/11 10:23 AM
 

juanvi
Get Out!

Member since 10/06

4463 total posts

Name:
Christina

Re: Tax Cap

There is a huge difference between a 30 student class size of elementary students versus teens.If the sister taught high school or even junior high, those numbers are with in my expectations. That wouldn't be ok for me for elementary schools.


Agreed!

As for Special Education, something also has to be done. No child left behind from a HS perspective makes no sense. While I agree that special ed is much better than it was years ago, forcing a student to pass a now" watered down" regent exam is not going to help. Like I said, I am talking on a HS level. The Special Ed department has more than doubled. Schools can't do much about it because it's law. I don't think it's fair for those who don't have children that require these services. There is no law protecting what they get so with a tax cap, if there is just no money because of special education that needs to be funded, they will be hit with more electives, EC avctivities cuts. And of course, class size.

Posted 2/17/11 10:41 AM
 

mommy2bella
Where does time go?

Member since 12/05

9747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Tax Cap

I live in a small town on the South Shore of Nassau. So small that Bella's graduating class will most likely be UNDER 100. The High School is 7th through 12th grade and has something like 450 kids. The Superintendent makes 250k, the principal 175, the kindergarten teachers each make 150k....we have over 100 teachers and other admin making well over 100 thousand dollars. Many, many people have been there over 25 years. Which is great, but it breaks the back of taxpayers....there HAS to be a CAP somewhere....

I go to every board meeting. The scare tactics used are abhorrent. They complain about the state, they complain about the governor. And in part they are right....but how to fix it??

Bella's class is maxed out at 25 (and I mean spatially and with several inclusion kids) so I would say with the EXTRA attention needed for inclusion children, it is just like a class of 30. Adding even one more kid would be detrimental...

On the other end, my sister is a teacher, a damn fantastic one. Do I feel like she needs to suffer, no! Do I feel it's fair that two friends are bracing to be laid off because they were hired in the last five years? no!

I just don't know anymore. I get letters in the mail that Nassau Count assesses my house at 45k less than what I bought it for, but my taxes will stay the same?? Why? Because have a terrible system reliant on figures that just don't make sense.

It all needs to be redone, but who will ever be in the best interest of parties all around...no one.

It will remain teachers vs homeowners vs administration vs state vs children....
Children always lose...

Posted 2/17/11 11:15 AM
 

jasmine
little boy blue <3

Member since 10/10

1475 total posts

Name:
x

Re: Tax Cap

I didnt realize kindergarten teachers make $150k! Chat Icon I'm not in a position to judge whether they deserve it but with the hours and vacation schedule I definitely picked the wrong career Chat Icon

Posted 2/17/11 11:19 AM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Tax Cap

Posted by Jenhos

I work in the private sector and I do make good money (non of which comes from the tax payer). My raises and bonuses are paid for performance. Over the last few years no matter how well I performed bonuses and raises are minimal if any. I pay into my benefits, I will fund my own retriement. I have no pension because the BIG company I work for did away with that to save money. My cost of living is increasing waaay faster than my salary these days.

I don't have a contract that ensures I get a x% raise every year. I don't get tenure that basically ensures I won't ever get laid off.

Maybe it is time for teachers as well as super int. and administrators get paid how every private sector gets paid. You negotiate a salary when you get hired, you get increases based on performance and do away with pensions and have them fund their own retirements.

Every industry is taking a hit and I think at this point everyone has to share in the pain.

I pay more than 13k in taxes and my kids go to Catholic school. Should I get a break because I am not even using the schools in my town?

My dad is retired and all his kids are way past school age yet he still pays a crazy amount in taxes. How can we expect seniors on a fixed income to keep up?

I don't think this is just a teacher issue. All the schools need to investigate where they can cut costs. But the teachers have to expect that they need to do more with less like everyone else (at least for awhile)



totally agree. Also, if I went back to school for an advanced degree my employer may or may not see is as an asset and I may or may not get a raise because of it. I am expected to keep up with my industry, know the players and I get reviewed. My 5 star review year over year has gotten me 5% raises and some years nada. I don't get bonused, I pay over $350 a month for my benefits and that is subsidized by my employer. I have no pension and will have to fund my retirement entirely myself.

Posted 2/17/11 11:29 AM
 

mommy2bella
Where does time go?

Member since 12/05

9747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Tax Cap

I misspoke, Bella's teacher makes 122,000 dollars a year. The principal makes 150,000 and the superintendent makes She makes 220,000 dollars a year and received a 40,000 RAISE since 2008. Not bad to get a 20% raise in these times. In fact, they have all received raises since 2008 of close to 10 percent (less for the teacher)

I have heard the superintendent OVER AND OVER again tell people at board meetings how TOUGH it is and that EVERYONE needs to sacrifice...but it's hard when people don't practice what they preach.

Again, my sister BUSTS her tail working as a teacher and earns every penny of her salary. I feel there needs to be an overhaul haul and maybe the pain will be spread around, but admins REALLY need to step up.

Message edited 2011-02-17 11:48:12.347000.

Posted 2/17/11 11:47 AM
 

Little-J-Mommy
I'm a Big Brother

Member since 5/06

8041 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Tax Cap

Don't even get me started on the Asst. Superintendent of Blah Blah Blah. Every district on LI has like 6 of them!!! SIX? Not necessary. Each one of those salaries are a good 4-5 entry level teachers if not more. Just sayingChat Icon

Posted 2/17/11 11:52 AM
 

hanna7636
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

921 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

My SIL who is a teacher on Long Island is all for voting yes for school budget (she makes $130 a year). Besides this being an issue I am against the teachers in my school district telling the kids if their parents do not vote yes to the budget they will have nothing. My SIL tells me this is what the teachers are telling her kids (who come home crying from school).

This is from Elwood website

Superintendent's Salary: $256,130

I graduated from Harborfields and in my opinion being from such a small school had disadvantages (no diversity, choices of classes).

Posted 2/17/11 11:53 AM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

Every year we are asked to pay more and more to educate the population yet it appears the quality of the students is continually on the decline.

What percent of students need remedial classes as they start college? That is unacceptable.

Sorry but I don't think throwing money at the problem is the solution.

Time for districts to do more with less like the rest of us have been the past few years.

Posted 2/17/11 11:56 AM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Tax Cap

LI taxes are one of the HIGHEST in the country. LI teachers salaries are one of the HIGHEST in the country. I dont see every student on LI moving on to a ivy league school. I dont think that our kids education is that much better than any other state.

And not for nothing, correct me if I'm wrong, but the US places maybe 17th in the WORLD for education. It's embarrassing!


ETA: I want to add that there is a lot more going into the tax problems on LI. The administrators salaries in the districts. The pensions we are paying for. The Nassau & Suffolk cops salaries. Frivolous spending in local gov't offices.

I dont want to bash teachers. I have family members and good friends that are teachers. I know they work hard. I know they put alot into their education to get where they are.


Message edited 2011-02-17 12:13:03.903000.

Posted 2/17/11 12:02 PM
 

DMT
LIF Adult

Member since 6/05

2277 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax Cap

I just think we need to do more with our money period. There is so much waste. I have seen it first hand.

Supply rooms full of materials that sit year after year and never get used.....heat on so high that people have to open their windows....food being taken home by cafeteria workers because so much was ordered that it will all go bad.....waste waste and more waste

I have no problem paying higher taxes to give kids a great education...I have no issue paying teachers the salary they deserve....I have no problem paying more taxes to make sure kids who need more help get the help they need....the only thing I have an isuse with is wasting what money has already bought...that pisses me off to no end

Message edited 2011-02-17 12:10:37.707000.

Posted 2/17/11 12:09 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Capital Gains Tax Aliking 9/14/05 12 Home
Tax Free Week! christy 9/1/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
tax free??? momAGAIN 8/29/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
tax free week? CarrieAnn 8/28/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Tax question checka 8/26/05 3 Home
tax question Redhead 6/17/05 6 Home