Slate article: Private v. public school

Posted By Message

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Slate article: Private v. public school

A friend just posted this on FB and I read it - kind of agreed with the author - and then started reading the comments, which are just ON FIRE! Thought it was interesting to share since SDs are always a heated debate on here.

http://www.slate.com/articles/double_x/doublex/2013/08/private_school_vs_public_school_only_bad_people_send_their_kids_to_private.html

Posted 8/29/13 1:27 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

I hate when public and private schools are pitted against each other in a general fashion. I feel that parents have different needs and wants for their children. In some cases, private schools can accommodate those needs better; in others, public schools can.

If, for example, I want to send my children to a school where they receive religious instruction each day, I won't get that from a public school no matter what. The author seems to entirely dismiss that argument as nothing important, so I feel the author's argument is a bit weak and unsubstantiated in general.

Posted 8/29/13 1:33 PM
 

ThreeforTea
Girls just want to have fun..

Member since 5/12

7482 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

Posted by peanutbutter2

I hate when public and private schools are pitted against each other in a general fashion. I feel that parents have different needs and wants for their children. In some cases, private schools can accommodate those needs better; in others, public schools can.

If, for example, I want to send my children to a school where they receive religious instruction each day, I won't get that from a public school no matter what. The author seems to entirely dismiss that argument as nothing important, so I feel the author's argument is a bit weak and unsubstantiated in general.



I agree with you

Posted 8/29/13 1:35 PM
 

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

I guess, in respect to that argument re: religious education - or really any area that might be lacking in public education - could be supplemented by good parenting. I've actually heard co-workers of mine, who send their kids to city public schools, supplement art, music, phys ed themselves because those areas are terribly lacking, if not missing altogether, from their kids's schools. I can agree with that too.

Posted 8/29/13 1:39 PM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

Posted by LovesMike

I guess, in respect to that argument re: religious education - or really any area that might be lacking in public education - could be supplemented by good parenting. I've actually heard co-workers of mine, who send their kids to city public schools, supplement art, music, phys ed themselves because those areas are terribly lacking, if not missing altogether, from their kids's schools. I can agree with that too.



I think if that argument is true, we can also argue that any school-regardless of affiliation, location, etc.- is not needed. Parents and tutors could supplement everything at home with homeschooling.

Posted 8/29/13 1:45 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

That's one of the worst arguments for public school that I've ever read.

My local school sucks and it's not good enough for my children, so I pay for private. If that makes me bad, so be it.

Posted 8/29/13 3:21 PM
 

Mustanggrl
LIF Infant

Member since 10/12

154 total posts

Name:
Newlywed

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

Posted by peanutbutter2

I hate when public and private schools are pitted against each other in a general fashion. I feel that parents have different needs and wants for their children. In some cases, private schools can accommodate those needs better; in others, public schools can.

If, for example, I want to send my children to a school where they receive religious instruction each day, I won't get that from a public school no matter what. The author seems to entirely dismiss that argument as nothing important, so I feel the author's argument is a bit weak and unsubstantiated in general.



ITA. They unleashed the havoc now bc posters are bashing public schools now. Chat Icon

Posted 8/29/13 3:38 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

I adore this article.

I really relate to what the author said here:

going to school with poor kids and rich kids, black kids and brown kids, smart kids and not-so-smart ones, kids with superconservative Christian parents and other upper-middle-class Jews like me was its own education and life preparation. Reading Walt Whitman in ninth grade changed the way you see the world? Well, getting drunk before basketball games with kids who lived at the trailer park near my house did the same for me. In fact it’s part of the reason I feel so strongly about public schools.

I went to public school in Queens, while the neighborhood I grew up in is an expensive area, going to public school in the 80's and 90's meant busing, I went to school with all types of kids. I grew up white, upper middle class and the exposure I got as a public school student to people of other races, socioeconomic backgrounds, religions is invaluable to molding who I am today.

I honestly believe that I am better in my career and as a person bc of this social learning, learning that could not and did not (I know bc friends of mine went there) happen at my local catholic school.

I would also like to add that I attended CCD (religion class) once a week, I also attended mass with my family every sunday, my parents are devout Catholics and they as well as my religion classes taught me my religion. I do not say this to say that those who send their kids to Catholic are wrong, everyone should do what works for them but I say this to say that you can go to public school and be raised a practicing Catholic who knows as much about their religion as a Catholic school kid.

Message edited 2013-08-29 16:05:03.517000.

Posted 8/29/13 4:04 PM
 

sameinitials
insert creative comment here

Member since 2/12

1998 total posts

Name:

Slate article: Private v. public school

The arguments in the article are dumb, though I do agree that parents should just leave it up to the school to educate their child - I don't have kids yet, but when I do I certainly plan on supplementing and getting involved.

Posted 8/29/13 4:04 PM
 

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

Diamondgirl-I feel the same.

My own education is a mix of public and private and, if I could go back, I might change it to all public-if not for the cost alone! I definitely don't think the private education was any better than the public-quite the opposite. There was a lot of entitled, presumptuous kids that never really understood how hard I worked to be there. I'm comparing private undergrad, but there were kids whose parents paid for them to be there without the grades, credentials, or 3 summer jobs that I juggled!

I don't think that private schools on LI are better than the public schools, and this article captures the essence of what I hope for my future kids in my public SD.

Posted 8/29/13 5:26 PM
 

CunningOne
***

Member since 5/05

26975 total posts

Name:

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

I'm a pretty bad, bad parent. Go ME!

Posted 8/29/13 5:49 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

Posted by LovesMike

Diamondgirl-I feel the same.

My own education is a mix of public and private and, if I could go back, I might change it to all public-if not for the cost alone! I definitely don't think the private education was any better than the public-quite the opposite. There was a lot of entitled, presumptuous kids that never really understood how hard I worked to be there. I'm comparing private undergrad, but there were kids whose parents paid for them to be there without the grades, credentials, or 3 summer jobs that I juggled!

I don't think that private schools on LI are better than the public schools, and this article captures the essence of what I hope for my future kids in my public SD.



I had a mix as well, I loved my college and graduate experience at private schools but I appreciate public education.

Posted 8/29/13 5:53 PM
 

seaside
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

3101 total posts

Name:

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

Meh. People on both sides of this "debate" nationwide need to step back and realize that it's not a debate--it's a choice.

People need to spend their money on what they think will be the best use for them and not feel defensive or like they have less because of someone else choice.

I also hate generalizations about what kind of people go to private schools or what public or private schools have or lack. It's such a school by school thing.

For me, education is a top priority, and IF I felt that a local private school was better (based on my definition of better) than the public school, I wouldn't hesitate. No apologies. No guilt. Nothing I'd be taking away from anyone else's kids.

Posted 8/29/13 8:32 PM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

Posted by seaside

Meh. People on both sides of this "debate" nationwide need to step back and realize that it's not a debate--it's a choice.

People need to spend their money on what they think will be the best use for them and not feel defensive or like they have less because of someone else choice.

I also hate generalizations about what kind of people go to private schools or what public or private schools have or lack. It's such a school by school thing.

For me, education is a top priority, and IF I felt that a local private school was better (based on my definition of better) than the public school, I wouldn't hesitate. No apologies. No guilt. Nothing I'd be taking away from anyone else's kids.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/29/13 8:39 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

Posted by seaside

Meh. People on both sides of this "debate" nationwide need to step back and realize that it's not a debate--it's a choice.

People need to spend their money on what they think will be the best use for them and not feel defensive or like they have less because of someone else choice.

I also hate generalizations about what kind of people go to private schools or what public or private schools have or lack. It's such a school by school thing.

For me, education is a top priority, and IF I felt that a local private school was better (based on my definition of better) than the public school, I wouldn't hesitate. No apologies. No guilt. Nothing I'd be taking away from anyone else's kids.



These are very valid points and I agree. I will say *for me* I would really try to live in area where my children were able to have a (good) public education, specifically K-8, HS and college I would be open to a private school option.

Posted 8/29/13 9:03 PM
 

shadows
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

4694 total posts

Name:

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

Posted by eroxgirl

That's one of the worst arguments for public school that I've ever read.

My local school sucks and it's not good enough for my children, so I pay for private. If that makes me bad, so be it.



Chat Icon

I find this article totally ridiculous

Posted 8/29/13 9:22 PM
 

MommaG
Yay Spring!

Member since 5/05

5133 total posts

Name:
Gloria

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

Posted by DiamondGirl

I adore this article.

I really relate to what the author said here:

going to school with poor kids and rich kids, black kids and brown kids, smart kids and not-so-smart ones, kids with superconservative Christian parents and other upper-middle-class Jews like me was its own education and life preparation. Reading Walt Whitman in ninth grade changed the way you see the world? Well, getting drunk before basketball games with kids who lived at the trailer park near my house did the same for me. In fact it’s part of the reason I feel so strongly about public schools.

I went to public school in Queens, while the neighborhood I grew up in is an expensive area, going to public school in the 80's and 90's meant busing, I went to school with all types of kids. I grew up white, upper middle class and the exposure I got as a public school student to people of other races, socioeconomic backgrounds, religions is invaluable to molding who I am today.

I honestly believe that I am better in my career and as a person bc of this social learning, learning that could not and did not (I know bc friends of mine went there) happen at my local catholic school.

I would also like to add that I attended CCD (religion class) once a week, I also attended mass with my family every sunday, my parents are devout Catholics and they as well as my religion classes taught me my religion. I do not say this to say that those who send their kids to Catholic are wrong, everyone should do what works for them but I say this to say that you can go to public school and be raised a practicing Catholic who knows as much about their religion as a Catholic school kid.




For my DS, it's just the opposite. He goes to Catholic school, and his school has a huge mix of people from various racial and ethnic backgrounds, whereas if he went to public school, it would be something like 96% white. He has rich and poor kids in his school, and even children who are not Catholic. I feel he is getting a better overall education even though I live in what is considered to be a good district (his school did better than all the local schools on those new core curriculum tests or whatever they're called).

I think everyone should just make the decision that's right for them with no apologies or judgments.

Posted 8/30/13 12:00 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

Posted by MommaG

Posted by DiamondGirl

I adore this article.

I really relate to what the author said here:

going to school with poor kids and rich kids, black kids and brown kids, smart kids and not-so-smart ones, kids with superconservative Christian parents and other upper-middle-class Jews like me was its own education and life preparation. Reading Walt Whitman in ninth grade changed the way you see the world? Well, getting drunk before basketball games with kids who lived at the trailer park near my house did the same for me. In fact it’s part of the reason I feel so strongly about public schools.

I went to public school in Queens, while the neighborhood I grew up in is an expensive area, going to public school in the 80's and 90's meant busing, I went to school with all types of kids. I grew up white, upper middle class and the exposure I got as a public school student to people of other races, socioeconomic backgrounds, religions is invaluable to molding who I am today.

I honestly believe that I am better in my career and as a person bc of this social learning, learning that could not and did not (I know bc friends of mine went there) happen at my local catholic school.

I would also like to add that I attended CCD (religion class) once a week, I also attended mass with my family every sunday, my parents are devout Catholics and they as well as my religion classes taught me my religion. I do not say this to say that those who send their kids to Catholic are wrong, everyone should do what works for them but I say this to say that you can go to public school and be raised a practicing Catholic who knows as much about their religion as a Catholic school kid.




For my DS, it's just the opposite. He goes to Catholic school, and his school has a huge mix of people from various racial and ethnic backgrounds, whereas if he went to public school, it would be something like 96% white. He has rich and poor kids in his school, and even children who are not Catholic. I feel he is getting a better overall education even though I live in what is considered to be a good district (his school did better than all the local schools on those new core curriculum tests or whatever they're called).

I think everyone should just make the decision that's right for them with no apologies or judgments.



Yes I suppose it really does depend on the area. Also when the author says "private school" I think she means a fancy private school as opposed to you're local Catholic school.

Reality is a childs success or failure depends more on what goes on in their in home than their classroom.

Posted 8/30/13 8:03 AM
 

Lola0703
LIF Adolescent

Member since 4/07

677 total posts

Name:

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

Posted by MommaG

Posted by DiamondGirl

I adore this article.

I really relate to what the author said here:

going to school with poor kids and rich kids, black kids and brown kids, smart kids and not-so-smart ones, kids with superconservative Christian parents and other upper-middle-class Jews like me was its own education and life preparation. Reading Walt Whitman in ninth grade changed the way you see the world? Well, getting drunk before basketball games with kids who lived at the trailer park near my house did the same for me. In fact it’s part of the reason I feel so strongly about public schools.

I went to public school in Queens, while the neighborhood I grew up in is an expensive area, going to public school in the 80's and 90's meant busing, I went to school with all types of kids. I grew up white, upper middle class and the exposure I got as a public school student to people of other races, socioeconomic backgrounds, religions is invaluable to molding who I am today.

I honestly believe that I am better in my career and as a person bc of this social learning, learning that could not and did not (I know bc friends of mine went there) happen at my local catholic school.

I would also like to add that I attended CCD (religion class) once a week, I also attended mass with my family every sunday, my parents are devout Catholics and they as well as my religion classes taught me my religion. I do not say this to say that those who send their kids to Catholic are wrong, everyone should do what works for them but I say this to say that you can go to public school and be raised a practicing Catholic who knows as much about their religion as a Catholic school kid.




For my DS, it's just the opposite. He goes to Catholic school, and his school has a huge mix of people from various racial and ethnic backgrounds, whereas if he went to public school, it would be something like 96% white. He has rich and poor kids in his school, and even children who are not Catholic. I feel he is getting a better overall education even though I live in what is considered to be a good district (his school did better than all the local schools on those new core curriculum tests or whatever they're called).

I think everyone should just make the decision that's right for them with no apologies or judgments.



I agree with you. I went to Catholic school my from K through 12. My school had a huge mix of people from all different backgrounds, racial, cultural, ecomomic, etc. It was a wonderful experience for me. To this day I have friends from all different walks of life.

In my opinion it's not just rich kids that go to private schools. I came from a blue collar, working class neighborhood in Queens. My parents worked hard to send us to Catholic school. They had no choice. My zoned public school was not an option as it was not safe especially in the late 80's early 90's.

Posted 8/30/13 9:26 AM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

I definitely had the same experience that a few other Catholic school folks are reporting. The students in my schools were from all racial, cultural, religious, economic, etc. backgrounds.

I also know A LOT about MANY religions because we were taught it on a daily basis.

Again, I don't think one is better than the other in the sense of general terms. I had a phenomenal schooling experience, so I'll do the same for my kids...just as parents who believe in public school will do for theirs. As someone else said, it's not a debate. It's just what personally works.

Posted 8/30/13 9:42 AM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: Slate article: Private v. public school

Posted by MommaG

For my DS, it's just the opposite. He goes to Catholic school, and his school has a huge mix of people from various racial and ethnic backgrounds, whereas if he went to public school, it would be something like 96% white. He has rich and poor kids in his school, and even children who are not Catholic. I feel he is getting a better overall education even though I live in what is considered to be a good district (his school did better than all the local schools on those new core curriculum tests or whatever they're called).

I think everyone should just make the decision that's right for them with no apologies or judgments.



We have the same circumstances, I wonder if we're in the same school-- I just couldn't get excited about our school district (which happens to be like 99% white and kind of middle/upper-middle class) so I decided to send our kids to the local Catholic school (which happens to be very diverse, both racially and economically). I could not be happier with my choice. But I'm sure lots of people in our school district our just as happy with their choice, for different reasons. Different strokes...

Posted 8/30/13 10:12 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Private vs Public school brownie 3/7/11 3 Parents of School-Aged Children
Public vs Private School AJsmom10 1/28/11 5 Parents of School-Aged Children
Going to public school after Private Kindergarten? CaidensMommy 6/11/10 3 Parents of School-Aged Children
Private Elementary School vs. Public Elementary MammaPappaBear 1/17/10 14 Parenting
Question about Private School/Public Schooling! Luvlylady 3/5/08 26 Families Helping Families ™
Private vs. Public School for kids Lauren 11/30/06 54 Families Helping Families ™