Shock Treatments
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Shock Treatments I am surious what others feel about this... |
|
Posted 3/21/06 3:10 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Shock Treatments I think it's cruel and the parents have every right to oppose it. Do you think it would be ok (or more acceptable) if the parents consented to shock therapy? |
|
Posted 3/21/06 3:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments I'm confused. It seems like some parents are aware and some aren't. |
|
Posted 3/21/06 3:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments Posted by MrsS2005 I think it's cruel and the parents have every right to oppose it. Do you think it would be ok (or more acceptable) if the parents consented to shock therapy? i don't really think of this as shock therapy...as in ECT and i think that this kind of thing is abuse and terribly out dated Sick what people will think helps their child |
|
Posted 3/21/06 3:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments Posted by leighla I'm confused. It seems like some parents are aware and some aren't. I am opposed to it if parents aren't consented. But if the parents are on board and the kids are on board and it's helping them I don't see why it's a problem. because things like this get ABUSED very easily and relatively doesn't teach them anything other than pain or discomfort |
|
Posted 3/21/06 3:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments I have a problem with it because it concerns children. I saw this on the news and I have been thinking about it a lot. I understand that parents have a hard time with children like this, but I wonder if children in this condition are capable of consenting to the treatment. Some parents are going to consent to whatever makes the child easier to control, and I know that their lives are incredibly difficult, caring for a child like this. |
|
Posted 3/21/06 3:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments don't agree with it at all. and this statement pretty much sums it up for me: |
|
Posted 3/21/06 3:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments Posted by dpli I have a problem with it because it concerns children. I saw this on the news and I have been thinking about it a lot. I understand that parents have a hard time with children like this, but I wonder if children in this condition are capable of consenting to the treatment. Some parents are going to consent to whatever makes the child easier to control, and I know that their lives are incredibly difficult, caring for a child like this. However, I read an autobiographical story recently of an adult woman, who was a therapist who had undergone shock treatment for her depression when nothing else was working. She claimed it helped her a great deal and she is much better after having the shock treatment. Sometimes these articles raise more questions for me than give answers. these are two entirely different things ECT, shock treatments are used for Depression and are in fact proven to be useful the shock that they above article describes is completely differnt... it is aversion techniques... so if someone was to go to hit themselve they would send a quick shock to the body that hurt them to stop the behavior...Like a police tazer... these are very differet things |
|
Posted 3/21/06 3:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments I agree with it so long as there is parental consent. I think therapy can only go so far in some cases...You can counsel someone to try to change their behavior, but at the root they must understand their behavior is wrong. As a last resort, this affects the physiological system when the psychological system is unable or unwilling to change. |
|
Posted 3/21/06 3:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments Posted by Redhead these are two entirely different things ECT, shock treatments are used for Depression and are in fact proven to be useful the shock that they above article describes is completely differnt... it is aversion techniques... so if someone was to go to hit themselve they would send a quick shock to the body that hurt them to stop the behavior...Like a police tazer... these are very differet things I guess I was thinking about the whole idea of using any type of shock to the body and grouping them together. I do think there is room for a lot of abuse in what they are describing in the article. I think these parents are so desperate for something to work that they consent to it, thinking that they have no other choice. ETA: I just looked at the article again - it doesn't say whether these students have a choice in whether or not they go to this school, or are assigned to it, and if they are assigned there, are the parents asked for consent to this technique in advance? Or did I miss that? Message edited 2006-03-21 15:44:40.563000. |
|
Posted 3/21/06 3:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments Posted by nov04libride I agree with it so long as there is parental consent. I think therapy can only go so far in some cases...You can counsel someone to try to change their behavior, but at the root they must understand their behavior is wrong. As a last resort, this affects the physiological system when the psychological system is unable or unwilling to change. I think if this was offered as a method of weight control plenty of people would line up because they are unable to stop themselves and need this physiological intervention. honestly that just isn't true you don't have to truly understand behavior to change it... ETA...they have used stuff like this for behavior control...usually is ineffective Message edited 2006-03-21 15:44:30.487000. |
|
Posted 3/21/06 3:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments Posted by Redhead Posted by nov04libride I agree with it so long as there is parental consent. I think therapy can only go so far in some cases...You can counsel someone to try to change their behavior, but at the root they must understand their behavior is wrong. As a last resort, this affects the physiological system when the psychological system is unable or unwilling to change. I think if this was offered as a method of weight control plenty of people would line up because they are unable to stop themselves and need this physiological intervention. honestly that just isn't true you don't have to truly understand behavior to change it... ETA...they have used stuff like this for behavior control...usually is ineffective Understand that it is wrong, and want to change it. Someone can say don't hit that person, but unless the person realizes it was wrong and wants to change the punishment or words from an authoritative figure will have little long-term effect. I don't think I would ever use this on a child of mine, but I'm not in this situation. I would hope parents have exhausted all other options. Message edited 2006-03-21 15:51:06.573000. |
|
Posted 3/21/06 3:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments Posted by nov04libride Understand that it is wrong, and want to change it. Someone can say don't hit that person, but unless the person realizes it was wrong and wants to change the punishment or words from an authoritative figure will have little long-term effect. I don't think I would ever use this on a child of mine, but I'm not in this situation. I would hope parents have exhausted all other options. what i am saying is wrong is that the method of it and it being linked to the only way to teach someone of profoundly/severely retarded, autistic of of any mental illness is actually WRONG. Hurting someone to get them to stop isn't really doing anything...and it never lasts. You can in fact look at a persons behavior, try to figure out why the person is doing what they are doing and create method of ALL TYPES of people to stop the behavior. This kind of thing is considered abuse in NY. And i think it is sad that it still goes on... THANKFULLY these places are slowly being shut down... And it is sad that these parents THINK that by shocking their child is the way to go... It is an illusion of change |
|
Posted 3/21/06 3:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments I would have to agree w/ 04 bride that if a parent gives the consent to use it then so be it. I think it's a tough call when we are not in these parents shoes, if I had a daughter w/ mental disabilities and felt I was at my wit's end then maybe I would opt for this type of therapy. I don't know, I really think I would have to be in the situation to know what I would do. |
|
Posted 3/21/06 3:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments Posted by Redhead Posted by nov04libride Understand that it is wrong, and want to change it. Someone can say don't hit that person, but unless the person realizes it was wrong and wants to change the punishment or words from an authoritative figure will have little long-term effect. I don't think I would ever use this on a child of mine, but I'm not in this situation. I would hope parents have exhausted all other options. what i am saying is wrong is that the method of it and it being linked to the only way to teach someone of profoundly/severely retarded, autistic of of any mental illness is actually WRONG. Hurting someone to get them to stop isn't really doing anything...and it never lasts. You can in fact look at a persons behavior, try to figure out why the person is doing what they are doing and create method of ALL TYPES of people to stop the behavior. This kind of thing is considered abuse in NY. And i think it is sad that it still goes on... THANKFULLY these places are slowly being shut down... And it is sad that these parents THINK that by shocking their child is the way to go... It is an illusion of change I'll admit that I finally stopped sucking my thumb at 8 when my father kept putting the disgusting tasting stuff on it every day. Soon the desire just wasn't there anymore, and he stopped with the gross tasting stuff. |
|
Posted 3/21/06 3:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments true...but at age 8 you were able to understand more than the average severely retarded and autistic kid/adult will ever... Message edited 2006-03-21 16:02:46.000000. |
|
Posted 3/21/06 4:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments So then do you believe in the Placebo Effect? |
|
Posted 3/21/06 4:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments Posted by leighla So then do you believe in the Placebo Effect? If it's helping, it's helping. Even if it is an illusion of helping. I'm not saying this should be the first choice, but it sounds like they've exhausted other options so this is their last resort. i don't believe it is helping at all... and since for the most part this isn't done in all of NY state...there are other options out there |
|
Posted 3/21/06 4:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments Posted by Redhead Posted by leighla So then do you believe in the Placebo Effect? If it's helping, it's helping. Even if it is an illusion of helping. I'm not saying this should be the first choice, but it sounds like they've exhausted other options so this is their last resort. i don't believe it is helping at all... and since for the most part this isn't done in all of NY state...there are other options out there I understand your point that it can be dangerous. But if the parents are saying it's helping and the patients are saying it's helping than how can you say it's not helping? |
|
Posted 3/21/06 4:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments Scary! |
|
Posted 3/21/06 4:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments Posted by leighla I understand your point that it can be dangerous. But if the parents are saying it's helping and the patients are saying it's helping than how can you say it's not helping? IMO it is abuse... plain and simple... they think it helps because they see the temporary effects... and the idea of my child or an adult living life always havving to be "shocked" or "sprayed" is sad... In the end....EVERYONE can learn at some level... and that is what changes behavior ultimately |
|
Posted 3/21/06 4:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments are there any postive articles about this form of treatment? |
|
Posted 3/21/06 4:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments and to be honest.... |
|
Posted 3/21/06 4:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments Posted by LadyLainez are there any postive articles about this form of treatment? sure there are the majority of psychiatric facilities used to do this kind of thing It now ILLEGAL in all forms and considered abuse. In NYS you can go to jail if you do it |
|
Posted 3/21/06 4:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Shock Treatments Posted by Redhead and to be honest.... like i said above... ALL behavior has a function, a reason. WHAT if that reason was to express pain? Or to communicate? and now we are shocking these kids or adults when they are trying to communicate with us? I don't know. I feel the article is geared towards the negative end, but there are always two sides to things and though I don't think it's humane, if I was in this situation maybe I would have to consider this form of treatment. |
|
Posted 3/21/06 4:15 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| and what a shock.. i have another movement question... | 04bride | 5/24/06 | 2 | Pregnancy |
| Those who went through IF treatments to get PG | DebG | 3/23/06 | 14 | Pregnancy |
| Window Treatments | Diana1215 | 3/8/06 | 16 | Home |
| For those interested in Custom Window Treatments | skew | 1/27/06 | 2 | Home |
| Anyone have custom window treatments made by the Fabric Mill? | skew | 1/19/06 | 1 | Home |
| Can I see pics of your LR window treatments? | KaRiSsA | 12/30/05 | 11 | Home |










