SAHM vs. Working

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

twinkletoes807
Mommy's Girls! ♥

Member since 11/07

10116 total posts

Name:
Gabi

Re: SAHM vs. Working

For us, it is strictly money. If I had my way, I would be a SAHM. My DH was previously married, had 3 children, and pays a lot of child support. If I don't work, the mortgage does not get paid. It sucks. Chat Icon

Posted 10/1/09 9:37 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: SAHM vs. Working

This is such a hard thing and only you will know what you feel is right and hoenstly you wont know until you are in the position.

I always thought I wanted to SAH. But after DS was born I returned FT to a job I LOVED! loved the people I worked with, what I was doing, my salary etc. My ILs watched DS FT which was wonderful but alot for them. DH and I decided that working PT would be best for us. So I found a PT job, had to leave the position I loved found a job that was okay but had such great flexibility (WAH option, flexible days/hours etc) I was planning on working there for the next 4+ years. Then I got laid off.

So for the past 6 months I have been a SAHM, while I enjoy it and have loved this time with DS. I do plan on returning PT I am just not sure when yet.

For my family, for my sanity, for my personality, working PT is when I am at my best. I love getting out a few days, I know my DS is in good hands, I think its great for him to be so bonded to his grandparents, and I like having the extra income to pad our savings, do the extras etc.

So in the 18 months since my maternity leave ended I have spent
3 months working FT
9 months working PT
6 months as a SAHM

I have tried it all on and some days honestly I still am not confident which is the right fit!
Chat Icon

Posted 10/1/09 9:52 PM
 

dapnkap
Our 3 angels

Member since 7/07

4824 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: SAHM vs. Working

Both DH and I work 9-5 jobs. Being a SAHM just wasn't an option for us. Between the mortgage, monthly bills, and living the life we want to live, we both need to work.

We don't have to pay for daycare, DD is watched by both grandma's in our own home.

I do like to work, but of course I would prefer to be home with DD. My ideal situation would be to work PT, but that's not an option right now.

Posted 10/3/09 10:21 AM
 

Leeners
:)

Member since 5/05

4898 total posts

Name:
Eileen

Re: SAHM vs. Working

Posted by Bxgell2

Working mom here - I went back to work because I love my job and love my career - I'm not cut out to be a SAHM, and am happier as a person, and as a mother, when I work.



Ditto

Posted 10/3/09 11:08 AM
 

nicrae
He's here!

Member since 12/06

9289 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: SAHM vs. Working

I am a working mom....

The only reason I am is because we can't afford for me to stay home.

I am currently a NYC Teacher so luckily I have a lot of time off.

Posted 10/3/09 11:15 AM
 

karenchad
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/09

518 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: SAHM vs. Working

I was a working mom from the time my DS was 6 weeks until he was 1 1/2. That was when I got pregnant with my 2nd DS. When my job found out that I was prego again, they fired me, but since I can't prove it, there is nothing I can do!

I will be going back to work in January (if I can find something!!) after my DS is born.

Ideally, I would love to stay home all the time, but financially, we can not afford it! Fortunately, my parents are both retired now, so they will be watching my sons when I do go back...there is no way we could afford 2 in daycare!

Good luck with your decision!

Posted 10/3/09 11:29 AM
 

Alli06
Baby #3 coming this June

Member since 8/05

6721 total posts

Name:
A

Re: SAHM vs. Working

THe only reason I went back to work FT was for the money. We hope to buy a house in a year and we need to save money.
I don't like working at all, and wish I could stay home with DS.

Posted 10/3/09 12:01 PM
 

lakadema
LIF Adult

Member since 5/08

1180 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: SAHM vs. Working

For us, we can afford for me to stay home so money wasn't a deciding factor.

So the question for me was:

At the end of my life would I regret not having worked as much as I wanted in my career(which I love) or regret not being home to raise my son?

The answer was simple for me. Even though it may be hard to go back to work after years off and I will never make as much $$ as I could have, it is not impossible and my son is worth the wait.

Posted 10/3/09 12:21 PM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: SAHM vs. Working

I am a working Mom. One of the biggest reasons I went back to work was my benefits. DH has a good job and makes a decent salary which we can live off of (tight but doable)..but he works for a family owned business and the benefits suk. He is doing what he loves and eventually God willing one day our family will own a similar business but right now he's still "getting his feet wet".

When I first went back to work I was miserable...but honestly now I'm glad I went back. I make good money and have excellent benefits. In an ideal world, I would love to cut my days from 5 to 3 but right now thats not possible. My income allows us to go on vacation, make those purchases that I would otherwise be unable to make if I was a SAHM, afford to save for DD's future as well as our own. Also if I were to quit my job now the chances of me getting aother job that I love making the money that I make in the future are probably slim. I think its a very personal decision and one that has to be examined per couple.

Honestly, coming from a single parent family I saw my mother struggle to raise 2 kids on her own with no support and it was scary. I love DH with all my heart and I pray that we will spend the rest of our lives together however, nothing in life is guaranteed. A part of me does feel good knowing I make my own money and if God forbid something was to happen I can support DD and myself. I also get satisfaction in working...I love my job and the people I work with so I'm sure that has a lot to do with it also. I also work close to home (can get home or to pick up DD in 5 minutes if I take a cab) which is a big plus for me.

Posted 10/3/09 12:44 PM
 

mtnmama

Member since 5/06

4794 total posts

Name:

Re: SAHM vs. Working

I went back to work strictly because we need the money to cover bills.

Posted 10/3/09 12:55 PM
 

MrsGmomof3
...

Member since 6/08

3290 total posts

Name:
Irrelevant

Re: SAHM vs. Working

We figured out the real "costs" of my returning to work and with daycare, commuting, etc. etc.... it was more cost-effective for me to be a SAHM. It would have COST us money for me to return to work.

I am VERY glad to be lucky enough to be a SAHM, but I know that its not for everyone.

Posted 10/3/09 1:33 PM
 

Tah-wee-ZAH
Kisses

Member since 5/05

15952 total posts

Name:

Re: SAHM vs. Working

Posted by nrthshgrl

I chose to work. DH wanted me to be a SAHM. I'm in HR. He is IBEW, Local #3 - with very good benefits.

My reasons are I feel it is a huge mistake for someone to give up the opportunity to support themselves. Believe it or not I'm not a pessimist but everyone's marriage will end either in death or divorce. If you're not the one that dies, you will be the one left supporting yourself & your family (unless of course you are independently wealthy).

Even for a few years as a SAHM changes your earning potential unless you are in a set pay scale like a union job. Also speaking to the SAHMs that I know, they found it extremely hard to go back to work after being out while their children were in elementary school. 10 years out of the workforce is a long time.

We just had women on this board become widows this year. We've had many women going through divorce. We've had many DHs that have been laid off. I worry about SAHMs on here being able to pick themselves up if they were put in that same situation.

I do love my job & get a lot out of it. In the 8 years that I've had children, my salary has almost doubled. My 401(k) has grown. As much as he wants me to be a SAHM, we would have a very different life without it. He would work OT & I would be itching for him to get home so I could get a break. It's not the life I want for my family.



EXACTLY!!!

Barb brings up a lot of points that I never see discussed on the SAHM v. working mom posts but are very valid and very real. No one thinks it's going to happen to them but it does.

First, I can honestly say, I don't know where I would be had my father died suddenly instead of my SAHM. She was out of the workforce for 8 years. It was 1979 and she had a high school diploma. I really don't want to think about itChat Icon That is what has always driven me. From an early age I made sure that I would go into a profession where, if the worst happend, I could not only support myself but my family.

My dad, as a single parent, was on strike for a full year when I was in college... a private college... no paycheck coming in and he had a $1400 a month tuition payment and a mortgage payment of the same amount... 20 years ago. He hustled, used up what little savings he had (he always saved) but he did it... I truly, truly learned from that. Yeah, I still cry to know the sacrifices we went through.

In my 20's I had to assume my father's mortgage and bills when he had a sudden and massive stroke. I've always had a p/t time job since I was 12 and I've always saved. We had enough to worry about... my father couldn't walk or talk. The day after his stroke, I grabbed his checkbook and realized his mortgage was due in three days. I was able to pay his $1400 mortgage and a $2K credit card bill because he just bought new carpeting and appliances for the kitchen. One less thing to worry about because of my career and how I handle finances.

People thought I was nuts to go back to work after having twins. Daycare is over $20K a year.

Daycare is a temporary expense and like Barb said, women pay a lot more in the long run... the loss of salary, difficulty even getting back into your field and loss of compounding interest on your 401K contributions. Women tend to outlive their DH's... retirement $$$ is critical. SS will not be there.

Last Sept. DH's old company had massive layoffs. He had to take a furlough. We were so nervous... in Dec. they were bought by a startup. I still held my breath... after 9 months, I was just starting to relax.
And now it's happened to us.

My heart SANK last week when I turned down my block at 3pm to see my DH's car in the driveway...

"Oh please God, please... let it just be a migraine".
My gut told me differently.

No. My DH, the ONLY salesperson for his company... the ONE who brought the $$$ in, was laid off. He wasn't low-man, he was even holding his numbers in this deep, deep recession... a miracle in itself. His boss of 9 months bought his company last year and basically had no idea what he was doing.

So our family, like so many others, is unemployed.

I scrimped and saved on my maternity leave.
I scrimped and saved last year rewrapping toys to put under the Christmas tree because I was so nervous to spend for the holidays.

DH has hit the ground running looking for his next job but his sector is shrinking.

Thank God I make what I make.
Thank God I hold the medical benefits.
Thank God I have a pension and contribute healthy to my 403B.

But with all of that being said my salary will pay the mortgage and most of the daycare bill... unemployment will kick in soon to cover food and other necessities but not much else.

Our saving grace is our savings... guess all of those hand me downs I've always said yes to are paying off nowChat Icon Being the daughter of a single parent and having lived through a year long strike has given me the invaluable experience of knowing how to live through such hard financial times.

On the flip side, it also scares the c r a p out of me because I know. I know several professionals... 20 plus years with companies who have been out of work for a full year!!! I don't care how much my DH brings home... my job is my family's security... as of last Thursday it has become our lifeline.Chat Icon

We could have lived on my DH's old salary and not had me working. Thank God, I made the choice to go back.

Message edited 2009-10-03 14:17:14.157000.

Posted 10/3/09 2:11 PM
 

ME75

Member since 10/06

4563 total posts

Name:

Re: SAHM vs. Working

i've done both and prefer being a working mom. but i love my job and have awesome hours/vacation and my daycare situation is great too. i feel lonely and "bored" just being home-but that is just me.
also, DH lost his job while i was on my 1st maternity leave and it was then that i realzied how important it is for me to have a job-i am VERY grateful for it!

Posted 10/3/09 2:13 PM
 

bayla
Love my two kiddos :)

Member since 8/06

7178 total posts

Name:

Re: SAHM vs. Working

i work part time 3 days a week and its perfect. My DH has the benefits so I work per diem and make good $$. Also we had family to watch my DS 2 of the 3 days, so he was only in daycare 1 day a week (and I got a discount b/c of my job)

Posted 10/3/09 2:15 PM
 

MEWF
LIF Adolescent

Member since 4/07

503 total posts

Name:
M

Re: SAHM vs. Working

I was always going to be a SAHM. working has alwyas been financial. I dont understand ppl who say what would you do if you didnt work. as if it was entertainment. work is work. not entertainment.

my plan was have my babies take 3 months off, go back to work for 3 months, get a bonus and quit. When i worked full time i never saw my children ( 15 months old twins).
THen the economy went down and DH's job was in jeporady. i went to work for 3 more months. then i quit to stay home. work was 100% for financial securty when DH's job was shaky. wk asked me to do pt time. i work between 1 & 4 days a week.

the 1 day a week was great in the sense i got out of the house and felt financially i was making a contribution. but i dreaded going and i hardly got anything accomplished. when i was working 4 days a week it was very stressful and the off days i had a million things to do and i hardly saw my babies. next week is my last week of 4 days and then its 3 days and then 1 day and dec 16 is my last day. i am thrilled.

work was never fullfilling. For short periods of time it was but not overall, not truly. in the back of my mind i was always going to be home with my children.
i hate having less money but these are my only children, i am not having more and for me seeign them only on the weekends was not good enough. I am already splittign my time between them and neither has every had 100% of my attention. that is hard for me. I was married for several years before having children just to have a cusion for when i stopped working.

its a really hard decision with no easy answer. i feel important and useful by working and i am happy to have more money but when i weigh it with seeing my children more is more important. i will say being home with them is often exhausting sometimes frustrating and always more challenging than going to an office. but its so much more rewarding.

GL

Posted 10/3/09 4:13 PM
 

csorisi
My 2 LOVES

Member since 11/05

1984 total posts

Name:
Corinne

Re: SAHM vs. Working

I always knew I would go back to work after having my DD. I had her in april and took off over 4 months to be with her--I worked from home during that time and now work 4 days a week. I love my job--or at least when I left in April to go on maternity leave I did--now I find that I am just there doing what I have to do...I think it is just leaving her everyday and after some time it will become part of my everyday routine. My DH and I have talked about what we would do after our second child because right now our parents watch DD 3 days a week. I have $900 a month student loan payments every month and I spent 3 yrs going to school to be a lawyer and I couldn't imagine giving that up at the same time though I dread every day I go to work. Being a working mom is alot of work--for me it is a lot of running around to get DD to our parents house in the am and then picking her up and starting her night time routine when I get home. UNfortunately I do not have a 9-5 job so it makes my days a little unpredictable and work has been crazy. I just trying to manage it all. I know in the end though it is worth every second.

Posted 10/3/09 6:20 PM
 

july06bride
I'm a mom!

Member since 5/05

3966 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: SAHM vs. Working

When my DD was 6 months old I went back to work, to teaching. I did it because we wanted to have extra. I could have stayed home and we could have paid the bills and would have been fine. We have a house already but we would like a bigger house eventually...plus we wanted to be able to still go on vacations, give DD all the stuff we had growing up plus more. For us to do that, I have to work...

BUT, I won't lie, I am second guessing it now- sometimes I wonder if it is worth it....should I just cut corners and give her ME or should I go to work and give her all the extras... I don't know, I am torn.

Posted 10/3/09 6:36 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: SAHM vs. Working

Well, I don't have the option to stay home, but I wouldn't stay home even if I could. I am a teacher and having the summers off is enough for me to know that I'm meant to be a working mom. I enjoy the adult time I get, but music (what I teach) is also my passion, so I can't imagine not waking up everyday and doing what I love. And it's not that I don't love being my DD's mom, but it's not the only thing I love. I really define myself more by my career than by the fact that I'm someone's mom.

Posted 10/3/09 7:41 PM
 

leighla
Support Cancer Research

Member since 5/05

16353 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: SAHM vs. Working

Posted by Bxgell2

Working mom here - I went back to work because I love my job and love my career - I'm not cut out to be a SAHM, and am happier as a person, and as a mother, when I work.



Ditto.

Posted 10/3/09 8:00 PM
 

MrsRivera
2 under 2...whew!!

Member since 2/07

9876 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: SAHM vs. Working

Posted by Bxgell2

Working mom here - I went back to work because I love my job and love my career - I'm not cut out to be a SAHM, and am happier as a person, and as a mother, when I work.



I couldn't have said it better myself. While there are a LOT of benefits to staying home, I found that I went stir-crazy. I need to have a reason to get up, get showered, and put makeup on.

Though, I am still trying to "tweak" things a bit with work. I'm a 5th grade teacher, and I'm feeling like the age group is still too young for me. I need to feel as though I'm leaving DD at daycare every day to go to a job that I love...and I'm not quite there yet.

Monetarily, I COULD be a SAHM, but I work so that I have something else to keep me sane, and the extra salary is pretty much a bonus.

Posted 10/3/09 8:06 PM
 

CaseyGirl
Mommy to 3 Boys :)

Member since 5/05

19978 total posts

Name:
Jen - counting my blessings...

Re: SAHM vs. Working

Have to go back FT for financial reasons, my salary alone pays the mortgage and I carry the (very good) insurance. But DH and I still think about relocating to NC or SC sometimes and I would stay home. Though now that I am home on mat leave I think PT would be nice to contribute income and have some adult interaction.

Posted 10/3/09 8:25 PM
 

Candy Girl
Candy girl- you are so sweet!

Member since 11/07

6349 total posts

Name:
erin

Re: SAHM vs. Working

I have no choice because I carry the benefits for the family. I thought I wanted to be a working Mom, but ever since I went back to work I am sooooo blue.

Posted 10/3/09 8:57 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
SAHM's with 2 under 2 (especially if you were a working mom before), what to do with little one's in bad weather clwp 9/12/09 11 Parenting
Is anyone a working, SAHM? Advice...can I have it all? MrsR 5/8/09 16 Parenting
Anyone go from a FT working mom to a SAHM after baby #2 arrived? ckone 11/26/07 8 Parenting
IF you have been both a SAHM and a working mom please tell me about your experience ME75 11/20/07 15 Parenting
What do YOU do for a living...SAHM or working mom's... aliasPook 6/28/07 78 Parenting
Calling all Working SAHM..How do you do it? ckone 10/3/06 17 Parenting