Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

Posted By Message

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

A co-worker of DH's posted about the Supernanny episode tonight...a father forces his kids to eat hot sauce if they misbehave and if that doesnt work, he gets out the wood spoon. DH's friend make a joke "whatever happened to the belt" Chat Icon

Another friend of his responded to his post. He said time out does work. He makes his daughter face the wall on her knees with her hands in the air and he tells his daughter "if those hands only slip once yuh gettin ah hot belt across yuh back!!!...Knock on wood, except for a few times when she gave me no choice but to use the belt"

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

It is taking everything in me not to respond to this post Chat Icon They are joking about hitting kids with a belt. How is that funny?

Message edited 2011-03-04 21:16:39.017000.

Posted 3/4/11 9:14 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Ang-Rich
Beyond Compare

Member since 5/05

17988 total posts

Name:

Re: Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I mean..I have to be honest...we laugh about how back in the day our mother's hit us with wooden spoons but I would never think - much less say - anything about hitting my kids with anything.

Posted 3/4/11 9:19 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

Posted by Ang-Rich

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I mean..I have to be honest...we laugh about how back in the day our mother's hit us with wooden spoons but I would never think - much less say - anything about hitting my kids with anything.





My mother used to chase me with a wooden spoon too but a swat on the butt with a wooden spoon is MUCH different than getting hit across the back with a leather belt Chat Icon

Posted 3/4/11 9:20 PM
 

waterspout4
My loves

Member since 5/06

19150 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

uh-oh. DS was evil tonight and kicked a hole in the wall of his bedroom when he was mad. He did get a smack on his butt, but my BIL did FB that if his kids ever did that they would get the belt. My BIL was joking. He was waiting for his wife to respond and call him an idiot, but he really didn't mean it, other than to rile her up. (They are newlyweds.)

But am I evil that I do have DS sit on the floor and face the wall for his time out? He doesn't put his hands on the wall, just faces it.

Posted 3/4/11 9:21 PM
 

8ternity
<3

Member since 11/08

10586 total posts

Name:
Formally NYPD-Wife

Re: Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

Posted by Ang-Rich

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I mean..I have to be honest...we laugh about how back in the day our mother's hit us with wooden spoons but I would never think - much less say - anything about hitting my kids with anything.




I was thinking the same thing...My parents used to threaten me with the hot pepper thing but never did it.

Posted 3/4/11 9:21 PM
 

longford73
Welcome to the world Baby Boy!

Member since 8/06

3127 total posts

Name:

Re: Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

Chat Icon Chat Icon

Wow just wowChat Icon

I got the wooden spoon. Not bad but it was always a threat - so much so that my brother & I would hide them. Don't get me wrong we were never "beaten" but I still got a wack now and then. My father used to go nuts when he couldn't find one to make sauce. Chat Icon

Even though I don't feel like we were "abused" I still remember that feeling when the drawer opened and you heard the SPOON was coming out. I would never want my kids to have that fear and I dont' think it's funny. Hell I feel bad enough when I have to put DD on the step for time out.Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-03-04 21:27:05.790000.

Posted 3/4/11 9:25 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

Posted by waterspout4

But am I evil that I do have DS sit on the floor and face the wall for his time out? He doesn't put his hands on the wall, just faces it.



You're not evil at all! I put TJ in time out too.

But I looked at a picture of this guys kids...the girl couldnt be more than 4 or 5. I couldnt imagine having TJ kneeling, facing a wall with his arms up and if his arms dropped hitting him across the back with a belt. How do you sleep at night after doing something like that???

Posted 3/4/11 9:26 PM
 

Ang-Rich
Beyond Compare

Member since 5/05

17988 total posts

Name:

Re: Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

Posted by Mommy2Boys

Posted by Ang-Rich

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I mean..I have to be honest...we laugh about how back in the day our mother's hit us with wooden spoons but I would never think - much less say - anything about hitting my kids with anything.





My mother used to chase me with a wooden spoon too but a swat on the butt with a wooden spoon is MUCH different than getting hit across the back with a leather belt Chat Icon



I agree...I can't even image. And I realize how fortunate I am to say that because my father used to threaten it but never hit us with a belt. My skin hurts thinking of it and that makes me want to cry for that little girl.

Posted 3/4/11 9:29 PM
 

longford73
Welcome to the world Baby Boy!

Member since 8/06

3127 total posts

Name:

Re: Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

I don't think facing the wall is bad at all. I equate that to me having to move DD to the step for time out so there are no distractions. I used to put her in the corner but a lot of her toys are there so she would either play during time out or toss them around because she was angry. Now she has to sit on the first step that goes to our second floor but the step faces a door - no distractions.

Posted 3/4/11 9:30 PM
 

Lucky
Growing up fast!

Member since 4/07

12683 total posts

Name:
Dawn

Re: Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

Crazy! I don't understand going over the edge like that...these are children for crying out loud!

I've swatted my DD on the backside a handful of times but nothing that would be considered corporal punishment...I would never hurt her or god forbid, scar her for life. And of those handful of times, I have felt so badly afterward. A few of those times have been when she has hit her baby sister and I wanted her to have a taste of her own medicine. She doesn't hit her sister anymore!

Posted 3/4/11 9:58 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

My father used a belt on us. Right between our butt and our thighs, three swats. OMG they hurt like heck!

He didn't abuse us. We had it coming. We always had to tell him why and let me tell you we had PLENTY of chances before it got that far!

A belt is not abuse to me.

A wooden spoon over the head is. A pointy side of a hairbrush to the face is. A random slap across the face is. Fists are, broomsticks on backs and a belt anywhere else.

I don't think the belt itself is abuse. Its how its used and not just where but HOW. You can't beat a child and say its discipline. But you can use a belt and still respect a child and show them that its a last resort and teach them to try to avoid that outcome.

I swear I saw my Dad cry each time we 'got it'.

JMHO



now the hot sauce stuff, insane. The hold your hands up while in time out is crazy too. But that is again just my opinion. Then again I could never CIO so to each their own, right? And no I don't think its in the same realm.

Posted 3/4/11 10:23 PM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

Posted by Xelindrya

My father used a belt on us. Right between our butt and our thighs, three swats. OMG they hurt like heck!

He didn't abuse us. We had it coming. We always had to tell him why and let me tell you we had PLENTY of chances before it got that far!

A belt is not abuse to me.

A wooden spoon over the head is. A pointy side of a hairbrush to the face is. A random slap across the face is. Fists are, broomsticks on backs and a belt anywhere else.

I don't think the belt itself is abuse. Its how its used and not just where but HOW. You can't beat a child and say its discipline. But you can use a belt and still respect a child and show them that its a last resort and teach them to try to avoid that outcome.

I swear I saw my Dad cry each time we 'got it'.

JMHO



now the hot sauce stuff, insane. The hold your hands up while in time out is crazy too. But that is again just my opinion. Then again I could never CIO so to each their own, right? And no I don't think its in the same realm.




ITA with pretty much EVERYTHING you said.

The belt was used as discipline in my house growing up, never as abuse, and it was never used when Dad was angry. We had chance after chance to correct our behavior, and if it wasn't corrected the belt came out (after ample warning). I think it was used a total of 4 times on me growing up, and my feelings were hurt more than anything. Don't get me wrong, it did hurt though!

Posted 3/4/11 10:32 PM
 

Michelle1123
Baby #5 on the way!

Member since 9/05

7919 total posts

Name:

Re: Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

Posted by OrganicMama

Posted by Xelindrya

My father used a belt on us. Right between our butt and our thighs, three swats. OMG they hurt like heck!

He didn't abuse us. We had it coming. We always had to tell him why and let me tell you we had PLENTY of chances before it got that far!

A belt is not abuse to me.

A wooden spoon over the head is. A pointy side of a hairbrush to the face is. A random slap across the face is. Fists are, broomsticks on backs and a belt anywhere else.

I don't think the belt itself is abuse. Its how its used and not just where but HOW. You can't beat a child and say its discipline. But you can use a belt and still respect a child and show them that its a last resort and teach them to try to avoid that outcome.

I swear I saw my Dad cry each time we 'got it'.

JMHO



now the hot sauce stuff, insane. The hold your hands up while in time out is crazy too. But that is again just my opinion. Then again I could never CIO so to each their own, right? And no I don't think its in the same realm.




ITA with pretty much EVERYTHING you said.

The belt was used as discipline in my house growing up, never as abuse, and it was never used when Dad was angry. We had chance after chance to correct our behavior, and if it wasn't corrected the belt came out (after ample warning). I think it was used a total of 4 times on me growing up, and my feelings were hurt more than anything. Don't get me wrong, it did hurt though!




The belt was not used ever on me, but I agree with both of you.

I have snapped it to make that loud scary noise which has been enough to get my kids back in line.

And I would never post it on fb or online if I did hit my kids with a belt (not that I think *I* ever could).

Posted 3/4/11 10:40 PM
 

Momma2Be
Mommy of an angel

Member since 10/09

5911 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

Posted by OrganicMama

Posted by Xelindrya

My father used a belt on us. Right between our butt and our thighs, three swats. OMG they hurt like heck!

He didn't abuse us. We had it coming. We always had to tell him why and let me tell you we had PLENTY of chances before it got that far!

A belt is not abuse to me.

A wooden spoon over the head is. A pointy side of a hairbrush to the face is. A random slap across the face is. Fists are, broomsticks on backs and a belt anywhere else.

I don't think the belt itself is abuse. Its how its used and not just where but HOW. You can't beat a child and say its discipline. But you can use a belt and still respect a child and show them that its a last resort and teach them to try to avoid that outcome.

I swear I saw my Dad cry each time we 'got it'.

JMHO



now the hot sauce stuff, insane. The hold your hands up while in time out is crazy too. But that is again just my opinion. Then again I could never CIO so to each their own, right? And no I don't think its in the same realm.




ITA with pretty much EVERYTHING you said.

The belt was used as discipline in my house growing up, never as abuse, and it was never used when Dad was angry. We had chance after chance to correct our behavior, and if it wasn't corrected the belt came out (after ample warning). I think it was used a total of 4 times on me growing up, and my feelings were hurt more than anything. Don't get me wrong, it did hurt though!




Same here. My mom always also threatened to get the wooden spoon and like a PP said, my brother and I used to hide them or bury them in the yard Chat Icon

Posted 3/4/11 10:49 PM
 

Twstdvenus1
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/10

777 total posts

Name:

Re: Really upset about a FB post I read tonight

Posted by Momma2Be

Posted by OrganicMama

Posted by Xelindrya

My father used a belt on us. Right between our butt and our thighs, three swats. OMG they hurt like heck!

He didn't abuse us. We had it coming. We always had to tell him why and let me tell you we had PLENTY of chances before it got that far!

A belt is not abuse to me.

A wooden spoon over the head is. A pointy side of a hairbrush to the face is. A random slap across the face is. Fists are, broomsticks on backs and a belt anywhere else.

I don't think the belt itself is abuse. Its how its used and not just where but HOW. You can't beat a child and say its discipline. But you can use a belt and still respect a child and show them that its a last resort and teach them to try to avoid that outcome.

I swear I saw my Dad cry each time we 'got it'.

JMHO



now the hot sauce stuff, insane. The hold your hands up while in time out is crazy too. But that is again just my opinion. Then again I could never CIO so to each their own, right? And no I don't think its in the same realm.




ITA with pretty much EVERYTHING you said.

The belt was used as discipline in my house growing up, never as abuse, and it was never used when Dad was angry. We had chance after chance to correct our behavior, and if it wasn't corrected the belt came out (after ample warning). I think it was used a total of 4 times on me growing up, and my feelings were hurt more than anything. Don't get me wrong, it did hurt though!




Same here. My mom always also threatened to get the wooden spoon and like a PP said, my brother and I used to hide them or bury them in the yard Chat Icon





My mother made us kneel on raw rice with our hands in the air in front of the alter with all her saints on in. She also would take her slipper off to give a whack on the behind.
My mother used hot sauce to get use to stop biting our nails...but not the tabasco type...i'm talking the indian burn a whole in your esophagus type.

DD1 is 5 years old and I dont know how many times she has pushed my buttons to the point that I have threatened to hit her. I did give her a flick to the lips once when she was younger and wouldnt stop saying the word 'sh*t'. I still refer to that day as the day I gave DD a beating.

Posted 3/5/11 8:38 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
UPDATED!! I dont know where else to post this ......(if you get upset easily dont read this) MamaNDaddyof3 4/5/06 28 Pregnancy
i read the entire baby laughs book tonight!! raken40 7/26/07 6 Pregnancy
X-post: Nassau County spraying tonight for mosquitos jms100303 9/4/08 0 Pregnancy
x-post All Star FANFEST Tix for tonight Little-J-Mommy 7/11/08 0 Families Helping Families ™
cross post ***yankee tix for tonight Little-J-Mommy 4/16/08 0 Parenting
X-post - Please light a candle tonight in honor of Pregnancy and Infant Loss Remembrance Day LIMOMx2 10/15/07 25 Parenting