Re: Spinoff to BOTB's post about vaccinations...
Posted 2/26/2009 9:37:26 PM by Kerie-is-so-very
Posted by itsbabytime
Posted by Kerie-is-so-very
I believe that the child has to be immune to chicken pox before entering school. So, either the vaccination or actually having had chicken pox will do. There is a test for immunity to chicken pox. I don't know whether they will have your child take the test if you say that their immunity is from having had the virus and not the vaccine. Maybe the medical records will do. A friend of mine who had chicken pox, the actual virus and not the shot, later found out that she was not immune to another case of it. Another choice might be to vaccinate and then test for immunity later on. I guess I just feel that the vaccination is not harmful and I would rather give that than have my child go through having the virus then have to go through testing to prove to the school that he had it (if they ask for such testing). We have already given DS the chicken pox vaccine. We only gave that shot and no others on the day he had it.
I don't think you can ever really say that the vaccination is not harmful. For starters just look at the vaccine insert to see all the things that are being injected into DC. And, beyond that, although rare both the manufacturer and the ped have said there are some very serious potential reactions to this shot - rare, but, possible.
You have to show proof either way so either the ped says he has the shot or he says he had the cp - not sure why one would be more difficult than the other. And, your child will have to have more than one CP vaccine (at least three I think) so I don't see how having the CP and having a blood test (which at some point the child will have anyway) - if necessary is that much more burdensome.
Anyway, all that said - I am just playing devil's advocate here. I honestly really cannot understand the rationale behind having no choice with regard to this particular shot. That said, DS will likely get it at his 18 mo visit. I only posted b/c on BOTB's thread it was made as if we have a choice in these issues - and, i really don't see much of a real choice here and was wondering if I was missing something.
THanks so much to all that responded!!!!
I wrote a long answer, then deleted it by mistake. What I meant to say was that I decided that the vaccine was not likely to harm my child. I did read about it beforehand. There are risks with the vaccine and with the illness. I felt that the risks with the illness were worse. My doctor addressed my concerns about scheduling vaccines but I am not looking to avoid any particular vaccines, even after reading a lot. The lack of choice is another issue. It's a battle I will take on if I change my mind. I have read literature from both sides and some that was neutral.
|