Spinoff to boy stabbed at D&B

Posted By Message

whatalife24
LIF Infant

Member since 5/10

151 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Spinoff to boy stabbed at D&B

So this story got me thinking. First, that I can't believe the restraint that the boy's father had in not killing that man. Then, I thought about if that were my child. I talked about it with my dh, who thinks that he would honestly would have killed the guy.
So, for anyone that might know the answer.....my question is this:
In this situation, if the father had seen the man stabbing his son and had run over and snapped the guy's neck and killed him, would the father be charged with anything or would that be considered some sort of self defense?

Posted 10/10/10 9:59 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Spinoff to boy stabbed at D&B

I'm thinking self defense would likely be a good defense.

Heres' my take though.....if someone physically harmed my child, I probably WOULDN'T be going after and attacking the assailant immediately after. I'd be tending to my child. In this circumstance especially. I'll bet that kid's poor parents thought he might die right there. I couldn't imagine wasting precious moments with my badly injured baby by attacking some POS.

Posted 10/10/10 10:04 AM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to boy stabbed at D&B

I'm sure if the guys neck was snapped they would have to charge the father with something. There is not a doubt in my mind that my DH wouldn't have snapped the guys neck because that would be too quick. He would beat the guy to death.

I think even though everyone's first reaction is "I would kill the guy", in actuality I think it is a far less number that would. I think the shock alone of seeing that would delay your reaction.

ETA: I also agree with your child's well being being your first thought.

Message edited 2010-10-10 10:10:31.917000.

Posted 10/10/10 10:05 AM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: Spinoff to boy stabbed at D&B

I agree with the PP. First thing I'd do is get help for and stay with my child.

Posted 10/10/10 10:07 AM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Spinoff to boy stabbed at D&B

First instinct - protect my child.

Odds are if a parent went after the assailant, I'm willing to bet a charge would not be self-defense, but temporary insanity and he would walk..

Message edited 2010-10-10 10:21:03.477000.

Posted 10/10/10 10:20 AM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Spinoff to boy stabbed at D&B

DH and I were having the same convo and he too says he wouldve killed him right there.

I would hope no jury would find him guilty of anything....how could they.

Posted 10/10/10 10:27 AM
 

Momma2Be
Mommy of an angel

Member since 10/09

5911 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Spinoff to boy stabbed at D&B

Posted by eddiesmommy

DH and I were having the same convo and he too says he wouldve killed him right there.

I would hope no jury would find him guilty of anything....how could they.



Same here. I know if I were on a jury for a case like this, there would be no way I'd be able to find the parent guilty.

Posted 10/10/10 10:39 AM
 

LizD
LIF Adolescent

Member since 4/06

763 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Spinoff to boy stabbed at D&B

My first instint would be to tend to my child. My second would be to kill the person who hurt my baby.

I would never convict a parent in that situation if I were on a jury for a case like that

Posted 10/10/10 1:09 PM
 

Kate
*****

Member since 5/05

7557 total posts

Name:
Kate

Re: Spinoff to boy stabbed at D&B

If the father killed him while the man was still attacking the child, I would consider it self-defense. If he chases the guy down and then beats him to death, that is not self-defense. More like justifiable homicide maybe.

Posted 10/10/10 2:01 PM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Spinoff to boy stabbed at D&B

i dont know if that would be considered self defense b/c he wasnt defending himself, you know? i understand he would be defending his son, but I would think he murdered the assailant he may be charged with a lesser degree of murder. would he be convicted, who knows? but i would think the justice system wouldnt let him off without any charges.

Posted 10/10/10 4:58 PM
 

8ternity
<3

Member since 11/08

10586 total posts

Name:
Formally NYPD-Wife

Re: Spinoff to boy stabbed at D&B

Its all on the Grand Jury to say if the father did a criminal act. If they think he did then a warrant goes out for his arrest.

We wear talking about this yesterday too!

Posted 10/10/10 7:39 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Spinoff to boy stabbed at D&B

it's heat of the moment... not quite self-defense... i'm forgetting the technical name for it at the moment, but there's a term for it.

eta - a crime of passion. it's not a complete defense but rather a "mitigation" defense. like for ex. it could reduce a murder charge to a manslaughter conviction.

i honestly don't remember if this applies in ny, or whether it would apply to the scenario presented by the OP.

anyway im rambling now lol

Message edited 2010-10-10 20:05:49.030000.

Posted 10/10/10 7:59 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
LI boy stabbed at Westbury D & B! Porrruss 10/9/10 71 Families Helping Families ™
my little boy Myrockette 7/17/05 2 Pets
Spinoff from jennygs' announcement post....boy vs girl PG symptoms btrflygrl 7/7/05 3 Pregnancy
New pics of my baby boy GOLEM! bluegrl24NY 6/22/05 14 Pets
Boy names jcndd 6/21/05 10 Pregnancy
My little boy finally made his debut! steph4777 6/4/05 51 Pregnancy