Spinoff: how much milk???Conflicting Dr. Advice? Why sooooo different??

Posted By Message

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Spinoff: how much milk???Conflicting Dr. Advice? Why sooooo different??

I dont get it. .My dr is ok with John still getting 21 oz of milk per day.

but.. My SIL'S Ped doesn't want my nephew getting more the 8-10??

Now it doesn't have to do with his body or health issues...that's their advice to all kids that age.


How could drs. be sooooo off. If it's not good to have so much dairy...why is one dr. saying 24 oz is ok and another says only 10 oz per day.. that's a big difference/

what are you thoughts?

Posted 6/3/11 9:44 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Spinoff: how much milk???Conflicting Dr. Advice? Why sooooo different??

Wow that is a huge difference.
And a bit scary to think their advice is so differing.

My ped told me that when we start milk at 12 months, no more than 24 oz a day.
Not sure if that changes with age though?

Posted 6/3/11 9:49 AM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff: how much milk???Conflicting Dr. Advice? Why sooooo different??

How old is your nephew? 8-10 oz. seems too low--it seems like more peds. say around 20-24 oz. Maybe he wasn't eating enough food, and she didn't tell you? I know my ped. recommends less if the child isn't eating enough, or enough variety.

Posted 6/3/11 9:50 AM
 

BethanyLynn
Love these munchkins

Member since 10/09

6295 total posts

Name:
Bethany

Re: Spinoff: how much milk???Conflicting Dr. Advice? Why sooooo different??

I always find the differing opinions from peds on lots of stuff, shots, eggs, milk etc very disturbing!
K is 16 months and gets 20oz still. Ped is ok with that- says no more than that though.

Posted 6/3/11 9:58 AM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Spinoff: how much milk???Conflicting Dr. Advice? Why sooooo different??

Posted by nov04libride

How old is your nephew? 8-10 oz. seems too low--it seems like more peds. say around 20-24 oz. Maybe he wasn't eating enough food, and she didn't tell you? I know my ped. recommends less if the child isn't eating enough, or enough variety.



5 months older than John. .but told her this at 18 month appt. Nope has nothing to do with what he's eating either... he eats a lot of food.. I even mentioned that to her and she shaid he didn't even mention food...just that's what he should be drinking at his age!!
weird.

Posted 6/3/11 9:58 AM
 

jlk51496
Mom of 3 - YIKES! =)

Member since 10/09

6758 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: Spinoff: how much milk???Conflicting Dr. Advice? Why sooooo different??

Posted by nov04libride

How old is your nephew? 8-10 oz. seems too low--it seems like more peds. say around 20-24 oz.



I agree...My 2.5 and 3.5 yr olds still drink more than that!

Posted 6/3/11 10:07 AM
 

Shorty
.

Member since 5/05

30390 total posts

Name:
really

Re: Spinoff: how much milk???Conflicting Dr. Advice? Why sooooo different??

my ped said 20-24oz max.
8-10 does NOT seem like enough!

Posted 6/3/11 10:08 AM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Spinoff: how much milk???Conflicting Dr. Advice? Why sooooo different??

Posted by Shorty

my ped said 20-24oz max.
8-10 does NOT seem like enough!



I know......and she swears her peds are right.. about everything.....

Posted 6/3/11 10:11 AM
 

shapla79
Where Does The Time Go?

Member since 11/07

4619 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff: how much milk???Conflicting Dr. Advice? Why sooooo different??

I'm wondering if your SIL's ped was saying 18 and not 8-10 oz? My ped asked us to keep it at 16-18 oz once they turned one. It never really bothered me because my kids love eating yogurt and cheese in addition to their milk. If that ped really did say 8-10 oz, that seems low to me!

Message edited 2011-06-03 10:15:57.940000.

Posted 6/3/11 10:14 AM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Spinoff: how much milk???Conflicting Dr. Advice? Why sooooo different??

I don't remember the amount my ped told me when my DD turned 1 - I'll find out at DS's 1 year appointment in a few weeks - but the reason to limit it was because too much calcium can constipate children and at this point they should be getting the majority of their nutrients from food as opposed to drinking.

I can't help but think your cousin misheard. I feel like my ped told me a range of about 16-24oz, but I'm not sure. It was DEFINITELY more than 8oz. That's 1 glass of milk!

Posted 6/3/11 10:17 AM
 

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Spinoff: how much milk???Conflicting Dr. Advice? Why sooooo different??

8 -10 oz seems LOW

Joey's ped said up to 24oz.

Posted 6/3/11 10:40 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
when do I switch to a different milk? livy820 1/21/10 4 Parenting
Different or Same Sippy for Milk/Juice metsgirlie 10/9/08 12 Parenting
Can you combine breast milk from different pumpings? sunny 12/4/05 2 Parenting
Advice Please/ cow's milk and diaper rash/poopies mommy2devin 5/6/08 2 Parenting
My turn for milk advice... lipglossjunky73 4/6/08 25 Parenting
feeding advice- refusing milk sal79 3/29/08 4 Parenting