Should Pre-K Students Have Homework Assignments?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: Should Pre-K Students Have Homework Assignments?

Posted by KartveliT

Posted by KennysMommy

No and neither should kindergarten kiddos! They're so little!!!!! Let kids be kids!

ITA.
If you want your kid to "learn" at a very early age then work with your child yourself. My DD knows everything from what DH and I teach her and have taught her since she was a baby just by playing games, reading, singing, stories and whatever else it might be... just making it fun for her.... she hasn't really learned anything new at preK and I didn't expect her to (other than learning how to be in school setting , socializing , interacting with other kids/teachers) everything they "learn" at her preK she already knows.
I would actually be pretty annoyed if she came home with homework from preK or even kindergarten..



ITA

I would be annoyed as well if DC had homework in pre k, kinder

Posted 2/28/11 9:55 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

SweetCin
My green-eyed boy

Member since 5/05

13499 total posts

Name:
Cin

Re: Should Pre-K Students Have Homework Assignments?

As a Pre-K teacher I assign HW that goes home on Monday & it is due on Friday (a letter sheet, tracing & then writing the letter of the week & coloring something in w/ specific colors) & since Jan. we've also been working on numbers, so they have 1 worksheet due on Thursday writing that number & adding that amount of things into the jar.

Every year I have parents asking for additional homework & then others who for whatever reason, don't hand it in or are totally shocked w/ HW in Pre-K.

In class we don't outright do addition & subtraction, yet we do it in our everyday learning. You all ready have 2 blue beads, how many more do you need to finish Cookie Monster's face.

IMO in K they DEFINITELY need HW as the things they learn in K these days are what was previously learned in 1st. Children are learning to read, do addition/subtraction, going to Science/computers/spanish, etc.

Posted 2/28/11 10:13 PM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Should Pre-K Students Have Homework Assignments?

My daughter receives a homework packet with about 5 to 6 pages every week.

The work is varied: tracing and then writing letters, tracing and then writing numbers, tracing shapes, counting, matching, etc.

The pages are fun and take about 1 minute to do each. Perfect for her attention span.

At first I thought it was ridiculous but now I really see a big change in her. She has learned a lot more than a I thought she was capable of and I know she will be well prepared for next year.

Posted 2/28/11 10:31 PM
 

mommy0604
My Son is my world...

Member since 10/07

3270 total posts

Name:

Re: Should Pre-K Students Have Homework Assignments?

Posted by Sassyz75

The work is varied: tracing and then writing letters, tracing and then writing numbers, tracing shapes, counting, matching, etc.





That's exactly what I do with my son. The worksheets I do are varied. That's why for me it makes no difference if he gets homework in Pre-K or not.

I understand that Kindergarten is another story and they should be getting homework.

Posted 2/28/11 10:54 PM
 

pnbplus1
Family

Member since 5/09

5751 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Should Pre-K Students Have Homework Assignments?

HW in Pre-K is ridiculous! I can't understand why people have forgotten that the most important activity in early childhood is PLAY. They learn so many things about the world, how things work, physics, logic, math, etc just from playing. They need to be able to explore, learn on their own, use their imagination.

I am always saddened when i read things like this, I do not want DS to be immersed in a strictly academic environment initially. There is so much time to focus on academics, to have test points drilled into him (which i don't consider learning), to have the pressure of being a good test taker - I want him to PLAY in pre-school and Kindergarten. I need to find a school that focuses on play more than test-taking and strictly traditional academic skills and ways of learning.

Message edited 2011-03-01 08:03:21.053000.

Posted 3/1/11 7:45 AM
 

CunningOne
***

Member since 5/05

26975 total posts

Name:

Re: Should Pre-K Students Have Homework Assignments?

Neither of my kids had HW in pre-K. Kindergarten was another story! They had a lot!

Posted 3/1/11 7:48 AM
 

pnbplus1
Family

Member since 5/09

5751 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Should Pre-K Students Have Homework Assignments?

Posted by SweetCin

IMO in K they DEFINITELY need HW as the things they learn in K these days are what was previously learned in 1st. .



See, I have such a problem with this. Why are they learning these things earlier? I didn't yet I managed to turn out fine. Play keeps getting pushed out of Pre-K and K without regard for the implications of this when they get older. The studies on the detriment of not letting kids just play in school are just coming out now so it will be a long time before things change, if they ever do, given the importantance placed on test scores.

Editted to delete something not necessary.

Message edited 2011-03-01 08:04:20.093000.

Posted 3/1/11 7:49 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Should Pre-K Students Have Homework Assignments?

My daughter's preschool class has one or two homework assignments a week, but they are usually very creative, fun assignments, not worksheets. Once a week they have "secret sound" where each child is assigned a letter of the alphabet, and have to cut out of a magazine something that starts with that letter. For a week when they were learning about the solar system, the moon and outer space, her teacher sent home a journal and every night I had to take Alex outside to observe the night sky and the atmosphere, and then draw her observations in the journal. Or, last week, in celebration of the 100th day of school, each child had to bring 100 items of something, anything, and the parents were asked to help their children count out the items, put them in a bag and bring them to school. It's little assignments like that... I don't mind at all, I think they're fun!

As for lesson plans... Alex's class is particularly mature, so the teacher has developed a more sophisticated plan for the year. The children are learning basic math and most of them are starting to read at this point, and write. Alex even read her first book all by herself a few nights ago Chat Icon

I AM worried that Alex is going to be VERY bored in kindergarten next year, and her preschool teacher even confessed to me that this is the largest complaint she gets from parents, that the kids are overprepared for kindergarten and are bored when they get there. And I am very mindful that Alex NEVER feels any kind of pressure - I like the way that the teacher is doing it - she has a feel for the class and their maturity level, and adapts her lesson plans to THEIR ability and interest. As a result, Alex is having the time of her life, and is truly learning to LOVE to learn, which is the most important lesson of all.

Message edited 2011-03-01 08:37:47.957000.

Posted 3/1/11 8:36 AM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Should Pre-K Students Have Homework Assignments?

Posted by pnbplus1

Posted by SweetCin

IMO in K they DEFINITELY need HW as the things they learn in K these days are what was previously learned in 1st. .



See, I have such a problem with this. Why are they learning these things earlier? .



Now doesnt that make you want to be a teacher? Teaching material that is not age appropriate and feeling like an unsuccessful teacher when they dont get it?

I have to teach my 1st graders to add up coins to over $1.00 and how to make change, yet the standards only call for them to be able to identify the coins by name and value.Chat Icon

Posted 3/1/11 8:38 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Should Pre-K Students Have Homework Assignments?

Posted by pnbplus1

Posted by SweetCin

IMO in K they DEFINITELY need HW as the things they learn in K these days are what was previously learned in 1st. .



See, I have such a problem with this. Why are they learning these things earlier? I didn't yet I managed to turn out fine. Play keeps getting pushed out of Pre-K and K without regard for the implications of this when they get older. The studies on the detriment of not letting kids just play in school are just coming out now so it will be a long time before things change, if they ever do, given the importantance placed on test scores.

Editted to delete something not necessary.



The flip side of this is that, if you don't challenge kids enough in pre-k, they will get bored and start to act out - this is happening in Alex's afternoon class. I think it really comes down to "reading" the interest and ability of the pre-k class and adapting to them to create lesson plans that are challenging and engage them enough to keep them interested, without putting any pressure on them.

Posted 3/1/11 8:39 AM
 

mommy0604
My Son is my world...

Member since 10/07

3270 total posts

Name:

Re: Should Pre-K Students Have Homework Assignments?

Posted by pnbplus1

Posted by SweetCin

IMO in K they DEFINITELY need HW as the things they learn in K these days are what was previously learned in 1st. .



See, I have such a problem with this. Why are they learning these things earlier? I didn't yet I managed to turn out fine. Play keeps getting pushed out of Pre-K and K without regard for the implications of this when they get older. The studies on the detriment of not letting kids just play in school are just coming out now so it will be a long time before things change, if they ever do, given the importantance placed on test scores.

Editted to delete something not necessary.



Totally agree. When I was 4 I didn't need Pre-K cuz that's what Kindergarten was for. What the preschool kids are doing now was K for me. I didn't start learning to read until 1st grade and we're talking sight words. In 2nd grade came reading sentences and so forth. I get it that times are different now and the kids need to be challenged more but bottom line is that kids are still kids and they still need that playtime and socializing part. I feel like too much is being focused on academics. My son has learned so much through playtime as well. For me the socialization was a big part because he's such a shy boy. He's gotten much better and I give the school a lot of credit for that.

I remember last year in the 3 year old classroom my DH and I went to parent teacher conference in may and I was all concerned because some of the kids were already writing letters and even their names and here was my son who couldn't even hold a crayon or a pencil the right way (but he did manage to know how to write some letters). I was like "how is he going to go into pre-k when he can't even hold a pencil or crayon the right way"...One of the first things the teacher told me was to relax because it's not like they were going to sit him down the first day of pre-k and tell him to write his name. She also said that right now it was all about socialization with my shy son and how well he had progressed. So I stopped worrying about it.

Well guess what? after about 2 weeks since the 1st day of school he was writing his name (first name) I was like Chat Icon I couldn't believe it! I said to the teacher: Does he know how to spell his name or are you telling him the letters to write: She was like "nope he's spelling it on his own"...and right before the x-mas break he started learning to spell his last name and can now write his full name. He still needs to work on his fine motor skills but he has progressed some...He now needs to work on how to cut with scissors...Chat Icon The Teacher's Asst. Says he's showing signs of hold the scissors better. See these are the things i'm focusing on...not adding, subtracting, coin counting, etc. etc. there is time for that in K or 1st grade or whatever...LOL

Message edited 2011-03-01 11:16:46.533000.

Posted 3/1/11 11:15 AM
 

Tine73

Member since 3/06

22093 total posts

Name:
*********

Re: Should Pre-K Students Have Homework Assignments?

DD is moving into the Pre-K room in a month or so instead of September and she already has one page of homework each night except for Fridays. She loves it and I think it's great that she is learning what homework is even if it only takes minutes to complete.

Posted 3/1/11 11:37 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
X-post...Pre-K homework opinions needed ! Bops 10/22/09 0 Teachers
Pre-K homework help needed ! -UPDATE Bops 10/22/09 19 Parenting