Re: Shoplifting Question? Any lawyers?
Posted 10/20/2010 3:46:28 PM by springsandra

Lawyer here...

It depends on what she "plead guilty" to... or if she even plead guilty.

A first arrest for a shoplift often is given an offer of either an Adjournment in Contemplation of Dismissal (ACD) along with a fine, community service, or some sort of program (in Brooklyn there is a program called "stoplift" that's supposed to discourage repeat shoplifting, for example) or an offer of a Violation, which is NOT a crime and not a criminal disposition. It's more like a traffic ticket sort of thing where you can honestly say you've never been convicted of a crime.

However, shoplifting in NY is an A misdemeanor and there is the possibility she plead guilty to that. But no lawyer would've told her that her record would be sealed if she plead to the A misemeanor, so I highly doubt that's what happened.

ACDs are automatically sealed if the person completes the terms of the release (community service / fine /etc) after 6 months as long as the person does not get arrested again. Violations are sealable one year after the disposition, but are NOT always automatically sealed. It is possible for either to come up on a person's criminal record, but more likely for a violation to appear on a record than an ACD. Still, it's not a crime.

The age of majority in NY is 16, not 18, so an arrest over 16 years of age would be treated the same as any other adult. If she were under 16 at the time of the incident, the rules are totally different and she would've been in family court, not criminal court, so I doubt that's applicable here.

Feel free to FM me if you have any other questions about it.
Print Post      Close Window