Shoplifting Question? Any lawyers?

Posted By Message

SuperHotSauce
LIF Infant

Member since 6/10

53 total posts

Name:

Shoplifting Question? Any lawyers?

My friend was caught shoplifting as a teenager and spent the night in jail, paid a fine, and did community service. That was her one and only brush with the law and she believes that her record is sealed as her court appointed lawyer said it would be.

I am not sure if that's the case since she says she's never followed up because she was embarrassed and believed it would automatically be sealed. This is New York City if it matters.

She has a good job now but wants to apply for a different position that may require a background check.

I've tried to encourage her to check if her records are indeed sealed, but she is at a loss of where to start or who to contact. It was so long ago she doesn't have any of the paperwork.

Any advice?

Posted 10/20/10 11:43 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Shoplifting Question? Any lawyers?

Not a lawyer, but speaking from my own experience, I think that she can go to District Court and request a copy of the disposition of the case - that should tell her if it's been sealed or not. She'll have to pay a fee but it's small.

Posted 10/20/10 12:02 PM
 

fins
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/07

821 total posts

Name:

Re: Shoplifting Question? Any lawyers?

not a lawyer either - in my experience from hiring people when there records are sealed it does not come back on our criminal background check....however we fingerprint and it comes back when they run the fingerprints.......

it has happen a few times to people who did little dumb things in college....i.e. a dine and ditch, stealing eggs on halloween from a store, etc. I am not sure why it comes up on the fingerprint check but it does......obviously this did not stop us from hiring but they had to jump through hoops with our home office.

Posted 10/20/10 1:12 PM
 

JDandMe
LIF Adult

Member since 9/10

996 total posts

Name:

Re: Shoplifting Question? Any lawyers?

In NY adult criminal convictions (with the expection of certain drug offensives)can't be sealed.

If it is a juvenile record it is most likely sealed. If she was an adult it is not sealed. Most background check for private companies go back 7 years.

Posted 10/20/10 1:12 PM
 

Cheeks24
Living a dream

Member since 1/08

8589 total posts

Name:
Cheeks

Re: Shoplifting Question? Any lawyers?

Posted by fins

not a lawyer either - in my experience from hiring people when there records are sealed it does not come back on our criminal background check....however we fingerprint and it comes back when they run the fingerprints.......

it has happen a few times to people who did little dumb things in college....i.e. a dine and ditch, stealing eggs on halloween from a store, etc. I am not sure why it comes up on the fingerprint check but it does......obviously this did not stop us from hiring but they had to jump through hoops with our home office.



I would imagine in college people are adult age so it would be a different story.

ETS: Under 18 records are sealed.

Message edited 2010-10-20 14:22:38.917000.

Posted 10/20/10 2:22 PM
 

fins
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/07

821 total posts

Name:

Re: Shoplifting Question? Any lawyers?

Posted by Mici C

Posted by fins

not a lawyer either - in my experience from hiring people when there records are sealed it does not come back on our criminal background check....however we fingerprint and it comes back when they run the fingerprints.......

it has happen a few times to people who did little dumb things in college....i.e. a dine and ditch, stealing eggs on halloween from a store, etc. I am not sure why it comes up on the fingerprint check but it does......obviously this did not stop us from hiring but they had to jump through hoops with our home office.



I would imagine in college people are adult age so it would be a different story.

ETS: Under 18 records are sealed.



True - I didn't even think about the age....

Posted 10/20/10 2:45 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Shoplifting Question? Any lawyers?

Not an attorney either.

I agree to double check but it would also depend on the depth of the background check. The standard background checks for our clients are a 7 year Federal & State criminal background check. Some clients require a 10 year.

If she's going for Top Secret clearance, even if it was sealed, I think she's better of disclosing it. They go back forever. I know someone who jumped a turnstyle when he was a teenager & it came up.

Posted 10/20/10 2:52 PM
 

mom2boys
LIF Infant

Member since 1/08

315 total posts

Name:
marie

Re: Shoplifting Question? Any lawyers?

ETS: Under 18 records are sealed.
Speaking from experince, i had a desk apperance for shoplifting ( wrong place kind of thing) i was under 18 the case was thrown out due tolack of evedince and my recordes sealed.. When figherprinted for vaious things it comes up a sealed file i had to go to the district court and get a copy of what happened.. Never came up in a background check, and not always when begin fingerprinted. Came up after i got my pistol permint, but never came up when i was fingerprinted for a daycare, I dont want to say the system sucks, but i already had my pistol permit a month when i got a call, and again it should have came on when they ran my prints to work in daycare.

Posted 10/20/10 3:09 PM
 

springsandra
Baby girl has a baby brother!

Member since 11/09

7155 total posts

Name:
Sandra

Re: Shoplifting Question? Any lawyers?

Lawyer here...

It depends on what she "plead guilty" to... or if she even plead guilty.

A first arrest for a shoplift often is given an offer of either an Adjournment in Contemplation of Dismissal (ACD) along with a fine, community service, or some sort of program (in Brooklyn there is a program called "stoplift" that's supposed to discourage repeat shoplifting, for example) or an offer of a Violation, which is NOT a crime and not a criminal disposition. It's more like a traffic ticket sort of thing where you can honestly say you've never been convicted of a crime.

However, shoplifting in NY is an A misdemeanor and there is the possibility she plead guilty to that. But no lawyer would've told her that her record would be sealed if she plead to the A misemeanor, so I highly doubt that's what happened.

ACDs are automatically sealed if the person completes the terms of the release (community service / fine /etc) after 6 months as long as the person does not get arrested again. Violations are sealable one year after the disposition, but are NOT always automatically sealed. It is possible for either to come up on a person's criminal record, but more likely for a violation to appear on a record than an ACD. Still, it's not a crime.

The age of majority in NY is 16, not 18, so an arrest over 16 years of age would be treated the same as any other adult. If she were under 16 at the time of the incident, the rules are totally different and she would've been in family court, not criminal court, so I doubt that's applicable here.

Feel free to FM me if you have any other questions about it.

Posted 10/20/10 3:46 PM
 

hazeleyes33
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

13060 total posts

Name:
Ginger

Re: Shoplifting Question? Any lawyers?

Posted by JDandMe

In NY adult criminal convictions (with the expection of certain drug offensives)can't be sealed.

If it is a juvenile record it is most likely sealed. If she was an adult it is not sealed. Most background check for private companies go back 7 years.




Untrue. Adults records could be sealed also.

Posted 10/20/10 3:48 PM
 

fujamaga
Loves her babies!

Member since 5/10

1513 total posts

Name:
Cathy

Re: Shoplifting Question? Any lawyers?

Posted by hazeleyes33

Posted by JDandMe

In NY adult criminal convictions (with the expection of certain drug offensives)can't be sealed.

If it is a juvenile record it is most likely sealed. If she was an adult it is not sealed. Most background check for private companies go back 7 years.




Untrue. Adults records could be sealed also.



lawyer here too - adult records (over 16) can be sealed (also know from a friend's experience Chat Icon )

Posted 10/20/10 5:06 PM
 

SuperHotSauce
LIF Infant

Member since 6/10

53 total posts

Name:

Re: Shoplifting Question? Any lawyers?

thank you all for your responses, they were very helpful Chat Icon

Posted 10/24/10 4:08 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Lawyers..Help BFing at work Question My3Shmoos 6/12/07 3 Parenting
dumb question on lawyers dbleplay17 3/17/07 4 Home
Any lawyers? I have a small claims question pinkandblue 3/14/07 0 Families Helping Families ™
Repost from Parenting Board: Question for lawyers/legal assistants about work as a legal assistant Mommy2Boys 1/28/07 5 Families Helping Families ™
Question for lawyers/legal assistants about work as a legal assistant Mommy2Boys 1/28/07 2 Parenting