Spinoff: Bridesmaids

Posted By Message

seaside
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

3101 total posts

Name:

Spinoff: Bridesmaids

All this talk about bridesmaids and $$ got me thinking. I think it's such a foreign idea to ask people to be bridesmaids with the expectation that they will do any more than buy their own dress. I had a few bridesmaids, but I asked them to accompany me down the aisle as an honor--for them--not for me. To be by my side during the best day of my life. I would have been mortified if they had been asked to pay for my shower. My family paid for all that. ...Now, I did have a b-party, but it was local, everyone paid for themselves, planned by MOH, who also insisted on paying for me, and people had the option of doing or not doing various parts of it. ...All in all, my bm's paid for their dresses and their entertainment at my b-party, but at least it was only for themselves and not for an extravagant oarty for others. It would have made me feel awful to know that my wedding was costing my friends so much $$$ and that they were paying for others' food, entertainment, flowers, etc. My friends did similar things.
I would feel very put upon if I agreed to accept an honor only to learn that x amount of $$$ was being extracted from me (w/o my input or asking about my ability to pay) so that a shower of a certain calibur could be thrown for lots of women at my expense. Maybe it's just the way I was raised. Anyone else? I just feel that being a bm should be a privilege and an honor, not a drain and a pressure.

Posted 8/19/08 3:31 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Jax430
Hi!

Member since 5/05

18919 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Spinoff: Bridesmaids

I have been in a number of wedding parties, and each one handle financial things a little differently. Right now, I am in my first one where I am expected to contribute to the shower. It is quite an expense. The MOB is paying for the shower itself, and the BMs are paying for the invitations, favors, game prizes, decorations, etc.

My mother was livid when she heard about the money we were spending on the shower b/c she never asked my bridal party to contribute at all. Then again, I got married a few years out of college, and most of my BP was in grad school or just working and had little money.

I have heard of things going both ways, but I agree with you as far as the way I prefer things to be done. I am in 3 wedding parties this year ( 2 down, 1 to go), and it has been Chat Icon!

Posted 8/19/08 3:38 PM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff: Bridesmaids

I think being a BM or MOH is a privilege and an honor but that it also comes with responsibilties.

I always thought that making the shower could be part of the deal when you agree to be bridesmaid. I think it's more common now for the mother or close family members to make the shower but from a traditional ettiquette standpoint - it's inappropriate because it is a public request for gifts.

I also think that anyone that is asked to contribute money to a party should have a say in the planning and costs. I think it's rude to basically invoice the people that are closest to the bride.

Message edited 2008-08-19 15:42:47.513000.

Posted 8/19/08 3:41 PM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: Spinoff: Bridesmaids

i think everyone has different expectation. i only had 2 girls in my party--if they were going to pay for my shower alone--omg i couldn't imagine the cost! Chat Icon

I just wanted them there with me -- they bought their dresses and paid for their hair. I paid for their make up and told them I didn't want them being all fancy and going out of their way--I found a dress that was less than $150 told them "wear whatever shoes you want--i don't care" i didn't want to dictate too much to them, cause in reality they were doing ME a favor by agreeing to stand by me on the most important day of my life.

my Bparty was simple...my MOH made a lot of food and we hung out--nothing crazy...some of us went to a bar but otherwise I just didn't want them spending all kinds of money!

Posted 8/19/08 3:41 PM
 

cindy104
This is my "Baby"

Member since 6/08

1522 total posts

Name:
Cindy

Re: Spinoff: Bridesmaids

I do very much agree with you.
This is one of the many reasons why I chose to actually only have a MOH....and that was my sister. I too had a bach-party; in which my other close girlfriends did attend, but we kept it very simple and just went out to dinner in the city....And took the train there and back. It was not costly at all...and I insisted that it be that way!

Posted 8/19/08 3:43 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Spinoff: Bridesmaids

Every time I've ever been asked to be a BM I've accepted with the understanding that I would have to pay for certain things above and beyond my dress.

That's just the way it's been with most of my friends. My BFF's parents couldn't have afforded her shower so the other BMs and I took on the responsibility happily. My mom couldn't afford my shower either - although that was a big ole mess - my girlfriends accepted the responsibility and were wonderful about it, considering what they had to deal with (but that's another drama for another day).

The ONLY time we ever expected NOT to pay for the shower was when the bride had over 100 people invited to the shower AND we knew her mom had the $$$. But otherwise we step in.

Posted 8/19/08 3:47 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Spinoff: Bridesmaids

I agree with you

I have never been asked to pay for a shower

and there is no way I would have asked the bridal party to pay for my sisters

the total cost of the shower was $4K- that would have been almost $700 each! (My Dad paid for the food, her FMIL let us use her house and got the tent and wine and beer, decorations and I picked up the other little things)

My Dad also paid for the dresses (for my wedding as well- his thing- he wanted to do it)

and all the Bridal party paid for my sister was her part of the van - plus we split the bill with out her- but she ended up getting US so many free drinks- no one spent more then $100 including the Van and the Ferry to FI

like I said before- I hated asking for the $45 for the van- how could I have asked for $700Chat Icon

Posted 8/19/08 3:50 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff: Bridesmaids

I think each situation is different and also depends on where you're from since weddings can be so different in different parts of the country.
I was a bridesmaid for a friend in Boston and all the bm's chipped in for a big gift for the brides shower (i gave my own gift as well), as well as chipped in for favors for the shower but the MOB paid for the majority of the shower.
My cousin got married in Ohio - all i did was pay for my dress.
I have no idea what was done for my wedding - i didn't ask Chat Icon However, i know that since my shower was at my mom's house that noone had to shell out major $$ - everyone brought food and one of the bm's made cute little pumpkins for everyone to take home as favors. I only asked my bm's to pay for their dresses and if they wanted to get their hair done (i certainly didn't demand they get it done). I paid for one bm's hair to be done since she didn't have a lot of $. I gave them earrings to wear and they wore whatever they wanted for shoes.

I feel that you have bm's because those are the people you want to be with you on your special day and share the excitement with you. They're your friends/family. Its bad enough they have to shell out lots of $$ on dresses.. i don't think people should have to add on to it for all the other stuff that comes with it (showers, engagement parties, favors, bach parties). Weddings have gotten out of hand!

Posted 8/19/08 4:00 PM
 

seaside
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

3101 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff: Bridesmaids

Glad to see I'm not alone. I have no problem with the over the top extras...but it's like everything else. Do what you can afford.
It kills me that some girls go so "bridezilla" making sure they come off the "right" "classy" way, and then invoice others (or have others do it).

Some of the classiset showers I've ever been to have involved pizza in someone's apartment and some of the tackiest, most offputting things I've witnessed have involved elaborate decorations, favors, and catering---with an invoice to each "honored" bm.

Posted 8/19/08 4:05 PM
 

MrsB-07
proud RELAXIVIST

Member since 11/07

2027 total posts

Name:
b

Re: Spinoff: Bridesmaids

I was only a bridesmaid once a few years ago. There was no bach party for the bride or the groom (the whole bridal party, bride and groom just went out to dinner and everyone paid for themselves) and I did put money towards the shower, but it was just little things like buying and putting together favors.... the mothers chipped in for food and decorations.

I got married a year ago and honestly dont know how they split the costs. I had a very low key bach party (the girls did pay for me) and I had a beautiful shower... but everyone made a dish to bring for food and I think my dad paid for the hall....

It's hard to expect ppl to put in a lot of their time and money for a wedding as it can get expensive. I also had two younger family members (early teens) so even though they were part of my BP they didn't contribute. I don't mind spending the money on wedding festivities as long as its within reason... I wouldn't want to go into debt over it and I wouldn't want my bp to go into debt either

Posted 8/19/08 4:12 PM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff: Bridesmaids

I totally agree with you!!! Thankfully, I have never had an issue with this, on either side.

As a bride, I only had 4 BM and 1 Bridesman: My sister, my SIL who lives in Israel, 2 girlfriends and 1 guy friend. One BM didn't come to my shower/bacheloreette paty because she lived in Boston. The bridesman also lived OOS and only was involved in the wedding. That left two girls: my sister and my best friend from childhood to do all the shower and b-party.

My b-party was comped since we knew the party promoter. There was a stripper- and I don't know who paid for that. My guess is that it was split amongst all those in attendance (which I have seen done before).

My shower was at my sister's home and was very low key. I assume my family paid for that.

As a bridesmaid, the only thing I have ever been expected to pay for is my dress. Each bride's family paid for the shower. Although one bride's family provided the food and the place so the girls split the decorations/paper plates/napkins, etc....

One wedding was out of the country, and I went. The bride specifcially told me NOT to get her a gift- that my presence was gift enough.

But also, almost every shower I have ever been to was at someone's house, which definitely helps keep costs low.

Message edited 2008-08-19 16:18:04.200000.

Posted 8/19/08 4:14 PM
 

Bri
I Love You to Pieces!

Member since 5/05

9919 total posts

Name:
Brianne

Re: Spinoff: Bridesmaids

I completely agree.

Posted 8/19/08 6:54 PM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: Spinoff: Bridesmaids

I agree it's an honor. I just think that brides get swept up in the planning and what everyone else is doing that they have to have trips to Vegas, huge bach parties and what have you.

Posted 8/19/08 6:56 PM
 

DandN
Twins are here!

Member since 3/06

3597 total posts

Name:
Deirdre

Re: Spinoff: Bridesmaids

I've been a bridesmaid a number of times and I remember once having to pay for my portion of the shower - I was in grad school, was broke and had to work a 2nd job to pay for my bridesmaid duties.

When I got married I asked my bridesmaids to wear something black to the wedding. I didnt care what it looked like. I didnt know what some of them were wearing until the day of the wedding - and not surprisingly, they all looked gorgeous in dresses that were unique to them.

My mom and dad paid for the shower and my sister organized a fantastic bachelorette weekend that my parents helped contribute to. I know that my friends paid some money for the bachelorette party.

Posted 8/19/08 7:09 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff: Bridesmaids

I've been a MOH 4x and I didn't pay anything towards the showers, except for invites, games and decorations (plus a gift obviously)

it was the same for my BP. they did the invites, got the games and decorations, but my Mom paid the tab at the restaurant.

Posted 8/19/08 7:09 PM
 

ml110
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

5435 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff: Bridesmaids

i've been a bridesmaid 3 times, and all 3 times i contributed to the shower... it was just one of the parts of being a bridesmaid.
for 2 of the showers, the MOBs went in on the shower with us, and we split it evenly among all the bridesmaids and her. one shower was at a restaurant, and the other shower was at the MOBs house, and we (BMs) made all the food, etc for it.
the other shower was at the brides neighbor's house, so she helped host. the MOB did not contribute in any way to the shower. shes VERY traditional in that the mother of the bride shouldn't host the shower because its asking for gifts Chat Icon Chat Icon
so i haven't had it too bad, but it was always just something i thought was part of being a bridesmaid...

Posted 8/19/08 7:34 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
bridesmaids dress question ml110 3/28/08 5 Families Helping Families ™
Spinoff: 80s Bridesmaids nrthshgrl 8/14/07 5 Families Helping Families ™
Pregnant bridesmaids? NJmom 4/19/07 12 Parenting
Out of town bridesmaids - where did you get measured? Nik09 2/10/07 3 Families Helping Families ™
Bridesmaids Dress want2beamom 2/3/07 5 Pregnancy
Maternity Bridesmaids Dresses ARIELSMOM 10/27/06 3 Pregnancy