Spinoff to BOTB's post about vaccinations...

Posted By Message

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Spinoff to BOTB's post about vaccinations...

BOTB and others in her post seemed to feel that there was some choice in the vaccination issue. This surprised me and I am very curious. If you live in New York and ARE vaccinating your child but have chosen to either not give certain shots or to delay certain shots past the age which DC goes to preschool how have you gotten around the school requirements? From what I have read there are only two exemptions neither of which I think would apply in this case (unless it is a second shot in a series). So how do you do it IF you have done it or know someone who has?

I am really only looking for an honest answer to this question...please fm if you want instead - the topic of pro-anti-vaccine has already been debated on a number of threads so lets not do it again here!

Thanks so much! Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-02-26 15:13:11.057000.

Posted 2/26/09 3:08 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

mia818
LIF Adult

Member since 12/07

2197 total posts

Name:
Mia

Re: Spinoff to BOTB's post about vaccinations...

my friend does not believe in vaccinations. when she registered her daughter for preschool, the nurse kept calling her about vaccinating her. so far she caved in and just gave her daughter the measle shot. i haven't seen her to ask about any others. i do hope she gets the rest....my ds will be attending kindergarten with her daughter this coming september

Posted 2/26/09 3:47 PM
 

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Spinoff to BOTB's post about vaccinations...

In NY you can't pick and choose which vaccines to give. To register your DC you'd have to be up to date.

One common misconception is that if you have vaccinated in the past you can't get an exemption. This is not true. If you have vaccinated your DC and stopped all vaccinations then you can still get one.

Posted 2/26/09 4:01 PM
 

wannabemom
look who's freshly baked!

Member since 12/07

7364 total posts

Name:
aka marriedinportjeff

Re: Spinoff to BOTB's post about vaccinations...

well, I'm delaying/spreading out DS's shots, but he WILL be completely caught-up prior to pre-school. He will receive almost all that are on the vaccination schedule (the only omission will be the rotavirus? (I think that's the one?) shot becuase it's new and my pediatrician doesn't trust that vaccine.... but it isn't required for school)

I believe a good portion of people who delay/spread have similar intentions to me... to be caught-up prior to school.

Posted 2/26/09 4:08 PM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to BOTB's post about vaccinations...

Posted by wannabemom

well, I'm delaying/spreading out DS's shots, but he WILL be completely caught-up prior to pre-school. He will receive almost all that are on the vaccination schedule (the only omission will be the rotavirus? (I think that's the one?) shot becuase it's new and my pediatrician doesn't trust that vaccine.... but it isn't required for school)

I believe a good portion of people who delay/spread have similar intentions to me... to be caught-up prior to school.



This is my plan. The only thing I am wondering about is the Chicken pox. I really would much rather DS get that on his own and have lifelong immunity than to have to keep getting shots his whole life - same thing if I eventually have a DD - i don't want her to have to worry ever when she is pg b/c the immunity from the shot is not 100%.....This is the one and only shot where I can truly say if there is a way around it i would take it.

Posted 2/26/09 5:09 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Spinoff to BOTB's post about vaccinations...

Posted by itsbabytime

Posted by wannabemom

well, I'm delaying/spreading out DS's shots, but he WILL be completely caught-up prior to pre-school. He will receive almost all that are on the vaccination schedule (the only omission will be the rotavirus? (I think that's the one?) shot becuase it's new and my pediatrician doesn't trust that vaccine.... but it isn't required for school)

I believe a good portion of people who delay/spread have similar intentions to me... to be caught-up prior to school.



This is my plan. The only thing I am wondering about is the Chicken pox. I really would much rather DS get that on his own and have lifelong immunity than to have to keep getting shots his whole life - same thing if I eventually have a DD - i don't want her to have to worry ever when she is pg b/c the immunity from the shot is not 100%.....This is the one and only shot where I can truly say if there is a way around it i would take it.



I believe that the child has to be immune to chicken pox before entering school. So, either the vaccination or actually having had chicken pox will do. There is a test for immunity to chicken pox. I don't know whether they will have your child take the test if you say that their immunity is from having had the virus and not the vaccine. Maybe the medical records will do. A friend of mine who had chicken pox, the actual virus and not the shot, later found out that she was not immune to another case of it. Another choice might be to vaccinate and then test for immunity later on. I guess I just feel that the vaccination is not harmful and I would rather give that than have my child go through having the virus then have to go through testing to prove to the school that he had it (if they ask for such testing). We have already given DS the chicken pox vaccine. We only gave that shot and no others on the day he had it.

Posted 2/26/09 5:20 PM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to BOTB's post about vaccinations...

Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

I believe that the child has to be immune to chicken pox before entering school. So, either the vaccination or actually having had chicken pox will do. There is a test for immunity to chicken pox. I don't know whether they will have your child take the test if you say that their immunity is from having had the virus and not the vaccine. Maybe the medical records will do. A friend of mine who had chicken pox, the actual virus and not the shot, later found out that she was not immune to another case of it. Another choice might be to vaccinate and then test for immunity later on. I guess I just feel that the vaccination is not harmful and I would rather give that than have my child go through having the virus then have to go through testing to prove to the school that he had it (if they ask for such testing). We have already given DS the chicken pox vaccine. We only gave that shot and no others on the day he had it.



I don't think you can ever really say that the vaccination is not harmful. For starters just look at the vaccine insert to see all the things that are being injected into DC. And, beyond that, although rare both the manufacturer and the ped have said there are some very serious potential reactions to this shot - rare, but, possible.

You have to show proof either way so either the ped says he has the shot or he says he had the cp - not sure why one would be more difficult than the other. And, your child will have to have more than one CP vaccine (at least three I think) so I don't see how having the CP and having a blood test (which at some point the child will have anyway) - if necessary is that much more burdensome.

Anyway, all that said - I am just playing devil's advocate here. I honestly really cannot understand the rationale behind having no choice with regard to this particular shot. That said, DS will likely get it at his 18 mo visit. I only posted b/c on BOTB's thread it was made as if we have a choice in these issues - and, i really don't see much of a real choice here and was wondering if I was missing something.

THanks so much to all that responded!!!!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/26/09 6:22 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Spinoff to BOTB's post about vaccinations...

Posted by itsbabytime

Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

I believe that the child has to be immune to chicken pox before entering school. So, either the vaccination or actually having had chicken pox will do. There is a test for immunity to chicken pox. I don't know whether they will have your child take the test if you say that their immunity is from having had the virus and not the vaccine. Maybe the medical records will do. A friend of mine who had chicken pox, the actual virus and not the shot, later found out that she was not immune to another case of it. Another choice might be to vaccinate and then test for immunity later on. I guess I just feel that the vaccination is not harmful and I would rather give that than have my child go through having the virus then have to go through testing to prove to the school that he had it (if they ask for such testing). We have already given DS the chicken pox vaccine. We only gave that shot and no others on the day he had it.



I don't think you can ever really say that the vaccination is not harmful. For starters just look at the vaccine insert to see all the things that are being injected into DC. And, beyond that, although rare both the manufacturer and the ped have said there are some very serious potential reactions to this shot - rare, but, possible.

You have to show proof either way so either the ped says he has the shot or he says he had the cp - not sure why one would be more difficult than the other. And, your child will have to have more than one CP vaccine (at least three I think) so I don't see how having the CP and having a blood test (which at some point the child will have anyway) - if necessary is that much more burdensome.

Anyway, all that said - I am just playing devil's advocate here. I honestly really cannot understand the rationale behind having no choice with regard to this particular shot. That said, DS will likely get it at his 18 mo visit. I only posted b/c on BOTB's thread it was made as if we have a choice in these issues - and, i really don't see much of a real choice here and was wondering if I was missing something.

THanks so much to all that responded!!!!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I wrote a long answer, then deleted it by mistake. What I meant to say was that I decided that the vaccine was not likely to harm my child. I did read about it beforehand. There are risks with the vaccine and with the illness. I felt that the risks with the illness were worse. My doctor addressed my concerns about scheduling vaccines but I am not looking to avoid any particular vaccines, even after reading a lot. The lack of choice is another issue. It's a battle I will take on if I change my mind. I have read literature from both sides and some that was neutral.

Posted 2/26/09 9:37 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to BOTB's post about vaccinations...

Since my sister & friend have already gone through it - I'll answer for them.

One is claiming a religious exemption; the other a medical exemption. Those are the only 2 exemptions allowed in NYS. There is legistlation to allow a philopsophical exemption but my guess is it will get shot down again.

The reigious exemption is under more scrutiny & the person had to go before some board at her school. She brought an attorney that specializes in vaccine exemptions. He's guided her & her husband through the process. Every few years it comes up again. You do not have to show any immunity towards chicken pox or any other disease.

For a religious exemption, they questioned both parents' religious backgrounds, the fact that one parent was an altar boy, etc. They don't have to be part of an organized religion (it comes close to Christian Scientist). The premise is she believes that God creates a biological miracle & it is her God-given right not to vaccinate.

That means no vaccinations. In other words you could have vaccinated in the past & opted to no longer based on a new religious belief, however if you are choosing not to vaccinate, you can't pick & choose your vaccines because it's not consistent with a religious exemption. You can't believe God will heal without the help of vaccines & then give a DTAP but not the MMR.

Posted 2/26/09 10:13 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Spinoff to BOTB's post about vaccinations...

Posted by wannabemom

well, I'm delaying/spreading out DS's shots, but he WILL be completely caught-up prior to pre-school. He will receive almost all that are on the vaccination schedule (the only omission will be the rotavirus? (I think that's the one?) shot becuase it's new and my pediatrician doesn't trust that vaccine.... but it isn't required for school)

I believe a good portion of people who delay/spread have similar intentions to me... to be caught-up prior to school.



Same here. DS did not get the rotovirus vaccine. He hasn't gotten the MMR yet (he will be 2 in April) but I will give it to him by the time he needs it for school. I also have not given him the flu vaccine, which I probably never will. And the chicken pox he will get when it is needed to enter school.

Posted 2/26/09 11:05 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
X-post from Sports.. when do Yankee tickets go on sale? melbalalala 2/26/09 0 Families Helping Families ™
Spinoff to BOTB post JennZ 10/20/08 9 Pregnancy
spinoff to BOTB's post - What was the 1st baby item you purchased? bonitachyc 8/4/08 6 Pregnancy
Childhood vaccinations usuk2004 2/26/09 3 Pregnancy
First Post! Question about co-op interest rates CMG920 2/26/09 12 Home
Didn't know where to post... BellaRock 2/26/09 18 Infertility