Spin off: playground

Posted By Message

A3CM
Avatar Title

Member since 9/08

3762 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Spin off: playground

for those of you who said that they would say something to the big girls, saying how its not nice not to include the little girl, or those who suggested to say something loud enough so their parents could hear... did you think maybe, that that was THEIR day to be and play with THEIR friends. maybe the little girls had little sisters or brothers at home and their mom said today we go to the playground so you and your friend could play and do big kid things.


yes of course it breaks our hearts as parents to see kids excluded, but just maybe, that was THEIR day to do things without a little sister or brother bothering them.


just a thought before we as mothers stoop to a little kids age, by trying to make them feel bad for something they didn't do wrong.

Posted 4/26/11 7:20 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Spin off: playground

I didn't suggest saying something loud enough for the mother to hear, but IF the mother were to ovehear I wouldn't be embarrased by saying something...I do agree that a 4 year old doesn't have much in common with a 2.5 year old but I feel like they could be taught to say it nicely to a younger child and not be mean about it if that makes sense....

Posted 4/26/11 7:32 AM
 

xten
LIF Infant

Member since 4/11

157 total posts

Name:
xten

Re: Spin off: playground

Posted by pickles16

I didn't suggest saying something loud enough for the mother to hear, but IF the mother were to ovehear I wouldn't be embarrased by saying something...I do agree that a 4 year old doesn't have much in common with a 2.5 year old but I feel like they could be taught to say it nicely to a younger child and not be mean about it if that makes sense....



my thoughts EXACTLY.

Posted 4/26/11 9:47 PM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spin off: playground

I agree with you 100% and I wrote that on the other thread. I do not think a 4,5 year old should be forced to play with a baby just b/c they are on the playground at the same time. I mean they are 4 - what should they say? "No, ma'm, I am really sorry but, we are playing a big girl game and at 2.5 it would be really hard for your DD to participate with us?" I mean, in reality there are ALWAYS little and big kids at the playground at the same time. Why should the older kids have to in a sense babysit the younger kids?

Honestly, I think that making a big deal out of this is what the problem is. I don't think explaining to a 2.5 yr old that they are big girls playing big girl games and that when she is old enough she will be able to play. At 2.5 they should be old enough to understand that and not feel bad. I mean, what if the girls were doing something that was just not safe for a 2.5 yr old or that a 2.5 yr old could not physically do, wouldn't that be the same thing? I think this would be an entirely different conversation if the girls were saying that to another 4 or 5 year old girl. Then, yes, I would think it was rude and would expect them to be kinder.

Message edited 2011-04-26 23:44:41.347000.

Posted 4/26/11 11:43 PM
 

BargainMama
LIF Adult

Member since 5/09

15660 total posts

Name:

Re: Spin off: playground

Posted by itsbabytime

I agree with you 100% and I wrote that on the other thread. I do not think a 4,5 year old should be forced to play with a baby just b/c they are on the playground at the same time. I mean they are 4 - what should they say? "No, ma'm, I am really sorry but, we are playing a big girl game and at 2.5 it would be really hard for your DD to participate with us?" I mean, in reality there are ALWAYS little and big kids at the playground at the same time. Why should the older kids have to in a sense babysit the younger kids?

Honestly, I think that making a big deal out of this is what the problem is. I don't think explaining to a 2.5 yr old that they are big girls playing big girl games and that when she is old enough she will be able to play. At 2.5 they should be old enough to understand that and not feel bad. I mean, what if the girls were doing something that was just not safe for a 2.5 yr old or that a 2.5 yr old could not physically do, wouldn't that be the same thing? I think this would be an entirely different conversation if the girls were saying that to another 4 or 5 year old girl. Then, yes, I would think it was rude and would expect them to be kinder.



I agree

Posted 4/27/11 7:57 AM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Spin off: playground

No one EVER said that an older child should be FORCED to play with a younger one.. For me, it's all about how the situation is handled and I think it's RUDE to be nasty to another child...

I try my hardest to teach my children to be kind to others..

it's never too early to teach your children kindness and tactic in handling certain situations..

Posted 4/27/11 10:10 AM
 

jambalady
Is it summer yet?

Member since 8/06

7392 total posts

Name:
Holly

Re: Spin off: playground

Posted by bicosi

No one EVER said that an older child should be FORCED to play with a younger one.. For me, it's all about how the situation is handled and I think it's RUDE to be nasty to another child...

I try my hardest to teach my children to be kind to others..

it's never too early to teach your children kindness and tactic in handling certain situations..



ITA.

I always tell DS it's ok that older kids don't want to play with him, but there are some that are just so nasty.

DS was following a 6 yr old boy once and the boy turned around and spit on him! Chat Icon

He was 2 years old.

Saying "I don't want to play with you" is fine, but some kids push, and shove the little ones away and say really nasty things.

Posted 4/27/11 10:15 AM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spin off: playground

Posted by jambalady

Posted by bicosi

No one EVER said that an older child should be FORCED to play with a younger one.. For me, it's all about how the situation is handled and I think it's RUDE to be nasty to another child...

I try my hardest to teach my children to be kind to others..

it's never too early to teach your children kindness and tactic in handling certain situations..



ITA.

I always tell DS it's ok that older kids don't want to play with him, but there are some that are just so nasty.

DS was following a 6 yr old boy once and the boy turned around and spit on him! Chat Icon

He was 2 years old.

Saying "I don't want to play with you" is fine, but some kids push, and shove the little ones away and say really nasty things.



This is an entirely different situation. The post this thread was referencing did not say the girls were spitting, hitting, saying nasty things. Just that the girls said you can't come over here or something like that and then said no when the mom asked if she could play. The poster seemed more upset that her 2.5 yr old was hurt that she couldn't play and should be included then at the words used. OF COURSE, if the 4 yr olds shoved her or were screaming or spitting at her or were calling her names that would be a different story. I believe both this thread and the other were dealing with an entirely different issue. The issue of whether it is mean for a 4/5 yr old to not play with a 2.5 yr old stranger on the playground b/c she wants to play with them.

Posted 4/27/11 11:11 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Spin off: playground

Posted by itsbabytime

Posted by jambalady

Posted by bicosi

No one EVER said that an older child should be FORCED to play with a younger one.. For me, it's all about how the situation is handled and I think it's RUDE to be nasty to another child...

I try my hardest to teach my children to be kind to others..

it's never too early to teach your children kindness and tactic in handling certain situations..



ITA.

I always tell DS it's ok that older kids don't want to play with him, but there are some that are just so nasty.

DS was following a 6 yr old boy once and the boy turned around and spit on him! Chat Icon

He was 2 years old.

Saying "I don't want to play with you" is fine, but some kids push, and shove the little ones away and say really nasty things.



This is an entirely different situation. The post this thread was referencing did not say the girls were spitting, hitting, saying nasty things. Just that the girls said you can't come over here or something like that and then said no when the mom asked if she could play. The poster seemed more upset that her 2.5 yr old was hurt that she couldn't play and should be included then at the words used. OF COURSE, if the 4 yr olds shoved her or were screaming or spitting at her or were calling her names that would be a different story. I believe both this thread and the other were dealing with an entirely different issue. The issue of whether it is mean for a 4/5 yr old to not play with a 2.5 yr old stranger on the playground b/c she wants to play with them.



Exactly! Making a passive agressive comment to the moms was not necessarily. The little girls did not need a guilt trip because a 2.5 yo wanted to play with them and they did not want to. Why should they be forced to play with a younger child they don't even know? They were not mean or pushed her. Telling her she could not use a particular area of the playground would be a different story. Yes, the 2.5 yo was disappointed. It's up to the mom not to make a big deal and redirect.


Posted 4/27/11 11:22 AM
 

jambalady
Is it summer yet?

Member since 8/06

7392 total posts

Name:
Holly

Re: Spin off: playground

Posted by itsbabytime

This is an entirely different situation. The post this thread was referencing did not say the girls were spitting, hitting, saying nasty things. Just that the girls said you can't come over here or something like that and then said no when the mom asked if she could play. The poster seemed more upset that her 2.5 yr old was hurt that she couldn't play and should be included then at the words used. OF COURSE, if the 4 yr olds shoved her or were screaming or spitting at her or were calling her names that would be a different story. I believe both this thread and the other were dealing with an entirely different issue. The issue of whether it is mean for a 4/5 yr old to not play with a 2.5 yr old stranger on the playground b/c she wants to play with them.



Point taken.

You are right that they are completely different situations.

And maybe bc I'm not a BTDT mom, I don't truly know how 4-5 yr olds behave. So maybe when my DS turns 4-5 this will all come back and bite me in the a$$.

What I do know is that my nieces are nephews who are that age are taught to be nice to everyone, especially to babies and toddlers.

And there is a nice way to redirect. I just see too many kids being rude on the playground and excluding other kids when it's a public playground that everyone should be enjoying.

Teaching manners and inclusiveness starts at a young age.

I never let my DS say no to a child when they ask to play nicely and when I am watching my nieces and nephews, I do the same.

Posted 4/27/11 11:27 AM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spin off: playground

Posted by jambalady

Posted by itsbabytime

This is an entirely different situation. The post this thread was referencing did not say the girls were spitting, hitting, saying nasty things. Just that the girls said you can't come over here or something like that and then said no when the mom asked if she could play. The poster seemed more upset that her 2.5 yr old was hurt that she couldn't play and should be included then at the words used. OF COURSE, if the 4 yr olds shoved her or were screaming or spitting at her or were calling her names that would be a different story. I believe both this thread and the other were dealing with an entirely different issue. The issue of whether it is mean for a 4/5 yr old to not play with a 2.5 yr old stranger on the playground b/c she wants to play with them.



Point taken.

You are right that they are completely different situations.

And maybe bc I'm not a BTDT mom, I don't truly know how 4-5 yr olds behave. So maybe when my DS turns 4-5 this will all come back and bite me in the a$$.

What I do know is that my nieces are nephews who are that age are taught to be nice to everyone, especially to babies and toddlers.

And there is a nice way to redirect. I just see too many kids being rude on the playground and excluding other kids when it's a public playground that everyone should be enjoying.

Teaching manners and inclusiveness starts at a young age.

I never let my DS say no to a child when they ask to play nicely and when I am watching my nieces and nephews, I do the same.




I agree with you! My kids are also still young so I am not 100% sure either. And, honestly, my kids will play with every body and would never be exclusionary. but, that said, I don't think these kids were necessarily wrong and I certainly think that a nasty comment loud enough for the parents to hear would have been uncalled for and ridiculous.

Posted 4/27/11 11:52 AM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Spin off: playground

I don't think you can expect 4-5 year olds to play with a 2.5 yo they do not even know, and it's ridiculous for a parent to place that expectation on them.

If the way they put it was harsh, maybe it was just because they are 4-5.

I do think older kids need to share playground equipment and such, and I have made them let DS go down the slide a couple times when it was getting monopolized and he couldn't ask for it on his own, but I wouldn't expect them to play with him.

Posted 4/27/11 12:23 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Spin off: playground

Posted by cjik

I don't think you can expect 4-5 year olds to play with a 2.5 yo they do not even know, and it's ridiculous for a parent to place that expectation on them.

If the way they put it was harsh, maybe it was just because they are 4-5.

I do think older kids need to share playground equipment and such, and I have made them let DS go down the slide a couple times when it was getting monopolized and he couldn't ask for it on his own, but I wouldn't expect them to play with him.



I know that being that I have an almost 5 YO, 2 1/2 YO and a 6 YO, I would expect my older children to be kind and polite...Being that my 2 1/2 yo is the youngest, I wouldn't expect her to know 100% BUT I will tell you that she follows by example.. meaning whatever I teach or have implemented in the older 2 has been passed down to the little one.. it's a domino effect.

Again, i would NEVER force them to play with anyone, regardless of age, that they didn't want to play with but I would not be happy if they told another child that that child could not go into a specific area or rudely tell the adult NO.. as the OP of the other thread stated these children said to her DC and to her.. that doesn't fly with me.. at 4-5 YOs, while they aren't perfect, manners should be taught and put into play from early on.. they know right from wrong...

Chat Icon

Posted 4/27/11 12:43 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spin off from oil price lock in thread. patti08 8/31/05 2 Home
Bachelor Party Spin Redhead 8/11/05 40 Families Helping Families ™
wedding gift spin off rose825 7/30/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Spin off kinda-double dose of fear... dm24angel 7/25/05 10 Infertility
Spin-off: TV couples you Hated neenie 6/10/05 40 Families Helping Families ™
spin off... have you had someone arrested janet 5/16/05 1 Families Helping Families ™