Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Posted By Message

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Do you think that it makes sense for them to promote breast feeding in low-income/poverty stricken areas? Just curious.

Posted 7/31/07 8:00 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

positivetests
LIF Toddler

Member since 6/06

402 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Um, not really. My Medela PIS was $350, and any lactation consultant I called was in the neighborhood of about $200/hour. All the breastmilk storage bags, pump accessories, supplies, etc. were additional hundreds and hundreds of dollars. DAILY I questioned myself, how is this shizz any cheaper than formula!? It is a new industry, just like anything else.

ETA - Can't forget my $36 nursing bras!

Message edited 2007-07-31 20:05:15.383000.

Posted 7/31/07 8:02 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Posted by positivetests

Um, not really. My Medela PIS was $350, and any lactation consultant I called was in the neighborhood of about $200/hour. All the breastmilk storage bags, pump accessories, supplies, etc. were additional hundreds and hundreds of dollars. DAILY I questioned myself, how is this shizz any cheaper than formula!? It is a new industry, just like anything else.

ETA - Can't forget my $36 nursing bras!



And don't forget the breastpads, boob cream.

And not pumping is not an option if you go back to work.

Posted 7/31/07 8:14 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Let me state that I do NOT think your income status should affect whether or not you breastfeed, but the other thread made me think about something an ignorant person said to me recently about how she can't stand that the government provides formula when women could just breastfeed. Um, hello, people have to work and not everyone can afford a pump, and just because you have a low income doesn't mean you shouldn't have a choice about how to feed your childChat Icon Ignorance. Can't get away from itChat Icon

Message edited 2007-07-31 20:17:52.500000.

Posted 7/31/07 8:17 PM
 

PatsBrat
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

2326 total posts

Name:
Ms. Brat

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

This is interesting. I actually always wondered about the "hidden" costs of breastfeeding because it seemed too good to be true ("free' nutrition for a baby, that is). I didn't realize all the little things that were necessary to make nursing successful.

Posted 7/31/07 8:22 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

I do believe that without WIC a whole lot more people would give it a shotChat Icon

Leo's family finds it appauling that I am still BFing-however, without WIC they would be f'ed.

I gave birth in a pro-breastfeeding hospital. All help was given free of charge, all hours of the night. It would be great if everyone could get that kind of help.

I believe it's also about education. I am not from a breastfeeding family, without the internet and books...I would have been lost. The fact that it reduces breast cancer is information that all women should be exposed to.

Posted 7/31/07 8:34 PM
 

leighla
Support Cancer Research

Member since 5/05

16353 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Not that I agree with the ban at all but...

Breastfeeding does cost nothing.

Technically you don't *need* all those things to breasfeed.

Regular bras will work fine.

Not everyone needs to pump - you can express by hand in a pinch.

Nipple cream and breast pads are a luxury.

Think of the third world countries where women exclusively breastfeed. They don't have all those things.

We've just gotten used to them.

Posted 7/31/07 8:58 PM
 

positivetests
LIF Toddler

Member since 6/06

402 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Posted by leighla

Nipple cream and breast pads are a luxury.

Think of the third world countries where women exclusively breastfeed. They don't have all those things.

We've just gotten used to them.



Women in 3rd world countries don't have office jobs that they can't leak milk through their shirts (hence the "luxurious" breast pads) and need to pump FAST and efficiently with a pump bc they need to get back to work.

Message edited 2007-07-31 22:16:38.957000.

Posted 7/31/07 10:16 PM
 

JessieQ
Rest in Peace baby Rogan

Member since 6/07

1122 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Posted by positivetests

Posted by leighla

Nipple cream and breast pads are a luxury.

Think of the third world countries where women exclusively breastfeed. They don't have all those things.

We've just gotten used to them.



Women in 3rd world countries don't have office jobs that they can't leak milk through their shirts (hence the "luxurious" breast pads) and need to pump FAST and efficiently with a pump bc they need to get back to work.



Exactly, it's a different society today, if a low-income woman needs to go back to work chances are 1. she can't afford a breast pump 2. her job may not provide a place or the time for her to pump 3. as others have said she probably doesn't have access to resources (such as this website, other sites, books, lactation consultants, etc) with advice if she has problems breastfeeding (which everyone who has read this board should know is very common).

As far as the original topic, I think instead of not giving away FREE formula, they should spend more time educating the women there on breastfeeding: train the nurses to support breastfeeding, and provide more lactation consultants to the new mothers.

Posted 7/31/07 11:32 PM
 

pharmcat2000
Mom of 2 + 1

Member since 10/05

7395 total posts

Name:
Catherine

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

My sister decided to BF both of her children mainly because of $$. The only thing she spent money on was breast pads. She hand pumped when she had to, and she was given a hand-me-down electric pump. She went back to work as a nurse and did not have to spend hundreds of dollars to do so.

I think women who are educated and/or wealthy are more likely to BF their children, just as they are more likely to get medical care when needed.

Posted 7/31/07 11:43 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Posted by leighla

Not that I agree with the ban at all but...

Breastfeeding does cost nothing.

Technically you don't *need* all those things to breasfeed.

Regular bras will work fine.

Not everyone needs to pump - you can express by hand in a pinch.

Nipple cream and breast pads are a luxury.

Think of the third world countries where women exclusively breastfeed. They don't have all those things.

We've just gotten used to them.



I agree

We live in a society where we think we need all these extras....some do, but some are marketing ploys ( sudden resurgence of $$$$ breast/nipple creams)


Bottom line is really...is breast feeding in itself free? ...yes its free.

YOUR OWN circumstances may lead to YOU needing to pay for something to assist you, but that doesnt mean breast feeding is not Free nutrition....

Posted 8/1/07 12:07 AM
 

annie
This is how I play basketball!

Member since 6/05

1980 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

My answer to the original post:
absolutely! I think many women do not choose to BF because of a lack of knowledge/education/experience regarding it. So many of us were formula fed and therefore do not have family support with BF. Training nurses, providing support like LCs and free training classes, and generally encouraging BF in low-income areas, and in all areas, is a good thing. However, revoking the free formula in hospitals is absurd. Encouraging one form of feeding does not mean you need to restrict the other.

Posted 8/1/07 12:39 AM
 

DandN
Twins are here!

Member since 3/06

3597 total posts

Name:
Deirdre

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

yes - I think promoting breast feeding is great. . . but above all people should decide for themselves what they want to do.

Posted 8/1/07 12:53 AM
 

Eleanor
LIF Adult

Member since 2/06

2223 total posts

Name:
Ellie

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Posted by positivetests

Um, not really. My Medela PIS was $350, and any lactation consultant I called was in the neighborhood of about $200/hour. All the breastmilk storage bags, pump accessories, supplies, etc. were additional hundreds and hundreds of dollars. DAILY I questioned myself, how is this shizz any cheaper than formula!? It is a new industry, just like anything else.

ETA - Can't forget my $36 nursing bras!



I hear you about the money spent, but it was one of my big motivaters in BFing for the entire year.


I thought of it this way. $100/month in formula + $1200 the first year.

My pump was $300 + $200 for freezerbags and pads + $100 extras = $600 half the cost

Now that I have the pump, it will be even more cost effective for #2 and if there is a #3

Posted 8/1/07 8:41 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Posted by positivetests

Posted by leighla

Nipple cream and breast pads are a luxury.

Think of the third world countries where women exclusively breastfeed. They don't have all those things.

We've just gotten used to them.



Women in 3rd world countries don't have office jobs that they can't leak milk through their shirts (hence the "luxurious" breast pads) and need to pump FAST and efficiently with a pump bc they need to get back to work.



ITA. No offence here but I can't wrap my baby to my boob and mill corn on a stone.

I can't express milk by hand for 10 hours while DS will be in daycare. This is really for a quick fix.

I also CANNOT not wear breast pads. I leak way too much. It's like comparing to the time when women used a "rag" before pads and tampons existed. Yes, those could be called luxury too!

Message edited 2007-08-01 09:19:39.987000.

Posted 8/1/07 9:18 AM
 

leighla
Support Cancer Research

Member since 5/05

16353 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Posted by positivetests

Posted by leighla

Nipple cream and breast pads are a luxury.

Think of the third world countries where women exclusively breastfeed. They don't have all those things.

We've just gotten used to them.



Women in 3rd world countries don't have office jobs that they can't leak milk through their shirts (hence the "luxurious" breast pads) and need to pump FAST and efficiently with a pump bc they need to get back to work.



Listen, I don't want to argue, I was playing devils advocate.

But I still stand by my statement. A woman who cannot afford breast pads can tuck tissues in her bra or something else. I don't think breast pads are high on the list of necessities.

And if we're talking about low-income welfare moms most of them don't have office jobs, or jobs at all for that matter.

My point was that it doesn't have to cost as much as we make it cost. When you have very little you make due without those things.

Posted 8/1/07 1:19 PM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Posted by JessieQ

2. her job may not provide a place or the time for her to pump

It is illegal in NYS to deny a woman a clean, private, non-bathroom facility in which to pump. just as an FYIChat Icon

And I think that income should have nothing to do with it. Especially where the government is concerned. I think that it is a very weird form of government control that just is not appropriate.

Posted 8/1/07 2:03 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Posted by MsMBV

It is illegal in NYS to deny a woman a clean, private, non-bathroom facility in which to pump. just as an FYIChat Icon



I would like to know how this is enforced. Really!

My company (who is one of the top employer of LI) does not have ANY room that is private. I know because even the HR people use their own conference rooms for BF (all our conference rooms have windows and no locks!).

Posted 8/1/07 2:11 PM
 

Dragonfly75
I love Hypnobabies

Member since 3/06

2333 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

I think it's very important to promote breastfeeding to low-income mothers. The costs associated with breastfeeding are a fraction of the cost of formula. Also, there are the health benefits. Since breastfed infants are generally healthier then formula fed infants breastfeeding mothers usually save money on healthcare costs, as well.

That being said, I do think insurance companies/gov't assistance should cover the cost of a good pump for mothers who have to return to work, so she will be able to continue to breastfeed.

Posted 8/1/07 3:30 PM
 

JessieQ
Rest in Peace baby Rogan

Member since 6/07

1122 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Posted by MsMBV

Posted by JessieQ

2. her job may not provide a place or the time for her to pump



It is illegal in NYS to deny a woman a clean, private, non-bathroom facility in which to pump. just as an FYIChat Icon




I know there is a law about breastfeeding, but I don't think there is one yet about providing a place and time to pump (I could be wrong though- as of 2006 according to the article below they were working on a law but it wasn't passed yet). However, I know in practice this is not the case in all or even most jobs.

Here's a NYT article from last year on the subject.

Here is an excerpt:
__________________
“They’re scared to death to even talk to their employers,” Dr. Barbara L. Philipp, an associate professor of pediatrics at Boston University School of Medicine, said of the housekeepers and fast-food servers whose children she treats. They may fear the kind of harassment that Laura Walker, a former server at a Red Lobster restaurant in Evansville, Ind., said she faced.

According to the complaint Ms. Walker filed with the Equal Opportunity Employment Commission, the restaurant ignored a note she brought from her nurse explaining her need to pump. The managers cut her hours, assigned her to the worst tables and ridiculed her — for instance, jiggling the restaurant’s milk containers and joking that they were for her. Eventually Ms. Walker’s milk ducts clogged, landing her in the hospital with mastitis.
__________________


Posted 8/1/07 4:10 PM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to formula "ban"....

Hmmmm I'll get the info from my HR rep. She is the one who told me about it.....

Posted 8/1/07 7:01 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spinoff to powdered formula... MrsJ 3/23/06 13 Parenting
Coupons for Formula Briannasmommy 3/23/06 2 Parenting
Powder Formula vs. RTF? preciouslove 3/23/06 25 Parenting
Similac Formula Gift in Mail Mommyof2 3/19/06 2 Parenting
formula up for grabs momAGAIN 3/19/06 0 Parenting
Formula Question Ali1 3/19/06 9 Parenting