So mad...car related..

Posted By Message

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

So mad...car related..

Major vent here and I need someone to let me know if I'm dillusional, overreacting, or whatever. Let me just say I know there are a lot of happy Nissan Murano owners and honestly I was one of them until not too long ago but heres my issue.

So long story short...this is the first car DH and I bought together...we were previously leasers and when our last lease was up we decided we were going to do the "right" thing financially and buy a car that would last us a while. We did some research and decided on the Nissan Murano. Good size, better fuel economy than the Explorers we previously leased, good reviews and we thought the car was going to last us a long time at least until 100,000 miles before it needed major repairs because of Nissans reputation for reliable cars. We bought the Murano one year old with 18K miles..so it was pretty new.

Well here we are 5 years and 78K miles later and the car needs $4K worth of work per Nissan. We took it to a local mechanic who verified that. Last year we put over $600 into the car because it didn't pass inspection.

And now we basically need:

New brakes and rotors (rotors were replaced 2 years ago). Brakes are fine because they are routine maintenance but even so in the 5 years we have owned the car this is the 4th time we are replacing brakes.

New Tires (OK maintenance once again) We already replaced 4 tires in 2008...but OK maintenance DH and I can deal with this.

Here goes the other part

Oil pan rusted out???
Right side engine mount needs to be replaced.
Suspension needs to be replaced
A whole slew of electrical things need to be reset
cooler line leaking
drive belts just replaced (fine maintenance)
Exhaust
Needs a new battery (3rd battery we put in this car??)

Last year we replaced tie rods and a whole slew of other things because the car did not pass inspection. Now we give oil changes every 7,500 or before per the manual, we've done tire rotation, balancing, alignment per maintenance, etc.

What made us take the car to the dealer is the fact that last week DH was driving and all of a sudden the car would not go over 20 mph...even pressing on the gas hard...apparently thats a CVT issue (found a 58 page thread on Edmunds of Murano owners with similar problems). DH had to turn the car off then turn it back on and it was fine. Nissan says it's not the CVT but what would make the car do that.

Now like I said I never owned a car for more than 3 years since we always leased but is this normal for a 6 year old car to need so much work. We don't drive alot...mainly city driving, occasional drives to LI on the weekend and we drove to FL once and a few times to PA but we are NOT hard drivers at all. I'm just baffled. Obviously we need to fix it but DH wants to sell it...he says he thinks its a POS and has never heard of a car needed so many repairs before 100,000 miles...any input? Thanks.

Posted 5/23/11 1:15 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

memi7206
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2355 total posts

Name:
Due Dec 29th!!!!!

Re: So mad...car related..

this just happened to my brothers Murano, he just had to replace a ton of the same things you did. It cost him a FORTUNE. His is 6 years old.

Posted 5/23/11 1:23 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: So mad...car related..

WOW that's a LOT of work

I have a 2001 Tribute (got it used in 2005) I have yet to change the tires (they don't need it). I've replaced the battery maybe twice in the 6yrs we've had it?

Rust is just part of the Northeast. Which is why we were very careful to rinse the bottom of our truck and car.

I also own a 2003 Mazda 6s (again got it used in 2005) just replaced the tires for the very first time as the wear indicator was showing up. But they were the original tires 2002 - 2011. Most tires will last 5yrs if you get the right type. Mine lasted 9.

We are replacing our oil pan as well but its covered under my warranty so I'm still good on that one.

Suspension and Engine mount? Really? wow. Exhaust? Double wow.

Every car is different, its use, storage and upkeep are all different as well. But I can't see why your suspension is out of whack that badly? Unless you are driving bumpy roads often.

Batteries are another Meh thing.. some are better that others but you seem to be on the high end. But not unusually so.

Standards:
Belts
Brakes
Rotors
Battery (maybe)
Tires (again maybe)

Odd but not crazy
Oil Pan
Cooler line

Interesting:
Exhaust
Suspension
Engine Mount (unless its the lower one, then its a salt/snow issue and it can happen).


I have over 115,000 on my Tribute. No major issues.

I have 61,000 miles on my 6s again, nothing that wasn't covered by warranty.

I highly recommend the AAA warranty because its saved us tons. I had the coils replaced on my 6s and that would have nearly been $1000. Warranty covered it.

Again every car is different.
I've heard horror stories from other Mazda Drivers. Which I'm a huge fan of Mazda and never had issues (im on my 3rd and 4th now). Every maker, every brand, every model has its fans and haters. Its like each car is their own little world. Some are saints and some are sinners.

But this is just my humble opinion. Seems like a lot of work on this vehicle. But what can you do?

Posted 5/23/11 1:29 PM
 

EclecticEsq10810
Bored Esq.

Member since 10/10

2156 total posts

Name:
L.

Re: So mad...car related..

I had no idea Nissan's had a reputation for being reliable. Every Nissan owner I know has had problems with their cars, my friend bought a Nissan Maxima brand new in 2008 and she's already had the car taken to the shop for numerous repairs. My other friend has a Durango and thats been nothing but a money guzzler with ridiculous repairs.

My vote for the best reliable car is a Honda, my mom has a 2005 CRV and with routine oil changes and check-ups, she's never had to take it in for any work or repairs...

have you tried to get another estimate? Maybe the guy was overzealous and mentioned all those repairs which really aren't "necessary?"..

Message edited 2011-05-23 15:11:08.043000.

Posted 5/23/11 3:04 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: So mad...car related..

Have you checked any recalls?

http://www-odi.nhtsa.dot.gov/recalls/RecallSearch.cfm

Posted 5/23/11 3:13 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: So mad...car related..

did you know the vehicle history before buying it?

Unfortunately this can happen to any car.

I had issues with my brand new Hyundai last month.

What model year was it?

I heard some Nissan's a few years back had issues.

I hate to say it but this is one major reason why I lease. I had this happen to me with other cars I owned and I said never again.

I wish you luck getting this done.

Can it be done over time? Maybe the tires and brakes now and a few months later do other repairs to help spread it out?

I had a 1989 240sx, a 2005 Pathfinder and now have a 2010 Maxima and have had no issues.

Message edited 2011-05-23 15:18:08.813000.

Posted 5/23/11 3:17 PM
 

acm1899
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

1085 total posts

Name:

Re: So mad...car related..

Posted by Blu-ize

did you know the vehicle history before buying it?



I was gonna ask this same question. Though 18k miles in one year is not ridiculously high, it could be that this car was a loaner car or rental before you bought it, and you know how people drive cars that aren't theirs. I mean, it doesn't really matter at this point but it might explain some things.

Another thing, even though the maintenance manual says to change the oil every 7,500 miles, that seems like a long span in between especially for driving around here where it's a lot of stop and go and also if you're using anything less than full synthetic oil.

Posted 5/23/11 3:36 PM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: So mad...car related..

Posted by BatGirl9910

I had no idea Nissan's had a reputation for being reliable. Every Nissan owner I know has had problems with their cars, my friend bought a Nissan Maxima brand new in 2008 and she's already had the car taken to the shop for numerous repairs. My other friend has a Durango and thats been nothing but a money guzzler with ridiculous repairs.

My vote for the best reliable car is a Honda, my mom has a 2005 CRV and with routine oil changes and check-ups, she's never had to take it in for any work or repairs...

have you tried to get another estimate? Maybe the guy was overzealous and mentioned all those repairs which really aren't "necessary?"..



Yes...we had one quote with Nissan and the other with a private mechanic so all the work is needed. The private mechanics cost was only a few hundred lower than Nissan but still considerable. I heard great things about the Maximas and Altimas before we bought the Murano and all the reviews on the Murano seemed to be positive hence why we bought one. How I wish I had a crystal ball. I'm sure not every Murano has this problem but doing some research online it seems like they do have more repairs than are normal.

My Parents have a Honda Odyssey with 140K miles and they have not even come close to doing half the stuff we have done on our car...

Barb..yes the car was brought in for some recalls a while back. Everything is up to date as far as recalls go.

I

Posted 5/23/11 3:38 PM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: So mad...car related..

Posted by acm1899

Posted by Blu-ize

did you know the vehicle history before buying it?



I was gonna ask this same question. Though 18k miles in one year is not ridiculously high, it could be that this car was a loaner car or rental before you bought it, and you know how people drive cars that aren't theirs. I mean, it doesn't really matter at this point but it might explain some things.

Another thing, even though the maintenance manual says to change the oil every 7,500 miles, that seems like a long span in between especially for driving around here where it's a lot of stop and go and also if you're using anything less than full synthetic oil.



No we didn't know the history that I can remember..it was bought from a dealer and honestly I can't remember if he told us. As far as the oil change we use synthetic oil and the farthest we have let it go for an oil change is about 7500 miles...the last one that was done was done around 4000 miles...but the manual does state oil change only needed every 7500 miles. Thanks.

ETA: I think 90% of the things need to be done now because it's classified as unsafe to drive..ooh and I forgot to mention something not quoted on the repairs but needs to be done is the drivers seat frame needs to be replaced...it's off the hinges and rocks slightly...apparently another issue on the Muranos but Nissan never did a recall on that. Total to fix that is $1200.

I sooo regret not leasing this time. Booo.Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-05-23 15:43:36.407000.

Posted 5/23/11 3:41 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: So mad...car related..

My mom and dad love Nissan cars and we have had 8 of them in the family over the past 20 years. I don't care for them as much and went with Toyota and Mazda. I feel like my mom and dad are always in the shop spending money on their cars. I have not had to spend that kind of money on my Toyota. I have had to spend some money on the Mazda. I think driving 18,000 in on year is a lot. I drive less than 10,000 per year per car. My brother on the other hand drives 30,000 a year which really is a lot of miles so it is all relative.

eta: I get my cars serviced at their regular intervals. I needed to replace the tires on the mazda relatively quickly. After 6 years I had to replace the battery on the toyota. The mazda is 3 years old.

Message edited 2011-05-23 15:46:52.580000.

Posted 5/23/11 3:44 PM
 

KittyGags
LIF Adult

Member since 7/09

5614 total posts

Name:

Re: So mad...car related..

My brother had a Maxima that he put a FORTUNE into. He blew a tranny with 3K miles on the car.

That was just the beginning. I've never bought a Nissan and I never will though I know many people who are very happy with them!

Posted 5/23/11 3:48 PM
 

evrythng4areason
And then there were 4

Member since 1/10

5224 total posts

Name:
Kayla

Re: So mad...car related..

i have an 08 nissan that i love
7500 miles seems like a lot for an oil change-i go every 3k miles

i currently have about 43k miles on the car, in just under 3 years-it was brand new when i bought it

no problems though...i really do love mine

Posted 5/23/11 9:02 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
personal question-car related kristen92450 8/7/07 20 Families Helping Families ™
what woudl you do? car related 04bride 7/23/07 6 Families Helping Families ™
My husband is "nesting" (car related) snuggleupagus 5/21/07 1 Pregnancy
Odd moral dilemma...car seat related. Eireann 7/20/06 17 Parenting
car related ~~~~ different question TAD 7/5/05 3 Families Helping Families ™
What do you think - Car Related danielleandscott 5/16/05 7 Families Helping Families ™