Should everyone get equally?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Should everyone get equally? If one child is helped out financially by the parents should the other kid(s) be given to as well? Message edited 2006-03-08 14:45:41.940000. |
|
Posted 3/8/06 2:45 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? If they need it I would say yes-although Iguess it depends on the parents financial status |
|
Posted 3/8/06 3:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? My mom had this problem with one of her sisters. My aunt got money when she bought her house because my grandparents moved into the house with them. When she got a divorce & sold the house she got the money that my grandparents had given to her. It was later changed in the will that she would get that minused out of whatever my grandparents left the 3 girls because she already got a portion of her inheritance. Unfortunately nobody ever thinks they won't speak to their sisters or brothers but money always makes people crazy. If you want talk to your parents to come to an agreement. |
|
Posted 3/8/06 4:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? my thoughts are if you give to one you give to all, my grandma helped out my uncle when he could not find an apartment so he lived there for about 9 months, sicne she was helping him out she made sure that she gave the other kids a "little something" since she knew she saved my uncle 9 minths worth if rent (which could of easilybeen a few thousand dollars). I think this is the proper way to do it. If one of my kids asked to borrow money I would make sure i gave to othe others too, or at least let them know they could count on us if ever needed. |
|
Posted 3/8/06 4:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? I agree it should be fair, but that kids shouldn't expect handouts forever. MIL and I were talking about this recently - she has friends who have bought an apt, paid off about $30k in debt, and paid for an engagement ring for their son. They gave their daughter almost the same amount for a downpayment on a house and baby furniture. |
|
Posted 3/8/06 4:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? There are four of us and my father won't ever GIVE anything to one of us without giving to all of us (loans are another story)...............my brothers even got "sweet 16" money b/c my sister and I had a party. |
|
Posted 3/9/06 10:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? no |
|
Posted 3/9/06 10:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? Posted by betty There are four of us and my father won't ever GIVE anything to one of us without giving to all of us (loans are another story)...............my brothers even got "sweet 16" money b/c my sister and I had a party. same with us- since neither one of my parents were treated equally- they make/made sure everyone was even my Brother got a car in place of my sweet 16 I am curious to see what happend when mybrother gets engaged- b/c my Dad paid for my wedding- but on the other hand- he has been helping my brother pay his rent for the last 3 years- |
|
Posted 3/9/06 11:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? I think adult children should never expect their parents to give them money - they should be able to support themselves. |
|
Posted 3/9/06 11:39 AM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? i think in that article I read it was "children should be treated with equity not treated equally" |
|
Posted 3/9/06 1:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? In my family things are very different. Each child's case is reviewed. |
|
Posted 3/9/06 2:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? Posted by emilain If one child is helped out financially by the parents should the other kid(s) be given to as well? If they need help yes, but I don't see any reason to have to pay the other kids to justify helping one of their kids that needs it. |
|
Posted 3/9/06 2:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? Posted by csorisi It was later changed in the will that she would get that minused out of whatever my grandparents left the 3 girls because she already got a portion of her inheritance. I was just talking about this with my mother. I think this is fair. Assuming everyone is healthy and no one is disabled, everything should be equal. If someone neesd money that the parent was planning on bequeathing, there is nothing wrong with giving them that money. But to be fair, it should be deducted from the inheritance. That way it all ends up even. Although sometimes fairness isn't always best. My aunt moved to Paris 25 years ago and my mom took care of both her parents as they got older. My grandmother was bed ridden for the last 10 years of her life and my mom would take care of her (along with the nurses), change her, etc... My sister and I took our grandparents to their doctors appointments, and I woudl take my grandfather to chemo when I wasn't working. My aunt would visit once a year, and stay with us- so she really didn't take care of my grandparents at all and I saw all the work my mom did- especially after my dad died and she also had to take care of his dad. I thought my mom deserved more than my aunt. |
|
Posted 3/9/06 4:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? I think the main thing is the resentment that builds, when one child is being helped out financially it causes great resentment in the other kids. I think it's a sticky situation, bt I personally would not give to 1 without giving or at least saying something to othe others about giving equally! Message edited 2006-03-09 16:30:30.007000. |
|
Posted 3/9/06 4:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? I totally get that, that is why I think it should all be out in the open, and the other kids should know about it. I can't tell you how many people have "surprises" at the reading of the will. |
|
Posted 3/9/06 4:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? I think so. Growing up we were always treated very fairly. |
|
Posted 3/9/06 4:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? Posted by emilain If one child is helped out financially by the parents should the other kid(s) be given to as well? if they need it yes |
|
Posted 3/9/06 5:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? I really think every situation needs to be judged separately. I sometimes think that the idea that one child was given something they needed, so the others have to get the same, regardless of need can create greedy monsters. If you're talking about a large sum of money, then I think deducting it from the inheritance in the end is acceptable. You never know what is going to happen over time. If one child needs now, another may need later on. If you constantly spend your time making everything "even" you'll either go broke or drive yourself nuts. I agree with giving $ to a son who didn't have a sweet 16 where a daughter did, or giving each child the same amount for a wedding -- whether to pay for it or as a gift, but just giving to children because another child needs, is unnecessary. If adult children can't understand that their siblings need something at one point that they don't need, then they need to reflect on their attitudes. This is all just my opinion. |
|
Posted 3/11/06 4:00 AM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? Posted by Sassyz75 no i actually red a psychological study that it should be based on NEED. that actually children like to be treated and recognized to be different and have different needs. I was also going to say this. I grew up thinking that everyone should get the same (especially since my mother was so anal about this). But then I took a class and the professor said that "fairness is not that everyone gets the same, but that everyone gets what they need." People have different needs and someone should not be given something that they don't need just because someone else got that. Now, I learned this on an educational perspective... If a child needs to have someone read his test to him because he has a disability, does that mean that everyone in the class should have the test read to them? No, because they don't need it. As long as everyone receives what they need, then there is fairness. |
|
Posted 3/11/06 6:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? Posted by VirginiaDeb Posted by Sassyz75 no i actually red a psychological study that it should be based on NEED. that actually children like to be treated and recognized to be different and have different needs. I was also going to say this. I grew up thinking that everyone should get the same (especially since my mother was so anal about this). But then I took a class and the professor said that "fairness is not that everyone gets the same, but that everyone gets what they need." People have different needs and someone should not be given something that they don't need just because someone else got that. Now, I learned this on an educational perspective... If a child needs to have someone read his test to him because he has a disability, does that mean that everyone in the class should have the test read to them? No, because they don't need it. As long as everyone receives what they need, then there is fairness. I agree with this. My mom was just talking about this with me, and she helped me with my wedding...Now some would say my brother deserves the same amount, but he is a lawyer in NYC making $$$$$$$ and though he has law school loans, he is making oodles of money and I chose to be poor and work in education. I've been thinking about this a lot lately though, and I think it does grown children a disservice to support them well into their 20s. I think when I become a parent I will emphasize giving my children the tools to become self-supporting (paying for education, etc.), but not pay for their rent, food, etc. I feel like when this happens not only do grown children expect this support, but it becomes learned dependence and they do not push or strive to become self-supporting. I've lived a lot of places, and it seems only on LI do I see so many grown children so reliant on their parents to pay their bills and support themselves. When I graduated college I was working on Wall Street and was so thankful for my mom's support throughout college that I spent my first paycheck buying her a computer. It felt amazing to know that I was sone being helped and could finally help in return. |
|
Posted 3/13/06 8:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? everyone has made such great points, I guess what is boils down to is "need", if one child is struggling to make ends meet and has watched another child be catered to when they were "able" to care for themselves but chose not to, that is where the conflict lies. I think if a child is being helped/supported for ridiculous reasons (doesn't want to move out, doesn't want to change jobs, etc) then the other child should be compensated too. |
|
Posted 3/14/06 8:21 AM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? My husband and I represent two ends of the spectrum. My Mom was always very into us being independed. She is not someone who will help you out of financial trouble or give loans without her arm being twisted. My in laws on the other hand ae very generous with both of their kids and if they have it it's yours. I feel sad as it is to say that my husband has a better relationship wth his parents than I do with my Mom because this makes me resent her sometimes. I am trying to get over this because I realize it is kind of superficial but I do tend to have these feelings. My Dad will help when he can but he is not rolling in it. |
|
Posted 3/14/06 1:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? Posted by Sassyz75 no i actually red a psychological study that it should be based on NEED. that actually children like to be treated and recognized to be different and have different needs. totally agree on the need part. |
|
Posted 3/15/06 10:38 AM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? I don't think it should be equal. I can't imagine saying well my brother got this, so I want it too! |
|
Posted 3/15/06 11:17 AM
|
|
|
Re: Should everyone get equally? Posted by Sassyz75 no i actually red a psychological study that it should be based on NEED. that actually children like to be treated and recognized to be different and have different needs. i agree |
|
Posted 4/4/06 6:04 AM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |



















