Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

Posted By Message

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

Do you HAVE to switch them to the straw cups from the regular sippy cups? Is there a benefit of the straw over the regular cups? Do kids HAVE to use a straw cup at some point? DD knows how to use a straw b/c she drinks out of our straws if we have them.

DD does just fine with the regular Born Free cups, I don't want to go buy a ton more cups just because they have straws.

ETA: I feel like I've asked this question before but the search function NEVER works for me Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-02-19 11:20:35.913000.

Posted 2/19/09 11:17 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

DmarieK
My loves!!

Member since 1/06

9203 total posts

Name:

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

I heard the straws were better for speech...not sure why though. I'm still working on the regular ones.

Message edited 2009-02-19 11:20:48.257000.

Posted 2/19/09 11:18 AM
 

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

Posted by DmarieK

I heard the straws were better for speach...not sure why though. I'm still working on the regular ones.



I read that yesterday too...but thankfully, DD doesn't have any speech issues.

Posted 2/19/09 11:19 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

Christopher has no problems with speech eitherChat Icon so I am not planning on switching over. He has two straw cups that he drinks juice/water out of.

But I'm also a freak and milk in a straw cup grosses me out

Posted 2/19/09 11:22 AM
 

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

Posted by KateDevine

Christopher has no problems with speech eitherChat Icon so I am not planning on switching over. He has two straw cups that he drinks juice/water out of.

But I'm also a freak and milk in a straw cup grosses me out



Chat Icon Chat Icon Well, that's an interesting thing to be grossed out by Chat Icon

Posted 2/19/09 11:23 AM
 

nylisa
My Children

Member since 5/05

7905 total posts

Name:
MaMa

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

When DS started taking the cup, he took a sippy cup and a few months ago (he is 2 1/2 years old) he finally got the hang of a straw cup. He has never had any problems with speech.

Posted 2/19/09 11:28 AM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

Posted by nbc188

Posted by DmarieK

I heard the straws were better for speach...not sure why though. I'm still working on the regular ones.



I read that yesterday too...but thankfully, DD doesn't have any speech issues.



Im going to assume that it is from an oral-motor prespective. Using a straw takes more muscles than a typical sippy cup. Similar motions are made with certain speech patterns.

Posted 2/19/09 11:37 AM
 

ml110
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

5435 total posts

Name:

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

i'm a speech therapist, and we do say to use the straw cuups because they use different motions than the sippy cups, which helps build up the muscles for speech.
BUT-its good that she can drink out of the straw when you guys use them. how often does she do that? as long as its often enough that she gets practice at it, thats good.

Posted 2/19/09 11:41 AM
 

luvsun27
Check out my cool glasses

Member since 5/05

8135 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

DD has only ever used the straw cups, because she could never figure out how to tilt her head back and get the water/milk/juice from a regular sippy, but she figured out how to use a straw at around 9 months Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/19/09 11:45 AM
 

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

Posted by ml110

i'm a speech therapist, and we do say to use the straw cuups because they use different motions than the sippy cups, which helps build up the muscles for speech.
BUT-its good that she can drink out of the straw when you guys use them. how often does she do that? as long as its often enough that she gets practice at it, thats good.



She doesn't do it very often at all, we rarely drink from straws.

Should I be doing it more? Should I really switch her to straw cups?

Thanks for your insight!

Posted 2/19/09 11:48 AM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

Posted by nbc188

Posted by ml110

i'm a speech therapist, and we do say to use the straw cuups because they use different motions than the sippy cups, which helps build up the muscles for speech.
BUT-its good that she can drink out of the straw when you guys use them. how often does she do that? as long as its often enough that she gets practice at it, thats good.



She doesn't do it very often at all, we rarely drink from straws.

Should I be doing it more? Should I really switch her to straw cups?

Thanks for your insight!



I have a zillion straw cups - want me to bring them to you tomorrow - still new in the package?! Give them a try!

Posted 2/19/09 12:05 PM
 

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

Posted by Diana1215

Posted by nbc188

Posted by ml110

i'm a speech therapist, and we do say to use the straw cuups because they use different motions than the sippy cups, which helps build up the muscles for speech.
BUT-its good that she can drink out of the straw when you guys use them. how often does she do that? as long as its often enough that she gets practice at it, thats good.



She doesn't do it very often at all, we rarely drink from straws.

Should I be doing it more? Should I really switch her to straw cups?

Thanks for your insight!



I have a zillion straw cups - want me to bring them to you tomorrow - still new in the package?! Give them a try!



Thank you-- 1 would be plenty Chat Icon

But do I really NEED to use them? That's what I'm trying to figure out. Chat Icon

Posted 2/19/09 12:08 PM
 

Bklyngrl
luvmyfamily

Member since 9/06

5307 total posts

Name:

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

my ped said it didnt matter but here's an article i found online?? hth i'm trying to wean dd to straw sippy only too. she'll drink water from straw but not milk??

Feb. 11, 2008 (New York) -- Toddlers could develop lisps and other speech problems from use of sippy cups, says a speech pathologist.
Sippy cups -- the often character-themed training cups that come with a snap-on lid and hard spout -- and/or thumb sucking can cause difficulty with articulation and clarity of speech in some children, says Sandra Holtzman, MS, a speech pathologist and certified orofacial myologist in Coconut Creek, Fla.
"When a child sucks their thumb, it's placed on the roof of their mouth, so the tongue is misplaced," Holtzman tells WebMD. "They keep their lips apart, which encourages open-mouth breathing, and their teeth are pushed forward or outward." When the tongue is misplaced, she says, a child also can't properly suction saliva or swallow food or liquid.
"The most common issues are types of lisps," she says, "but it can also cause imprecise articulation," such as slurred or difficult-to-understand speech.
But parents can make simple changes that will prevent these speech issues, says Holtzman, who spoke at a conference on orofacial myology, a field of study that looks at how certain structural or functional factors in the mouth can cause speech and swallowing issues.
(Does your toddler use a sippy cup? Will you change to a straw? Talk with others on WebMD's Parenting: 1-Year-Olds message board.)
Straws an Alternative to Sippy Cups
Thumb sucking and sippy cups can cause similar problems, Holtzman says.
"If a child goes from the breast or the bottle to a sippy cup, they tend to drink it as if it were a bottle. They lie back or tip their neck in the usual manner, so it's almost like drinking a bottle," she says. "They have a hard object or spout with various shapes depending on the type of cup, and their bodies are tipped back. This hard object or spout misplaces the tongue and pushes the teeth out as the thumb can."
Steer clear of sippy cups and use straws instead, she urges.
"Today, we are kind of spoiled and not as used to a mess when a cup spills, but that's a mistake," Holtzman says. Instead of cups with spouts, use cups with straws or simply place a straw in a paper or plastic cup, she says.
New York City speech pathologist Joslin Zeplin agrees. "A sippy cup can serve a function, which is to transition off of the bottle, but it should only be used for a brief time," she says. "It can be used for approximately a month and should never be used as a substitute for a bottle and it should not be treated like a bottle."
Transition to a straw cup after a month, says Zeplin, who helped organize the conference.
Thumb sucking is another habit that parents should nip in the bud, she says.
"Sucking the thumb places unnecessary pressure on the palate and can deform it," she says. "If a child's palate is misshapen, the tongue may not have place to rest, and this can lead to articulation issues," she says.
"Using a pacifier is better because at least you can take it away, unlike the thumb," she says.
Holtzman suggests dressing infants in outfits with mittens as a way to prevent thumb sucking.

Posted 2/19/09 12:21 PM
 

ml110
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

5435 total posts

Name:

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

Posted by nbc188

Posted by ml110

i'm a speech therapist, and we do say to use the straw cuups because they use different motions than the sippy cups, which helps build up the muscles for speech.
BUT-its good that she can drink out of the straw when you guys use them. how often does she do that? as long as its often enough that she gets practice at it, thats good.



She doesn't do it very often at all, we rarely drink from straws.

Should I be doing it more? Should I really switch her to straw cups?

Thanks for your insight!



your welcome! hmm.. well if she doesn't drink from teh straw too much, i would probably look into getting a straw cup for her. it can't hurt! even if she isn't having any speech issues now, it can't hurt for her to keep developing her mouth muscles for further down the road...

Posted 2/19/09 12:22 PM
 

SpiceGirl
Dream big

Member since 1/06

2486 total posts

Name:
j

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

DD uses reg sippy cups and thankfully has no speech problems. I've bought some of the straw cups and tried them myself...and I find it hard to drink out of...maybe it was just the brand I bought.

Posted 2/19/09 12:25 PM
 

cgdg61606
Little Brother Christopher

Member since 2/07

6815 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

My ped said that staw cups are better for speech development because it requires mature mouth/tongue movements. She also said that regular sippy cups are bad for the teeth because the liquid washes over the back of the front teeth.

We use mostly straw cups now.

However, she also mentioned that sippy cups are mostly for convenience and that a child should be taught to use a regular cup with a very little bit of liquid in it in a seated position. Sippy cups shouldn't be used as bottles.

Hope this helps!

Chat Icon

P.S. I really like the new Playtex Twist and Click Insulated straw cups.

Posted 2/19/09 12:48 PM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

We have switched DD completely off the sippy cups and to the straw sippy cups. Honestly we did it b.c she just seems to prefer the straws to the regular sippys. I also heard it helps with speech so I didn't see the harm when she liked the switch.

Posted 2/19/09 2:04 PM
 

InShock
life is good

Member since 10/06

9258 total posts

Name:

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

I don't know about the "have to" part of it, but DD drinks out of both kinds interchangeably and doesn't seem to prefer one over the other (I'm talking the take & toss kind). When we go out, I use the straw kind (not take & toss), but in the house, it's whichever is handy! So maybe just try to add some straws to the mix (the take & toss are so cheap, it's not like a huge investment or anything! Chat Icon)

Message edited 2009-02-19 14:12:37.467000.

Posted 2/19/09 2:12 PM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

I've read all the above about the sippys which was why I got him started on straw sippys months ago (he is 17.5 mos now). HOWEVER that said, I am mixing and matching again and back to using the spouts to. He likes the straw ones, has no problem drinking out of them HOWEVER they can be messy - When my DS is done eating or drinking he can be a bit of a nudge and his favorite thing to do is to turn the straw sippy upside down - shake it like crazy, and then "finger paint" all over the place with the liquid that comes out - he knows he can't do it with the spout so he doesn't even try. I think the fact that it annoys me gives him even more pleasure doing it Chat Icon

Does anyone have any tips to stop this?

Posted 2/19/09 2:52 PM
 

dawnygirl25
Growing up soo fast..

Member since 1/06

14917 total posts

Name:
Dawn

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

Posted by luvsun27

DD has only ever used the straw cups, because she could never figure out how to tilt her head back and get the water/milk/juice from a regular sippy, but she figured out how to use a straw at around 9 months Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



same with Alyssa.

Posted 2/19/09 7:39 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

The main concern with the hard spout sippy is that it *can* change the alignment of the teeth. Also, because the tongue is wrapping around the spout it tends to push it (the tongue) forward. Over extended time, this can cause forward posturing of the tongue/ tongue thrust. Tongue thrust can cause issues with production of speech sounds.

The same can be said for pacifiers, bottles, and thumbsucking. That said, most of this "damage" occurs over an extended amount of time. That's why it's not recommended for any of the above to be used into the 3rd year.

DD is 20 months and we go back and forth between a hard spout and straw cup. Once she's 2-2.5 I'm hoping to be rid of the hard spout and introducing a regular cup.

Posted 2/19/09 8:00 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Regular sippy cups vs straw sippy cups

Posted by itsbabytime

I've read all the above about the sippys which was why I got him started on straw sippys months ago (he is 17.5 mos now). HOWEVER that said, I am mixing and matching again and back to using the spouts to. He likes the straw ones, has no problem drinking out of them HOWEVER they can be messy - When my DS is done eating or drinking he can be a bit of a nudge and his favorite thing to do is to turn the straw sippy upside down - shake it like crazy, and then "finger paint" all over the place with the liquid that comes out - he knows he can't do it with the spout so he doesn't even try. I think the fact that it annoys me gives him even more pleasure doing it Chat Icon

Does anyone have any tips to stop this?



When we first introduced the straw cup, DD did the same thing. SO- we took it away for awhile. We reintroduced it a few months later. I'm not sure if it's a maturity thing or that she's interested in other things, but she rarely plays with it now.

Yes- they ARE a mess. As well as a hassle to clean.

Posted 2/19/09 8:02 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
UGH! My Mom is giving me the hardest time about the fact that we have switched Maddie over to sippy cups... johnsae 3/13/08 18 Parenting
Straw sippy cups... Diane 6/18/08 5 Parenting
Nuby straw sippy cups JessicaluvsCharles 5/30/08 4 Parenting
Do they sell BPA free straw sippy cups??? missrock 4/28/08 6 Parenting
Thanks for rec sippy cups with the straw... LIMOMx2 4/30/07 2 Parenting
ANyone use straw sippy cups by Nuby for toddler? MrsM 4/20/07 9 Parenting